DataPacts

Kadrey v. Meta: Claims, Rulings and Status

Checked

At a glance

Kadrey v. Meta is a copyright suit by 13 authors, among them Richard Kadrey, Sarah Silverman and Ta-Nehisi Coates, against Meta Platforms, Inc. in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California (No. 3:23-cv-03417-VC), over books Meta obtained from shadow libraries and used to train its Llama models.

Independent reference. Every buyer is covered on the same terms, every figure carries its source and check date, and no buyer pays to be listed or placed higher.

Request an independent introduction

Tell us what data your company holds. We reply with the buyers that fit and what their terms leave out. Your details reach a buyer only after you agree to a named introduction.

IndependentYour details stay with us until you agreeNot selling is a valid outcome

As of November 16, 2026, the training claim is decided for Meta on that record (Dkt. 598, June 25, 2025), the claim that Meta distributed the books while torrenting is still open, and summary judgment briefing is scheduled to end with a hearing on February 25, 2027.

The case is filed as a proposed class action, and no class has been certified. DataPacts is not affiliated with any party and gives no legal advice; this page is part of the independent reference on AI training data licensing.

Dates, dockets and quotations here come from the court filings named in each table, read on November 16, 2026, and how figures are sourced and dated is set out on the methodology page.

Kadrey v. Meta at a Glance: Court, Docket, Parties and Status

No final judgment exists in Kadrey: training was decided for Meta in June 2025, and the distribution claim is headed for summary judgment briefing that ends in February 2027. The table lists the case facts as of 2026-11-16.

Field Value Source
Case Kadrey et al. v. Meta Platforms, Inc. Dkt. 598
Court U.S. District Court, N.D. Cal., San Francisco Division Dkt. 879 caption
Docket 3:23-cv-03417-VC Dkt. 598
Judges Vince Chhabria, J.; discovery: Magistrate Judge Thomas S. Hixson Dkt. 598; Dkt. 879
Filed 2023-07-07 court docket
Plaintiffs 13 authors, among them Richard Kadrey, Sarah Silverman, Christopher Golden, Ta-Nehisi Coates, Junot Díaz Dkt. 598; Dkt. 879
Defendant Meta Platforms, Inc. Dkt. 598
Rulings 2025-06-25: summary judgment for Meta on training (fair use); 2025-06-27: summary judgment for Meta on the DMCA claim Dkt. 598; Dkt. 601
Open distribution claim; class certification; 1292(b) request Dkt. 598; Dkt. 749
Next date hearing on dispositive motions 2027-02-25 Dkt. 768; Dkt. 836
Class proposed class action; no class certified Dkt. 598; Dkt. 749

What the Authors Claim Meta Did With Their Books

The authors claim that Meta copied their books from shadow libraries to train Llama and that, while downloading them by BitTorrent, it uploaded pieces of the same books to other users. The complaint was filed on July 7, 2023.

The order of June 25, 2025 recites that every claim except direct copyright infringement was dismissed early, and that the authors were later given leave to add a theory of infringement by distribution (reuploading while torrenting), a different DMCA claim and a claim under the California Comprehensive Computer Data Access and Fraud Act (CDAFA). The CDAFA claim was dismissed and the DMCA claim survived that motion (Dkt. 598).

The table gives each claim with its basis and outcome as of 2026-11-16.

Claim Rests on Outcome Source
Direct copyright infringement (reproduction for training) copies of books used to train Llama summary judgment for Meta on fair use, 2025-06-25 Dkt. 598
Copyright infringement by distribution uploading while torrenting not moved on in 2025; open Dkt. 598; Dkt. 749
DMCA, 17 U.S.C. 1202(b)(1) removal of copyright management information summary judgment for Meta, 2025-06-27 Dkt. 601
California CDAFA access to data dismissed, as recited in Dkt. 598 Dkt. 598
Original non-copyright claims various dismissed early, as recited in Dkt. 598 Dkt. 598

Every statement about Meta's conduct on this page is the authors' allegation or the court's description of the record, not a finding.

The order also describes how BitTorrent works: a user downloads small pieces of a file from other users and, with default settings, may upload pieces to others while the file is still arriving, which is the conduct behind the distribution theory.

The court used that record, which names LibGen and Z-Library among the sources of the books, without making a finding of infringement on the downloads (Dkt. 598).

Kadrey v. Meta Docket Entries, 2023 to 2026

Nine filings carry Kadrey from the complaint to the order relating three further suits in October 2026. The table lists them as of 2026-11-16 with the document each rests on.

Date Entry What it decided or reported Source
2023-07-07 complaint authors sue Meta over Llama training court docket
2025-06-25 Dkt. 598 authors' motion denied, Meta's cross-motion granted on fair use; distribution claim left "a live issue" RECAP archive PDF
2025-06-27 Dkt. 601 partial summary judgment for Meta on the DMCA claim RECAP archive PDF
2026-06-08 Dkt. 739 authors' motion to certify an interlocutory appeal under 28 U.S.C. 1292(b) as recorded in Dkt. 749
2026-06-25 Dkt. 749 joint statement: remaining claims arise from torrenting; Meta's opposition filed 2026-06-22 (Dkt. 748) RECAP archive PDF
2026-07-10 Dkt. 768 joint statement: summary judgment schedule, hearing 2027-02-25 RECAP archive PDF
2026-09-14 Dkt. 836 stipulation moving expert deadlines and the first two summary judgment briefs RECAP archive PDF
2026-10-27 Dkt. 879 joint statement for five cases: Entrepreneur trial 2027-05-03 and a proposed trial order if it settles CourtListener PDF
2026-10-28 Dkt. 880 related case order: three suits reassigned to Judge Chhabria RECAP archive PDF

The latest public entry read is Dkt. 884, a joint discovery letter of 2026-11-03.

The June 25, 2025 Summary Judgment Order

Judge Vince Chhabria denied the authors' motion for partial summary judgment and granted Meta's cross-motion on fair use, holding that on this record Meta was entitled to summary judgment on its copying for training (Dkt. 598).

The ruling was made on the evidence the parties put in, and the court stressed that decisions follow that evidence rather than general understandings.

The order binds only the 13 named authors, because the court wrote that "this is not a class action, so the ruling only affects the rights of these thirteen authors". The three sections below give the reasoning, what the order says about licensing, and what it leaves undecided.

Why the Court Ruled for Meta on Training

The court found Meta's use for training Llama highly transformative and held that the authors, to win, needed evidence of market harm, which they did not present. It rejected two market theories as "clear losers": that Llama regurgitates the authors' text, and that training destroys a market for licensing the books.

It called a third theory, market dilution, "the potentially winning argument", but found that the authors barely developed it. The four statutory factors that frame this analysis are set out on the page on fair use and AI training in US law.

On the downloads, the court weighed Meta's use of shadow libraries in light of its purpose of training Llama rather than as a separate use (Dkt. 598).

The order describes Meta's torrenting of shadow-library collections, including LibGen. That is the court's reasoning on this record. It is not a statement that downloading pirated books is lawful, and the order's last section says as much.

What the Order Says About a Market for Licensing Books

The order states that the authors were "not entitled to the market for licensing their works as AI training data", so a lost licensing fee did not count as market harm on this record.

It records that Meta explored licensing books and that, in spring 2023, after failing to acquire licenses, it decided to use works from LibGen and abandoned its licensing efforts.

The order also records Meta's evidence that publishers generally do not hold the rights to license books for AI training, and that no organization for collective licensing of those rights exists (Dkt. 598).

Each of those points is the order's account of the evidence, not a market finding for all books. The order reasons that treating lost licensing fees as harm would make the fourth factor circular and favor the rightsholder in every case, so harm from the loss of fees for a transformative use is not cognizable.

It does not decide whether a functioning licensing market for training could matter in a case with different evidence. Meta's licensing deals and acquisition practices are covered on the profile of Meta as a data buyer.

What the Order Expressly Left Undecided

The court wrote that its ruling "does not stand for the proposition that Meta's use of copyrighted materials to train its language models is lawful"; it rests on the plaintiffs having made the wrong arguments and failed to develop a record for the right one (Dkt. 598). Three things stay open after it:

  • market dilution, which the order says a plaintiff with better evidence may establish in another case;
  • the distribution claim, covered in the next sections;
  • the effect on anyone but these 13 authors, which is none.

The June 27, 2025 Ruling on the DMCA Claim

Two days after the fair use order, the court granted Meta partial summary judgment on the authors' DMCA claim under 17 U.S.C. 1202(b)(1), the claim that Meta removed copyright management information from the books (Dkt. 601).

The ruling is partial summary judgment on the DMCA claim only. The court reasoned that because the copying for training was fair use and so not infringement, removing the information could not have furthered an infringement.

It added that no evidence in the record showed that the removal would reveal redistribution of the books over a torrenting network, and that the plaintiffs had not alleged this (Dkt. 601).

The Torrenting Distribution Claim That Remains Open

The claim still open in Kadrey is that Meta infringed the authors' distribution right by uploading pieces of their books to other BitTorrent users while it downloaded them, a claim on which neither side moved for summary judgment in 2025.

The order of June 25, 2025 called it "a live issue in the case", noted that distribution and reproduction are separate rights, and described the record on it as incomplete because Meta had leave to serve a supplemental expert report on distribution (Dkt. 598).

The parties' joint statement of June 25, 2026 describes the remaining claims as Meta having "reproduced, made available, and distributed" the works through torrenting, and lists fair use and class certification among the open issues (Dkt. 749).

Discovery disputes over torrenting records and expert reports continued into November 2026 (Dkt. 879; Dkt. 884). The disputes concern Meta's torrenting expert, testimony about the Books3 dataset, command history files and privilege. They are party disputes, and this page does not repeat what either side says in them.

Which shadow libraries the court records name, and what other courts have said about pirated copies, is set out on the page on pirated books and shadow libraries in AI training. The distribution claim has no ruling of its own.

Summary Judgment Schedule and the Request to Appeal

Summary judgment on the remaining claims is briefed in four rounds between December 2026 and February 2027, with the hearing on dispositive motions set for February 25, 2027. The schedule comes from the joint statement of July 10, 2026 (Dkt. 768).

A stipulation of September 14, 2026 proposes moving the close of expert discovery and the first two briefs (Dkt. 836), and the table shows both sets of dates as of 2026-11-16.

Step Date per Dkt. 768 Date proposed in Dkt. 836 Source
Close of expert discovery 2026-11-20 2026-12-02 Dkt. 768; Dkt. 836
Brief 1 (authors) 2026-12-11 2026-12-16 Dkt. 768; Dkt. 836
Brief 2 (Meta) 2027-01-11 2027-01-12 Dkt. 768; Dkt. 836
Brief 3 (authors) 2027-01-29 unchanged Dkt. 768
Brief 4 (Meta) 2027-02-12 unchanged Dkt. 768
Hearing on dispositive motions 2027-02-25 unchanged Dkt. 768

No trial date for Kadrey appears in the filings read; the parties called the length of trial premature (Dkt. 768).

On June 8, 2026 the authors moved under 28 U.S.C. 1292(b) to certify for appeal the question whether downloading copyrighted works through a shadow library is fair use based on the company's ultimate use of them to train artificial intelligence (Dkt. 739, as quoted in Dkt. 749).

Meta opposed on June 22, 2026 (Dkt. 748), and a hearing was set for July 16, 2026 unless the motion was decided on the papers. No ruling on the request appears in the public record read on November 16, 2026, so it is a request only.

Four later suits by a publisher and other authors and rightsholders are coordinated with Kadrey before Judge Chhabria, and the first of them, Entrepreneur Media v. Meta, is set for trial on May 3, 2027. The table lists them as of 2026-11-16, with the docket numbers from the court's captions.

Case Docket Status Source
Entrepreneur Media, LLC v. Meta Platforms, Inc. 3:25-cv-09579-VC trial set 2027-05-03; amended complaint due 2026-11-06 Dkt. 879
Cambronne, Inc. et al. v. Meta Platforms, Inc. 3:26-cv-03725-VC proposed next for trial if Entrepreneur settles Dkt. 879; Dkt. 884
Chicken Soup for the Soul, LLC v. Meta Platforms, Inc. 3:26-cv-02333-VC coordinated Dkt. 879
Cognella, Inc. v. Meta Platforms, Inc. 3:26-cv-04053-VC coordinated Dkt. 879; Dkt. 884
Hobbs, Older and Sheard v. Meta 26-cv-11420, 26-cv-12115, 26-cv-12126 related to Kadrey 2026-10-28 Dkt. 880
Elsevier et al. v. Meta Platforms and Mark Zuckerberg 3:26-cv-11415-VC transferred from S.D.N.Y. 2026-09-25 court docket

The first four rows are the related cases named in Dkt. 879. If Entrepreneur settles, the parties propose that the trial date pass to Cambronne, then Chicken Soup for the Soul, then Cognella, and Entrepreneur's amended complaint, due November 6, 2026, was expected to add more than 400 books and more than 140 magazine issues (Dkt. 879).

On October 28, 2026 the court related three further suits to Kadrey and reassigned them to Judge Chhabria (Dkt. 880). The suit led by Elsevier, with Cengage, Hachette, Macmillan, McGraw Hill and Scott Turow, was transferred to the Northern District of California on September 25, 2026.

What the Kadrey Record Shows Holders of Licensable Books

Kadrey shows that a court may find training on books fair use when the rightsholders bring no evidence of market harm, while claims about how the copies were obtained and shared are judged separately.

The statement that the authors were not entitled to a market for licensing their works as AI training data applies to this record only, and the order itself says that plaintiffs with better evidence of market dilution may win (Dkt. 598).

For a holder, the record also shows what the court weighed: evidence on market effects, not the general principle that training copies need a license.

How rightsholders license books for training is covered on the page on book publishers and authors licensing books for AI training. Licensing, not licensing and joining a lawsuit are separate choices, and this page does not advise on any of them.

Kadrey is one of two June 2025 district court rulings on training with books, decided two days after Bartz v. Anthropic. The tracker of AI copyright lawsuits over training data lists it next to Bartz and the OpenAI litigation, each with docket and status. The table compares four related matters as of 2026-11-16.

Case Court and docket Status Page
Bartz v. Anthropic N.D. Cal. 3:24-cv-05417-AMO training fair use, pirated library copies not excused (Dkt. 231, 2025-06-23); USD 1.5 billion settlement, final approval 2026-07-20 (Dkt. 680) live
OpenAI copyright litigation (MDL 3143) S.D.N.Y., MDL No. 3143 pending live
Authors and publishers v. xAI N.D. Cal., filed 2026-11-04 (Cognella, Chicken Soup for the Soul and Cambronne also sue there) pending in preparation
Strike 3 Holdings v. Meta N.D. Cal. 5:25-cv-06213-EKL motion to dismiss denied 2026-06-11 in preparation

The Silverman plaintiffs also appear in the Authors v. OpenAI class actions, a separate set of suits.

More About Kadrey v. Meta

Decided Versus Still Open in Kadrey

Training and the DMCA claim are decided for Meta on this record; distribution, class certification, the appeal request and the related trials are open.

Decided Still open
training fair use (Dkt. 598) distribution claim
DMCA claim (Dkt. 601) class certification
CDAFA claim dismissed (recited in Dkt. 598) 1292(b) request
three suits related on 2026-10-28 (Dkt. 880) Entrepreneur trial, 2027-05-03

Frequently Asked Questions About Kadrey v. Meta

Did Meta win the Kadrey lawsuit?

On training, yes, on this record. The court granted Meta summary judgment on fair use on June 25, 2025 (Dkt. 598), said the ruling does not make Meta's use lawful, and left the distribution claim open.

Is Kadrey v. Meta a class action?

It is filed as a proposed class action, but no class has been certified as of 2026-11-16. The 2025 rulings therefore bind only the 13 named authors, and no claims process exists on the court record.

Did the court find that Meta used pirated books?

No, the court made no infringement finding on the downloads. The order describes Meta's downloads from shadow libraries such as LibGen as part of the record, and the distribution claim is undecided (Dkt. 598).

How is Kadrey different from Bartz v. Anthropic?

Bartz did not excuse pirated library copies and then settled; Kadrey turned on missing evidence of market harm and has no settlement. The Bartz settlement is USD 1.5 billion with final approval on 2026-07-20.

What is the citation for Kadrey v. Meta?

Kadrey et al. v. Meta Platforms, Inc., N.D. Cal. No. 3:23-cv-03417-VC. The fair use order is Dkt. 598 of 2025-06-25.