Salesforce, filed on October 15, 2025, was consolidated with Alexander v. Salesforce and was renamed on February 9, 2026. As of November 17, 2026 the case is in discovery before Judge Charles R. Breyer, with no ruling on the merits, no certified class and no trial date.
Salesforce answered in February 2026 with 13 affirmative defenses and denies that it infringed. The court-adopted schedule sets summary judgment motions for December 14, 2027.
Every statement about the books and datasets below is the authors' allegation, not a finding. DataPacts is not affiliated with any party, and this page is information, not legal advice, within the independent reference on AI training data licensing.
Dates, docket numbers and quotations come from the court filings named in each table, read on November 17, 2026, and how figures are sourced and dated is set out on the methodology page.
In re Salesforce at a Glance: Court, Docket, Parties and Status
No court has ruled on the authors' claim: Salesforce answered the amended complaint in February 2026, and the parties are exchanging documents under a schedule that runs to summary judgment and class certification motions in December 2027. The table lists the case facts as of 2026-11-17.
| Field | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Case | In re Salesforce LLM Copyright Infringement Litigation (formerly Tanzer et al. v. Salesforce, Inc.) | Dkt. 30 |
| Court | U.S. District Court, N.D. Cal., San Francisco Division; Judge Charles R. Breyer | Dkt. 1; Dkt. 30 |
| Master docket | 3:25-cv-08862-CRB | Dkt. 30 |
| Member case | Alexander v. Salesforce, Inc., filed 2025-11-05 as 5:25-cv-09560-VKD, later 3:25-cv-09560-CRB, administratively closed 2026-02-09 | Dkt. 8; Dkt. 30 |
| First complaint filed | 2025-10-15 | Dkt. 1 |
| Plaintiffs | E. Molly Tanzer, Jennifer Gilmore, Tasha Alexander, Jon McGoran, Art Kleiner (proposed class) | Dkt. 23 |
| Defendant | Salesforce, Inc. (Delaware corporation, San Francisco) | Dkt. 23; Dkt. 31 para. 16 |
| Claim | 1 count: direct copyright infringement, 17 U.S.C. 501 | Dkt. 23 |
| Datasets named | The Pile, RedPajama (RedPajama-Books), Books3 (alleged) | Dkt. 23 |
| Models named | XGen-7B series, xGen-Sales, xGen-Small; CodeGen | Dkt. 23 |
| Response | answer with 13 affirmative defenses, 2026-02-19; no motion to dismiss | Dkt. 31 |
| Status | discovery; no merits ruling; no class certified; no trial date | Dkt. 45; Dkt. 68 |
What the Authors Claim: One Count of Direct Infringement Over XGen Training
The authors plead a single count, direct copyright infringement under 17 U.S.C. 501, for downloading, storing, copying and using datasets that contain their books to develop Salesforce's language models.
The original complaint of October 15, 2025 (Dkt. 1) had two plaintiffs, and the First Amended Consolidated Complaint of January 20, 2026 (Dkt. 23) has five, named in the caption as E. Molly Tanzer, Jennifer Gilmore, Tasha Alexander, Jon McGoran and Art Kleiner.
Both carry the same count. The amended version adds a fair use section and a theory of lost licensing revenue. The authors allege all of it, and no finding exists.
How the Authors Trace Their Books Into Salesforce's Training Data
The authors allege a chain of copies: Books3, a collection of books derived from the Bibliotik private tracker, sat inside both The Pile and RedPajama, so anyone who downloaded either corpus from Hugging Face before October 2023 also downloaded Books3. The Pile was introduced by EleutherAI in December 2020, and the complaint quotes the Pile paper for the Bibliotik origin (Dkt. 23, paras. 20 and 23). The page on The Pile, EleutherAI's mixed corpus describes what the corpus contains.
| Dataset | Publisher (as alleged) | What the authors allege | Salesforce's answer | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Pile | EleutherAI, December 2020 | contains Books3; CodeGen pre-trained on it; linked in a 2023 GitHub reply for XGen | lacks knowledge of third-party allegations; denies the rest | Dkt. 23 paras. 20, 23, 38, 43; Dkt. 31 |
| RedPajama ("Books" or "RedPajama-Books" slice) | Together AI, in or around April 2023 | slice was a copy of Books3; listed in the June 2023 XGen data chart | lacks knowledge; denies the rest | Dkt. 23 paras. 25, 26, 40, 41; Dkt. 31 |
| Books3 | derived from the Bibliotik tracker | includes the plaintiffs' Exhibit A books; marked defunct in October 2023 | lacks knowledge; denies | Dkt. 23 paras. 19 to 27; Dkt. 31 |
The table compares the three datasets as alleged in the amended complaint of 2026-01-20; no court has made a finding on any row.
The RedPajama "Books" slice, published by Together in or around April 2023, is alleged to have been a direct copy of Books3 until Books3 was removed from Hugging Face in October 2023, after which the documentation marked it defunct "due to reported copyright infringement" (Dkt. 23, paras. 24 to 26).
The authors say their Exhibit A books are among the works in Books3 (para. 27). The page on Books3 and how it left its hosts covers the collection itself, and this page adds nothing about it beyond the allegations.
XGen, xGen-Sales and xGen-Small: The Models Named in the Complaints
The complaints name four XGen-7B models released in June 2023, the xGen-Sales model of October 2024 and xGen-Small of May 2025, and they also point to Salesforce's earlier CodeGen models. CodeGen, released in March 2022, was "pre-trained on the Pile" according to Salesforce's own paper as the complaint quotes it (para. 38).
The June 2023 XGen announcement listed "RedPajama-Books" in a data chart (para. 40), and a GitHub reply by an unnamed then-Salesforce employee linked both corpora (paras. 42 and 43).
Salesforce admits developing XGen, releasing the XGen series in June 2023, uploading the models to GitHub as open-source models, releasing CodeGen 1.0 in March 2022 and that the GitHub user is a former employee. It denies the paragraphs alleging that it copied Books3 (Dkt. 31).
The authors allege that the chart was removed around September 2023, that the technical report of September 7, 2023 says only "publicly available data" and that a December 2023 post calls the data "legally compliant" (paras. 45 to 47).
They allege on information and belief that xGen-Sales and xGen-Small rest on the same corpora, and that xGen-Sales was built into the Agentforce platform (paras. 48 and 49).
The page on RedPajama and the models built on it holds Together's own model claims. The complaint also quotes chief executive Marc Benioff from a January 2024 interview: "all the training data has been stolen" (para. 66). It is a quotation in a pleading, not a finding.
The Proposed Class and What the Authors Ask the Court to Order
The proposed class covers every legal or beneficial owner of a registered U.S. copyright in a work Salesforce downloaded, copied, stored or otherwise used to develop any of its language models from at least October 15, 2022 (Dkt. 23, paras. 68 and 69). The authors ask for:
- certification of the class under Rule 23(a), (b)(2) and (b)(3);
- damages under 17 U.S.C. 504;
- fees and costs under section 505;
- a declaration that the infringement was willful;
- destruction or disposition of the copies under section 503(b);
- interest and the cost of a notice program.
No amount is pleaded, and no class is certified as of 2026-11-17.
From Two Complaints to One Case: Docket Entries, 2025 to 2026
Thirteen filings and orders carry the case from the first complaint in October 2025 to the latest deadline change in November 2026. Tasha Alexander filed her own complaint on November 5, 2025 (No. 5:25-cv-09560-VKD), with the same single count.
The court related the cases on November 18, 2025 under Civil Local Rule 3-12 and consolidated them "for all purposes" under Rule 42 on December 31, 2025.
Pretrial Order No. 1 of February 9, 2026 set the new caption and master docket, closed the Alexander docket and requires later similar cases to be noticed within 14 days. The table lists the entries as of 2026-11-17.
| Date | Entry | What it decided or recorded | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025-10-15 | Dkt. 1, 1-1 | Tanzer complaint, one count, Exhibit A works | RECAP archive |
| 2025-11-05 | Alexander complaint (5:25-cv-09560-VKD) | second complaint, same count | Dkt. 8; Dkt. 17 recitals |
| 2025-11-18 | Dkt. 13 | cases related under Civil L.R. 3-12 | RECAP archive |
| 2025-12-31 | Dkt. 17 | consolidated for all purposes (Rule 42); consolidated complaint due 2026-01-20 | RECAP archive |
| 2026-01-20 | Dkt. 23 | First Amended Consolidated Complaint, five plaintiffs | RECAP archive |
| 2026-02-09 | Dkt. 30 | Pretrial Order No. 1: new caption, master docket, Alexander docket closed | RECAP archive |
| 2026-02-19 | Dkt. 31 | Salesforce's answer, 13 affirmative defenses | RECAP archive |
| 2026-03-05 | Dkt. 38 | stipulated protective order (granted per the statement in Dkt. 45) | RECAP archive |
| 2026-03-16 | Dkt. 45 | court adopts plaintiffs' schedule; private mediation ordered | RECAP archive |
| 2026-04-02 | Dkt. 48 | ESI stipulation and order | RECAP archive |
| 2026-05-29 | Dkt. 53 | discovery referred to a magistrate judge | RECAP archive |
| 2026-07-08 | Dkt. 61 | request for seven more custodians denied | RECAP archive |
| 2026-11-09 | Dkt. 68 | substantial completion moved to 2026-12-11 | RECAP archive |
Entries come from the RECAP archive of the court docket; no later entry was located on 2026-11-17.
Salesforce's Answer: Admissions, Denials and Thirteen Affirmative Defenses
Salesforce answered the amended complaint on February 19, 2026 instead of moving to dismiss it, denying that it infringed and asserting 13 affirmative defenses (Dkt. 31). Beyond the admissions listed above, it also admits releasing the arXiv report of September 7, 2023 and the post of December 12, 2023.
It denies, among others, paragraphs 2, 4 to 6, 39, 44 and 50 to 56 of the complaint. No motion is pending according to the parties' March 2026 statement (Dkt. 45).
The defenses include no ownership, invalid registrations (17 U.S.C. 411 to 412), fair use, express or implied license, estoppel, merger, idea and expression, scènes à faire, de minimis copying, unprotectable facts, a Due Process Clause limit on damages and a reservation of further defenses.
In the March 2026 case-management statement Salesforce disputes the claim and asks for summary judgment on threshold issues, including fair use, before class certification (Dkt. 45). How courts weigh the defense is covered on the page on fair use and AI training in US law.
The authors rely on Bartz v. Anthropic, 787 F. Supp. 3d 1007 (N.D. Cal. 2025), on pirated copies (Dkt. 23, paras. 53 to 56). That is their citation, and no court has applied it to Salesforce.
Discovery and the Court's Schedule to 2028
Judge Breyer adopted the authors' proposed schedule on March 16, 2026, which puts summary judgment and class certification on near-parallel tracks and leaves pretrial and trial dates to be determined (Dkt. 45). The table lists the dates as of 2026-11-17, as amended by Dkt. 68.
| Event | Date | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Substantial completion of productions | 2026-12-11 (was 2026-11-07) | Dkt. 68 |
| Close of fact discovery | 2027-07-23 | Dkt. 45 |
| Opening expert reports | 2027-08-27 | Dkt. 45 |
| Close of expert discovery | 2027-11-19 | Dkt. 45 |
| Class certification motion | 2027-12-03 | Dkt. 45 |
| Summary judgment motions | 2027-12-14 | Dkt. 45 |
| Oppositions to summary judgment | 2028-01-28 | Dkt. 45 |
| Replies in support of summary judgment | 2028-03-24 | Dkt. 45 |
| Pretrial conference and trial | to be determined (the proposed 2028-06-02 and 2028-06-23 dates were not adopted) | Dkt. 45 order text |
The court adopted these dates from the plaintiffs' proposal, with hearing dates at the court's convenience.
The court entered a stipulated protective order (Dkt. 38) and an ESI order (Dkt. 48), and referred discovery to a magistrate judge on May 29, 2026 (Dkt. 53).
On July 8, 2026 Magistrate Judge Robert M. Illman denied the authors' request for seven additional custodians, including the chief executive, because with discovery only just begun the authors could not show the extra custodians would add non-duplicative material; eight custodians were agreed (Dkt. 61).
The order of November 9, 2026 moved substantial completion of productions from November 7 to December 11, 2026, where the parties' stipulation had asked for November 30 for source code and training data (Dkt. 68).
Other dates are unchanged, and the court ordered private mediation, which the parties plan to begin at or around the close of fact discovery (Dkt. 45).
What the Case Shows Book Rightholders and Buyers of Training Data
The case tests whether a company that never contracted for books is liable because open corpora it downloaded allegedly carried a copied book collection.
The authors frame their harm as lost licensing revenue (Dkt. 23, para. 89) and say Salesforce's payments to other rightholders prove a licensing market (para. 63); the complaint pleads no specific amount for those payments.
For buyers of training data, the complaint turns on provenance questions: which corpus version was downloaded, whether before or after October 2023, whether it was used only in ablation tests and whether copies were retained (paras. 30 to 36 and 44).
The page on pirated books and shadow libraries in AI training shows what courts have found about pirated copies elsewhere.
Nothing is decided here. Whether Salesforce used Books3, whether a license existed and whether fair use applies all remain open as of 2026-11-17.
The licensed route for books is described on the page on book publishers and authors licensing books for AI training. This page gives no advice on suing, joining a class or licensing.
Where In re Salesforce Sits Among Authors' Book Cases
In re Salesforce is one of several authors' suits that name Books3 or similar book collections, next to a settled case, a decided training claim and cases still in discovery.
The case tracker of AI copyright lawsuits over training data lists each with docket and status. The table compares five related matters, alphabetically, as of 2026-11-17.
| Case | Court and docket | Books or dataset at issue | Status | Page |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bartz v. Anthropic | N.D. Cal. 3:24-cv-05417-AMO | Books3, LibGen and PiLiMi copies in a central library | settled; final approval 2026-07-20 (Dkt. 680), USD 1.5 billion fund | /cases/bartz-anthropic/ |
| Huckabee v. Bloomberg | S.D.N.Y. 1:23-cv-09152-MMG | Books3 for BloombergGPT | motion to dismiss denied 2025-11-24; later entries not checked | /cases/huckabee-bloomberg/ |
| In re Mosaic LLM Litigation | N.D. Cal. 3:24-cv-01451 (Breyer, J.) | books datasets for MPT and DBRX | cross-motions for summary judgment filed 2026-06-30; ruling pending | /cases/mosaic-databricks/ |
| Kadrey v. Meta | N.D. Cal. 3:23-cv-03417-VC | shadow-library books for Llama | training claim decided for Meta 2025-06-25; first trial in the coordinated cases set for 2027-05-03 | /cases/kadrey-meta/ |
| Nazemian v. NVIDIA | N.D. Cal. 4:24-cv-01454-JST | Books3 for NeMo Megatron | discovery; fact discovery close 2027-02-12 | /cases/nazemian-nvidia/ |
In re Mosaic LLM Litigation is before the same judge as In re Salesforce.
More About In re Salesforce
Decided Versus Still Open in In re Salesforce
Only procedure is decided: the cases are consolidated, the pleadings are closed and a schedule is in place.
- Decided:
- related and consolidated (Dkt. 13, 17);
- caption and master docket (Dkt. 30);
- answer filed, no motion to dismiss (Dkt. 31);
- schedule adopted (Dkt. 45).
- Still open:
- whether Salesforce downloaded or trained on Books3;
- the fair use and license defenses;
- class certification;
- damages and any trial date.
Frequently Asked Questions About In re Salesforce
Is In re Salesforce the same case as Tanzer v. Salesforce?
Yes, it is the same case under a new name. Tanzer (filed 2025-10-15) and Alexander (filed 2025-11-05) were consolidated on 2025-12-31 and renamed on 2026-02-09.
Did Salesforce ask the court to dismiss the case?
No, Salesforce filed an answer on 2026-02-19 (Dkt. 31). It denies infringement and raises fair use among 13 affirmative defenses.
Has Salesforce settled with the authors?
No settlement is on the docket as of 2026-11-17. The court ordered private mediation, which the parties planned for around the close of fact discovery.
When will In re Salesforce go to trial?
No trial date is set. The March 16, 2026 order leaves pretrial and trial dates to be determined, and summary judgment motions are due 2027-12-14.
Is the case about Salesforce CRM customer data?
No, the complaints concern books in training corpora, not customer records.
The Salesforce systems page explains how CRM data is exported and licensed.
Is every author in Books3 part of the class?
No class is certified. The proposed class covers owners of registered U.S. copyrights in works Salesforce allegedly used, and the class motion is due 2027-12-03.