As of November 17, 2026, each docket shows only the complaint and a scheduling order, with no answer, motion or ruling.
The defendants are the three former xAI entities, not Space Exploration Technologies Corp., which acquired xAI in February 2026. This page is part of the independent reference on AI training data licensing; DataPacts is not affiliated with any party and gives no legal advice.
Every date and quotation here comes from court filings or the defendant's own public summary; how figures are sourced and dated is set out on the methodology page.
The Three xAI Suits at a Glance: Courts, Dockets, Parties and Status
The three complaints are nearly identical, were filed the same day by the same two law firms, and plead the same four counts; they differ in their plaintiffs and works. The table compares the three cases as of 2026-11-17.
| Field | Cambronne | Chicken Soup for the Soul | Cognella | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Case | Cambronne, Inc. et al. v. SpaceX Super Intelligence Corp. et al. | Chicken Soup for the Soul, LLC v. SpaceX Super Intelligence Corp. et al. | Cognella, Inc. v. SpaceX Super Intelligence Corp. et al. | Dkt. 1 captions |
| Court | U.S. District Court, N.D. Cal. | U.S. District Court, N.D. Cal. | U.S. District Court, N.D. Cal. | Dkt. 1 |
| Docket | 5:26-cv-13187-SVK (filed as 3:26-cv-13187) | 3:26-cv-13188-SK (filed as 3:26-cv-13188) | 4:26-cv-13189-KAW (filed as 3:26-cv-13189) | Dkt. 1 and Dkt. 5 headers |
| Filed | 2026-11-04 | 2026-11-04 | 2026-11-04 | Dkt. 1 |
| Plaintiffs | Cambronne, Inc.; Lisa Barretta; Jane Adams; Matthew Sacks; Michael Kochin | Chicken Soup for the Soul, LLC | Cognella, Inc. | Dkt. 1 paras. 1, 15 to 19 |
| Defendants | SpaceX Super Intelligence Corp., LLC and Holdings LLC (formerly xAI) | same | same | Dkt. 1 (Cambronne para. 21; Cognella para. 17) |
| Counts | 4 (17 U.S.C. 501 twice, contributory, 1202(b)(1)) | 4 | 4 | Dkt. 1 |
| Class action | no (individual suit) | no | no | Dkt. 1 para. 12 |
| Assigned to | Magistrate Judge Susan van Keulen | Magistrate Judge Sallie Kim | Magistrate Judge Kandis A. Westmore | Dkt. 5 |
| Initial case management conference | 2027-02-09, 9:30 AM | 2027-02-08, 1:30 PM | 2027-02-09, 1:30 PM | Dkt. 5 |
| Status | complaint and scheduling order only; no ruling | same | same | RECAP archive, checked 2026-11-17 |
Who Sues and Who Is Sued: Four Authors, Three Rights Holders and the SpaceX Super Intelligence Companies
The plaintiffs are two publishers, one author's company and four authors, and the defendants are the three Nevada companies that own and operate Grok.
Cambronne, Inc. is wholly owned by the author and journalist John Carreyrou and is the assignee of the copyright in Bad Blood; it sues with the authors Lisa Barretta, Jane Adams, Matthew Sacks and Michael Kochin (Dkt. 1, paras. 15 to 19).
Chicken Soup for the Soul, LLC is a Connecticut company that owns or exclusively licenses copyrights in books under its brand, and Cognella, Inc. is a California academic publisher that describes itself as owner or exclusive licensee of thousands of textbook and course-material copyrights. Each complaint lists works non-exhaustively in an exhibit and states no count of works.
The defendants are SpaceX Super Intelligence Corp. (formerly SpaceXAI Corp. and X.AI Corp.), SpaceX Super Intelligence LLC (formerly SpaceXAI LLC and X.AI LLC) and SpaceX Super Intelligence Holdings LLC (formerly SpaceXAI Holdings LLC and X.AI Holdings LLC). Holdings owns Corp. and Corp. owns LLC, per paragraph 18.
SpaceX appears only as the acquirer of xAI in February 2026 and, per Nevada filings cited in paragraph 22, a managing member of Holdings; it is not a defendant.
How the Complaints Say xAI Got Books for Grok
The complaints plead two separate routes by which xAI allegedly obtained the plaintiffs' books: downloading pirated copies, and buying print copies to scan.
Every statement under this heading is the plaintiffs' allegation, often on information and belief, never a finding. "Grok" in the complaints covers every version from Grok-0 to Grok 5 and derived models (footnote 1).
The Allegations of Pirated Copies: LibGen, Books3 and BitTorrent
The complaints allege that the plaintiffs' works sit in Books3, LibGen, Z-Library and Anna's Archive, that xAI downloaded books from those collections or datasets derived from them, and that a reasonable inference follows that xAI copied the plaintiffs' works.
As support, the complaints quote a shared Grok conversation in which Grok said it was "very likely that some portion of the texts I was exposed to during training came from LibGen mirrors or similar sources" (paras. 3, 68 to 70).
They also allege, on information and belief, that xAI ran torrent clients and uploaded pieces of the works to peers (para. 75), the basis of the contributory count. Which collections court records name is on the page about pirated books and shadow libraries in AI training.
The complaints quote Elon Musk's 2023-11-29 remark that "These AIs are all trained on copyrighted data. Obviously." as evidence of willfulness (paras. 5, 76). No court has found that xAI used these collections.
The Scanning Allegations: Print Books Bought and Digitized
The second count rests on a different act: the complaints allege that xAI bought physical books, scanned them and used the digital copies to train Grok, which they plead as infringement even if no pirated copy was ever downloaded.
The allegation rests on a Musk post of 2026-07-27 quoted in the complaints, saying rare books were to be scanned "the hard way vs just cutting off the spine and scanning", and on the allegation that the program ran by July 2026 and is disclosed nowhere else (paras. 6, 7, 85, 90 to 92).
The plaintiffs argue that buying a copy conveys no reproduction right (17 U.S.C. 202, 106(1)) and that each scan, OCR pass and training copy is a reproduction (paras. 94, 95).
In Bartz v. Anthropic, the court held on its record (Dkt. 231, 2025-06-23) that scanning purchased print books was fair use, while pirated library copies were not excused.
No court has addressed this count in the xAI cases, and this page makes no prediction.
xAI's EU Disclosures as the Complaints Read Them
The complaints build much of their case on xAI's own public summary of training content for Grok 4.7 of September 21, 2026, published under the EU AI Act.
In it SpaceXAI states, as of 2026-09-21, that its text exceeds 10 trillion tokens, that its web crawler ran from January 2024 to August 2026, that it holds commercial licensing agreements with rightsholders for text and images, that it uses the USTR Notorious Markets list as an exclusion signal, and that it is not a Code of Practice copyright signatory.
The complaints argue that the USTR sentence shows piracy sites reach the crawler (para. 67) and that the licensing answer shows a license market existed (paras. 8, 42).
What Article 53 requires is set out on the page on the EU AI Act training data summary. The complaints also cite xAI's California challenge for its trade-secret position (paras. 46, 83).
Four Counts in Each Complaint: Infringement, Contributory Infringement and Removed Copyright Notices
Each complaint pleads four counts, all under federal law: direct infringement through pirated copies, direct infringement through scanning, contributory infringement through torrenting, and removal of copyright management information under 17 U.S.C. 1202(b)(1). The table lists them as pleaded on 2026-11-04.
| Count | Statute | Act alleged | Remedy pleaded | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| I Direct copyright infringement: pirated copies from shadow libraries | 17 U.S.C. 501 | downloading, copies in ingestion, preprocessing, storage and training | statutory and actual damages, restitution of profits, other remedies; fees under 17 U.S.C. 505 | Cognella paras. 104 to 112 |
| II Direct copyright infringement: scanning of physical books | 17 U.S.C. 501 | scans, OCR and training copies of bought print books | same | Cognella paras. 113 to 122 |
| III Contributory copyright infringement | 17 U.S.C. 501 | uploading pieces of works to peers while torrenting | statutory or actual damages, restitution; fees under 505 | Cognella paras. 123 to 129 |
| IV Removal of copyright management information | 17 U.S.C. 1202(b)(1) | stripping titles, author names, notices and copyright pages in processing | statutory and actual damages, restitution of profits; fees under 1203(b)(5) | Cognella paras. 130 to 135 |
Every act is the plaintiffs' allegation, and paragraph numbers differ slightly between the three complaints.
Jurisdiction is pleaded under 28 U.S.C. 1331 and 1338(a), and willfulness on Counts I and II. They plead separate accrual of each act and, in the alternative, equitable tolling because xAI kept its sources secret (paras. 84, 85). They plead no state-law claim and demand a jury.
What the Plaintiffs Ask the Court to Order
The plaintiffs ask for statutory damages, declarations of willful infringement and an injunction that would also require xAI to keep provenance records for every training copy of their works. The prayer lists twelve items, grouped below, and no damages amount is pleaded.
- Judgment and declarations of infringement, willfulness and a 1202(b) violation.
- A permanent injunction against the infringing conduct.
- An injunction against removing copyright management information, plus preservation of provenance records.
- An accounting of profits.
- Statutory damages under the Copyright Act, and statutory or actual damages under 17 U.S.C. 1203(c).
- Restitution, disgorgement, fees, costs and interest.
Why the Plaintiffs Sue One by One Instead of as a Class
Each complaint states that the plaintiff elects not to bring a class action, so that a jury sets individual statutory damages for its own works.
The complaints reason that class settlements "structured to resolve claims for pennies on the dollar" serve infringers, citing the jury right on statutory damages in Feltner v. Columbia Pictures (523 U.S. 340, 1998) (paras. 12 to 14).
These are individual actions, not class actions; the Bartz settlement, by contrast, was a class settlement.
From One Joint Suit Against Six Developers to Three Separate Suits
John Carreyrou and most of the Cambronne co-plaintiffs first sued xAI in a joint complaint of December 22, 2025 against several AI developers, and the court split that case on June 8, 2026, when Cambronne, Inc. led the plaintiffs. The joint suit was filed as 3:25-cv-10897 (now 5:25-cv-10897-PCP) with xAI Corporation among the defendants.
Judge P. Casey Pitts granted severance (Dkt. 195): no common transaction or occurrence links competing developers, and training on the same works is not enough. Google, xAI, Perplexity, Apple and NVIDIA were severed and dismissed from that case, which continues against Anthropic.
The 2026 Cambronne complaint keeps the company and four of the authors; Philip Shishkin, named in Dkt. 195, is not a plaintiff here. The complaints call the joint suit the first to allege Grok training on pirated books (paras. 79, 84). Severed and dismissed means removed from that case, not a merits ruling.
Docket Entries for the xAI Book Suits, 2025 to 2027
Eight entries carry the claims against xAI from the joint complaint to the initial case management conferences set for February 2027. The table lists them as of 2026-11-17.
| Date | Court and entry | What it decided or set | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025-12-22 | N.D. Cal. 3:25-cv-10897, Dkt. 1 | joint complaint naming xAI Corporation among the defendants | joint complaint PDF (cand.461656) |
| 2026-06-08 | 5:25-cv-10897-PCP, Dkt. 195 | motions to sever granted; Google, xAI, Perplexity, Apple and NVIDIA severed and dismissed; continues against Anthropic | Dkt. 195 PDF |
| 2026-11-04 | 5:26-cv-13187, Dkt. 1 | Cambronne complaint, four counts | complaint PDF (cand.483039) |
| 2026-11-04 | 3:26-cv-13188, Dkt. 1 | Chicken Soup for the Soul complaint, four counts | complaint PDF (cand.483040) |
| 2026-11-04 | 4:26-cv-13189, Dkt. 1 | Cognella complaint, four counts | complaint PDF (cand.483043) |
| 2026-11-05 | Dkt. 5 in each case | initial case management orders; ADR certification and Rule 26(f) deadline 2027-01-19 | Dkt. 5 PDFs |
| 2027-02-08 | 3:26-cv-13188-SK | initial case management conference, 1:30 PM (scheduled) | Dkt. 5 |
| 2027-02-09 | 5:26-cv-13187-SVK (9:30 AM); 4:26-cv-13189-KAW (1:30 PM) | initial case management conferences (scheduled) | Dkt. 5 |
Entries available on the RECAP archive on 2026-11-17; scheduled dates move if the court changes the conference. No later entry was confirmed.
What the Suits Mean for Holders of Book Copyrights
The suits test whether a developer that holds licenses for some text can be liable for books it allegedly downloaded or scanned without one, and they add the scanning of purchased copies to the claims a rights holder can plead.
The complaints use xAI's stated licensing agreements to argue that a licensing market existed (para. 97).
Bartz and Kadrey both held training fair use on their records, and Kadrey held the plaintiffs "not entitled to the market for licensing their works as AI training data" (Dkt. 598, 2025-06-25). The factors as courts applied them are on the page on fair use and AI training in US law.
The same plaintiffs sue Meta in coordinated cases, listed in the table below, and the xAI suits are at the pleading stage.
How book rights are licensed is covered in the guide to book publishers and authors licensing books for AI training.
Where the xAI Suits Sit Among Book-Training Cases
The xAI suits are among the newest book-training cases in the tracker and share plaintiffs with the coordinated Meta cases and a severed defendant with the NVIDIA case.
Every tracked case with its docket and status is in the case tracker of AI copyright lawsuits over training data. The table compares three related cases as of the date in each row.
| Case | Court and docket | Link to the xAI suits | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kadrey v. Meta and coordinated suits | N.D. Cal. 3:23-cv-03417-VC | Cambronne, Chicken Soup for the Soul and Cognella also sue Meta in coordinated cases | training claim decided for Meta 2025-06-25 (Dkt. 598); first coordinated trial set 2027-05-03; as of 2026-11-16 | Dkt. 598; Dkt. 879 |
| X.AI v. Bonta | C.D. Cal. 2:25-cv-12295-JGB-SSC; 9th Cir. 26-1591 | xAI's trade-secret position on its data sources, cited in the complaints | preliminary injunction denied 2026-03-04 (Dkt. 35); appeal pending; as of 2026-11-10 | Dkt. 35 |
| Nazemian v. NVIDIA | N.D. Cal. 4:24-cv-01454-JST | NVIDIA was severed from the same joint suit on 2026-06-08 | discovery, no merits ruling; as of 2026-11-17 | Dkt. 195 |
What xAI acquires, which licenses it states and how it identifies itself belong on the profile of xAI as a data buyer.
More About the Suits Against xAI
Decided Versus Still Open in the xAI Book Suits
Nothing on the merits is decided: the only orders are the 2026 severance in the joint suit and the scheduling orders in the three new cases.
Decided:
- xAI was severed and dismissed from the joint suit (Dkt. 195).
- The three cases were assigned to magistrate judges (Dkt. 5).
- Initial conference dates were set (Dkt. 5).
Still open:
- Service and xAI's response.
- Any motion to dismiss, or to relate the three cases.
- Whether xAI downloaded or scanned the works.
- Fair use.
- Damages.
Frequently Asked Questions About the xAI Copyright Lawsuits
Who is suing xAI over Grok's training data?
Cambronne, Inc. with the authors Lisa Barretta, Jane Adams, Matthew Sacks and Michael Kochin, Chicken Soup for the Soul and Cognella are the plaintiffs in three suits filed on 2026-11-04. This page does not state that these are the only suits.
Is SpaceX a defendant?
No: the defendants are SpaceX Super Intelligence Corp., LLC and Holdings LLC, the former xAI companies. SpaceX is named in the complaints as the acquirer of xAI.
Is this a class action?
No: each plaintiff elects to sue individually so that a jury sets statutory damages for its own works.
Has a court ruled in the xAI book suits?
No: as of 2026-11-17 only the complaints and scheduling orders are on the docket. Initial conferences are set for February 8 and 9, 2027.
Is this the same case as the Anthropic book settlement?
No: Bartz v. Anthropic (N.D. Cal. 3:24-cv-05417-AMO) is a class case with final approval on 2026-07-20 of a USD 1.5 billion settlement.