DataPacts

In re Google Generative AI Copyright Litigation and Hachette v. Google: Gemini Training Claims and Status

Checked

At a glance

In re Google Generative AI Copyright Litigation is a consolidated putative class action in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California (No. 5:23-cv-03440-EKL) over Google's use of books and images to train Gemini, Imagen and earlier models, and as of November 17, 2026 the motion to certify a class is pending, the case is stayed and no ruling on infringement or fair use exists.

Independent reference. Every buyer is covered on the same terms, every figure carries its source and check date, and no buyer pays to be listed or placed higher.

Request an independent introduction

Tell us what data your company holds. We reply with the buyers that fit and what their terms leave out. Your details reach a buyer only after you agree to a named introduction.

IndependentYour details stay with us until you agreeNot selling is a valid outcome

Hachette Book Group, Cengage, Elsevier, an author and his company filed a separate class action against Google in New York on July 10, 2026 (S.D.N.Y. No. 1:26-cv-05870-LAP), where Google has asked for a transfer to California.

This page belongs to the independent reference on AI training data licensing, is not affiliated with any court, party or counsel and gives no legal advice.

The facts below come from the court documents, each with its docket entry. The documents read run to November 9, 2026 for the California docket and to November 4, 2026 for the New York docket, and how figures are sourced and dated is set out on the methodology page.

Google Generative AI Copyright Litigation at a Glance: Court, Docket, Parties and Status

The California case is pending, with discovery closed and stayed and one motion, class certification, awaiting decision. The table lists the case facts as of 2026-11-17 with the court document behind each.

Field Value Source
Case In re Google Generative AI Copyright Litigation, master file, consolidating Leovy et al. v. Google LLC and Zhang et al. v. Google LLC Dkt. 216
Court U.S. District Court, N.D. Cal., San Jose Division GovInfo record
Docket 5:23-cv-03440-EKL (originally 3:23-cv-03440-AMO; Zhang 5:24-cv-02531) Dkt. 478, Dkt. 216
Judges Eumi K. Lee, U.S.D.J.; Susan van Keulen, U.S.M.J. (discovery) Dkt. 216, Dkt. 139
Filed 2023-07-11 (Leovy, Dkt. 1); Zhang filed 2024-04-26 Dkt. 216; Dkt. 478
Named plaintiffs Steve Almond, Sarah Andersen, Burl Barer, Jessica Fink, Kirsten Hubbard, Hope Larson, Mike Lemos, Jill Leovy, Connie McLennan, Jingna Zhang Dkt. 216
Defendants Google LLC; Alphabet Inc. (vicarious claims dismissed with prejudice); the GovInfo party list also names Google DeepMind and XXVI Holdings Inc. Dkt. 216; GovInfo
Objector Evox Productions LLC GovInfo party list
Status pending; discovery closed 2026-02-13 and stayed 2026-02-18; class certification pending Dkt. 421, Dkt. 479
Separate suit Hachette Book Group, Inc. et al. v. Google LLC, S.D.N.Y. 1:26-cv-05870-LAP, filed 2026-07-10 S.D.N.Y. Dkt. 1

What the Plaintiffs Say Google Copied to Train Its Models

Ten visual artists and authors allege that Google copied their registered works into datasets and used them to train language models and the Imagen image model, and they do not allege infringing outputs (Dkt. 216). The works at issue are books and images, and the models named include PaLM, GLaM, LaMDA, Bard, Gemini and Imagen.

For books, the order describes the Infiniset and C4 datasets, which it says include text from Z-Library and oceanofpdf.org. For images, the complaint says Imagen was first trained on LAION-400M and later versions "likely" on LAION-5B, and the page on LAION-5B sets out what those datasets contain.

These are allegations in the complaint and the order records them as such. The vicarious claims against Alphabet Inc. are dismissed with prejudice (Dkt. 216). Leovy claims against Alphabet and DeepMind were also dismissed voluntarily early in the case (Dkt. 13).

Plaintiffs plead that copying works into training datasets and training the models on them infringes their registered copyrights, and Dkt. 216 held the registration allegations and the representative-works pleading sufficient. The court has not decided whether the copying was lawful.

No fair use ruling exists in this case, and Dkt. 216 states that Google's use of the models in products "may inform the fair use analysis at a later stage of the case."

The doctrine itself, with the four factors and the rulings in other cases, is covered on the page about fair use and AI training in US law.

Docket Entries in the Northern District of California, 2023 to 2026

Fifteen docket entries carry the case from the July 2023 complaint to the October 2026 supplemental authority. The table lists them as of 2026-11-17, and the court document behind each is in the source column; the class certification motion is dated by month only because Plaintiffs and Google give different days.

Date Dkt. Entry What it decided or reported Source
2023-07-11 1 Leovy v. Google complaint opens 3:23-cv-03440 Dkt. 216
2024-04-26 Zhang Dkt. 1 Zhang v. Google complaint (5:24-cv-02531) LAION-400M and Imagen claims; later consolidated Dkt. 478
2025-04-21 128 Order granting motion to strike class allegations fail-safe class definition struck; leave to amend GovInfo, court order
2025-05-22 139 Order on discovery dispute (RFP No. 1) granted with a use restriction GovInfo, court order
2025-09-11 216 Order granting motion to dismiss in part ten models and vicarious claims dismissed with prejudice GovInfo, court order
2025-09-25 234 Second amended consolidated complaint operative pleading Dkt. 478
2025-10 251 Motion for class certification Books Class, three subclasses, Images Class Dkt. 418
2025-12-19 311 Order on discovery dispute request to produce evidence identifying works denied GovInfo, court order
2026-02-02 387 Order on three discovery disputes extra depositions denied; discovery to close 2026-02-13 GovInfo, court order
2026-02-18 421 Order regarding deadlines deadlines and discovery stayed; hearing 2026-02-20 RECAP Dkt. 421
2026-04-24 445, 446 Class certification motion and Google's opposition operative motion and opposition RECAP Dkt. 445, 446
2026-08-21 477 Order granting motion to withdraw motion to intervene publishers out; fee request denied RECAP Dkt. 477
2026-08-24 482 Order terminating duplicative motions earlier motions replaced by Dkt. 445 and others RECAP Dkt. 482
2026-09-29 499 Order denying joint discovery letter without prejudice privilege-log dispute, action stayed GovInfo, court order
2026-10-09 502 Plaintiffs' motion to file supplemental authority Third Circuit Ross decision RECAP Dkt. 502

Pleadings: A Class Definition Struck and Claims Narrowed

Judge Lee struck the first consolidated class definition on April 21, 2025 as a fail-safe class and, on September 11, 2025, dismissed claims about ten models and vicarious claims against Alphabet with prejudice (Dkt. 128, Dkt. 216). The ten models are Codey, Chirp, Veo, MedLM, LearnLM, SecLM, Gemma, CodeGemma, RecurrentGemma and PaliGemma.

Dkt. 128 reasoned that membership in the class of Dkt. 91 would turn on whether each member has a valid claim, and gave leave to amend.

Dkt. 216 held the registration allegations and the representative-works pleading sufficient, did not dismiss the request for injunctive relief and ordered a second amended complaint, which Plaintiffs filed on September 25, 2025 (Dkt. 234).

Class Certification: Hearing, Stay and No Ruling Yet

No ruling on class certification appears in the court documents read through November 9, 2026, and the case has been stayed since February 18, 2026 so that the motion can be decided first (Dkt. 421).

A ruling after that date is not excluded by the documents read, so a reader needing the current state should check the docket itself.

Plaintiffs moved for certification in October 2025 (Dkt. 251), and the hearing was set for February 20, 2026 (Dkt. 418, Dkt. 421).

Google's New York letter says the motion was argued in February 2026 (S.D.N.Y. Dkt. 28), but no transcript was read. The operative motion is Dkt. 445 of April 24, 2026, and Dkt. 482 terminated the earlier filings as duplicative.

Google's opposition of the same day (Dkt. 446) argues that the class definitions are improper, that ownership, registration, defenses and damages raise individual questions, that a class is not the superior method, and that injunctive and issue classes should be denied.

Plaintiffs filed the Third Circuit decision in Thomson Reuters v. Ross of September 29, 2026 as supplemental authority (Dkt. 502), and Google does not oppose filing it (Dkt. 503).

Google's motion for sanctions under Rules 16(f) and 37(c) over the class definitions (Dkt. 463, April 24, 2026) has no ruling in the documents read. The Ross opinion held that use of 2,243 headnotes was not fair use and noted that the AI at issue was not a generative AI (3d Cir. No. 25-2153).

Discovery Orders and the Stay

Fact discovery closed on February 13, 2026 and was stayed with the other deadlines five days later (Dkt. 387, Dkt. 421). Dkt. 387 denied six more depositions beyond the ten per side in the case management order, noting that nine had been taken.

The orders matter for class certification because the datasets, not the source corpora, determine which works can be class works. Dkt. 311 held that only the training datasets show which works were used, not source corpora, and denied a request for evidence identifying them.

The district judge denied Plaintiffs' motions for relief from both orders on August 24, 2026 (Dkt. 479, Dkt. 481). Sealing orders of November 10, 2025 and March 11, 2026 protect dataset composition, deposition excerpts, Google's privilege log and the class certification record (Dkt. 274, Dkt. 438).

The Publishers' Intervention Withdrawn and a New Motion by Textbook Authors

Cengage and Hachette moved in January 2026 to intervene and lead any class (Dkt. 342), withdrew the motion on July 10, 2026 to pursue their own New York case, and Judge Lee granted the withdrawal on August 21, 2026 (Dkt. 477).

The publishers are therefore not parties to the California case, and any earlier description of them as intervenors is out of date.

The motion to withdraw was filed in the California case on July 10, 2026, the same day as the New York complaint (Dkt. 473 to 475). The order denied Google's request for fees and called the New York filing "3,000 miles away" a tactic that "will surely duplicate efforts and waste judicial and party resources."

On September 28, 2026 textbook authors and a company moved to intervene (Dkt. 490), and Google says the motion is untimely. Briefs were filed on October 19, 2026 (Dkt. 504, Dkt. 505), and the motion has no ruling in the documents read.

Hachette Book Group v. Google in the Southern District of New York

Hachette Book Group, Cengage Learning and Elsevier, with the author Scott Turow and his company S.C.R.I.B.E., Inc., sued Google on July 10, 2026 in the Southern District of New York (No. 1:26-cv-05870-LAP, Judge Preska) as a putative class action over Gemini.

The complaint (Dkt. 1) alleges that books and journal articles obtained for limited use in Google Books and other services, plus web scrapes, were copied again to train Gemini, and it adds a claim for removal of copyright management information.

The complaint is 57 pages and the putative class is pleaded in its paragraph 139.

Plaintiffs say the California class leaves out works copied but not used to train, U.S. copyrights owned by foreign rightsholders, academic and research journals, and the removal claim (Dkt. 31). These are Plaintiffs' characterizations. The table lists eight docket entries as of 2026-11-17.

Date Dkt. Entry What it says Source
2026-07-10 1 Class action complaint Hachette, Cengage, Elsevier, Turow and his company v. Google; copyright infringement and CMI removal (Gemini) S.D.N.Y. Dkt. 1
2026-08-10 26 Google's reply on its request for a pre-motion conference seeks transfer to N.D. Cal. Dkt. 26
2026-08-21 28 Google's request for a pre-motion conference seeks stay pending transfer; cites Dkt. 477 Dkt. 28
2026-08-26 31 Plaintiffs' response opposes stay; lists claims outside the California class Dkt. 31
2026-08-27 32 Google's reply stay and burden arguments Dkt. 32
2026-09-08 36 Letter from N.D. Cal. co-lead counsel (dated 2026-08-31) asks for remote access to the 2026-10-08 hearing Dkt. 36
2026-09-29 37 Google's notice of developments Elsevier v. Meta transferred 2026-09-25; textbook authors' motion Dkt. 37
2026-11-04 52 Order on joint letter (Dkt. 51, filed 2026-11-03) briefing on Google's motion to dismiss (Dkt. 49) extended Dkt. 52

Google asks the court to transfer the case to the Northern District of California and to stay it meanwhile (Dkt. 21, Dkt. 26, Dkt. 28), citing Judge Castel's transfer of Elsevier v.

Meta on September 25, 2026 (Dkt. 37). Plaintiffs, who describe their own suit as covering claims the California class does not, oppose (Dkt. 25, Dkt. 31), and Google's reply argues stay and burden points (Dkt. 32).

A hearing before Judge Preska was set for October 8, 2026 (Dkt. 36). Google moved to dismiss on October 29, 2026 (Dkt. 49, as cited in Dkt. 51), and Judge Preska extended the briefing on November 4, 2026 (Dkt. 52). No transfer or stay order was read, so the status is open.

The Proposed Classes: Books, Subclasses and Images

Plaintiffs ask the court to certify a Books Class with three subclasses and an Images Class, and none has been certified. The table lists the class definitions in the pleadings and the motion as of 2026-11-17.

Pleading or motion Date Class as defined Source
Leovy second amended complaint (Dkt. 47) 2024-06-27 U.S. owners of a U.S. copyright in any work used as training data for Google products Dkt. 418
Amended consolidated complaint (Dkt. 91) 2024-12-20 registered owners whose rights Google infringed (struck as fail-safe) Dkt. 128
Second amended consolidated complaint (Dkt. 234) 2025-09-25 U.S.-domiciled owners of a U.S. copyright in any work used to train Google's models Dkt. 478
Books Class (Dkt. 253-1 as quoted in Dkt. 418) October 2025 registered owners of ISBN works downloaded or ingested for GLaM, LaMDA, PaLM, PaLM 2, Imagen or Gemini base models Dkt. 418
Google Books Library Project Subclass October 2025 ISBN works acquired through that project and used for those models Dkt. 418
Google Books Partner Program Subclass October 2025 ISBN works acquired through that program and used for those models Dkt. 418
Pirated Books Subclass October 2025 ISBN works with URL provenance from shadow libraries Dkt. 418
Images Class October 2025 registered owners of two-dimensional images used for Imagen and Gemini base models Dkt. 418

No class has been certified as of 2026-11-17. Because the classes are proposed, no work is yet in or out of a class by court order. The proposed classes cover registered works only, registered within five years of publication before training or within three months of publication.

The Pirated Books Subclass rests on works with provenance in shadow libraries, which the page on pirated books and shadow libraries in AI training explains, and four definitions were proposed between 2024 and 2025.

What the Record Shows About Licensing and Sourcing Evidence

The court record treats licensing as evidence in the case, not as a settlement price: no settlement exists, so it fixes no per-work value. Three entries show where licensing matters.

Dkt. 139 allowed Google to use the account email addresses Plaintiffs used to check whether they licensed works to Google, which the order calls "a potentially significant issue for class certification." Dkt. 387 records Google's showing that licensing and pricing for content acquisition was covered by three custodians and three depositions.

The Google Books Partner Program subclass exists because some books came through partner programs, and how such books are licensed and disputed is covered on the page about books as AI training data.

Google's sealing rationale, accepted in Dkt. 274, is that dataset details and negotiations with content partners are confidential. The case therefore supplies no price per work. License prices appear on the page about AI training data prices per work, and nothing in this record changes them.

The Google case is one of four tracked suits in which the same court or the same plaintiffs' bar is also handling a related training-data claim. Every tracked case with docket and status is on the case tracker of AI copyright lawsuits over training data, and the table lists the related ones as of 2026-11-17.

Case Court and docket Status Page
EVOX Productions LLC v. Google LLC N.D. Cal. 5:26-cv-07013-EKL related to this case and reassigned to Judge Lee on 2026-09-09 (Dkt. 22); response due 2026-11-25 EVOX Productions v. Google
Bartz v. Anthropic PBC N.D. Cal. 3:24-cv-05417-AMO final approval and judgment 2026-07-20 (Dkt. 680) Bartz v. Anthropic
Kadrey v. Meta Platforms N.D. Cal. 3:23-cv-03417-VC training claim decided for Meta on its record 2025-06-25 (Dkt. 598); related cases coordinated Kadrey v. Meta
Elsevier et al. v. Meta Platforms and Mark Zuckerberg N.D. Cal. 3:26-cv-11415-VC (from S.D.N.Y. 1:26-cv-03689) transferred 2026-09-25; no trial date none

How Google acquires training data and its other programs are on the profile of Google as a data buyer.

Pending Versus Final: What Is Decided and What Is Open

The pleading rulings of 2025 are decided; class certification, the intervention motion, the sanctions motion and the New York transfer are open.

  • Decided: the class definition of Dkt. 91 struck (2025-04-21); claims about ten models and vicarious claims against Alphabet dismissed (2025-09-11); the publishers' withdrawal granted (2026-08-21); relief from two discovery orders denied (2026-08-24).
  • Open: class certification (Dkt. 445); the textbook authors' motion to intervene; Google's sanctions motion (Dkt. 463); transfer, stay and Google's motion to dismiss in S.D.N.Y.

Has the court certified a class against Google?

No. The motion is pending and no ruling appears in the documents read through November 9, 2026.

No. No merits ruling exists, and the 2025 orders dealt with the pleadings.

Is Hachette v. Google the same case as In re Google Generative AI?

No. It is a separate S.D.N.Y. suit filed on July 10, 2026, the day the publishers moved to withdraw from the California case, and Google seeks transfer.

Is Sarah Andersen's case against Google the same as her case against Stability AI?

No. She is a named plaintiff in both, and the Stability case has its own page, Andersen v. Stability AI.

Is there a settlement or a trial date?

None appears in the documents read. The deadlines are stayed (Dkt. 421).

This page is information, not legal advice.