The Directive is published in the Official Journal (OJ L 157, 15.6.2016, p. 1; CELEX 32016L0943; EUR-Lex text). It entered into force on 2016-07-05, member states had to transpose it by 2018-06-09, and it is in force as of 2026-11-17. A licensor reads it as the confidentiality layer of AI training data licensing.
The Directive's Provisions a Data Licensor Meets
Thirteen provisions of the Directive reach a company that licenses or sells data for AI training, and the table gives each article, its effect in a data deal and its date. The table is as of 2026-11-17 and rests on the Official Journal text.
| Article | Rule (Directive wording, shortened) | What it means in a data deal | Date | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Art. 1(1) | Minimum rules; member states may protect more, within listed limits | National law can add conditions or remedies | Transposition by 2018-06-09 | eur-lex.europa.eu |
| Art. 2(1) | Trade secret: secret, commercial value because secret, reasonable steps | The three tests a dataset must pass | In force 2016-07-05 | eur-lex.europa.eu |
| Art. 2(2) | Holder: person lawfully controlling the secret | Control, not ownership, decides who may sue | 2016-07-05 | eur-lex.europa.eu |
| Art. 3 | Lawful acquisition, including testing a product lawfully held without a duty to limit | A sample without written limits can be studied lawfully | 2016-07-05 | eur-lex.europa.eu |
| Art. 4(2) | Unlawful acquisition by unauthorized access or copying of electronic files | Copying beyond agreed access during talks | 2016-07-05 | eur-lex.europa.eu |
| Art. 4(3) | Unlawful use or disclosure in breach of a confidentiality agreement or a contractual duty to limit use | Backs field-of-use and no-retraining clauses | 2016-07-05 | eur-lex.europa.eu |
| Art. 4(4) | Unlawful where the person knew or ought to have known of an unlawful source | Reaches buyers of others' secrets in an archive | 2016-07-05 | eur-lex.europa.eu |
| Art. 5 | Claims dismissed for expression, whistleblowing in the public interest, workers' representatives, legitimate interests | Limits of enforcement | 2016-07-05 | eur-lex.europa.eu |
| Art. 8(2) | Limitation period not more than 6 years | Outer limit; a national period may be shorter | 2016-07-05 | eur-lex.europa.eu |
| Art. 9 | Confidentiality of the secret in court proceedings | Suing does not have to expose the dataset | 2016-07-05 | eur-lex.europa.eu |
| Arts. 12 to 14 | Injunctions, destruction or delivery up of files; compensation capped at royalties; damages or a royalty lump sum | Remedies measured against a license fee | 2016-07-05 | eur-lex.europa.eu |
| Art. 19(1) | Transposition by 2018-06-09 | National law applies from then | 2018-06-09 | eur-lex.europa.eu |
| Art. 20 | Entry into force on the 20th day after publication (OJ 2016-06-15) | In force | 2016-07-05 | eur-lex.europa.eu |
The sections below follow a deal from qualification to remedies, and the Directive's articles address neither licensing nor AI training.
When a Dataset Qualifies: The Three Conditions of Article 2(1)
A dataset is a trade secret under Art. 2(1) only if all three conditions hold: it is secret, it has commercial value because it is secret, and the person lawfully in control has taken reasonable steps to keep it secret. The Directive words them as follows.
- (a) The information "is not, as a body or in the precise configuration and assembly of its components, generally known among or readily accessible to persons within the circles that normally deal with the kind of information in question".
- (b) It "has commercial value because it is secret".
- (c) It "has been subject to reasonable steps under the circumstances, by the person lawfully in control of the information, to keep it secret".
The wording "as a body or in the precise configuration and assembly of its components" in limb (a) means the test looks at the compilation as well as at single records, so a set of individually ordinary records can be assessed as a whole. Whether a given dataset qualifies is not stated here.
Reasonable Steps Under the Circumstances, Read for a Data Archive
The Directive does not list the reasonable steps, but it tells courts to weigh "the measures taken to protect the trade secret" when they decide on provisional measures and injunctions (Arts. 11(2)(b), 13(1)(b)), so the steps a company took become evidence.
The EU's own example list sits in the Data Act, Art. 4(6): identifying trade secrets including in metadata, model contractual terms, confidentiality agreements, strict access protocols, technical standards and codes of conduct, described in the Data Act section below.
What Licensing or Selling a Dataset Does to Its Trade-Secret Status
The Directive has no article on licensing or assigning a trade secret: it protects the "trade secret holder", defined by lawful control of the information rather than by ownership (Art. 2(2)), so what a sale or license transfers is set by the contract and national law.
A license that keeps the buyer under confidentiality keeps the information within limits the Art. 2(1) test can still meet, while a disclosure without any duty works against limbs (a) and (c).
The Directive itself values a license: compensation and damages are measured by the royalties or fees an authorization would have cost (Arts. 13(3), 14(2)), detailed in the remedies section. The confidentiality and use terms sit in the clauses of an AI data licensing agreement.
Protection is not time-limited in the Directive, but it ends with the conditions. Court-ordered confidentiality lapses once the information becomes generally known (Art. 9(1)(b)), and injunctions are revoked at the respondent's request once it no longer meets Art. 2(1) for reasons not attributable to the respondent (Art. 13(2)).
The Directive says nothing on whether training a model on the data is "use" or whether a model is an "infringing good".
License Terms the Directive Backs: Article 4(3)
Use or disclosure of a trade secret without the holder's consent is unlawful when the person breaches a confidentiality agreement or a contractual duty to limit use (Art. 4(3)(b) and (c)), so a buyer that trains beyond the licensed scope can be liable under trade secret law as well as in contract.
Field-of-use and no-retraining clauses therefore carry statutory weight in the EU. One published example, as a claim: micro1's Data License Master Terms s.2.3 keep confidentiality for 3 years after termination and indefinitely for trade secrets (micro1's claim, checked 2026-11-17).
Drafting of the licensed scope is covered under field of use and scope limits in AI data licenses.
Lawful Acquisition Under Article 3: When a Recipient Needs No Consent
Art. 3(1) makes acquisition lawful, without the holder's consent, in four cases, and Art. 3(2) adds acquisition required or allowed by Union or national law.
- (a) Independent discovery or creation.
- (b) Observation, study, disassembly or testing of a product lawfully in the acquirer's possession, where the acquirer is "free from any legally valid duty to limit the acquisition".
- (c) Workers' information and consultation rights.
- (d) Other honest commercial practice.
For a sample, point (b) applies only where the acquirer is free from a legally valid duty to limit the acquisition, so a sample handed over without a written limit can be studied lawfully. The limit belongs in writing before the sample, a step described under proving data quality without sharing the data.
Unauthorized Access and Copying Before a License Is Signed (Article 4(2))
Acquiring a trade secret without consent is unlawful when it happens through unauthorized access to, appropriation of or copying of documents or electronic files lawfully under the holder's control, or through other conduct contrary to honest commercial practices (Art. 4(2)).
During talks this reaches a prospective buyer that copies more than it was allowed to see. Access limits and logs show the limit and the breach.
The folder index, staged disclosure and login rules are on the page about setting up a data room for an AI data licensing deal.
Other Parties' Secrets in the Archive: The Knowledge Test of Article 4(4)
Acquisition, use or disclosure is also unlawful when the person knew or ought to have known that the trade secret came, directly or indirectly, from someone using or disclosing it unlawfully (Art. 4(4)), which reaches an AI buyer receiving customer or supplier secrets inside a company archive.
On the seller side, records held under a customer's or supplier's confidentiality clause are not the seller's to disclose (Art. 4(3)(b)). A buyer acting in good faith may be ordered to pay compensation instead of an injunction, capped at the royalties a license would have cost (Art. 13(3)).
The review of such clauses is set out in customer consent and confidentiality clauses before licensing data.
What a Court Can Order: Remedies, Court Confidentiality and the 6-Year Ceiling
Member states must give trade secret holders civil redress (Art. 6), and the Directive fixes what courts can order and the outer limit for claims.
- Limitation: not more than 6 years, with start and suspension set nationally (Art. 8).
- Confidentiality of the secret inside proceedings, with restricted access to documents and hearings (Art. 9(1), (2)).
- Provisional measures and injunctions, including destruction or delivery up of electronic files containing the secret (Arts. 10, 12(1)(d)).
- Damages for actual prejudice, or a lump sum based, at a minimum, on the royalties that would have been due (Art. 14).
- Dismissal of claims where acquisition, use or disclosure served free expression, revealing wrongdoing in the public interest, workers' representation or another legitimate interest (Art. 5).
One Directive, 27 National Laws
The Directive is addressed to the member states (Art. 21), which had to transpose it by June 9, 2018 (Art. 19(1)), so a licensor's claim runs under its national trade secret law.
Art. 1(1) allows more far-reaching national protection within limits. Germany's GeschGehG s.2 Nr. 1 adds a condition the Directive lacks, a legitimate interest in secrecy (checked 2026-11-16). No other national law is described here.
How the Data Act Reuses the Directive's Definition
The Data Act, Regulation (EU) 2023/2854, applying since September 12, 2025, defines "trade secret" and "trade secret holder" by Art. 2(1) and (2) of the Directive (Data Act Art. 2(18), (19)).
For connected-product data, trade secrets are disclosed only after the data holder identifies them, including in metadata, and agrees confidentiality measures with the user or third party (Data Act Arts. 4(6), 5(9)).
Without agreement the holder may withhold or suspend, and in exceptional circumstances refuse (Arts. 4(7), (8), 5(10), (11)). The product-data rules are covered under EU Data Act and AI training data.
Relying on the Directive When Licensing Data: Benefits, Risks, Downsides and Alternatives, Including Not Licensing
The Directive gives a licensor statutory remedies behind its contract, but only for data that meets all three Art. 2(1) conditions, and not licensing remains a valid choice.
Benefits
- Breach of a confidentiality or use clause is also unlawful use (Art. 4(3)).
- Remedies include destruction of electronic copies (Art. 12(1)(d)).
- Damages can be set at a royalty measure (Art. 14(2)).
- Onward recipients who knew or ought to have known are reached (Art. 4(4)).
Risks
- Data shared without a written limit can be acquired lawfully (Art. 3(1)(b)).
- A national limitation period may be shorter than 6 years (Art. 8(2)).
- A good-faith recipient may pay compensation instead of stopping use (Art. 13(3)).
- The exceptions in Art. 5 can defeat a claim.
Downsides
- Protection has to be proven condition by condition (Art. 2(1)).
- Each member state runs its own procedure.
- The Directive has no rule on model training.
Alternatives
- Rely on contract terms alone.
- License only non-confidential data after a rights check.
- Share descriptions or samples under written limits first.
- Not license at all.
None of these routes is required by the Directive, and the options are compared under alternatives to selling data to AI labs, including not selling.
Beyond This Page: US and UK Rules, Other EU Instruments and Seller Steps
The Directive is one of several EU instruments on a training data deal. The parent page on EU rules for AI training data sets it beside the GDPR, the AI Act, the text and data mining exception and the Data Act.
The US federal statute ties protection to reasonable measures as well and gives 3 years from discovery to sue (18 U.S.C. 1836(d), in force 2016-05-11), against the EU ceiling of 6 years, as set out under the Defend Trade Secrets Act and licensed AI training data.
The UK keeps "reasonable steps" in SI 2018/597 reg. 2 (in force 2018-06-09). A comparison of trade secrets in AI data licensing compared across four regimes is planned.
- Law outside the EU: AI training data law by jurisdiction.
- National rules: Germany's rules for licensing data, UK rules for licensing data and Japan's rules for licensing data.
- Seller steps: NDAs before sharing data with an AI buyer, delivering licensed data to an AI buyer, deletion, return and machine unlearning clauses and a rights audit before licensing data to AI companies.
- Related and planned: database right and licensing datasets and sublicensing and onward transfer in AI data licenses.
- The full process: sell or license company data to AI companies.
How This Page Is Sourced and Dated
Every rule here cites the Official Journal text of Directive (EU) 2016/943 or Regulation (EU) 2023/2854 by article, read on 2026-11-17. The methodology page explains how we source, date and check every figure. This page is general information about the Directive, not legal advice for any dataset, contract or dispute.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the EU Trade Secrets Directive?
Directive (EU) 2016/943 sets EU-wide minimum rules against the unlawful acquisition, use and disclosure of trade secrets. It entered into force on July 5, 2016 and had to be transposed by June 9, 2018.
What information counts as a trade secret under the Directive?
Information that is secret, has commercial value because it is secret and has been subject to reasonable steps to keep it secret (Art. 2(1)).
What type of law protects trade secrets in the EU?
Civil law: member states must provide civil redress (Art. 6).
Does licensing a dataset end its trade-secret protection?
Not by itself. The Directive defines the holder by lawful control and has no licensing rule, and protection lasts while the Art. 2(1) conditions hold, so the license must keep the buyer under confidentiality.