DataPacts

Getty Images v. Stability AI (UK High Court and Court of Appeal): Claims, Rulings and Status

Checked

At a glance

Getty Images v. Stability AI is the English High Court case (Claim No. IL-2023-000007) in which five Getty companies and a photographer's company sued Stability AI Limited over photographs used to develop Stable Diffusion.

Independent reference. Every buyer is covered on the same terms, every figure carries its source and check date, and no buyer pays to be listed or placed higher.

Request an independent introduction

Tell us what data your company holds. We reply with the buyers that fit and what their terms leave out. Your details reach a buyer only after you agree to a named introduction.

IndependentYour details stay with us until you agreeNot selling is a valid outcome

The High Court decided it on November 4, 2025 in [2025] EWHC 2863 (Ch), and it is now on appeal to the Court of Appeal (CA-2026-000007).

As of November 16, 2026 the appeal has been heard and judgment is reserved, so no appeal outcome exists. The High Court dismissed Getty's secondary copyright claim and found trademark infringement in part, and the appeal concerns only the copyright question of whether a trained model is an "infringing copy".

This is a separate case from Getty's lawsuit in the United States, with its own court, claims and docket. DataPacts is not affiliated with any party and gives no legal advice; this page is part of the independent reference on AI training data licensing.

Dates, citations and tracker entries here come from the judgments and the Court of Appeal case tracker, read on November 16, 2026, and how figures are sourced and dated is set out on the methodology page.

Getty v. Stability AI in England at a Glance: Court, Claim Numbers, Parties and Status

The High Court dismissed Getty's secondary copyright claim and upheld part of its trademark claim, Getty appealed the copyright point, and the Court of Appeal reserved judgment on November 12, 2026. The table lists the case facts as of 2026-11-16.

Field Value Source
Case Getty Images (US) Inc & Ors v Stability AI Ltd [2025] EWHC 2863 (Ch)
Court High Court of Justice, Business and Property Courts of England and Wales, Intellectual Property List (ChD); appeal: Court of Appeal (Civil Division) judgment; case tracker
Judge (High Court) Joanna Smith J [2025] EWHC 2863 (Ch); [2025] EWHC 3343 (Ch)
Claim numbers IL-2023-000007; appeal CA-2026-000007 judgment; case tracker
Claim issued 2023-01-16 judgment para 51
Claimants Getty Images (US) Inc, Getty Images International U.C., Getty Images (UK) Limited, Getty Images Devco UK Limited, iStockphoto LP, Thomas M. Barwick, Inc judgment
Defendant Stability AI Limited (Companies House 12295325, checked 2026-11-09) judgment; Companies House
Judgment 2025-11-04, [2025] EWHC 2863 (Ch) Find Case Law
Status appeal part heard 2026-11-11; judgment reserved 2026-11-12; no judgment published case tracker; Find Case Law, checked 2026-11-16

What Getty Pleaded in London and Which Claims It Dropped Before Judgment

Getty's claim, issued on January 16, 2023, pleaded primary copyright infringement over training and outputs, secondary infringement, database right, trademark infringement under TMA s.10(1) to (3) and passing off. The table gives each claim with its outcome as of 2025-11-04, the date of the judgment.

Claim Legal basis Outcome Source
Primary infringement: training and development copyright abandoned by Getty (no evidence of training in the UK) judgment
Primary infringement: outputs copyright abandoned by Getty judgment
Database right database right abandoned by Getty judgment
Secondary infringement CDPA ss.22, 23, 27(3) dismissed: model not an infringing copy judgment para 758(viii)
Trademark infringement TMA s.10(1), (2), (3) found in part (iStock v1.x s.10(1) and (2); Getty v2.x s.10(2)); s.10(3) dismissed judgment
Passing off common law not separately decided judgment

By the time of judgment only secondary infringement, trademark infringement and passing off remained. The Training and Development Claim, the Outputs Claim and the database claim were abandoned by Getty, so the court did not decide them. The judgment also records Getty's estimate of more than 50,000 photographers and contributors (para 59).

The claimants were six companies: five Getty entities, including iStockphoto LP, and Thomas M. Barwick, Inc, and the defendant is Stability AI Limited, registered at Companies House under number 12295325 (checked November 9, 2026). The trial ran for 12 days in June 2025, and the court gave its judgment on November 4, 2025.

Why the Training Claim Was Never Decided in England

Getty abandoned its Training and Development Claim because it had no evidence that Stable Diffusion was trained in the United Kingdom, so the court never ruled on whether training on Getty's images infringed copyright. Copyright is territorial, and a claim of copying by training needed that copying to have happened in the UK.

Without proof of UK training, the claim could not go forward, and Getty withdrew it rather than have it decided. The same abandonment covered the Outputs Claim and the database claim, which are listed in the claims table.

The judgment therefore says nothing about whether training done abroad is lawful or unlawful under the law of the place of training, and it says nothing about training done in the UK, which was never argued.

English law has only a non-commercial research exception for text and data analysis (CDPA s.29A, in force since June 1, 2014), and the rules and the government's position are set out on the page on UK copyright and AI training under section 29A.

The November 4, 2025 Judgment: Why Stable Diffusion Is Not an "Infringing Copy"

Joanna Smith J held that Stable Diffusion is not an "infringing copy" under CDPA ss.22, 23 and 27(3), because a model that does not store or reproduce any of the copyright works, and has never done so, is not a copy of them.

The claim was one of secondary infringement, which asks whether importing or dealing with an "article" that is an infringing copy infringes copyright. The court accepted that an article may be intangible, so a model could in principle be one.

The decisive finding is that the model weights do not store or reproduce the works (para 758(viii)). Training the model abroad and then making it available in the UK was therefore not secondary infringement, and the claim was dismissed.

In plain terms, the court treated the model as software that learned from the images, not as a store of copies of them, and a model that is not a copy cannot be an infringing copy under the sections cited above.

The reasoning rests on the statute's wording of "article" and "infringing copy" (CDPA s.27), not on any view about whether training itself is permitted.

The judgment cites the training material LAION-5B at 5.85 billion URL-text pairs (para 47), with LAION subsets of about 3 billion; what the dataset contains is covered on the page on LAION-5B and what it contains.

Getty has permission to appeal this point, and no appeal outcome exists as of November 16, 2026.

The Watermark Findings Under the Trade Marks Act

The court found limited, historic trademark infringement where early Stable Diffusion models produced images carrying Getty and iStock watermarks, and dismissed the rest of the trademark claim. Getty won in part on trademarks, and the findings by model version are:

  • iStock watermarks in v1.x models: infringement under TMA s.10(1) and (2).
  • Getty watermarks in v2.x models: infringement under TMA s.10(2).
  • Reputation claim under TMA s.10(3): dismissed.
  • Passing off: not separately decided, because the judge did not see that it added anything to the s.10(1) and (2) findings.

Stability AI was refused permission to appeal these findings on December 16, 2025, so they stand. The findings are tied to specific model versions and to watermarks appearing in generated images, which is why the court called them limited and historic. They do not concern the lawfulness of training.

Permission to Appeal and the Costs Ruling of December 2025

On December 16, 2025 the judge gave Getty permission to appeal on every ground of the secondary infringement issue, calling it "a pure question of law ... novel and important", and refused Stability AI permission to appeal the trademark findings ([2025] EWHC 3343 (Ch)). The table lists the dated steps in the English case as of 2026-11-16.

Date Citation or record What it decided Source
2023-01-16 Claim No. IL-2023-000007 claim issued judgment para 51
June 2025 (9 to 12, 17 to 20, 25 to 27, 30) trial heard over 12 days in the High Court in London judgment
2025-11-04 [2025] EWHC 2863 (Ch) secondary infringement dismissed; trademark infringement in part Find Case Law
2025-12-16 [2025] EWHC 3343 (Ch) permission to appeal granted to Getty; refused to Stability AI; penal notice refused Find Case Law
2025-12-17 [2025] EWHC 3419 (Ch) costs: Stability AI overall winner; Getty 75 % of trademark claim costs; 30.6 % reduction Find Case Law

Earlier interlocutory rulings in the case are not listed here.

The same judgment refused a penal notice. The permission ruling matters because the court treated the infringing-copy point as one of law that the Court of Appeal should decide, not as a dispute about evidence.

On costs ([2025] EWHC 3419 (Ch), December 17, 2025), Stability AI is the overall winner, and Getty recovers 75 % of its costs of the trademark claim, which made up 17.5 % of overall costs. Stability AI's costs are reduced by 30.6 % in total.

Appeal CA-2026-000007: Heard in November 2026, Judgment Reserved

As of November 16, 2026 the Court of Appeal has heard Getty's appeal and reserved judgment: the case tracker records the case as part heard on November 11, 2026 and judgment reserved on November 12, 2026, with no judgment published.

The table gives the tracker entries as of 2026-11-16 (tracker page "Information correct as of: 15-Nov-2026").

Date Tracker entry or field (verbatim) Source
2026-01-12 "Case file passed to Case Management" case tracker
2026-01-13 "Letter sent to applicant/solicitor to request bundles and/or documents" case tracker
2026-05-11 "Case passed to List Office" case tracker
2026-11-11 "Case Part Heard" case tracker
2026-11-12 hearing status "Fixed on 12-Nov-2026 - estimated length (in hours): 4:30", venue London case tracker
2026-11-12 case results "Judgment reserved (CAV) on 12-Nov-2026"; current status "Matter Part Heard - see Case Results" case tracker

No Court of Appeal judgment in the case was published on Find Case Law when checked on 2026-11-16.

The tracker describes the appeal as from the order of Mrs Justice Joanna Smith dated December 17, 2025, lists the hearing as fixed for November 12, 2026 with an estimated length of 4:30 hours in London, and shows the constitution as "Not assigned", so this page names no appeal judges.

Find Case Law held no Court of Appeal judgment in the case for 2026 when read on November 16, 2026.

A reserved judgment means the court gives its decision later, in writing. No date for it is published, and this page records no party statement because none was found on a primary page. A new entry on the tracker or a judgment on Find Case Law is what changes this status.

The tracker lists a hearing estimate of 4:30 hours, records the case as part heard on November 11, 2026 and records judgment reserved on November 12, 2026. The status before the hearing, including the January and May 2026 case management entries, is in the table above.

What the English Record Shows Holders of Licensable Images

The English record shows that an image library's claim against a model developer turned on where training happened and on watermarks in outputs, not on any price for the images.

The claims that reached judgment concerned the model as a copy and the watermarks, and the abandoned training claim shows that proof of where copying took place decided what could be argued.

The watermark findings, in turn, turned on what the models produced in specific versions. A holder of licensable images can read from this that the English court did not value the images, price a license or rule on training consent.

How photo and image holders license their material for training is covered on the page on selling photos and images for AI training.

The judgment sets no license value, and the appeal concerns only the infringing-copy question. Whether to license, to sell or to keep images out of training is a decision for each holder, and the English record offers no guidance on it beyond the points above.

The English Getty case is one of the image and dataset cases in the case tracker, next to Getty's separate US lawsuit, the German dispute over LAION and the artists' suit against Stability AI.

Every tracked lawsuit, with docket and status, is listed in the case tracker of AI copyright lawsuits over training data. The table compares three related cases as of 2026-11-16.

Case Court and docket Status Source
Getty Images v. Stability AI (US) N.D. Cal. 3:25-cv-06891-TLT stayed until 2027-01-13 (Dkt. 81, 2026-10-30), checked 2026-11-16 CourtListener docket
Kneschke v. LAION BGH I ZR 281/25 pronouncement set for 2026-12-17 Federal Court of Justice
Andersen v. Stability AI N.D. Cal. 3:23-cv-00201-WHO discovery as of 2026-11-09 court record

Getty's own AI licenses and its 2026 chapter 11 case are recorded on the page on Getty's own licenses and its 2026 restructuring, with no deal terms repeated here. The US lawsuit is a different case with different claims, so its outcome does not carry over to the English judgment or to the appeal.

More About Getty Images v. Stability AI in England

Decided Versus Still Open in the English Case

The trademark findings are final, while the secondary infringement question waits for the Court of Appeal.

Decided Still open
Three claims abandoned by Getty (training, outputs, database) Whether a model can be an infringing copy (appeal reserved)
Trademark infringement found in part; permission to appeal refused to Stability AI The date of the appeal judgment
Reputation claim under s.10(3) dismissed Any further appeal
Costs order of December 17, 2025 Any UK ruling on training in the UK (never argued)

Frequently Asked Questions About Getty Images v. Stability AI in the UK

Did Getty win against Stability AI in the UK?

In part. Trademark infringement was found for some watermarks, the secondary copyright claim was dismissed, and Stability AI was the overall winner on costs.

Is the UK case the same lawsuit as the US case?

No, they are two lawsuits in two courts. The US case is N.D. Cal. 3:25-cv-06891-TLT, stayed until January 13, 2027 (Dkt. 81, checked November 16, 2026).

What are the citations for Getty Images v. Stability AI in England?

The citations are [2025] EWHC 2863 (Ch) for the judgment, [2025] EWHC 3343 (Ch) for permission to appeal and [2025] EWHC 3419 (Ch) for costs. The claim number is IL-2023-000007 and the appeal number is CA-2026-000007.

When will the Court of Appeal decide?

No date is published. Judgment was reserved on November 12, 2026, and the court gives its decision in writing at a later date.

No, because the training claim was abandoned.

The court decided only whether the model is an infringing copy and whether watermarks infringed trademarks; how other countries treat training copies is set out on the cross-jurisdiction copyright page.

When was the trial?

The trial ran on 9 to 12, 17 to 20, 25 to 27 and 30 June 2025. It was held in the High Court in London.