As of November 16, 2026 the judgment is not final. The court held that lyrics memorized in the models are copies and that § 44b UrhG does not cover them.
This page is part of the independent reference on AI training data licensing and gives no legal advice. DataPacts is not a party to the case and is not affiliated with GEMA, OpenAI or anyone else involved.
All dates and dockets come from the court's press releases, the WIPO Lex case summary and GEMA's own statements, and how figures are sourced and dated is set out on the methodology page.
GEMA v. OpenAI at a Glance: Court, Docket, Parties and Status
The case has one first-instance judgment, which is not final, and no court publication on further proceedings has been found as of November 16, 2026. The table lists the case record as of 2026-11-16.
| Field | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Case | GEMA v. OpenAI | LG München I press release 11/2025 |
| Court | Landgericht München I (Munich Regional Court I), 42nd civil chamber | press release 11/2025 |
| Docket | 42 O 14139/24 | press release 11/2025 |
| Claimant | GEMA Gesellschaft für musikalische Aufführungs- und mechanische Vervielfältigungsrechte | gema.de imprint |
| Defendants | OpenAI, L.L.C.; OpenAI Ireland Ltd. | WIPO Lex case summary |
| Works | lyrics of 9 German songs | press release 11/2025 |
| Models | language models 4 and 4o | press release 11/2025 |
| Judgment | 2025-11-11, copyright claims granted in substance; personality-right claim dismissed | press release 11/2025 |
| Status | not final; no court publication on further proceedings found (checked 2026-11-16) | press release 11/2025; LG München I releases to 18/2026 |
Two kinds of source sit behind the table. The court's press release supplies the docket, the works, the models and the holdings, and the WIPO Lex case summary supplies the names of the two defendants.
GEMA's own statements supply its licensing position, and this page labels each of them as GEMA's statement. OpenAI's own statement on the judgment is not part of the record used here.
What GEMA Claimed: Lyrics of Nine Songs in Models 4 and 4o
GEMA claimed that OpenAI infringed the copyright in the lyrics of nine German songs by memorizing them in its language models 4 and 4o and by reproducing them in ChatGPT outputs, and added a claim under the general personality right over altered lyrics attributed to their authors.
GEMA sues as the society that manages its members' rights, an economic association under § 22 of the German Civil Code (BGB). The court's release names two of the nine titles, "Atemlos" and "Wie schön, dass du geboren bist", and does not list the other seven. This page names no lyricists.
Three acts are in the claim, and each has its own legal footing. The memorization of the lyrics in the models is one act, the reproduction of the lyrics in ChatGPT answers is a second, and the altered lyrics attributed to their authors are a third. The court's release gives no filing date, so this page states none.
The suit concerns text. Lyrics are one layer of a song that carries its own rights, and the page on lyrics as one layer of music used as AI training data sets out the layers of a song and their rights holders.
That split is why this case is about lyrics, while GEMA v. Suno, decided by the same chamber, is about musical compositions.
What the Munich Court Held on November 11, 2025
The 42nd civil chamber granted GEMA's copyright claims in substance and dismissed the personality-right claim, and its reasons address four questions: memorization, the reach of § 44b, the outputs and the attribution claim. The same chamber decided GEMA v.
Suno on 2026-07-31. The holdings follow the path of a work through a language model: first the copies that assemble the training corpus, then the copy that remains in the model, then the answers the model gives to users.
The court treated the second and the third as infringements and read the exception as reaching only the first. The table gives the four holdings as of 2025-11-11.
| Question | Holding | Provision | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Memorization in the model | lyrics are memorized in the parameters; reproduction | § 16 UrhG | press release 11/2025 |
| Exception for mining | covers corpus copies, not reproduction in the model | § 44b UrhG | press release 11/2025; WIPO Lex |
| Outputs | reproducing outputs infringe; OpenAI, not users, responsible as direct infringer | § 16 UrhG | press release 11/2025; WIPO Lex |
| Attribution | general personality-right claim dismissed | general personality right | press release 11/2025 |
Four holdings in GEMA v. OpenAI, Munich Regional Court I, 42 O 14139/24.
Lyrics Memorized in Model Parameters Count as Copies Under Section 16
The court held that the lyrics are memorized in the parameters of models 4 and 4o and that this memorization is a reproduction under § 16 UrhG, even though the model stores them as probability values.
The press release treats the model as a place where a work can be fixed, not only as a tool that reads works. The court's reasoning rests on the fact that a work can be recovered from the model, which makes the stored data a fixation of the work, whatever form the stored values take.
For this case the consequence is narrow. A model that can return a work holds a copy of it in law, so the questions of license and exception attach to the model, not only to the training corpus.
The judgment is a first-instance decision on nine lyrics, and this page states nothing beyond what the court's release and the WIPO Lex summary record.
Where Section 44b Stops: Corpus Copies Versus Copies in the Model
The court held that § 44b UrhG covers the copies made to assemble a training corpus but not the reproduction of works in the model itself, so the exception did not justify the memorized lyrics.
The provision implements Article 4 of Directive (EU) 2019/790, and for works accessible online a reservation of rights is effective only in machine-readable form (§ 44b(3) UrhG).
The same section requires copies to be deleted when they are no longer needed for mining (§ 44b(2) UrhG). The directive entered into force on 2019-06-06 and its transposition deadline was 2021-06-07. These rules are context here, not a finding about any reservation by GEMA.
The line the court drew separates two acts. Copying works to build a corpus can fall under the exception, while a model that holds the work in its parameters is a different reproduction.
The German text and data mining rules in UrhG sections 44b and 60d are explained on the Germany page, which also covers reservations and the Federal Court of Justice case on the scope of § 44b, with its pronouncement scheduled for 2026-12-17.
ChatGPT Outputs and OpenAI's Responsibility for Them
The court held that ChatGPT's outputs reproducing the lyrics infringe as well, and that OpenAI, not its users, is responsible for them as the direct infringer. The WIPO Lex summary and the press release give the same holding.
The point of the holding is who counts as the author of the act: the court looked to the party that operates the model, not to the person who typed the request.
The consequence for training-data questions is that liability attached to the operator of the model even where the user's prompt was simple. Who is liable for publishing an output, and whether an output is copyrightable, are separate questions that this page does not answer.
The Attribution Claim the Court Dismissed
The court dismissed GEMA's claim under the general personality right, which concerned altered lyrics attributed to their authors, together with the related information and damages claims.
This is why the WIPO Lex summary says the action succeeded in substantial part and not in full. The court's press release does not give the reasons for the dismissal in the text this page relies on, so none are stated here.
GEMA v. OpenAI Status as of November 16, 2026: Not Final
The judgment of November 11, 2025 is not final, as the Munich court's own press release states, and no court publication on further proceedings has been found as of November 16, 2026.
The release reads "Das Urteil ist nicht rechtskräftig", and no settlement is recorded. A first-instance judgment of this kind can be followed by an appeal, and this page records further proceedings only once a court publication names them; no such publication has been found.
The accurate reading is therefore that finality, any further instance and the amount of damages stay open. The status line changes only on a court publication naming 42 O 14139/24, and never on commentary. Trade-press and tracker pages are not treated as evidence of further proceedings. The checks of 2026-11-16 were:
- press release 11/2025 of the Munich Regional Court I, still reading "nicht rechtskräftig"
- the Regional Court's press releases up to 18/2026, which carry no notice on this docket
- the Higher Regional Court's press pages, which could not be retrieved on that date
What the Judgment Signals to Holders of Lyrics and Other Text
The judgment does not set a license fee: it grants an injunction, information and damages, while the statement that OpenAI needs a GEMA license comes from GEMA, not from the court.
GEMA states that it has offered an AI licensing model since September 2024 and that OpenAI showed a general unwillingness to follow it, both GEMA's statements of 2025-11-11. OpenAI's own licensing deals and crawler terms are covered in the profile of OpenAI as a data buyer.
Neither GEMA's offer nor OpenAI's reply is a term of the judgment, and no license between the two is recorded.
GEMA's licensed route for training is PLAI by GEMA, a catalog of about 57,000 works and about 178,000 audio files, which are GEMA's figures checked on 2026-11-09. GEMA says contributors are paid "anteilig und angemessen" (proportionately and appropriately) and publishes no formula. Collective licensing for AI training covers PLAI by GEMA and the other society licenses.
What the judgment does not decide:
- a price or license term for any AI developer
- the amount of damages
- whether the training itself needed a license beyond § 44b
A holder who wants license income for training must still reserve rights in machine-readable form for works online under § 44b(3) UrhG, because a reservation in another form is not effective.
For lyrics and other text alike, the practical question the judgment raises is therefore which copies a developer holds, not only which works it read.
Where GEMA v. OpenAI Sits Among Other Training-Data Cases
GEMA v. OpenAI is the first of two GEMA judgments from the same Munich chamber, and OpenAI also defends training-data suits in the United States. The case tracker of AI copyright lawsuits over training data lists every tracked case with docket and status. The table compares four related cases as of 2026-11-09.
| Case | Court and docket | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| GEMA v. Suno | LG München I, 42 O 763/25 | judgment 2026-07-31 largely for GEMA over six musical works; not final | LG München I press release 16/2026 |
| Kneschke v. LAION | LG Hamburg 310 O 227/23; OLG Hamburg 5 U 104/24; BGH I ZR 281/25 | BGH pronouncement scheduled 2026-12-17 | Federal Court of Justice hearing notice |
| Like Company v. Google | CJEU C-250/25 | Advocate General opinion 2026-11-03; judgment pending | CJEU press release 155/26 |
| The New York Times v. Microsoft and OpenAI | S.D.N.Y. 1:23-cv-11195-SHS-OTW (MDL No. 3143) | summary-judgment stage, no ruling located as of 2026-11-09 | S.D.N.Y. docket |
GEMA v. Suno is the sibling case: the same chamber applied the memorization line to music in Suno's models v3.5 and v4 on servers in Germany.
The table mixes German and EU proceedings with a United States suit that also names OpenAI, and the courts apply different law in each, so the rows are not comparable on the merits.
More About GEMA v. OpenAI
Decided Versus Still Open
The Munich court has decided liability at first instance; finality, any further instance and the amount of damages remain open.
| Decided at first instance | Still open |
|---|---|
| memorization in the model is reproduction | finality of the judgment |
| § 44b does not cover the model | further proceedings (none on a court source as of 2026-11-16) |
| outputs infringe and OpenAI is responsible | the amount of damages (not published) |
This page is information, not legal advice.
Frequently Asked Questions About GEMA v. OpenAI
Did GEMA win against OpenAI?
Yes at first instance. The Munich court granted the copyright claims in substance on 2025-11-11 and dismissed the personality-right claim, so GEMA succeeded in substantial part and not in full.
Is the GEMA v. OpenAI judgment final?
No. The court's press release states that the judgment is not final, and the check of 2026-11-16 found no court publication changing that.
Has a higher court ruled on GEMA v. OpenAI?
No higher-court decision or docket has been published on a court source as of 2026-11-16. The Higher Regional Court's press pages could not be retrieved on that date, and the status line changes only on a court publication.
Which song lyrics were at issue?
The lyrics of nine German songs. The court names "Atemlos" and "Wie schön, dass du geboren bist" and does not list the other seven.
Does the judgment set a license fee for OpenAI?
No. The court granted an injunction, information and damages, and the demand for a license is GEMA's statement, not a holding.