DataPacts

Raw Story v. OpenAI: Claims, Rulings and Status

Checked

At a glance

Raw Story v. OpenAI is the lawsuit that Raw Story Media, Inc. and AlterNet Media, Inc. filed on February 28, 2024 in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York (No. 1:24-cv-01514) under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, alleging that OpenAI stripped author, title and copyright information from their news articles before using them to train ChatGPT.

Independent reference. Every buyer is covered on the same terms, every figure carries its source and check date, and no buyer pays to be listed or placed higher.

Request an independent introduction

Tell us what data your company holds. We reply with the buyers that fit and what their terms leave out. Your details reach a buyer only after you agree to a named introduction.

IndependentYour details stay with us until you agreeNot selling is a valid outcome

As of November 17, 2026 the complaint was dismissed for lack of Article III standing on November 7, 2024 (Judge McMahon), leave to amend was denied on April 3, 2025, reconsideration was denied on June 18, 2025 (Judge Stein), and Second Circuit appeal No. 25-1756 is briefed with no decision recorded as of 2026-11-09. No court has ruled on whether the use of the articles was lawful.

DataPacts is not affiliated with any party, counsel or the court and gives no legal advice; this page is part of the independent reference on AI training data licensing.

Dates, dockets and quotations come from the court filings named in each table, and how figures are sourced and dated is set out on the methodology page.

The Raw Story Action at a Glance: Court, Docket, Parties and Status

The Raw Story action is a dismissed one-count DMCA case on appeal, and no court has ruled on whether OpenAI's use of the articles was lawful. The table lists the case facts as of 2026-11-17.

Field Value Source
Case Raw Story Media, Inc. and AlterNet Media, Inc. v. OpenAI, Inc. et al. RS Dkt. 1
Court U.S. District Court, S.D.N.Y. (McMahon, J., then Stein, J. after transfer); appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit RS Dkt. 117; RS Dkt. 178
Docket 1:24-cv-01514-CM (later filings 1:24-cv-01514-SHS and -SHS-OTW); appeal No. 25-1756; MDL No. 3143 (1:25-md-03143-SHS-OTW) RS Dkt. 1, 138, 178
Filed 2024-02-28 RS Dkt. 1
Plaintiffs Raw Story Media, Inc.; AlterNet Media, Inc. RS Dkt. 1
Defendants OpenAI, Inc.; OpenAI GP, LLC; OpenAI, LLC; OpenAI OpCo LLC; OpenAI Global LLC; OAI Corporation, LLC; OpenAI Holdings, LLC RS Dkt. 1
Claim one cause of action, 17 U.S.C. 1202(b)(1) RS Dkt. 178
Outcome dismissed 2024-11-07 for lack of Article III standing; leave to amend denied 2025-04-03; reconsideration denied 2025-06-18 RS Dkt. 117, 137, 178
Status appeal No. 25-1756 briefed; no decision recorded as of 2026-11-09 appellate record, last checked 2026-11-09
Settlement none recorded docket record

The Single DMCA Count and the Training Sets the Complaint Names

The complaint pleads one cause of action, removal of copyright management information under 17 U.S.C. 1202(b)(1), against seven OpenAI entities.

Copyright management information (CMI) is, in the statute's terms and the complaint's, information such as the author's name, the title, the copyright notice and the terms of use that travels with a work (17 U.S.C. 1202(c)).

Microsoft is not a defendant in this action. According to the complaint, Raw Story Media, Inc. is a Massachusetts corporation and AlterNet Media, Inc. a Delaware corporation, and both have their headquarters in Miami Beach, Florida.

The complaint makes three allegations, which are the plaintiffs' words and not findings:

  • the training sets were WebText, WebText2 and Common Crawl;
  • "thousands" of the plaintiffs' articles were stripped of author, title and copyright information before being input;
  • an earlier version of ChatGPT produced plagiarized content, as shown by a study the complaint attributes to Copyleaks.

WebText is the training set that OpenAI described for GPT-2, and the open reproduction of it has its own page on what the open reproduction of WebText holds. The plaintiffs describe themselves as publishers of "more than 400,000" articles, which is their own count.

The complaint of February 28, 2024 asks for actual damages and profits or statutory damages of no less than USD 2,500 per violation, and for an injunction requiring the removal of the stripped copies from the training sets.

Section 1203(c)(3)(B), as in force on 2026-11-17, sets statutory damages for a CMI violation at USD 2,500 to USD 25,000 per violation. These are requests, and the court granted neither.

Raw Story Docket Entries, 2024 to 2025

Eleven docket entries carry the action from the February 2024 complaint to the June 2025 order refusing reconsideration. The table lists them as of 2026-11-17, where "RS Dkt." is the entry number on the Raw Story docket 1:24-cv-01514.

OpenAI moved to dismiss the whole complaint, arguing among other grounds that it showed no Article III injury because it did not allege that the defendants disseminated copies of the articles without CMI, and the plaintiffs opposed.

Date Entry What it shows Source
2024-02-28 RS Dkt. 1 complaint, one count under 1202(b)(1) court PDF
2024-04-29 RS Dkt. 68 OpenAI's motion to dismiss (date as cited in RS Dkt. 119) court PDF
2024-05-13 RS Dkt. 70 plaintiffs' opposition (date as cited in RS Dkt. 119) court PDF
2024-11-07 RS Dkt. 117 decision and order: dismissed for lack of standing; replead request denied without prejudice court PDF
2024-11-21 RS Dkt. 118 and 119 motion for leave to amend or to continue jurisdictional discovery, with memorandum and proposed amended complaint court PDFs
2024-12-20 RS Dkt. 122 OpenAI's opposition court PDF
2025-01-21 RS Dkt. 127 plaintiffs' reply court PDF
2025-04-03 RS Dkt. 137 order denying leave to amend (recited in RS Dkt. 178; entry image-only) court PDF
2025-04-03 RS Dkt. 138 JPML transfer order entered on this docket court PDF
2025-04-18 RS Dkt. 139 plaintiffs' motion for reconsideration court PDF
2025-06-18 RS Dkt. 178 opinion and order denying reconsideration under Rule 60(b)(6) court PDF

Some entries after the April 2025 transfer, such as RS Dkt. 156 and 178, carry the MDL caption 1:25-md-03143-SHS-OTW. For membership, cross-cutting orders and schedule, see the parent page on In re OpenAI Copyright Infringement Litigation.

Why Judge McMahon Found No Article III Injury

Judge McMahon's decision of November 7, 2024 (RS Dkt. 117) held that the plaintiffs had no Article III standing for either damages or an injunction, and did not reach OpenAI's alternative argument that the complaint failed to state a claim.

On damages, the court applied TransUnion LLC v. Ramirez, 594 U.S. 413 (2021). It was "not convinced that the mere removal of identifying information from a copyrighted work, absent dissemination, has any historical or common-law analogue."

Section 1202 protects the integrity of CMI, not the owner's right to control how a work is changed, and the complaint did not allege that a copy without CMI was disseminated by ChatGPT to anyone.

On the injunction, the court accepted that a risk of future harm can ground injunctive relief if the risk is substantial.

It found the likelihood that ChatGPT would output plagiarized content from one of the plaintiffs' articles "remote" given the quantity of information in its repository, and held that third-party statistics about an earlier version did not plausibly allege a substantial risk from the current one.

The opinion then states "what is really at stake": the injury the plaintiffs truly sought to redress was OpenAI's use of their articles to develop ChatGPT without compensation, which is not the type of harm that Section 1202(b)(1) elevates to a legally cognizable injury.

In the court's words, "whether there is another statute or legal theory that does elevate this type of harm remains to be seen."

The court added that it was skeptical the plaintiffs could plead a cognizable injury, but it was prepared to consider an amended pleading at least for injunctive relief. No fair-use analysis was reached.

The Proposed Amended Complaint and Why Leave Was Denied

The November 7 decision denied the plaintiffs' request to replead without prejudice and required a noticed motion with a proposed pleading, which the plaintiffs filed on November 21, 2024.

The motion (RS Dkt. 118, with a memorandum at Dkt. 119 and a proposed First Amended Complaint attached) argued that the removal was itself copyright infringement on the facts alleged and that OpenAI was unjustly enriched, each said to supply standing.

In the alternative it asked to continue jurisdictional discovery into whether ChatGPT disseminated the articles. OpenAI opposed on 2024-12-20 (Dkt. 122), the plaintiffs replied on 2025-01-21 (Dkt. 127), and notices of supplemental authority followed on 2025-02-24, 2025-03-11 and 2025-03-28 about rulings in other 1202(b)(1) cases.

Judge McMahon denied the motion on April 3, 2025 (Dkt. 137, as recited in the later opinion; the entry is image-only and its reasoning is not stated here). The proposed pleading never became operative: OpenAI's letter of November 25, 2024 describes "no operative complaint" while the motion was pending.

Reconsideration After Transfer and the Second Circuit Appeal

On April 3, 2025, the same day Judge McMahon denied leave to amend, the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation transferred the action to Judge Stein for inclusion in MDL 3143, and on June 18, 2025 he denied the plaintiffs' motion to reconsider her dismissal.

Schedule A of the transfer order lists the action. The plaintiffs moved on April 18, 2025 (Dkt. 139), arguing that the dismissal conflicted with Judge Stein's opinion of April 4, 2025 in the Times action, which found a standing analogue for a similar CMI claim.

In the opinion of June 18, 2025 (Dkt. 178), the court held the dismissal to be a final order, so Rule 60(b)(6) and its "extraordinary circumstances" standard apply.

It called Judge McMahon's order "admittedly inconsistent" with its own Times decision, yet held that disagreement between district judges is not extraordinary, because the plaintiffs can appeal to the Second Circuit, which could resolve the question for the MDL.

The plaintiffs had argued that consistency within a multidistrict litigation justifies relief. The court answered that the interest in consistency, without more, is not an extraordinary circumstance, and it noted that the cases the plaintiffs cited involved interlocutory orders, which Rule 54(b) governs more permissively.

The appeal is No. 25-1756: the appellants' brief is dated 2025-09-05 and the appellees' brief 2025-11-10. No decision is recorded as of 2026-11-09, and the appellate record was not re-checked on 2026-11-17.

What the Standing Ruling Signals to Content Holders

The record shows that the court treated the missing attribution and the lack of payment as separate questions, and it decided only the first. A standing dismissal is not a ruling on the lawfulness of training.

In the table below, other courts let a similar 1202(b)(1) claim against OpenAI proceed, and the court here said that the harm the plaintiffs described, uncompensated use, is not one that Section 1202(b)(1) addresses.

Three items remain pending or open, and none is predicted here:

  • the Second Circuit's treatment of the standing question;
  • whether the district rulings in MDL 3143 and this dismissal stay inconsistent;
  • whether any other statute or theory is pleaded for uncompensated use.

For publishers, the practical point is documentary: what metadata travels with an article, such as author, title, copyright and terms notices, is a matter of record in these cases.

Licensing terms and options sit on the page on news publishers licensing content to AI companies. A pending appeal is not a reason to sell, license or wait, and this page is information, not legal advice.

Five court records put the Raw Story outcome next to the other section 1202 claims over AI training. The tracker holds every case with docket and status, and the case tracker of AI copyright lawsuits over training data is the parent page.

Case Court and docket 1202(b) outcome Page
The Intercept v. OpenAI S.D.N.Y. 1:24-cv-01515 1202(b)(1) against OpenAI survived 2025-02-20 The Intercept v. OpenAI
Daily News v. Microsoft and OpenAI S.D.N.Y. 1:24-cv-03285-SHS 1202(b)(1) against OpenAI survived 2025-04-04 Daily News v. Microsoft and OpenAI
The New York Times v. Microsoft and OpenAI S.D.N.Y. 1:23-cv-11195-SHS-OTW 1202(b)(1) against OpenAI dismissed without prejudice 2025-04-04 The New York Times v. Microsoft and OpenAI
Doe v. GitHub (Copilot) 9th Cir. No. 24-7700 dismissal of the 1202(b) claim affirmed 2026-09-16 Doe v. GitHub (Copilot)
Raw Story v. OpenAI (this page) S.D.N.Y. 1:24-cv-01514 dismissed for lack of standing 2024-11-07; appeal pending n/a

The Intercept action, filed the same day against OpenAI, kept its 1202(b)(1) claim against OpenAI after the Raw Story dismissal, and its own page on The Intercept v. OpenAI sets out how the court reached that result.

More About the Raw Story Lawsuit

Pending Versus Decided in the Raw Story Action

The dismissal for lack of standing, the denial of leave to amend and the denial of reconsideration are decided; the Second Circuit appeal is not.

  • Decided: 2024-11-07 (Dkt. 117), 2025-04-03 (Dkt. 137), 2025-06-18 (Dkt. 178).
  • Pending: appeal No. 25-1756, no decision recorded as of 2026-11-09. No settlement is recorded.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Raw Story Lawsuit

Was the Raw Story lawsuit dismissed?

Yes, Judge McMahon dismissed the complaint on November 7, 2024 for lack of Article III standing, without ruling on the merits. The court denied leave to amend on April 3, 2025, and Judge Stein denied reconsideration on June 18, 2025.

Is Raw Story part of the OpenAI multidistrict litigation?

Yes, the action was transferred into MDL 3143 on April 3, 2025 (Schedule A), but the dismissal was entered before the transfer and stayed in place. Judge Stein decided the later reconsideration motion in the MDL.

Did Raw Story appeal?

An appeal, No. 25-1756, is briefed in the Second Circuit; no decision is recorded as of 2026-11-09. The appellants' brief is dated 2025-09-05 and the appellees' brief 2025-11-10.

Did the court decide whether OpenAI used the articles lawfully?

No, the court decided only that the plaintiffs lacked standing to sue under Section 1202(b)(1) and did not decide whether the use of the articles was lawful. No fair-use ruling exists in this action.