
As of November 10, 2026, no Federal Court of Justice (BGH) ruling exists and the two Hamburg judgments stand.
The open question for rightholders is the form of an opt-out: the appeal court held that a reservation is effective only in machine-readable form, and the claimant had not shown that the plain-words reservation in the case met that test.
This page is part of the independent reference on AI training data licensing, is not legal advice, and DataPacts is not affiliated with either party.
All dates and dockets here come from the BGH case notice and the German statutes, checked on November 10, 2026; how figures are sourced and dated is set out on the methodology page.
Kneschke v. LAION at a Glance: Courts, Dockets, Parties and Status
The case is pending at Germany's Federal Court of Justice, which heard the revision on September 3, 2026 and will pronounce its decision on December 17, 2026 at 08:45. The table lists the case facts as of 2026-11-10 with the source of each.
| Field | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Case | Robert Kneschke v. LAION e.V. | BGH case notice I ZR 281/25 |
| Courts | Landgericht Hamburg; Hanseatisches Oberlandesgericht Hamburg; Bundesgerichtshof, I. Zivilsenat | BGH case notice |
| Dockets | 310 O 227/23 (LG); 5 U 104/24 (OLG); I ZR 281/25 (BGH) | BGH case notice |
| Claimant | a photographer | BGH case notice |
| Defendant | LAION e.V., Vereinsregister Amtsgericht Hamburg VR 25085 | laion.ai/impressum; BGH case notice |
| Subject | reproduction of a photograph to build LAION-5B | BGH case notice |
| Defenses | §§ 44b and 60d UrhG | BGH case notice |
| Status | revision pending; hearing 2026-09-03; pronouncement 2026-12-17, 08:45 | BGH case notice (checked 2026-11-10) |
What the Photographer Claimed About the LAION-5B Copy
The photographer claimed that LAION reproduced his photograph without a license when it copied images to build LAION-5B, and LAION defended the copy under the German text and data mining provisions, §§ 44b and 60d UrhG.
The BGH describes LAION-5B as 5.85 billion image-text pairs that hold links and descriptions, not the images themselves.
LAION announced the set on March 31, 2022 and releases its metadata under CC BY 4.0, while the images keep their own copyright. What the dataset contains and under which license is set out on the page about LAION-5B and Re-LAION-5B.
LAION later withdrew and replaced the set. LAION-5B was taken down on December 19, 2023, and LAION released Re-LAION-5B on August 30, 2024 under the Apache-2.0 license, with 5,526,641,167 text-link pairs by LAION's own count.
The two licenses are separate: CC BY 4.0 covers the LAION-5B metadata, Apache-2.0 covers Re-LAION-5B, and neither changes the copyright in the images behind the links.
The third issue in the case record is whether a reservation written in natural language on the website that carried the photograph took the image out of the exception.
The time of use at issue is the second half of 2021, so the question is what a machine could read on the website at that time, not what a publisher could write into a page today. The case turns on the exceptions, not on a license price.
Kneschke v. LAION Rulings, 2024 to 2026
Three courts have handled the case: two Hamburg judgments for LAION and a pending revision at the Federal Court of Justice. The table gives the date, docket and outcome of each as of 2026-11-10.
| Date | Court | Docket | Outcome | Final? | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024-09-27 | Landgericht Hamburg | 310 O 227/23 | claim dismissed | no | BGH case notice |
| 2025-12-10 | Hanseatisches OLG Hamburg | 5 U 104/24 | appeal dismissed: § 44b (reservation not shown machine-readable for the second half of 2021) and § 60d(1); three-step test met | no (revision pending) | BGH case notice |
| hearing 2026-09-03; pronouncement 2026-12-17, 08:45 | Bundesgerichtshof, I. Zivilsenat | I ZR 281/25 | pending | n/a | BGH case notice |
No Federal Court of Justice ruling exists as of 2026-11-10.
Regional Court of Hamburg, September 27, 2024
The Regional Court of Hamburg (Landgericht Hamburg) dismissed the photographer's claim on September 27, 2024, in case 310 O 227/23.
The claimant appealed against the dismissal, and the case moved on to the Higher Regional Court of Hamburg. The judgment is the first of the three entries in the table above, and it is not final, because the appeal court and now the Federal Court of Justice have taken the case further.
This page does not state how the Regional Court split its reasoning between § 44b and § 60d, because the BGH notice sets out the reasoning in the words of the appeal court only.
Higher Regional Court of Hamburg, December 10, 2025: Reservation Form and Research Use
On December 10, 2025 the Hanseatic Higher Regional Court (OLG Hamburg, 5 U 104/24) dismissed the photographer's appeal and held the reproduction justified under § 44b UrhG and, in addition, under the research exception in § 60d(1) UrhG.
Under § 44b(3) UrhG a reservation of rights in an online work is effective only in machine-readable form, and the claimant had not shown that the natural-language reservation was machine-readable at the relevant time of use, the second half of 2021.
On § 60d, the court held the use covered by the research exception as well, and it found the three-step test met.
In one clause, § 60d lets research organisations, cultural heritage institutions and individual researchers mine works without an opt-out, and it excludes organisations controlled by a private company with privileged access (§ 60d UrhG on gesetze-im-internet.de, checked 2026-11-10).
The court gave the three-step test as met. The BGH case notice, checked on November 10, 2026, is the source for this holding. The Article 4 doctrine and the national provisions behind both defenses are covered on the page about the EU text and data mining exception and the opt-out.
The Federal Court of Justice Revision: Hearing and Pronouncement Date
The photographer's revision is pending before the First Civil Senate of the Federal Court of Justice under I ZR 281/25, which held its hearing on September 3, 2026 and has scheduled the pronouncement for December 17, 2026 at 08:45.
The hearing took place on September 3, 2026, and the pronouncement date of December 17, 2026 is the next dated event in the case. Until then the record consists of the notice and the two Hamburg judgments, and nothing else on this page should be read as a forecast.
What is open is whether the Hamburg reading of § 44b(3) and § 60d holds at the highest German court. This page states nothing about the likely outcome, and it will be updated after December 17, 2026.
What the Hamburg Record Means for Holders of Licensable Images and Web Content
For a holder of images or web content, the Hamburg record says that a reservation written only in plain words was not shown to meet the machine-readable requirement of § 44b(3) UrhG for content online in 2021, so the form of an opt-out decides whether it counts.
The protocols that express a reservation in code are described on the page about machine-readable TDM reservations.
The ruling is not final. A holder reading the Hamburg record should keep three points apart: the appeal court's holding on the form of a reservation, its separate holding on research use, and the pending revision that can confirm or change both.
Both Hamburg judgments concern the copy made to build a dataset of links and captions, not a license price, and the BGH pronouncement of December 17, 2026 can change the reading.
The practical consequence for licensing is stated neutrally: a holder who wants to license rather than be mined has to make the reservation machine-readable, and can then negotiate the terms of a license. This page is information, not legal advice.
Tracker updates by email
Where Kneschke Sits Among Other Dataset and Training Cases
Kneschke v. LAION is the case in the tracker that tests a dataset publisher's own copying under the German exceptions, while LAION-5B also appears in a US suit and a UK judgment.
The parent page holds the case tracker of AI copyright lawsuits over training data with every tracked case, docket and status, and the table lists four related cases as of 2026-11-09.
| Case | Court and docket | Link to LAION-5B or the German exceptions | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Andersen v. Stability AI | N.D. Cal. 3:23-cv-00201-WHO | LAION-based training of image models (complaint) | DMCA claims dismissed 2024-08-12 (Dkt. 223), copyright claims survive; discovery | court PDF (archive.org) |
| Getty Images v. Stability AI (UK) | High Court [2025] EWHC 2863 (Ch); Court of Appeal CA-2026-000007 | judgment cites LAION-5B, 5.85 billion URL-text pairs (para 47) | secondary infringement dismissed 2025-11-04; permission to appeal 2025-12-16; appeal pending | caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk |
| GEMA v. OpenAI | Landgericht München I, 42 O 14139/24 | § 44b UrhG and copies in a model | first-instance judgment, not final | justiz.bayern.de |
| Like Company v. Google | CJEU C-250/25 (request lodged 2025-04-03) | Article 4 DSM Directive and LLM training | Advocate General opinion 2026-11-03 (training questions proposed inadmissible; obiter: training as a rule permitted); not binding; judgment pending | curia.europa.eu |
LAION-5B draws on the archive of Common Crawl, which has its own dataset page.
More About Kneschke v. LAION
This section collects the status split and the common questions about the case.
Pending Versus Final: What Is Settled and What Is Still Open
No judgment in the case is final, because the revision is pending; what is settled is the record of the two Hamburg decisions and the BGH's schedule.
| Settled (as of 2026-11-10) | Still open (as of 2026-11-10) |
|---|---|
| Regional Court judgment of 2024-09-27: claim dismissed | Federal Court of Justice outcome |
| Higher Regional Court judgment of 2025-12-10: appeal dismissed | The § 44b(3) form question at the highest court |
| Hearing held on 2026-09-03 | Effect on later AI training, which no instance has decided on this record |
Frequently Asked Questions About the LAION Case
Has the Federal Court of Justice decided Kneschke v. LAION?
No, the pronouncement is scheduled for December 17, 2026 at 08:45 (I ZR 281/25). The hearing took place on September 3, 2026.
Did LAION win in the Hamburg courts?
Yes, the claim was dismissed on September 27, 2024 and the appeal on December 10, 2025.
Both judgments are subject to the pending revision. The full text of the provisions is set out on the page about text and data mining under UrhG sections 44b and 60d.
Who is LAION?
LAION is LAION e.V., a registered non-profit association in Hamburg (Vereinsregister Amtsgericht Hamburg VR 25085). "Gemeinnützig" describes its tax status and is not part of the name. LAION published LAION-5B and, later, Re-LAION-5B.
Does the case decide whether AI training is lawful?
Not on this record. The claims concern the reproduction of a photograph to build LAION-5B, and no BGH ruling exists. The appeal court's holding is limited to the reservation form and the research exception on the facts of 2021.
Is a "no AI" notice on a photo site enough to opt out?
The Higher Regional Court held that the claimant had not shown a natural-language reservation to be machine-readable for 2021, and the BGH has not ruled.
Licensing photos instead of being mined is covered on the page about selling photos and images for AI training. Nothing on this page is legal advice.