DataPacts

Andersen v. Stability AI: Claims, Rulings and Status

Checked

At a glance

Andersen v. Stability AI is a putative class action by visual artists in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California (No. 3:23-cv-00201-WHO), filed on January 13, 2023, alleging that Stability AI, Midjourney, DeviantArt and, since the First Amended Complaint, Runway AI infringed copyrights in registered artworks by copying them to train image models.

Independent reference. Every buyer is covered on the same terms, every figure carries its source and check date, and no buyer pays to be listed or placed higher.

Request an independent introduction

Tell us what data your company holds. We reply with the buyers that fit and what their terms leave out. Your details reach a buyer only after you agree to a named introduction.

IndependentYour details stay with us until you agreeNot selling is a valid outcome

As of November 16, 2026 the case is in discovery under the schedule order of September 28, 2026, which sets the motion hearing for September 29, 2027 and leaves the trial date to be set by the court, no class has been certified and no court has ruled on fair use.

No trial or verdict has taken place, whatever some trackers say, and the claims described here are the artists' allegations, not findings.

Two orders on motions to dismiss, of October 30, 2023 and August 12, 2024, decided which claims go forward: the copyright claims proceed against all four defendants, the Lanham Act claims proceed against Midjourney, and the DMCA claims are gone.

DataPacts is not affiliated with any party and gives no legal advice; this page is part of the independent reference on AI training data licensing.

Dates, dockets and counts here come from the court filings named in each table, read on November 16, 2026, and how figures are sourced and dated is set out on the methodology page.

Andersen v. Stability AI at a Glance: Court, Docket, Parties and Status

No judgment exists in Andersen: two orders on motions to dismiss have narrowed the claims, expert reports are due under the order of September 28, 2026, and the trial date is to be set by the court. The table lists the case facts as of 2026-11-16.

Field Value Source
Case Sarah Andersen, et al. v. Stability AI Ltd., et al. Dkt. 117; Dkt. 223
Court U.S. District Court, N.D. Cal., San Francisco Division Dkt. 759 caption
Docket 3:23-cv-00201-WHO (discovery filings: -WHO (LJC)) Dkt. 223; Dkt. 623
Judges William H. Orrick, J.; discovery: Magistrate Judge Lisa J. Cisneros Dkt. 223; Dkt. 250; Dkt. 623
Filed 2023-01-13 Dkt. 1
Plaintiffs eight artists (named below), putative class Dkt. 442; Dkt. 778
Defendants Stability AI Ltd. (Companies House 12295325, checked 2026-11-09), Stability AI, Inc., Midjourney, Inc., DeviantArt, Inc., Runway AI, Inc. Dkt. 223; Companies House
Operative complaint Third Amended Complaint, 2026-02-27 Dkt. 431
Claims copyright (9 counts), Lanham Act against Midjourney (2 counts) Dkt. 431
Rulings 2023-10-30 (Dkt. 117); 2024-08-12 (Dkt. 223) court orders
Status discovery; 60-day extension of expert report dates requested 2026-09-23, granted 2026-09-28; hearing 2027-09-29; trial date to be set by the court Dkt. 759; Dkt. 764
Class putative; not certified Dkt. 597

Who Is Suing Whom: Eight Artists Against Four Image-Model Developers

Eight artists are plaintiffs in the 2026 filings: Sarah Andersen, Karla Ortiz, Grzegorz Rutkowski, Gregory Manchess, Gerald Brom, Jingna Zhang, Julia Kaye and Adam Ellis (Dkt. 442, Dkt. 778). They sue as a putative class, which means no group of artists has been certified as a class.

The case began with three plaintiffs, Sarah Andersen, Kelly McKernan and Karla Ortiz, against Stability AI Ltd., Stability AI, Inc., DeviantArt and Midjourney (Dkt. 117). The First Amended Complaint, recorded in later filings as filed on November 29, 2023, added seven artists and Runway AI, Inc. as a defendant (Dkt. 223).

On November 21, 2024 the plaintiffs dismissed the DMCA counts of the Second Amended Complaint, and Kelly McKernan and Hawke Southworth withdrew from the action (Dkt. 241).

The notice preserved a request for reconsideration if the Ninth Circuit dropped the "identicality" requirement adopted from Doe v. GitHub, whose DMCA dismissal the Ninth Circuit affirmed on September 16, 2026.

What the Artists Claim in the Third Amended Complaint

The operative complaint is the Third Amended Complaint of February 27, 2026 (Dkt. 431), which pleads nine copyright counts against the four defendant groups and two Lanham Act counts against Midjourney. The table lists each count as of 2026-02-27, and every row is an allegation.

Count Claim Against Rests on Source
One direct infringement by training (Stable Diffusion 2.0, XL 1.0) Stability AI LAION-5B registered works Dkt. 431
Two inducement by distributing models free of charge Stability AI LAION-5B registered works Dkt. 431
Four direct infringement by training Midjourney LAION-400M registered works Dkt. 431
Five direct infringement by training Midjourney LAION-5B registered works Dkt. 431
Seven direct infringement by training Midjourney DataComp xLarge registered works Dkt. 431
Eight Lanham Act false endorsement Midjourney use of artists' names Dkt. 431
Nine Lanham Act vicarious trade dress Midjourney imitations of trade dress Dkt. 431
Ten direct infringement by training (Stable Diffusion 1.5) Runway LAION-5B registered works Dkt. 431
Eleven inducement by distributing Stable Diffusion 1.5 free of charge Runway LAION-5B registered works Dkt. 431
Twelve direct infringement by copying the DreamUp-CompVis model DeviantArt LAION-5B registered works Dkt. 431
Thirteen direct infringement by training the DeviantArt Clip model DeviantArt DreamUp registered works Dkt. 431

Count Three and a second Count Five carry only a heading in the public copy; the DMCA counts of the Second Amended Complaint were Counts Three, Six and Eleven (Dkt. 241).

The court allowed the complaint without opposition on February 25, 2026 and kept the names of datasets that defendants say are undisclosed under seal (Dkt. 429).

The Training Allegations: Registered Works in Public Image Datasets

The artists allege that each defendant copied their registered works by training image models on datasets that contain them: LAION-5B for Stability AI, Midjourney, Runway and DeviantArt, LAION-400M for an early Midjourney model, and DataComp xLarge for Midjourney (Counts One, Four, Five, Seven, Ten, Twelve and Thirteen).

The counts are framed by registered works, such as the "LAION-5B Registered Works", and the putative classes and subclasses follow the same lines. The original complaint alleged that over five billion images were scraped for training through LAION (Dkt. 117), and the page on what LAION-5B contains covers the dataset itself.

The order of June 27, 2025 describes the datasets as LAION-400M with 400 million images and LAION-5B with 5.85 billion, and it also mentions LAION-2B from the Second Amended Complaint (Dkt. 314).

The two inducement counts say Stability AI and Runway distributed Stable Diffusion models free of charge, inviting others to copy (Counts Two and Eleven). DeviantArt is accused of copying a model into its DreamUp product and of training its Clip model (Counts Twelve and Thirteen).

The False Endorsement and Trade Dress Counts Against Midjourney

Two counts accuse Midjourney under the Lanham Act: false endorsement through commercial use of artists' names, and vicarious trade dress violation by profiting from imitations of the artists' work (Counts Eight and Nine).

The counts are brought for the five "Midjourney Named Plaintiffs", Rutkowski, Andersen, Ortiz, Brom and Kaye, as the order of August 12, 2024 recites (Dkt. 223), and that order denied Midjourney's motion against them.

Midjourney pleads nominative fair use and the First Amendment as defenses to these counts (Dkt. 246). These two counts rest on names and on the look of outputs, not on a copy of a training image, so they are separate from the dataset counts above.

Andersen v. Stability AI Docket Entries, 2023 to 2026

Seventeen entries carry the case from the complaint of January 2023 to the October 2026 stipulation that is the latest filing in the public archive. The table lists them as of 2026-11-16, each with its docket number as the source.

Date Entry What it decided or reported Source
2023-01-13 Dkt. 1 complaint, three artists, putative class Dkt. 1
2023-10-30 Dkt. 117 motions granted except Andersen's direct claim against Stability AI; leave to amend Dkt. 117
2023-11-29 Dkt. 129 First Amended Complaint: seven artists and Runway added (date as recorded in later filings) Dkt. 223
2024-08-12 Dkt. 223 copyright and Lanham Act claims survive; DMCA dismissed with prejudice Dkt. 223
2024-10-29 Dkt. 240 discovery stay lifted; trial set 2027-04-05 by jury Dkt. 240
2024-10-31 Dkt. 238 Second Amended Complaint Dkt. 238
2024-11-21 Dkt. 241 DMCA counts dismissed; McKernan and Southworth withdraw Dkt. 241
2024-12-06 Dkt. 244 to 247 answers by all four defendant groups; fair use pleaded Dkt. 244 to 247
2024-12-10 Dkt. 250 all discovery referred to a magistrate judge Dkt. 250
2025-06-27 Dkt. 314 Midjourney need not produce non-LAION datasets Dkt. 314
2026-02-02 Dkt. 409 schedule modified; trial 2027-06-01 Dkt. 409
2026-02-27 Dkt. 431 Third Amended Complaint (leave granted 2026-02-25, Dkt. 429) Dkt. 431
2026-04-21 Dkt. 499 fact discovery to 2026-07-01, depositions to 2026-08-15 Dkt. 499
2026-06-15 Dkt. 597 schedule order; trial 2027-09-20 Dkt. 597
2026-09-23 Dkt. 759 plaintiffs' third motion to modify the schedule (60 days) Dkt. 759
2026-09-28 Dkt. 764 motion granted; hearing 2027-09-29; pretrial and trial to be set by the court Dkt. 764
2026-10-19 Dkt. 778 sanctions motion against DeviantArt resolved; hearing vacated Dkt. 778

The latest entry in the public archive on 2026-11-16 is Dkt. 778.

Judge William H. Orrick granted the motions to dismiss in full on October 30, 2023, except for the direct copyright infringement claim of Sarah Andersen against Stability AI, and gave the artists 30 days to amend (Dkt. 117).

The copyright claims of Kelly McKernan and Karla Ortiz were dismissed with prejudice because their works were unregistered and counsel said they were not asserting them. Andersen's claim was limited to her registered collections, which the complaint pleads as sixteen (Dkt. 117).

The DMCA, right of publicity, unfair competition and breach of contract claims were dismissed with leave to amend. The court denied the motion to strike the class allegations and deferred DeviantArt's special motion to strike under California law.

It described the complaint as "defective in numerous respects" (Dkt. 117). The order gave the plaintiffs 30 days to file an amended complaint, and the First Amended Complaint that followed added seven artists and Runway AI, Inc. as a defendant (Dkt. 223).

The August 12, 2024 Order: Copyright Claims Proceed Against All Four Defendants

On August 12, 2024 the court denied every motion to dismiss the Copyright Act claims, including the inducement claim against Stability AI, and let the Lanham Act claims against Midjourney proceed (Dkt. 223). The table shows the outcome by defendant as of 2024-08-12.

Defendant Copyright Act claims DMCA Other claims Source
Stability AI survive (direct and inducement) dismissed with prejudice unjust enrichment dismissed with leave Dkt. 223
Runway survive (direct and inducement) dismissed with prejudice unjust enrichment dismissed with leave Dkt. 223
Midjourney survive dismissed with prejudice Lanham Act claims survive; unjust enrichment dismissed with leave Dkt. 223
DeviantArt survive dismissed with prejudice breach of contract and implied covenant dismissed with prejudice; unjust enrichment dismissed with leave Dkt. 223

The order covers all four defendants, and each defendant's position is in the table. The DMCA claims fell for every defendant. Unjust enrichment was dismissed with one last leave to amend and does not appear in the Second or Third Amended Complaint, and DeviantArt's breach of contract and implied covenant claims were dismissed with prejudice.

The court wrote that "the plausible inferences at this juncture are that Stable Diffusion by operation by end users creates copyright infringement and was created to facilitate that infringement by design", and that whether this is true "will be tested at a later date" (Dkt. 223). That is a pleading-stage ruling and not a finding of infringement.

No ruling on fair use exists. The defendants pleaded it as an affirmative defense in their answers of December 6, 2024 (Dkt. 244, 245, 246, 247), and the rule itself is set out under fair use and AI training in US law.

Discovery Over Training Datasets, Source Code and Artist Data

Discovery opened on October 29, 2024, when the court lifted its discovery stay, and has been run by Magistrate Judge Lisa J. Cisneros since the referral of December 10, 2024 (Dkt. 240, Dkt. 250, Dkt. 623).

On June 27, 2025 the magistrate judge refused to order Midjourney to produce non-LAION training datasets, holding that the operative complaint at that date was about LAION (Dkt. 314). The Third Amended Complaint of 2026 later added a count over DataComp xLarge.

The court extended fact discovery to July 1, 2026 and depositions to August 15, 2026, and wrote "I do not expect to grant any further extensions to this schedule" (Dkt. 499).

In their motion of September 23, 2026 the plaintiffs state that their forensic experts had worked through about 15 billion image records, that Midjourney produced art and artist datasets of about 25 million image-text pair records on September 11, 2026 after a court order of August 26, 2026, and that extracting Stability AI data held in one cloud location takes eight weeks (Dkt. 759); the court granted the motion on September 28, 2026 (Dkt. 764).

After the referral, the magistrate judge handles disputes over the exchange of electronic data and protective orders, and these are the filings that carry the -WHO (LJC) caption (Dkt. 250, Dkt. 623). The sanctions dispute with DeviantArt over two former employees' depositions was resolved by stipulation on October 19, 2026 (Dkt. 778).

Expert Reports, Class Certification and the September 2027 Hearing

The schedule in force is the order of September 28, 2026 (Dkt. 764), which granted the plaintiffs' motion of September 23, 2026, hears class certification and summary judgment together on September 29, 2027 and leaves the pretrial conference and trial to be set by the court.

The table compares the order of 2026-06-15 (Dkt. 597) with the order of 2026-09-28, as of 2026-11-16.

Step Order of 2026-06-15 Order of 2026-09-28 Source
Fact depositions completed 2026-08-15 not changed Dkt. 597
Opening expert reports 2026-10-09 2026-12-08 Dkt. 597; Dkt. 764
Responsive expert reports 2026-11-16 2027-01-25 Dkt. 597; Dkt. 764
Reply expert reports 2026-12-18 2027-03-11 Dkt. 597; Dkt. 764
Close of expert discovery 2027-02-05 2027-04-12 Dkt. 597; Dkt. 764
Motions for class certification and summary judgment 2027-03-05 2027-06-17 Dkt. 597; Dkt. 764
Oppositions 2027-04-14 2027-07-29 Dkt. 597; Dkt. 764
Replies 2027-05-19 2027-09-03 Dkt. 597; Dkt. 764
Hearing 2027-06-02 2027-09-29 Dkt. 597; Dkt. 764
Pretrial conference 2027-08-23 to be set by the court Dkt. 597; Dkt. 764
Trial 2027-09-20 to be set by the court Dkt. 597; Dkt. 764

The latest entry in the public archive on 2026-11-16 is Dkt. 778, and no later schedule order appears there.

Trial was first set for April 5, 2027 by jury (Dkt. 240), moved to June 1, 2027 (Dkt. 409) and then to September 20, 2027 (Dkt. 597), and the Third Amended Complaint demands a jury (Dkt. 431).

The plaintiffs asked on September 23, 2026 to move the opening expert reports by 60 days and the later dates with them (Dkt. 759), and the court granted the motion on September 28, 2026, adding "I do not expect to grant any further continuances" (Dkt. 764).

A claim that a jury trial began on September 8, 2026 has no support on the docket. The responsive expert reports, once due on November 16, 2026, now fall due on January 25, 2027, and the hearing of September 29, 2027 comes after the old trial date, so no trial date is in force.

What the Andersen Record Shows Holders of Registered Artwork

The Andersen record shows that registration decided who could sue: unregistered works fell out in 2023, and every copyright count in the operative complaint is built on registered works.

The 2023 order dismissed the McKernan and Ortiz copyright claims because their works were unregistered, and the Third Amended Complaint frames each count and class by registered works (Dkt. 117, Dkt. 431). This is a fact about the record, not advice.

Infringement, fair use and class certification are undecided, and no price for training follows from this record. Nothing in the filings states what any defendant paid or would pay for the registered works, and no settlement is on the docket, so the record gives holders neither a valuation nor a forecast.

How artists license, reserve or decline training use is set out on the page for visual artists and illustrators: licensing and opt-out.

Andersen is the artists' case in a group of image-training disputes that also includes Getty Images' suits against Stability AI in the US and the UK and the German case over LAION.

Every tracked case with its docket and status is on the case tracker of AI copyright lawsuits over training data. The table compares five cases as of 2026-11-16.

Case Court and docket Status Source
Getty Images v. Stability AI (US) N.D. Cal. 3:25-cv-06891-TLT stayed until 2027-01-13 (Dkt. 81, 2026-10-30), checked 2026-11-16 court docket
Getty Images v. Stability AI (UK) [2025] EWHC 2863 (Ch); Court of Appeal CA-2026-000007 part heard 2026-11-11, judgment reserved 2026-11-12 Court of Appeal case tracker
Kneschke v. LAION BGH I ZR 281/25 pronouncement set for 2026-12-17 Federal Court of Justice calendar
Disney, Universal and Warner Bros. v. Midjourney C.D. Cal. 2:25-cv-05275-JAK-AJR, filed 2025-06-11 discovery court record
In re Google Generative AI Copyright Litigation N.D. Cal. 5:23-cv-03440 pending; Sarah Andersen among the consolidated plaintiffs court record

The Getty US case is a separate suit by an image library and is stayed until 2027-01-13. Stability AI's licensing and data practices belong on its buyer profile, Stability AI's licensing and acquisition.

More About Andersen v. Stability AI

This section lists what is decided and what is open, and answers the questions the case prompts. It is information, not legal advice.

Decided Versus Still Open in Andersen

The pleadings are settled and the DMCA claims are gone; infringement, fair use, class certification and the trial are open.

Decided Still open
DMCA claims dismissed with prejudice in 2024 and dropped from the later complaints infringement on the merits
Copyright claims survive against all four defendants fair use
Lanham Act counts against Midjourney survive class certification
Third Amended Complaint allowed on 2026-02-25; schedule reset on 2026-09-28 the trial date, to be set by the court

Frequently Asked Questions About Andersen v. Stability AI

Is Andersen v. Stability AI a class action?

It was filed as a putative class action, and no class has been certified. Motions for class certification are due by June 17, 2027 under the order of September 28, 2026 (Dkt. 764).

Has there been a jury verdict in Andersen v. Stability AI?

No, no trial has taken place, and the trial date is to be set by the court. The order of September 28, 2026 (Dkt. 764) is the schedule in force as of November 16, 2026.

Is Kelly McKernan still a plaintiff?

No, she and Hawke Southworth withdrew on November 21, 2024 when the DMCA counts were dismissed (Dkt. 241). The eight current plaintiffs are named in the 2026 filings.

Did the court rule on fair use?

No, the defendants plead fair use as a defense, and no ruling exists as of November 16, 2026. The page on fair use and AI training explains the doctrine.

What is the docket number for Andersen v. Stability AI?

The docket number is N.D. Cal. No. 3:23-cv-00201-WHO. Discovery filings are captioned -WHO (LJC).

Is Sarah Andersen's case against Google the same lawsuit?

No, it is a separate case. She is also among the consolidated plaintiffs in In re Google Generative AI Copyright Litigation, N.D. Cal. 5:23-cv-03440.