As of November 17, 2026 all four are pending, only the Stanford case is past the pleadings, and its jury trial is set for May 3, 2027.
No court has ruled on fair use or on damages in any of the four.
Every claim below is EVOX's allegation unless an order is cited, DataPacts is not affiliated with any party and gives no legal advice, and the case belongs to the wider independent reference on AI training data licensing. How figures are sourced and dated is set out on the methodology page.
The Four EVOX Productions Lawsuits at a Glance: Courts, Dockets and Status
The four suits run in two federal districts before four judges, and only the oldest, against Stanford, has an answer on file and a trial date. The table compares them as of 2026-11-17, using the latest archived entry for each docket.
| Case | Court and docket | Filed | Defendants | Claims | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EVOX Productions, LLC v. The Leland Stanford Junior University | N.D. Cal., San Jose, 5:24-cv-09521-NW (Wise, J.) | 2024-12-31 | Stanford (originally also Rice, Michigan, Baylor) | direct and contributory copyright infringement | discovery; answer and first amended answer filed; jury trial set 2027-05-03 | Dkt. 1, Dkt. 90 |
| EVOX Productions, LLC v. Stability AI, Inc. et al. | C.D. Cal., 2:26-cv-07201-SVW-DMK (Wilson, J.) | 2026-07-02 | three Stability AI entities, Runway AI, Hugging Face, DeviantArt | training, outputs, distribution, contributory, 17 U.S.C. 1202 | four motions to dismiss filed; status conference 2026-12-07 | Dkt. 1, Dkt. 91 |
| EVOX Productions, LLC v. Google LLC | N.D. Cal., 5:26-cv-07013-EKL (Lee, J.) | 2026-07-09 | Google LLC | unlicensed copies, license scope, outputs, 17 U.S.C. 1202(b)(1) (amended complaint) | related to the Google generative AI litigation; response due 2026-11-25 | Dkt. 1, Dkt. 29 |
| EVOX Productions LLC v. Midjourney, Inc. | C.D. Cal., 2:26-cv-08408-JAK-E (Kronstadt, J.) | 2026-07-30 | Midjourney, Inc. | training, contributory, 17 U.S.C. 1202(b) | motion-to-dismiss hearing set 2026-12-07 | Dkt. 1, Dkt. 26 |
EVOX v. Stanford: Car Photos in the Stanford Cars Research Dataset
EVOX v. Stanford is a copyright case about a research dataset: EVOX says a university team gathered its car photographs online, built the "Stanford Cars Dataset" from them and made the files downloadable. Four universities and Does 1-10 were sued at filing, and Stanford alone remains before Judge Noël Wise (Dkt. 55, 78).
What EVOX Alleges About the Stanford Cars Dataset
EVOX alleges that around September 2020 it found that researchers from Stanford, the University of Michigan, Baylor College of Medicine and Rice University had collected vehicle images online, including its registered photographs, to develop a computer program.
It says 11,364 images were made available from links on a Stanford website and 7,875 of them match its registrations, and that a second set of 225 images was available as recently as January 2023 and later on sites such as tensorflow.org, kaggle.com and pytorch.org (Dkt. 1).
The complaint pleads direct and contributory infringement and names no individual researcher and no company as a defendant.
The parties signed a tolling agreement effective May 31, 2023 and held a mediation on April 25, 2024 before suing (Dkt. 1; Dkt. 87). How institutions license research data to AI developers, apart from this case, is covered on the page about universities and research groups licensing data.
Three Pleading Rulings That Narrowed the Stanford Case, 2025 to 2026
Judge Wise ruled three times on motions to dismiss without a hearing, and each ruling cut the case down without reaching the merits. The table lists the three orders as of 2026-03-03.
| Order | Date | Motion | Outcome | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Order granting joint motion and granting in part Stanford's motion | 2025-07-23 | Rice and Baylor (Dkt. 29); Stanford (Dkt. 28) | standing upheld; Rice and Baylor dismissed for lack of personal jurisdiction without leave; direct infringement kept; contributory dismissed with leave; Rule 8(a) motion denied | Dkt. 55 |
| Order granting motion with leave to amend | 2025-10-30 | Stanford (Dkt. 58) against the first amended complaint | material-contribution theory sufficient at the pleading stage; inducement theory dismissed with leave | Dkt. 65 |
| Order granting motion to dismiss second amended complaint | 2026-03-03 | Stanford (Dkt. 68) | inducement theory dismissed without leave to amend; answer due in 14 days | Dkt. 74 |
Orders of Judge Noël Wise, N.D. Cal. 5:24-cv-09521-NW. None decides fair use.
Standing rests on EVOX's lost licensing fee, which the court said "plausibly alleges a monetary harm" (Dkt. 55).
Fair use was set aside as "inapplicable" at the pleading stage (Dkt. 55), and the third order "makes no determination" on it (Dkt. 74 n. 3). The University of Michigan left earlier by EVOX's own dismissal (Dkt. 20).
Stanford's Defenses, the Damages Dispute and the Trial Date
Stanford answered on March 31, 2026, denying infringement and pleading eleven affirmative defenses, among them that EVOX owns no protectable rights and that any use was fair use under 17 U.S.C. 107; an amended answer accepted on October 13, 2026 adds a limitations defense under 17 U.S.C. 507(b) (Dkt. 77, 90).
In a joint filing Stanford states that the images served research published in PNAS on December 12, 2017 and that the data was shared for peer review under academic-use terms (Dkt. 87, Stanford's statement).
Whether training on such images is fair use is the question treated on the page on fair use and AI training in US law.
In the joint filing of September 25, 2026, EVOX counts at least 8,100 works and a statutory minimum of USD 6,075,000, and says damages can reach USD 150,000 per work if infringement is willful (Dkt. 87, EVOX's position). Stanford seeks remission of damages under 17 U.S.C. 504(c)(2), fees and summary judgment.
The order of April 9, 2026 sets dispositive motions for December 18, 2026, a hearing on February 17, 2027 and a four-day jury trial on May 3, 2027 (Dkt. 78).
The parties proposed later dates on September 25, 2026 (Dkt. 87), and no order adopting them is in the record read. A mediation was set for October 21, 2026 and its result is not stated here.
EVOX v. Stability AI, Runway, Hugging Face and DeviantArt: Link Lists and a Hosted Copy
EVOX sued three Stability AI entities, Runway AI, Hugging Face and DeviantArt in the Central District of California on July 2, 2026 (No. 2:26-cv-07201-SVW-DMK), with five counts: AI training, generated output images, distribution, contributory infringement and removal of copyright management information under 17 U.S.C. 1202 (Dkt. 1).
EVOX alleges that the LAION-2B-en list links to at least 103,957 of its registered photographs on licensed automotive sites, many marked "©EVOX IMAGES", and that Stable Diffusion, Runway Gen-4 and DreamUp were trained on them. It asks for an injunction, actual or statutory damages and fees, and pleads no amount (Dkt. 1).
EVOX also alleges that Hugging Face hosts a copy of the Stanford Cars dataset with 8,144 images, 225 of them EVOX photographs, downloaded at least 90,000 times (on information and belief).
The Stanford complaint also counts 225 images, and the two lists were not compared here. What the link lists contain is covered on the page about the LAION-5B and Re-LAION-5B datasets.
Hugging Face moved to dismiss on October 5, 2026 (Dkt. 58), and the Stability entities, Runway and DeviantArt did so on October 12, 2026 (Dkt. 70 to 72). The movants argue, among other things, fair use, a limitations bar and that a photographic "look" is not protected (Dkt. 70, the movants' arguments).
The case was reassigned to Judge Stephen V. Wilson on November 5, 2026 (Dkt. 91), with a status conference on December 7, 2026 (Dkt. 92). A motion to disqualify EVOX's counsel is pending beside a substitution request (Dkt. 85, 96).
EVOX v. Google: A Licensee Accused of Going Beyond Its License
Unlike the other defendants, Google held an EVOX license: EVOX states that Google licensed its images, spins and interior panoramas for model years 2017 to 2021 in January 2020, extended the image license to later model years in July 2020, and did not extend it to later spins and panoramas (Dkt. 1). EVOX alleges that Google:
- reproduced, distributed and displayed 3,522 unlicensed images;
- reproduced more than 200,000 other unlicensed images;
- used licensed content for Nano Banana Pro and Google Ads although section 2.2(e) says "Licensed Content will not be offered to AdWords customers as a creative asset";
- used 16,008 images linked in LAION-400M to train Imagen 1.
The court related the case to In re Google Generative AI Copyright Litigation and reassigned it to Judge Eumi Lee on September 9, 2026 (Dkt. 22). EVOX is listed as an objector in that consolidated case, which has its own page, In re Google Generative AI Copyright Litigation.
EVOX filed an amended complaint on October 23, 2026 with five counts, adding output infringement and narrowing the copyright management information count from 17 U.S.C. 1201-1205 to 1202(b)(1) (Dkt. 1; Dkt. 29). Google's response to it is due November 25, 2026 (Dkt. 28), and no answer or ruling is in the record read.
EVOX v. Midjourney: Training and Output Claims Awaiting a Motion Hearing
EVOX's July 30, 2026 complaint against Midjourney, Inc. (C.D. Cal. No. 2:26-cv-08408-JAK-E, Judge John A. Kronstadt) pleads direct infringement through AI training, contributory infringement and removal of copyright management information over 103,957 registered photographs EVOX says appear in the LAION-400M and LAION-5B datasets (Dkt. 1).
EVOX alleges that watermarks were removed in pre-processing. In its complaint of July 30, 2026 it asks for an injunction, impoundment, disgorgement and statutory damages of up to USD 150,000 per work for willful infringement (Dkt. 1).
The schedule of September 28, 2026 sets a hearing on a motion to dismiss for December 7, 2026 (Dkt. 26), and the grounds of that motion are not in the record read.
EVOX Productions Docket Entries, 2024 to 2026
Eighteen filings and orders across the four dockets trace the dispute from the Stanford complaint to the reassignment of the Stability case in November 2026. The table lists them as of 2026-11-17, from the court PDFs on the RECAP archive; later entries may exist, and none was confirmed on that date.
| Date | Case and entry | What it decided or reported | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2024-12-31 | Stanford, Dkt. 1 | complaint against four universities and Does 1-10, two counts | court PDF |
| 2025-02-14 | Stanford, Dkt. 20 | EVOX voluntarily dismisses the University of Michigan | court PDF |
| 2025-07-23 | Stanford, Dkt. 55 | first pleading order (see the table above) | court PDF |
| 2025-08-12 | Stanford, Dkt. 57 | first amended complaint against Stanford alone | court PDF |
| 2025-10-30 | Stanford, Dkt. 65 | second pleading order | court PDF |
| 2025-11-19 | Stanford, Dkt. 67 | second amended complaint | court PDF |
| 2026-03-03 | Stanford, Dkt. 74 | third pleading order | court PDF |
| 2026-03-31 | Stanford, Dkt. 77 | Stanford's answer, eleven affirmative defenses | court PDF |
| 2026-04-09 | Stanford, Dkt. 78 | case management and trial-setting order, jury trial 2027-05-03 | court PDF |
| 2026-07-02 | Stability, Dkt. 1 | complaint against six companies, five counts | court PDF |
| 2026-07-09 | Google, Dkt. 1 | complaint, four counts | court PDF |
| 2026-07-30 | Midjourney, Dkt. 1 | complaint, three counts | court PDF |
| 2026-09-09 | Google, Dkt. 22 | related to 5:23-cv-03440-EKL and reassigned | court PDF |
| 2026-09-28 | Midjourney, Dkt. 26 | briefing schedule, hearing 2026-12-07 | court PDF |
| 2026-10-05 and 2026-10-12 | Stability, Dkt. 58, 70, 71, 72 | motions to dismiss by Hugging Face, the Stability entities, Runway and DeviantArt | Dkt. 58, Dkt. 70 |
| 2026-10-13 | Stanford, Dkt. 90 | first amended answer accepted (limitations defense) | court PDF |
| 2026-10-23 | Google, Dkt. 29 | first amended complaint, five counts | court PDF |
| 2026-11-05 | Stability, Dkt. 91, 92 | reassigned to Judge Wilson, status conference 2026-12-07 | court PDF |
What the EVOX Cases Show Holders of Image Libraries
The EVOX cases show an image library pursuing the same photographs by three routes: a university that published a dataset, developers that trained on link lists, and a licensee that allegedly used licensed images for purposes the license excluded.
The Google count rests on a purpose carve-out, not on a missing license, which makes the drafting of field of use and scope limits the point in dispute. Three features of the record matter to a holder:
- Per-image registration underpins the statutory damages EVOX counts in the Stanford case (Dkt. 87).
- Standing was tied to the lost licensing fee (Dkt. 55).
- Fair use, limitations and the academic-use terms Stanford invokes are undecided.
How image libraries license to AI developers outside litigation is covered on the page about selling photos and images for AI training.
In its complaint of July 9, 2026, EVOX itself states that a license for one image can exceed USD 1,300 (Dkt. 1, Google), a claim not tested in any court. Nothing here advises a holder to sue or to license.
Where the EVOX Cases Sit Among Image and Dataset Lawsuits
The EVOX suits share defendants and datasets with the artists' case against Stability AI and Midjourney, Getty's US case against Stability AI, the studios' case against Midjourney and the German LAION case.
The case tracker of AI copyright lawsuits over training data lists every tracked case with docket and status, and the table compares five related proceedings as of the date in each row.
| Case | Court and docket | Shared element | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Andersen v. Stability AI | N.D. Cal. 3:23-cv-00201-WHO | Stability AI, Midjourney, DeviantArt and Runway as defendants | discovery as of 2026-11-09 | case page |
| Getty Images v. Stability AI (US) | N.D. Cal. 3:25-cv-06891-TLT | image library v. Stability AI | stayed until 2027-01-13 (Dkt. 81), as of 2026-11-17 | case page |
| Disney, Universal and Warner Bros. v. Midjourney | C.D. Cal. 2:25-cv-05275-JAK-AJR | Midjourney; same judge | discovery as of 2026-11-16 | case page |
| Kneschke v. LAION | BGH I ZR 281/25 | the LAION dataset | pronouncement scheduled 2026-12-17, as of 2026-11-09 | case page |
| In re Google Generative AI Copyright Litigation | N.D. Cal. 5:23-cv-03440 | related-case order for EVOX v. Google; EVOX listed as objector | pending as of 2026-11-09 | govinfo |
The defendants' own data practices belong on their buyer profiles: Stability AI as a data buyer and Google as a data buyer.
More About the EVOX Productions Lawsuits
Decided Versus Still Open in the EVOX Cases
Only pleading questions are decided, and only in the Stanford case.
- Decided: standing on the lost license fee; Rice and Baylor out for lack of personal jurisdiction; direct infringement and material contribution survive; inducement out.
- Still open: fair use; limitations; damages; the 2026 motions and responses in the three newer suits.
Frequently Asked Questions About the EVOX Productions Lawsuits
Who is EVOX Productions and why is it suing AI companies?
EVOX Productions LLC is a Chino, California company that licenses car photographs, spins and panoramas. It alleges that its registered photographs were copied into research and training datasets without permission.
Was the Stanford Cars dataset used to train AI models?
EVOX alleges so, and Stanford says it shared the data for peer review under academic-use terms. No court has made a finding.
Has any court ruled on fair use in the EVOX cases?
No. The Stanford court set fair use aside at the pleading stage and made no determination on it, and the other three cases have no ruling.
Is the EVOX case against Stanford going to trial?
A four-day jury trial is set for May 3, 2027. The parties have proposed later dates, and no order adopting them is in the record read.
Did Google have a license from EVOX?
Yes, per EVOX, from January 2020 for model years 2017 to 2021 with limits. EVOX says the license excluded offering the content to advertisers and later spins and panoramas.