It has been consolidated with Dubus v. NVIDIA since May 2025. As of November 17, 2026, the case is in fact discovery, no court has ruled on fair use or liability, and no trial date is set.
The only ruling on the pleadings so far, of May 5, 2026, dismissed the vicarious infringement claim with leave to amend and let the direct and contributory claims go forward. DataPacts is not affiliated with any party and gives no legal advice; this page belongs to the independent reference on AI training data licensing.
Dates, docket numbers and quotations come from the court filings named in each table, read on November 17, 2026, and how figures are sourced and dated is set out on the methodology page.
Nazemian v. NVIDIA at a Glance: Court, Docket, Parties and Status
No court has ruled on whether NVIDIA infringed or on fair use: the ruling of May 5, 2026 decided only which claims the authors may pursue. The table lists the case facts as of 2026-11-17.
| Field | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Case | Nazemian et al. v. NVIDIA Corporation (consolidated with Dubus et al. v. NVIDIA Corporation) | Dkt. 1; Dkt. 144 |
| Court | U.S. District Court, Northern District of California, Oakland Division | Dkt. 407 |
| Docket | 4:24-cv-01454-JST (master file; consolidated with 4:24-cv-02655-JST) | Dkt. 144; Dkt. 407 |
| Filed | 2024-03-08 (Dubus: 2024-05-02) | Dkt. 1 stamp; Dkt. 144 |
| Judges | District Judge Jon S. Tigar; discovery: Magistrate Judge Sallie Kim | Dkt. 303; Dkt. 105 |
| Plaintiffs | Abdi Nazemian, Brian Keene, Stewart O'Nan, Andre Dubus III, Susan Orlean (putative class) | Dkt. 235; Dkt. 413 |
| Defendant | NVIDIA Corporation, Delaware (SEC CIK 0001045810) | Dkt. 1; EDGAR |
| Claims | direct and contributory copyright infringement (vicarious dismissed with leave to amend, 2026-05-05) | Dkt. 235; Dkt. 303 |
| Defenses pleaded | include fair use, non-infringement, express or implied license | Dkt. 321 |
| Status | fact discovery; closes 2027-02-12; class certification hearing 2027-08-26; no trial date; no settlement | Dkt. 279; Dkt. 477 |
What the Authors Claim: From One Count in 2024 to Three in 2026
The authors began with one count of direct copyright infringement under 17 U.S.C. 501 and, in the consolidated complaint of January 16, 2026, plead three: direct, contributory and vicarious infringement. Everything in this section and its subsections is the authors' allegation, never a finding, and NVIDIA denies infringement (Dkt. 321).
The 2024 Complaints: NeMo Megatron and the EleutherAI Corpus
The original complaint rests on NVIDIA's own model cards: it alleges that the NeMo Megatron models NVIDIA released in September 2022 state they were trained on The Pile, a dataset EleutherAI introduced in December 2020, and that one component of The Pile is Books3, which contains the authors' books (Dkt. 1). The models named are the 1.3B, 5B and 20B Megatron models and T5 3B.
The authors say Books3 derives from the Bibliotik private tracker, and they infer in paragraph 31 that the models were "necessarily also trained" on their books. The proposed class period runs from at least March 8, 2021. What the corpus contains is set out on the page on The Pile, EleutherAI's dataset.
Dubus v. NVIDIA (Andre Dubus III and Susan Orlean, No. 4:24-cv-02655) was filed on May 2, 2024, related to the Nazemian case on May 29, 2024 (Dkt. 47), and consolidated on May 13, 2025 under master file 4:24-cv-01454-JST (Dkt. 144).
The record read for this page does not include the Dubus complaint, so no Dubus-specific allegation is described here. The same three authors sued Databricks and MosaicML the same day as the Nazemian filing.
The 2026 Consolidated Complaint: More Models, More Sources
The First Consolidated Amended Complaint, filed on January 16, 2026 by all five authors after the court granted leave on January 15, 2026 (Dkt. 232), extends the case from the NeMo Megatron series to other NVIDIA models and from The Pile to other book sources.
It adds Megatron 345M, NeMo GPT-3 10B, InstructRetro-48B, Retro-48B and Nemotron-4 15B and 340B (Dkt. 235). It also alleges that NVIDIA used SlimPajama, derived from RedPajama and alleged to include Books3, to test tokenizers. In September 2025 the court had refused to widen discovery beyond The Pile (Dkt. 183).
The authors allege that NVIDIA took books from Bibliotik and Anna's Archive and, on information and belief, from LibGen, Sci-Hub and Z-Library. They quote NVIDIA documents saying that in 2023 the company "chatted with multiple publishers" but that none "wanted to enter into data licensing deals" (Dkt. 235, para. 54).
The contributory count names Amazon, Persimmon AI and Writer as customers that downloaded The Pile with NVIDIA scripts. How unlicensed copies enter training is covered on the page on pirated books and shadow libraries in AI training.
| Count | Legal basis | Rests on (authors' allegation) | Ruling 2026-05-05 | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Direct infringement | 17 U.S.C. 501, 106 | copies of The Pile, SlimPajama (with Books3) and a books dataset from Anna's Archive made to develop NVIDIA's models; willfulness | not challenged as a count; model and source challenges denied or withdrawn | Dkt. 235 paras. 74 to 82; Dkt. 271; Dkt. 303 |
| Contributory infringement | common-law secondary liability | scripts and resources that let customers (Amazon, Persimmon AI, Writer) fetch and preprocess The Pile | survives (inducement and tailored-service theories) | Dkt. 235 paras. 83 to 86; Dkt. 303 pp. 7 to 11 |
| Vicarious infringement | common-law secondary liability | right to control customers' downloads; revenue from customers using the framework | dismissed with leave to amend within 21 days | Dkt. 235 paras. 87 to 90; Dkt. 303 pp. 11 to 14 |
The table compares the three counts of the complaint of 2026-01-16 with the ruling of 2026-05-05.
What the Authors Ask the Court to Order
The authors ask for statutory and actual damages under the Copyright Act, destruction of the infringing copies and certification of a nationwide class, without stating an amount (Dkt. 1; Dkt. 235). The relief sought is:
- certification of a class of owners of a registered US copyright in a literary work that NVIDIA downloaded, copied or used in LLM training, research or development since no later than March 8, 2021;
- damages under 17 U.S.C. 504, with willfulness alleged (para. 82);
- destruction of the infringing copies under 17 U.S.C. 503(b);
- fees under 17 U.S.C. 505 and interest;
- a jury trial.
Nazemian v. NVIDIA Docket Entries, 2024 to 2026
Fourteen filings and orders carry the case from the first complaint to the restricted order of November 10, 2026. The table lists them as of 2026-11-17 with the document each rests on.
| Date | Entry | What it decided or recorded | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2024-03-08 | Dkt. 1 | complaint, one count of direct infringement, jury demand | RECAP archive PDF |
| 2024-05-02 | Dubus Dkt. 1 (No. 4:24-cv-02655) | Dubus and Orlean complaint | as recited in Dkt. 144 |
| 2024-05-29 | Dkt. 47 | Dubus related to Nazemian and reassigned to Judge Tigar | RECAP archive PDF |
| 2024-09-09 | Dkt. 69 | early summary judgment motions on fair use allowed before class certification | RECAP archive PDF |
| 2025-05-13 | Dkt. 144 | cases consolidated under master file 4:24-cv-01454-JST | Dkt. 144; Dkt. 149 |
| 2025-09-25 | Dkt. 183 | authors' bid to extend discovery beyond The Pile denied | RECAP archive PDF |
| 2026-01-15 | Dkt. 232 | leave to file the consolidated amended complaint granted | RECAP archive PDF |
| 2026-01-16 | Dkt. 235 | First Consolidated Amended Complaint, three counts | RECAP archive PDF |
| 2026-03-23 | Dkt. 279 | scheduling order to the 2027-08-26 class hearing | RECAP archive PDF |
| 2026-05-05 | Dkt. 303 | motion to dismiss granted as to vicarious claim only | RECAP archive PDF |
| 2026-06-09 | Dkt. 321 | NVIDIA's answer, fair use among the defenses | RECAP archive PDF |
| 2026-06-22 | Dkt. 340 | discovery period confirmed to end 2024-07-01 | as summarized in Dkt. 407 |
| 2026-09-11 | Dkt. 413 | authors' motion for relief from Dkt. 340 (a filing) | RECAP archive PDF |
| 2026-11-10 | Dkt. 477 | order denying motions for relief (ECF 476) restricted; redactions within seven days | RECAP archive PDF |
Entries from the court's public docket as archived; later entries were not confirmed on 2026-11-17.
The May 2026 Ruling on NVIDIA's Motion to Dismiss
Judge Jon S. Tigar granted NVIDIA's motion to dismiss only as to vicarious infringement on May 5, 2026 (Dkt. 303), with leave to amend within 21 days, and denied it on every other point, so the direct and contributory infringement claims go forward. The table lists the six issues as of 2026-05-05.
| Issue NVIDIA raised | Court's reasoning in one line | Outcome | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Megatron 345M | model card not judicially noticeable; Pile training plausibly alleged | denied | Dkt. 303 pp. 3 to 5 |
| Unidentified models | scope is the five listed models and their checkpoints | denied | Dkt. 303 p. 5 |
| Pirate Library Mirror, Bibliotik, unidentified datasets | no present allegation (mirror, unidentified); Bibliotik plausible | denied | Dkt. 303 pp. 5 to 6 |
| BitTorrent | "merely a tool, not a library or dataset" | denied | Dkt. 303 p. 6 |
| Contributory infringement | knowledge alleged; inducement and tailored service under Cox v. Sony | denied | Dkt. 303 pp. 6 to 11 |
| Vicarious infringement | no right and ability to control; no causal financial benefit | granted, leave to amend in 21 days | Dkt. 303 pp. 11 to 14 |
NVIDIA withdrew its challenge to the Nemotron-4 15B and 340B models and to the Anna's Archive, Z-Library, LibGen, Sci-Hub and SlimPajama sources on 2026-03-06 (Dkt. 271).
NVIDIA moved on January 29, 2026 (Dkt. 240); the authors opposed on February 12 and NVIDIA replied on February 18 (Dkt. 254, 255). Its notice of March 6, 2026 (Dkt. 271) dropped the challenges listed under the table.
The parties filed supplemental briefs on Cox v. Sony, a 2026 Supreme Court decision on contributory liability, and the court heard argument on April 16, 2026.
A ruling on a motion to dismiss takes the complaint's allegations as true for the motion only, so it is not a finding that NVIDIA copied any book.
The court declined to take judicial notice of the Megatron 345M model card, treated Bibliotik as plausibly alleged, and described BitTorrent as "merely a tool, not a library or dataset" (Dkt. 303).
The contributory claim survives on inducement and tailored-service theories, based on the allegation that NVIDIA gave customers scripts to fetch The Pile. The vicarious claim fails because the authors did not plead a right and ability to control customers' downloads or a causal financial benefit (Dkt. 303).
Discovery Disputes Over Downloaded Books and the July 2024 Cutoff
Since June 22, 2026, discovery has turned on a cutoff: Magistrate Judge Sallie Kim granted NVIDIA's request to confirm that the relevant period for discovery ends on July 1, 2024 (Dkt. 340), and the authors asked Judge Tigar to set that ruling aside.
Discovery was referred to Judge Kim on February 21, 2025 (Dkt. 105). Dkt. 340 also denied without prejudice the authors' motion to make NVIDIA name its "mirrors".
The authors' motions for relief (Dkt. 345, filed July 6, 2026; Dkt. 413, filed September 11, 2026) argue that NVIDIA should fully answer Interrogatory No. 20, which asks for all datasets or files containing books NVIDIA downloaded or torrented, without the cutoff.
Those are the authors' arguments, and this page does not state NVIDIA's answers as facts.
On November 10, 2026 the Order Denying Motions for Relief (ECF 476) was entered under restricted access, and Dkt. 477 gave the parties seven days to propose redactions. Which motions it covers and why is not public as of 2026-11-17.
What Comes Next: NVIDIA's Defenses, Class Certification and the 2027 Schedule
NVIDIA denies infringement and pleads fair use, and the court has scheduled class certification before any summary judgment or trial date is set. The answer of June 9, 2026 (Dkt. 321) pleads non-infringement, fair use under 17 U.S.C. 107, lack of copyrightability, de minimis copying, laches, limitations and express or implied license.
NVIDIA's legal questions in the joint statement of September 4, 2026 cite the Bartz and Kadrey fair-use rulings (Dkt. 407). How US courts weigh the defense is covered on the page on fair use and AI training in US law.
The scheduling order of March 23, 2026 (Dkt. 279) sets the deadline to serve written discovery for November 13, 2026, the close of fact discovery on February 12, 2027, the class certification motion for March 11, 2027, the expert discovery cutoff for June 3, 2027 and the class certification hearing for August 26, 2027.
Summary judgment and trial dates are set only after class and Daubert rulings. In 2024 the court allowed early summary judgment motions on fair use (Dkt. 69), and none appears on the record read.
The authors did not amend by the May 26, 2026 deadline. Their motion for a second amended consolidated complaint (Dkt. 368, filed July 31, 2026) has a hearing noticed for November 19, 2026, and the outcome is open.
The authors planned to seek a 90-day extension of the schedule, which NVIDIA opposed (Dkt. 407); no order on it was confirmed.
What the Case Shows Book Rightholders
For authors and publishers, the case shows a developer's own model documentation becoming the first evidence of which books it trained on, and a class defined by registered US copyrights. The model cards started the complaint, and the refusal to notice one judicially shows that such documents still need proof.
Registration decides class membership if a class is certified, and none is certified as of 2026-11-17. What the collection held is covered on the page on the Books3 collection.
The authors quote NVIDIA documents saying publishers did not want data licensing deals in 2023, while NVIDIA pleads an express or implied license among its defenses. Neither is decided, and neither is a finding about any publisher.
The licensed route for books is described on the page on book publishers and authors licensing books for AI training. This page gives no advice on joining a class or suing.
Where Nazemian v. NVIDIA Sits Among Other Authors' Book Cases
Nazemian v. NVIDIA is one of several authors' class actions over books in training sets, filed the same day as the authors' case against Databricks and MosaicML and still before any ruling on fair use.
The case tracker of AI copyright lawsuits over training data lists each with docket and status. The table compares five related matters, alphabetically, as of 2026-11-17.
| Case | Court and docket | Books at issue | Status | Page |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bartz v. Anthropic | N.D. Cal. 3:24-cv-05417-AMO | books including Books3, LibGen, PiLiMi copies | settled; final approval 2026-07-20 (Dkt. 680), USD 1.5 billion fund; no distribution confirmed (checked 2026-11-17) | /cases/bartz-anthropic/ |
| Huckabee v. Bloomberg | S.D.N.Y. 1:23-cv-09152-MMG | Books3 (BloombergGPT) | motion to dismiss denied 2025-11-24; later entries not checked | /cases/huckabee-bloomberg/ |
| In re Mosaic LLM Litigation | N.D. Cal. 3:24-cv-01451 | books datasets (MPT, DBRX); same three original authors | cross-motions for summary judgment filed 2026-06-30; ruling pending | /cases/mosaic-databricks/ |
| In re Salesforce (Tanzer v. Salesforce) | N.D. Cal. 3:25-cv-08862-CRB | The Pile, RedPajama, Books3 (XGen) | pending | /cases/tanzer-salesforce/ |
| Kadrey v. Meta | N.D. Cal. 3:23-cv-03417-VC | shadow-library books (Llama) | training claim decided for Meta 2025-06-25; first trial set 2027-05-03 (Dkt. 879) | /cases/kadrey-meta/ |
NVIDIA's licenses, identity and record as a company are covered on the profile of NVIDIA as a data buyer.
More About Nazemian v. NVIDIA
Decided Versus Still Open in Nazemian v. NVIDIA
Only the pleadings and the discovery period are decided; infringement, fair use, class status and damages remain open.
- Decided:
- consolidation of Dubus and Nazemian (Dkt. 144);
- direct and contributory claims survive, vicarious dismissed with leave (Dkt. 303);
- answer with fair use filed (Dkt. 321);
- discovery period to 2024-07-01 (Dkt. 340); an order titled Order Denying Motions for Relief (ECF 476) is restricted.
- Open:
- infringement;
- fair use;
- class certification (hearing 2027-08-26);
- second amended complaint (hearing noticed 2026-11-19).
Frequently Asked Questions About Nazemian v. NVIDIA
What is Nazemian v. NVIDIA about?
Authors allege NVIDIA copied their books from The Pile, Books3 and other sources to train its models. NVIDIA denies infringement and pleads fair use (Dkt. 235; Dkt. 321).
Is Dubus v. NVIDIA the same case?
Yes, since May 13, 2025. No. 4:24-cv-02655-JST is consolidated under master file 4:24-cv-01454-JST (Dkt. 144).
Did the court dismiss the authors' claims against NVIDIA?
Only the vicarious claim, on May 5, 2026, with leave to amend. The direct and contributory claims continue (Dkt. 303).
Has NVIDIA settled with the authors?
No settlement is on the record as of November 17, 2026. The docket read shows fact discovery and no settlement filing (Dkt. 477).
When will Nazemian v. NVIDIA go to trial?
No trial date is set. Trial follows the class certification hearing of August 26, 2027 (Dkt. 279).