On September 16, 2026 the Ninth Circuit affirmed the dismissal of the DMCA section 1202(b) claim (No. 24-7700), the mandate issued on October 8, 2026, and two breach-of-contract claims remain in the district court as of November 17, 2026.
The case is about what the tools output, not about anyone licensing code for training. DataPacts is not affiliated with any party and gives no legal advice; this page is part of the independent reference on AI training data licensing.
Dates, dockets and holdings here come from the Ninth Circuit opinion and the district-court filings named in each table, read on November 17, 2026, and how figures are sourced and dated is set out on the methodology page.
Doe v. GitHub at a Glance: Courts, Dockets, Parties and Status
The DMCA claim is finally dismissed and the contract claims are pending: the Ninth Circuit affirmed on September 16, 2026, and its mandate returned the case to Judge Jon S. Tigar on October 8, 2026. The table lists the case facts as of 2026-11-17.
| Field | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Case | Doe 1 et al. v. GitHub, Inc. et al. | opinion caption |
| Court | U.S. District Court, N.D. Cal., Oakland (Judge Jon S. Tigar) | Dkt. 95; Dkt. 282 |
| Docket | 4:22-cv-06823-JST, consolidated with 4:22-cv-07074-JST | Dkt. 95 fn. 2; Dkt. 273 |
| Appeal | 9th Cir. No. 24-7700 (permission granted in No. 24-6136) | Dkt. 285; Dkt. 286; opinion |
| Plaintiffs | anonymous programmers who published code on public GitHub repositories, putative class | opinion p. 7 |
| Defendants | GitHub, Inc.; Microsoft Corporation (SEC CIK 0000789019); OpenAI entities | opinion caption; SEC EDGAR |
| Filed | not stated | n/a |
| Claims on appeal | DMCA, 17 U.S.C. 1202(b)(1) and (b)(3) | Dkt. 282; opinion |
| Claims remaining | 2 breach-of-contract claims | opinion pp. 7, 9 |
| Ninth Circuit ruling | dismissal affirmed 2026-09-16 | opinion |
| Mandate | 2026-10-08 | Dkt. 297 |
| Status | contract claims pending in district court; no later entry on the public record; no trial date entered as of 2024-08-30 | RECAP listing 2026-11-17; Dkt. 275 |
What the Programmers Claim About Copilot and Codex
The programmers claim that Copilot and Codex, trained on billions of lines of public code including code from public GitHub repositories, sometimes emit their code without the attribution, copyright notices or license terms attached to it when it was published, and that this omission violates 17 U.S.C. 1202(b).
As the opinion recites the complaint, Copilot is a paid subscription service that GitHub and OpenAI developed jointly using a modified version of Codex, and Microsoft owns GitHub and is a major investor in OpenAI. The operative complaint was filed in the consolidated case Doe 3 v. GitHub (No. 4:22-cv-07074-JST) (Dkt. 95 fn. 2).
Section 1202(b) prohibits removing or altering copyright management information (CMI), distributing CMI knowing it was altered, and distributing copies knowing CMI was removed. Under 17 U.S.C. 1202(c), CMI is information "conveyed in connection with copies" of a work.
Which Claims the District Court Dismissed, 2023 to 2024
Judge Tigar dismissed the case in two rounds, first in part on May 11, 2023 (Dkt. 95) with 28 days to amend, and then the section 1202(b) claim with prejudice on June 24, 2024 (Dkt. 253).
The first order granted in part and denied in part the motions of GitHub and Microsoft (ECF No. 50) and of the OpenAI defendants (ECF No. 53), and it addressed Article III standing.
In the Ninth Circuit's account, the DMCA claim was dismissed under Rule 12(b)(6) "first with leave to amend, and then with prejudice", because the district court found the examples of reproduced code were not identical to the originals.
After the two rounds the complaint was "whittled down to three claims: one claim under the DMCA and two claims for breach of contract". OpenAI Investment LLC was voluntarily dismissed without prejudice on July 18, 2024 (Dkt. 263, corrected in Dkt. 264).
The Two Contract Claims Still Pending
The district court denied the motion to dismiss the two breach-of-contract claims, and the Ninth Circuit records that they remain pending. The appeal reached only the section 1202(b) claims, and the contract claims were stayed with the rest of the case (Dkt. 282).
The documents read do not say which licenses or terms each contract claim rests on. The case management schedule of July 11, 2023 (ECF No. 130) set no trial date, as the parties recorded on August 30, 2024 (Dkt. 275).
Doe v. GitHub Docket Entries, 2023 to 2026
Nine entries carry the case from the first dismissal order through the interlocutory appeal to the Ninth Circuit's mandate. The table lists them as of 2026-11-17.
| Date | Court and entry | What it decided or recorded | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023-05-11 | N.D. Cal. Dkt. 95 | motions to dismiss granted in part, denied in part; 28 days to amend | Dkt. 95 |
| 2023-07-11 | ECF No. 130 | case management schedule; no trial date entered | as recorded in Dkt. 275 |
| 2024-06-24 | Dkt. 253 | section 1202(b) claims dismissed with prejudice; motion to dismiss contract claims denied | as recorded in Dkt. 273, Dkt. 282 and the opinion |
| 2024-07-18 | Dkt. 263, 264 | OpenAI Investment LLC dismissed without prejudice | Dkt. 263; Dkt. 264 |
| 2024-09-27 | Dkt. 282 | June 24 order certified for interlocutory appeal; case stayed pending appeal | Dkt. 282 |
| 2024-12-19 | 9th Cir. No. 24-6136 (Dkt. 285) | permission to appeal granted; appeal docketed as No. 24-7700 on 2024-12-23 (Dkt. 286) | Dkt. 285; Dkt. 286 |
| 2026-02-11 | 9th Cir. No. 24-7700 | argued and submitted, San Francisco | opinion p. 2 |
| 2026-09-16 | 9th Cir. opinion (filed below as Dkt. 296) | dismissal affirmed | opinion; Dkt. 296 |
| 2026-10-08 | Mandate (Dkt. 297) | judgment takes effect | Dkt. 297 |
District entries come from the RECAP archive; Dkt. 253 and ECF No. 130 are as recorded in later filings. No district entry after Dkt. 297 was on the public record on 2026-11-17.
The Identicality Question Certified for Appeal
On September 27, 2024 Judge Tigar certified the June 24, 2024 dismissal order for interlocutory appeal under 28 U.S.C. 1292(b), framing the controlling question as whether sections 1202(b)(1) and (b)(3) of the DMCA impose an identicality requirement (Dkt. 282).
The order found a purely legal question of statutory interpretation, a substantial ground for difference of opinion, and a likelihood that an appeal would materially advance the litigation. GitHub, Microsoft (Dkt. 273) and the OpenAI defendants (Dkt. 274) opposed certification.
The ground for difference was a split in the district. In Andersen v. Stability AI (N.D. Cal., August 12, 2024) the court found an identicality requirement, while in Beijing Meishe Network Technology v. TikTok (N.D. Cal., July 23, 2024) the court declined to dismiss on identicality grounds, and no court of appeals had ruled.
The same order stayed the case pending appeal, because if the DMCA claim were revived the plaintiffs might have to redo fact discovery, expert work and class certification, and it ordered the parties to notify the court within 10 days of a Ninth Circuit decision.
A motions panel of Judge Thomas and Judge Tallman granted permission to appeal on December 19, 2024 (No. 24-6136, Dkt. 285), and the appeal proceeded as No. 24-7700 (Dkt. 286).
In Andersen v. Stability AI the court followed Judge Tigar's reasoning and dismissed the artists' DMCA claims with prejudice (Dkt. 223), which that case page covers.
The Ninth Circuit Opinion of September 16, 2026
A Ninth Circuit panel of Judges Sidney R. Thomas, Eric D. Miller and Stanley Blumenfeld, Jr. (a district judge sitting by designation) affirmed on September 16, 2026, in a published opinion by Judge Miller, after argument in San Francisco on February 11, 2026. The table lists the issues as of 2026-09-16 (No. 24-7700).
| Issue | Programmers' position | Panel's holding | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Article III standing | substantial risk that Copilot emits their code without CMI | standing found on the output theory | opinion pp. 11 to 13 |
| Input theory (CMI removed at training) | asserted on appeal | forfeited, not considered | opinion pp. 9 to 11 |
| Output theory (memorized code emitted without CMI) | violates 1202(b)(1) and (b)(3) | no claim: Copilot creates new works that never contained the CMI | opinion pp. 13 to 15, 17 |
| Identicality | requiring it would let copiers evade the DMCA | literal identicality not required; a gloss on "remove", "alter" and "copies"; still no removal alleged | opinion pp. 15 to 17 |
The panel held that Copilot and Codex "do not remove or alter copyright management information (CMI) from a copy of an existing protected work but instead create new works that never contained that information", and the disposition reads "AFFIRMED".
Amicus briefs came from both industry and author groups, among them the Authors Guild, the Electronic Frontier Foundation and Chamber of Progress.
Standing: A Substantial Risk That Copilot Emits the Code
The panel held that the programmers have Article III standing because they plausibly allege a substantial risk that Copilot will reproduce their code without its CMI, a question it reached although the certified question did not mention standing. Jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. 1292(b) extends to the whole certified order.
The complaint cites research that language models emit memorized training data, and it alleges that GitHub's duplicate-detection feature, which lets users block suggestions matching public code in verbatim snippets of 150 characters or more, is "some evidence" that Copilot can emit identical code.
At summary judgment the programmers would need evidence, and the panel did not decide whether the cited evidence would suffice.
Input Theory Forfeited, Output Theory Rejected
The panel separated two theories: an input theory, that CMI was stripped when code was copied into the training data, which it declined to consider as forfeited, and an output theory, that Copilot emits memorized code without CMI, which it rejected on the merits.
On the first, the district court said it did not understand the complaint to assert an input theory, and the programmers did not correct that understanding orally or in writing.
On the merits, the panel held that "remove" and "alter" imply an act on CMI attached to an existing work, while Copilot as alleged learns from existing works and creates new ones.
Identicality as Evidence of Removal, Not a Separate Element
The panel answered the certified question by holding that the DMCA does not require literal identicality: identicality is a gloss on the words remove, alter and copies, not an independent and atextual element of a section 1202(b) claim. A near-identical copy missing the CMI lets a factfinder infer removal (Friedman v.
Live Nation Merchandise, 9th Cir. 2016), while material differences suggest a new derivative work to which the CMI was never attached. The defendants conceded that works need not be literally identical, and the programmers still lost because they alleged no removal from a copy of their work.
In its opinion of September 16, 2026 the panel reasoned that treating any substantially similar output as a section 1202(b) violation would supplant copyright and expose defendants to "potentially ruinous liability", comparing up to USD 25,000 per violation under 17 U.S.C. 1203(c)(3) with USD 30,000 per work for ordinary statutory damages under 17 U.S.C. 504(c)(1). It expressed "no view" on whether the similarity would support a copyright infringement claim.
After the Mandate: Back in the Northern District of California
The Ninth Circuit's judgment took effect when its mandate was filed in the district court on October 8, 2026 (Dkt. 297), ending the appeal and returning the two contract claims to Judge Tigar. The opinion was filed on the district docket on September 16, 2026 (Dkt. 296).
No district-court entry after Dkt. 297 appears in the public RECAP record checked on November 17, 2026, so whether the stay has been lifted, a new schedule set or class certification briefed is not on the record.
The documents read show no petition for rehearing or for certiorari, and this page states neither as a fact.
What the Ruling Means for Holders of Code
The ruling concerns what an AI coding tool outputs, not whether a company may license its own private repositories for training, which is a contract question decided by who owns the code. Third-party open-source code inside a licensed codebase raises a different issue, covered under open-source license contamination when licensing a codebase.
In the Ninth Circuit, a DMCA attribution claim needs alleged removal of CMI from a copy of an existing work, and output that only resembles code is not enough on this record. The ruling does not decide three things:
- whether Copilot output infringes copyright;
- whether training on public code is lawful, because the input theory was not decided;
- the merits of the two contract claims.
Hosting on GitHub does not transfer ownership: GitHub's Terms of Service, effective April 27, 2026, state in section D.3 "You own Your Content". Terms and exports are set out under GitHub repositories, export rights and licenses.
Where Doe v. GitHub Sits Among DMCA 1202 Cases
Among the tracker's training-data cases, Doe v. GitHub is the one with an appellate ruling on section 1202(b), next to news publishers' CMI claims in New York and the artists' case in San Francisco.
Every tracked case sits in the case tracker of AI copyright lawsuits over training data. The table compares the DMCA point in each as of 2026-11-17, with the status as checked on the date in the column.
| Case | Court and docket | DMCA point | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Andersen v. Stability AI | N.D. Cal. 3:23-cv-00201-WHO | DMCA claims dismissed with prejudice 2024-08-12 (Dkt. 223); cited in Dkt. 282 as finding an identicality requirement | discovery as of 2026-11-09 | Dkt. 223 |
| Raw Story v. OpenAI | S.D.N.Y. 1:24-cv-01514-CM; 2d Cir. 25-1756 | 1202(b) claim dismissed for lack of standing 2024-11-07 (Doc. 117) | appeal briefed; no decision as of 2026-11-09 | Doc. 117 |
| The Intercept v. OpenAI | S.D.N.Y. 1:24-cv-01515 (MDL 3143) | 1202(b)(1) claim against OpenAI survives 2025-02-20; claims against Microsoft dismissed | pending in the MDL as of 2026-11-09 | MDL Dkt. 514 |
| In re OpenAI Copyright Infringement Litigation (includes New York Times v. Microsoft, cited by the panel at 777 F. Supp. 3d 283) | S.D.N.Y. 1:25-md-03143-SHS-OTW | 1202(b)(1) claims against Microsoft and all 1202(b)(3) claims dismissed without prejudice 2025-04-04 (Dkt. 514) | summary-judgment briefing; no ruling as of 2026-11-09 | Dkt. 514 |
Microsoft's own data licensing and other proceedings are on the profile of Microsoft's licenses and other proceedings. OpenAI's agreements are on the profile of OpenAI's data partnerships.
More About Doe v. GitHub
This section lists what is decided and what is open, and answers the questions the case prompts. It is information, not legal advice.
Decided Versus Still Open in Doe v. GitHub
The DMCA question is decided for this case; the contract claims and everything after the mandate are open.
| Decided | Still open |
|---|---|
| section 1202(b) claim dismissed with prejudice, affirmed 2026-09-16 | the two contract claims on the merits |
| standing found on the output theory | the stay and the schedule after the mandate |
| input theory forfeited | class certification |
| literal identicality not required in the Ninth Circuit | any copyright infringement question (never pleaded on appeal) |
Frequently Asked Questions About the GitHub Copilot Lawsuit
Is the GitHub Copilot lawsuit over?
No, the DMCA claim is finally dismissed, but two breach-of-contract claims are pending in the district court as of 2026-11-17. The Ninth Circuit's mandate issued on 2026-10-08.
Did the Ninth Circuit revive the DMCA claim?
No, it affirmed the dismissal on 2026-09-16 (No. 24-7700). It held that Copilot and Codex create new works rather than remove CMI from copies.
Did the court decide that Copilot infringes copyright?
No, the panel expressed no view on copyright infringement and decided only the section 1202(b) claim. Fair use is not at issue in this opinion.
Is Doe v. GitHub a class action against Microsoft?
It is a putative class action that names Microsoft with GitHub and OpenAI entities. No class certification ruling appears in the record read.
Is there a damages figure in the case?
No, no amount appears in the court documents read. The opinion of 2026-09-16 cites the statutory ranges only, up to USD 25,000 per violation and USD 30,000 per work.