Four programs name Workday on their own pages, one program says payroll is never used, and the vendors' customer terms are on record for BambooHR only, as of November 17, 2026.
HR systems are one source in AI training data licensing, and not licensing is a valid result. What can leave is at most a de-identified subset of workflow records, after staff law, any works council and the program's own conditions have been satisfied.
Why Programs Ask for HR and Payroll Systems
Four programs name Workday among the business systems they take records from, and the people-record workflows they describe are the reason HR systems appear in requests.
Table of the programs that name Workday, as of 2026-11-17, in alphabetical order, with the program's own words and one published term. No payout is shown by design. Roles are as each company describes itself; no program on this list is ranked or recommended.
| Program | Role | What it names (own words) | One published term relevant to HR records | Checked | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Centific Enterprise Data | data vendor | "Workday" among "Business platforms"; "People operations"; "Your people record" | read-only connection to in-scope systems; exclusions enforced in extraction code | 2026-11-17 (terms 2026-11-09) | centific.com/enterprise-data |
| Nyne data partnerships | data vendor | "Workday" with "CRM, HR, ERP, and support records" | data de-identified; training and evaluation only | 2026-11-17 | nyne.ai/data-partnerships |
| Scale Data Partnerships | human-data platform | "Workday" with "CRM, HR, ERP, and support records" | anonymizes inside the company's environment before extraction | 2026-11-17 | scale.com/data-partnership |
| Troveo business data licensing | intermediary (licenses on the seller's behalf) | "ServiceNow, Workday, SAP and Dynamics" (logo text) with "Records behind IT, HR, and operations tickets, workflows, and approvals" | seller retains ownership | 2026-11-17 (data list 2026-11-09) | troveo.ai/business-data |
Nyne states de-identification and use for training and evaluation only. Scale states that it anonymizes inside the company's environment. Centific states that exclusions are enforced in extraction code, and Troveo, an intermediary, licenses on the seller's behalf. No page says which HR fields it takes, and this page does not guess.
The wording differs by program: two describe HR records as one item in a list of core systems, one describes a people-record workflow, and one places Workday beside records behind IT, HR and operations workflows, so the named system alone does not show what a program would accept. Payout terms for programs sit in AI data partnership payouts and program terms compared.
What an HR or Payroll System Holds and What Stays Out of a License
An HR or payroll system holds six classes of record, and each one is personal data about a named employee before it is anything a program wants.
Table of the record classes, as of 2026-11-17, with the rule or record that gates each. The classes are product vocabulary, and no field counts are claimed.
| Record class | Why it is personal data | Rule or record that gates it | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Core employee record (name, address, identifiers, job history) | names a person | GDPR Art. 6 basis plus national Art. 88 rules; CCPA employee exemption inoperative from 2023-01-01; Spirit schedule line "Employee Records (UKG)" | eur-lex.europa.eu; cppa.ca.gov; ECF 1802 |
| Payroll and tax forms | pay, tax and bank details | Spirit schedule lines "Payroll" and "Tax Forms", "Not Included" in the revised schedule; 29 CFR 516.5 keeps a 3-year copy duty; AfterQuery: payroll never used | ECF 1802; ecfr.gov; afterquery.com |
| Time and attendance | hours per person | Spirit schedule line "Time Card", "Not Included"; 29 CFR 516.6, 2 years | ECF 1802; ecfr.gov |
| Benefits, leave and union fields | can reveal health or union membership | GDPR Art. 9(1): health data and trade union membership prohibited unless an Art. 9(2) exception applies | eur-lex.europa.eu |
| Applicants and former staff | people outside current payroll | § 26(8) BDSG treats applicants and persons whose employment has ended as employees; 29 CFR 1602.14, personnel records 1 year | gesetze-im-internet.de; ecfr.gov |
| Policy and approval workflow records | the "people record" programs describe: decisions about individual employees | personal data until de-identified; programs state de-identification or anonymization | program pages |
Workflow records (approvals, exceptions, policy applied to individuals) are the one class that can leave, only de-identified and only past the gates below. AfterQuery states on its page, re-read November 17, 2026, that sensitive categories such as payroll, privileged legal material and credentials are never used.
Product vocabulary differs between vendors, so a seller maps its own fields to these classes during the inventory step rather than relying on a program's label.
Methods are covered under PII removal and de-identification before licensing, and recruitment and HR records as a data type are covered under recruitment and HR records as AI training data.
Rules That Reach HR Records Before Any Export
Three kinds of rule stand between an HR system and a program: the staff-data law of the country, the special-category ban for health and union data, and the co-determination rights of a works council.
Table of the gates, as of 2026-11-17, with the instrument and what it does for HR records.
| Gate | Instrument and date | What it does for HR records | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Staff-data rules | GDPR Art. 88(1) and (2); CJEU C-34/21, 2023-03-30; C-65/23, 2024-12-19 | national or collective rules must meet Art. 88(2) and Arts. 5, 6(1), 9(1) and (2); a rule that fails is disregarded | eur-lex.europa.eu |
| Special categories | GDPR Art. 9(1) | health, trade union and biometric data need an Art. 9(2) exception in addition to an Art. 6 basis | eur-lex.europa.eu |
| German works council | BetrVG § 87(1) Nr. 6 and 87(2); BAG 1 ABR 7/15, 2016-12-13 | co-determination over devices objectively suitable to monitor behavior or performance; conciliation board decides without agreement | gesetze-im-internet.de; bundesarbeitsgericht.de |
| Dutch works council | WOR art. 27(1)(k) and (l), 27(4) | consent for rules on processing personnel data and for monitoring systems; application to licensing untested | wetten.overheid.nl |
Article 88(1) and (2) of Regulation (EU) 2016/679 lets member states and collective agreements set more specific rules on employee data, and the CJEU held in C-34/21 on March 30, 2023 that national rules not meeting Art. 88(2) must be disregarded unless an Art. 6(3) basis applies.
The staff rules sit under employee data under GDPR Article 88. The Federal Labor Court (BAG 8 AZR 209/21, decided May 8, 2025) disapplied § 26(1) BDSG, held that employee data beyond a temporary works agreement uploaded to a group SharePoint to test Workday was justified under Art. 6(1)(f) only where dummy data do not suffice, and set non-material damages at EUR 200. A test upload is not a license, and the ruling is about testing.
Article 9(1) lists health data and trade union membership, which benefit, leave and dues fields can reveal.
In Germany, BetrVG § 87(1) Nr. 6 gives the works council co-determination over devices objectively suitable to monitor behavior or performance (BAG 1 ABR 7/15, December 13, 2016), and in the Netherlands WOR art. 27(1)(k) and (l) require consent for personnel-data rules and monitoring systems.
Whether these provisions apply to a data license has not been tested in court. A works agreement that already restricts what the HR system may be used for can bind the employer before any program is asked, so the agreement is read at the start, not at signing.
This section is information, not legal advice.
Workday, BambooHR, Paychex and ADP: What Their Own Documents Say
Of the four vendors, only BambooHR has a customer agreement on public record here, and it reads that the customer keeps ownership of Customer Data.
Table of the vendor documents, as of 2026-11-17, in alphabetical order, with what each document states and whether it is on record.
| Vendor | Document read | What it states | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| ADP | adp.com "Terms and Conditions" and data-privacy page | the terms govern use of ADP's website; the privacy page states principles; neither is a client service agreement | not on record |
| BambooHR | Terms of Service, last updated 2026-09-18, sections 2.5, 6.1, 6.2 | customer retains ownership of Customer Data (6.2); BambooHR may use Performance Data, operational data about use of the service, for "training and improving AI offerings" (6.1); customer export for 30 days after non-renewal or termination (2.5); payroll data kept up to seven years for its payroll service (2.5) | on record |
| Paychex | legal and privacy pages | HTTP 403 to the fetcher on 2026-11-17 | not on record |
| Workday | privacy page | navigation and no customer-data terms on the page read; customer agreement not public on pages read | not on record |
The BambooHR sections concern different things: 6.2 is about ownership of Customer Data, while 6.1 is about Performance Data, the operational data about use of the service, so neither sentence says that BambooHR trains on customer records or that it does not.
Additional Terms and the Order Form become part of the agreement and are not public.
A vendor document governs the vendor and its customer; it does not decide whether employees, a works council or a program's conditions allow a license. For Workday, Paychex and ADP, export routes, limits, ownership and AI-use terms are not on record here, and a seller reads its own order form and master agreement.
The vendor agreement is one layer of a rights audit for data you want to license. Program connectors against native exports are compared under buyer connectors vs native exports.
HR Lines in the Spirit Airlines Asset Schedule
The Spirit Airlines chapter 11 record is the one court filing on the site's record that lists HR and payroll lines inside a data sale for AI use; the revised schedule marks employee records as included and the other three as Not Included.
Table of the lines, as listed by the debtor in Bankr. S.D.N.Y. 25-11897, revised asset schedule, ECF 1802, November 9, 2026. No sale order on the docket as of 2026-11-18; sale hearing set for 2026-11-17.
| Schedule line | Count | Schedule status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Employee Records (UKG) | 175,658 | Included | ECF 1802 |
| Payroll | 3,426,618 | Not Included | ECF 1802 |
| Tax Forms | 148,018 | Not Included | ECF 1802 |
| Time Card | 1,092,000 | Not Included | ECF 1802 |
The counts are the debtor's own listing and not a record of anything sold. The August schedule (Dkt. 1463) listed payroll as included, and the revised schedule moved it to Not Included; AfterQuery's page says payroll is never used.
The staff lines in full are under employee data in bankruptcy data sales, and the sale itself is covered under Spirit Airlines' data archive sale.
Benefits, Risks, Downsides and Alternatives of Licensing HR Records
Licensing HR-derived data can turn workflow records the company already keeps into license income, and it also puts employees' data into a model that cannot be untrained.
Benefits
- Workflow records the company already keeps, such as approvals and exceptions, are the "people record" that four programs describe.
- A de-identified subset can leave without payroll, tax or benefit fields, which AfterQuery's page states are never used.
Risks
- GDPR Art. 88 and Art. 9 can make processing unlawful for the employer, as BAG 8 AZR 209/21 shows for a test upload.
- A works council can hold co-determination rights, and the Netherlands and German provisions have not been tested for licensing.
- Employee data in a trained model cannot be withdrawn.
Downsides
- Retention duties (29 CFR 516.5, 3 years for payroll records) mean an export never replaces the company's own copies.
- A vendor's terms, such as BambooHR's 30-day export window after non-renewal or termination, limit the time to act.
Alternatives
- Not licensing, and weighing whether to sell or license your data at all.
- A de-identified workflow subset after notice to staff and a works-council step.
- Excluding payroll, tax and benefit fields entirely.
- Internal use only.
Each option is a valid result, and none is a recommendation. The choice rests on whether the company can show a lawful basis for each record class, whether staff and any works council have been informed or have agreed, and whether the program's own conditions, such as de-identification before extraction, can be met.
Where HR Systems Fit Among Source Systems and the Seller Process
HR systems are one source system among several, and for HR records the staff steps come before the export.
Compare export rights and mechanics by source system first. Notice to staff comes first: employee notice and consent, then employee data and AI training rules by jurisdiction. The general list is what company data cannot be licensed.
- Special category data in AI training
- Works council co-determination in Germany
- Works council consent in the Netherlands
- Data sale readiness
- Data inventory for an AI data sale
- Customer consent and confidentiality clauses
- AI data licensing agreement
HR Records of a Closed or Insolvent Company
A closed company keeps legal retention duties for payroll and personnel records even when it licenses nothing, so an export for a license never replaces the company's own copies.
US floors are 3 years for payroll records (29 CFR 516.5) and 1 year for personnel records (29 CFR 1602.14), and BambooHR keeps payroll data up to seven years for its payroll service under its Terms of Service. See the retention floors in record retention after closing a company.
Program Pages Named on This Page
The program statements above come from each program's own page, re-read November 17, 2026; Troveo's fuller data list dates from November 9, 2026.
Related pages: company data partnership programs, who buys AI training data, AfterQuery data buyer profile, Centific data buyer profile, Nyne data buyer profile, Scale AI data buyer profile and Troveo data buyer profile.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a company license its Workday or other HR system data to AI companies?
Not as raw records: HR data describes employees, so staff law, special-category rules and any works council apply first, and the vendor's customer agreement is read second. A de-identified subset of workflow records is the only class programs describe.
How does a company export its data from Workday?
Workday's own export routes and limits are not on record here. A seller checks its own agreement and Workday's admin documentation.
Does BambooHR use customer data to train AI?
BambooHR's Terms of Service, last updated September 18, 2026, say the customer retains ownership of Customer Data. They also say BambooHR may use Performance Data, its operational data about use of the service, for training and improving AI offerings (sections 6.2 and 6.1).
Why do some programs exclude payroll data?
AfterQuery states that sensitive categories such as payroll, privileged legal material and credentials are never used. Other programs name HR systems without saying which fields they take.