The third-party limb is the one an AI license touches, and the text of the section contains no consent mechanism, no notice rule and no form. The wording was read on gesetze-im-internet.de on 2026-11-17.
The page sets out the offence paragraph by paragraph, the licensing reading, what "without authority" leaves open, who can prosecute and by when, and the GDPR consent that sits beside the authorization.
Telecom secrecy, co-determination and staff consent have their own pages, so this page adds only the section 201 layer to AI training data licensing.
What Section 201 StGB Makes an Offence, Paragraph by Paragraph
Section 201 has five paragraphs, and the table lists each conduct with its consequence and its relevance to a call or meeting archive.
Table 1 compares the paragraphs of section 201 StGB as of 2026-11-17, with the source in the last column.
| Provision | Conduct (German term) | Consequence | Relevance to a call or meeting archive | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| § 201(1) Nr. 1 | records the non-publicly spoken word of another on a sound carrier without authority (aufnehmen, unbefugt) | up to 3 years or fine | the recording itself | gesetze-im-internet.de |
| § 201(1) Nr. 2 | uses (gebrauchen) or makes accessible to a third party (zugänglich machen) a recording made as Nr. 1 describes, without authority | up to 3 years or fine | the hand-over in a license (analysis) | gesetze-im-internet.de |
| § 201(2) Nr. 1 | listens with a listening device to non-publicly spoken words not meant for the listener's knowledge, without authority | same penalty ("ebenso") | live monitoring of a call, not a stored archive | gesetze-im-internet.de |
| § 201(2) Nr. 2 | publicly communicates, verbatim or in essential content, words recorded under (1) Nr. 1 or overheard under (2) Nr. 1; punishable only if suited to impair another's legitimate interests; not unlawful if made to safeguard overriding public interests | same penalty | publication, not a private license | gesetze-im-internet.de |
| § 201(3) | a public official or person specially bound to public service violates the confidentiality of the word ((1) and (2)) | up to 5 years or fine | relevant to public-sector archives | gesetze-im-internet.de |
| § 201(4) | attempt | punishable | an attempted hand-over | gesetze-im-internet.de |
| § 201(5) | sound carriers and listening devices used by the offender or a participant | may be confiscated; § 74a applies | the archive media and recording devices | gesetze-im-internet.de |
Section 201a (image recordings) is a different provision and is not covered here.
Which Speech Is Protected: Non-Public Words of Another on a Sound Carrier
The offence protects the "nichtöffentlich gesprochene Wort eines anderen", the non-publicly spoken word of another, and § 201(1) Nr. 1 applies when it is recorded on a Tonträger (sound carrier). Four readings follow from the text (analysis, not a court holding):
- The statute says "of another", so a speaker's own words are not the object of Nr. 1, and a participant who records a call records the other side's words.
- "Non-public" is not defined in the text, and no decision on a call-center or video-meeting setting is in the sources of this page.
- The object is the spoken word as sound, so a text written by hand from memory is not a recording.
- A transcript produced from a recording derives from a recording, and this page states no conclusion on it.
Meeting audio falls under the same words, and the data type page covers meeting recordings and transcripts for AI training.
Recording, Using and Making Available Are Separate Acts
Section 201(1) names three acts, each punished the same way: recording under Nr. 1, and under Nr. 2 using ("gebraucht") or making accessible to a third party ("einem Dritten zugänglich macht") a recording made as Nr. 1 describes.
Section 201(2) Nr. 1 separately covers listening in with an Abhörgerät (listening device) to words not meant for the listener's knowledge, and Nr. 2 covers public communication of recorded or overheard words.
Attempt is punishable under § 201(4).
When an Archive License Is the Act the Statute Describes
Handing a recording to an AI developer is making it accessible to a third party, so § 201(1) Nr. 2 is the limb a license of call or meeting audio touches.
The text of Nr. 2 refers to "eine so hergestellte Aufnahme", a recording made as Nr. 1 describes, and the offence needs the act to be "unbefugt".
The reading this page works with (analysis) is that a recording made without authority and passed on without authority is within Nr. 2. Whether a recording lawfully made for one purpose and then passed to a buyer without the speakers' authorization is within Nr. 2 is not answered by the text, and no decision on it is in the sources.
- A seller that can show authorization for the recording and for the hand-over has the offence questions answered on the document.
- A seller that can show neither should not rely on the second limb being narrow.
The data type page on selling call recordings for AI training holds the market, the buyer requirement that consent covers reuse and the vendor-recorded case.
What "Without Authority" Leaves Open and What the Text Excepts
Section 201 says only "unbefugt", without authority, and does not define it, so the text names no consent mechanism, no notice rule and no form. Three points follow from the text:
- The only exceptions written in the section are in § 201(2) sentences 2 and 3, and they concern public communication: it is punishable only if suited to impair another's legitimate interests, and it is not unlawful if made to safeguard overriding public interests.
- Neither exception covers recording or passing on a recording to a buyer.
- The general necessity defense in § 34 StGB requires a present danger not otherwise avertable and a protected interest that substantially outweighs the one impaired, and a commercial license does not fit that wording (analysis).
No court decision on what authorization means for a call archive is in the sources, so the page states no reading of it beyond the text.
A license plan should rest on documented authorization from each speaker (analysis, not advice). The phrase "all-party consent" is shorthand and not a term of the statute, which writes neither a one-party rule nor a consent rule.
Who Can Prosecute, by When and With What Consequence
Section 201(1) and (2) are prosecuted only on application, and the application must be made within three months of learning of the act and the offender.
Table 2 sets out the enforcement rules for section 201 as of 2026-11-17, with the section of the Criminal Code in the third column.
| Question | Rule | Section | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who starts a prosecution | only on application of the injured person for § 201(1) and (2) | § 205(1) sentence 1 | image recordings under § 201a are treated differently and are not covered here |
| By when | within 3 months, from the end of the day the person learns of the act and the offender; a weekend or holiday end moves to the next working day | § 77b(1), (2) | runs separately for each person entitled (§ 77b(3)) |
| Limitation period | 5 years for acts with a statutory maximum of more than one year up to five years | § 78(3) Nr. 4, (4) | computed from the maxima of 3 years (§ 201(1)) and 5 years (§ 201(3)), both in Nr. 4 (analysis) |
| Consequence | up to 3 years or fine; up to 5 years for officials; confiscation of devices | § 201(1), (3), (5) | no corporate fine is stated in § 201 |
The three-month period runs separately for each person entitled (§ 77b(3)), so every speaker on a recorded call has a clock of their own.
Two Consents on One Call: Authorization Under Section 201 and a GDPR Legal Basis
A speaker's authorization under § 201 and consent under the GDPR answer different questions, and neither replaces the other.
Table 3 compares the two as of 2026-11-17, citing Regulation (EU) 2016/679 and section 201 StGB.
| Question | Section 201 StGB (authorization) | GDPR (consent) |
|---|---|---|
| What the text says | "unbefugt", without authority; not defined | "freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous indication of the data subject's wishes" (Art. 4(11)) |
| Purpose | not addressed in the text | specific purposes (Art. 6(1)(a)) |
| Withdrawal and proof | not addressed in the text | withdrawal at any time, as easy as giving it (Art. 7(3)); the controller must be able to demonstrate consent (Art. 7(1)) |
| Consequence of a breach | criminal, on application (§ 201(1), § 205(1)) | administrative fine up to EUR 20,000,000 or, for an undertaking, 4 % of worldwide annual turnover of the preceding year, whichever is higher, for Arts. 5, 6, 7, 9 (Art. 83(5)(a)) |
The Regulation applies from 2018-05-25. A recording consent that did not name AI training is evidence of authorization to record at best (analysis), and under the GDPR it does not carry a new purpose. The page on the GDPR legal basis for AI training data covers the bases beyond consent.
What Section 201 Does Not Decide
Section 201 settles whether a recording or hand-over is a crime and nothing about who bears the duties of a telecom provider, whether staff representatives must agree, or what employees may be asked.
Telecom secrecy is a different provision: § 3 TDDDG has been in force since 2021-12-01 under its earlier name TTDSG and was renamed on 2024-05-14. It has its own addressees, covered under telecom secrecy under section 3 TDDDG. Three questions stay with other pages:
- whether the employer is a telecom provider at all;
- whether a works council must agree to the recording or export tooling;
- what notice and consent an employee can validly give.
Where a works council exists, technical devices designed to monitor employee behavior or performance need its co-determination under BetrVG § 87(1) no. 6, and the page on works council co-determination under BetrVG section 87 covers exports.
Checks for a German Call or Meeting Archive Before a License
Five checks, in this order, show whether a German call or meeting archive can go forward (questions to put to counsel, analysis):
- Who spoke and in what setting: staff, customers or third parties, and whether the words were non-public.
- What each speaker was told and agreed at the time of recording, and the record of it.
- Whether the planned hand-over is within what they authorized, with a specific purpose and AI training named.
- The GDPR basis and notice for the new purpose.
- Co-determination and telecom questions where staff channels are involved.
Notice for staff sits on employee notice and consent when licensing internal communications.
Benefits, Risks, Downsides and Alternatives for a German Call Archive, Including Not Licensing
Section 201 does not stop a German company from licensing audio it can show was recorded and passed on with the speakers' authorization, and licensing less, or not at all, remains a valid choice.
Benefits
- Documented authorization makes the offence questions answerable.
- A prosecution needs an application by the injured person (§ 205(1)).
- Transcripts de-identified at source may avoid handing over a recording.
Risks
- Up to 3 years or a fine, and confiscation of the carriers (§ 201(1), (5)).
- Each speaker has a separate three-month application window (§ 77b(3)).
- GDPR fines on top (Art. 83(5)(a)).
Downsides
- No court decision on a license of a call archive is in the sources of this page.
- Legacy recordings often carry only a recording notice, which may not reach a hand-over.
Alternatives
- License text-only or de-identified material after removal of the audio.
- License synthetic or newly recorded consented data.
- Wait for documented re-consent from the speakers.
- Do not license the archive.
The page on alternatives to selling data to AI labs sets these out, including not selling.
Beyond Section 201: The German Page, Recording Rules Elsewhere and the Seller Steps
Section 201 is one German layer, and the German overview sets it beside the copyright, staff-data and insolvency rules. The parent page covers Germany AI training data law.
- AI training data law by jurisdiction: recording and privacy law outside Germany.
- Call and meeting recording consent rules by jurisdiction: Germany beside the US states and the EU.
- Austria's rules for licensing data: the Austrian counterpart, § 120 StGB.
- Switzerland's rules for licensing data: the Swiss counterpart, Art. 179ter StGB.
- Germany employee data after the BAG ruling: staff data after BAG 8 AZR 209/21 held § 26(1) BDSG unapplied.
- Biometric data in AI training: when voice data counts as biometric data.
- Should you sell or license your data to AI companies: the decision before any German license.
- Sell or license company data to AI companies: the steps of a sale.
- German insolvency and data sales: when an administrator holds the archive.
How This Page Is Sourced and Dated
Every rule here cites a section of the Criminal Code or an article of the GDPR and the date it was read, 2026-11-17. The method is set out in how we source, date and check every figure. This page is general information about German law, not legal advice for any specific deal.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it a crime in Germany to record a call without consent?
Yes, where the words were non-publicly spoken by another and the recording was made without authority. The penalty is up to three years or a fine (§ 201(1) Nr. 1), and the act is prosecuted on application.
Is passing call recordings to an AI buyer a crime in Germany?
It can be. Using a recording or making it accessible to a third party without authority is the same offence (§ 201(1) Nr. 2), and whether a lawfully made recording is covered is not stated in the text.
Does section 201 StGB cover meeting transcripts?
The section names a sound carrier and the spoken word. This page found no source on a transcript made from a recording and states no answer.
Who decides whether a recording is prosecuted?
The injured person must apply within three months of learning of the act and the offender (§ 205(1), § 77b). The limitation period is five years (§ 78(3) Nr. 4).