A gap at any link limits what every later party can grant, so buyers ask the licensor to warrant the chain instead of inspecting it: micro1's master terms, last updated 2026-11-12, pair a no-prior-grant warranty (s.5.1) with a licensor indemnity (s.8.1).
US and UK statutes require a signed writing for a transfer of ownership, contributor terms decide whether the first link is an assignment or a license, and six gaps recur. The page follows the chain through AI training data licensing, link by link.
What a chain of rights records for licensed training data, link by link
Seven links recur in licensed training data, from the creator to the developer's own sublicensees, and each rests on a different document. The table lists them from the creator downstream, as of 2026-11-17.
| # | Link | Typical transfer | Document that evidences it | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Employee author to employer | ownership at creation (work made for hire; employer as first owner) | employment terms showing the work was made in the job | 17 U.S.C. 201(b), 101; CDPA s.11(2) (govinfo.gov; legislation.gov.uk) |
| 2 | Contractor or founder to company | assignment | assignment in writing signed by the owner or assignor | 17 U.S.C. 204(a); CDPA s.90(3) |
| 3 | Contributor to data platform | assignment or license in contributor terms | accepted terms version and date | Shipd s.3.1; Human Archive s.2 |
| 4 | User to online platform | license in the terms of service | terms version in force when the content was posted | the platform's own terms |
| 5 | Company to intermediary, if any | agreement under which the intermediary places or licenses data | platform or partner agreement | TollBit Publisher Platform Agreement, 2025-10-29: publisher warrants rights |
| 6 | Licensor to AI developer | exclusive or nonexclusive license | order form, master terms, data manifest | micro1 Data License Master Terms s.1.2, s.4.3 |
| 7 | Developer to affiliates, sublicensees, successors | sublicense or assignment | the license's sublicensing and assignment terms | micro1 s.1.2, s.9.1 |
The first two links are decided by employment law and signed assignments: under 17 U.S.C. 201(b) the employer owns a work made for hire unless both parties sign a written instrument saying otherwise, and under CDPA s.11(2) an employer is first owner of a work made by an employee in the course of employment, subject to agreement.
Employee, contractor and founder assignments are a rights audit topic, and the closing of gaps is left to that page.
Links 3 and 4 depend on terms the creator accepted, compared in the section on contributor terms. Links 5 to 7 are contracts the licensor signs or can read.
The chain is the rights record among the four that provenance covers, next to documentation, consent and processing, and the wider record is set out under training data provenance and its records.
Signed writing, recording and priority: the statutory rules for each transfer
US and UK law both require a signed writing for a transfer of copyright, and both decide in their statutes which grant wins when two conflict. The table sets the two regimes side by side, as read on 2026-11-17, with a dash where a rule is not compared on this page.
| Rule | United States | United Kingdom | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| What counts as a transfer | assignment, mortgage, exclusive license or other conveyance, limited or not; not a nonexclusive license (17 U.S.C. 101) | copyright transmissible by assignment, will or operation of law (CDPA s.90(1)) | govinfo.gov; legislation.gov.uk |
| Form | invalid unless an instrument, note or memorandum is in writing and signed by the owner or its authorized agent, except transfers by operation of law (204(a)) | assignment not effective unless in writing signed by or on behalf of the assignor (s.90(3)); exclusive licence is one in writing signed by or on behalf of the owner (s.92(1)) | 17 U.S.C. 204(a); CDPA s.90, s.92 |
| Evidence of signing | certificate of acknowledgement not required, but prima facie evidence of execution (204(b)) | - | 17 U.S.C. 204(b) |
| Partial grants | any exclusive right, or a subdivision of it, may be transferred and owned separately (201(d)(2)) | assignment may be limited to some acts or part of the term (s.90(2)) | 17 U.S.C. 201(d); CDPA s.90(2) |
| Recording | constructive notice only if the document identifies the work and the work is registered (205(c)) | - | 17 U.S.C. 205(c) |
| Two conflicting transfers | first executed prevails if recorded within 1 month (2 months if executed abroad) or before the later one; otherwise a later transfer recorded first, in good faith, for value and without notice prevails (205(d)) | - | 17 U.S.C. 205(d) |
| Earlier license against a later owner | signed nonexclusive license prevails if taken before the transfer, or in good faith before its recordation without notice (205(e)) | licence binds every successor in title, except a good-faith purchaser for value without notice and those claiming through it (s.90(4)) | 17 U.S.C. 205(e); CDPA s.90(4) |
| Author's termination | grants by the author on or after 1978-01-01, other than works made for hire, terminable during 5 years from 35 years after the grant; prior derivative works may continue (203(a), 203(b)(1)) | - | 17 U.S.C. 203 |
In the US, 17 U.S.C. 101 counts an exclusive license as a "transfer of copyright ownership" but not a nonexclusive license.
Section 204(a) makes a transfer "other than by operation of law" invalid unless an instrument, note or memorandum is "in writing and signed by the owner of the rights conveyed" or the owner's authorized agent.
Recording is optional: 205(c) gives constructive notice only when the document identifies the work and the work is registered, and 205(d) lets the first transfer win if recorded within one month of execution, or two months abroad, or before the later transfer. Under 205(e) a signed nonexclusive license can still prevail over a later conflicting transfer.
In the UK, CDPA s.90(3) makes an assignment ineffective unless in writing signed by or on behalf of the assignor, and s.92(1) defines an exclusive licence as one in writing signed by or on behalf of the owner.
Section 90(4) binds every successor in title to a licence already granted, except a purchaser in good faith for value without notice and those claiming through that purchaser.
No court decision applying these sections to an AI training data license is on record here, so the page says what the statute says, and the country rules for training itself are on United States AI training data law and the UK page below.
Contributor terms at the first link: assignment or license
Where data is made by contributors on a platform, the contributor terms are the first link, and they either assign the work outright or license it while the contributor keeps ownership. The table compares five sets of terms in alphabetical order, as of each check date, with the operators' wording quoted or closely paraphrased.
| Platform | Role (type) | Grant | Contributor keeps ownership | Onward grant | Checked | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alignerr | human-data platform | unlimited, irrevocable, perpetual, royalty-free right to use interview material (Terms) | not stated | sublicensable | 2026-11-09 | alignerr.com |
| Asimov | data buyer (collector program) | "worldwide, transferable, sublicensable, royalty-free, paid-up license" (contributor agreement version 2026-06-20.us-launch) | yes (license) | sublicensable; deletion does not recall data already licensed, sold or shared | 2026-11-09 | tryasimov.ai/contributor-agreement |
| Human Archive | data vendor | worldwide, perpetual, irrevocable, non-exclusive, royalty-free license (Contributor Terms s.2, last updated 2026-07-30) | yes | sublicensable | 2026-11-17 | humanarchive.ai/terms.html |
| Outlier (Scale AI) | human-data platform | contributor "irrevocably assign[s] all right title and interest throughout the world" in Work Product (ToS s.4(b), effective 2026-05-11) | no (assignment) | as owner | 2026-11-09 | outlier.ai/legal/terms-of-use |
| Shipd (Datacurve) | RL-environment builder | contributor "hereby irrevocably assign[s] to Shipd all right, title, and interest" in Work Product, on creation or submission (s.3.1) | no (assignment) | as owner | 2026-11-09 | shipd.ai/terms |
An assignment, as in Shipd's s.3.1 and Outlier's s.4(b), moves ownership to the platform on creation or submission, so the platform can grant on as owner.
A license, as in the Human Archive and Asimov terms, leaves ownership with the contributor and lets the platform pass on only what the license allows, which is why both are written as sublicensable; Alignerr's sublicensable right covers interview material, and its terms do not state who owns it.
Asimov adds that deleting an account does not recall data already licensed, sold or shared. Pay and job terms are a separate topic, covered under AI training platforms compared on pay and terms.
Gaps that break a chain of rights
A chain breaks where a link has no signed document, grants less than the next party claims, or collides with an earlier grant. Six gaps recur, each tied to one statute section or published term:
- No signed writing: a transfer without one is invalid under 17 U.S.C. 204(a) and ineffective under CDPA s.90(3).
- Partial transfer read as a whole one: rights can be split by right, time and place (201(d)(2); s.90(2)), so a grant of reproduction rights for one territory does not carry training rights everywhere.
- Earlier conflicting transfer: the first transfer wins on recordation under 205(d), whatever the later holder believed.
- Earlier license that survives: a signed nonexclusive license outlives a later transfer under 205(e), and a UK licence binds successors under s.90(4).
- Creator-side license not sublicensable or not transferable: the platform then cannot license on, the contrast with the contributor terms above.
- Author's termination right: a grant by the author, other than a work made for hire, can be terminated during the five years that begin 35 years after the grant (203(a), 203(a)(3)).
Termination leaves derivative works prepared before it usable under the grant (203(b)(1)), but no new ones. Whether a trained model counts as such a derivative work is not decided in any court decision on record here, so it stays an open question.
How a holder closes each gap inside its own records, through assignments, permissions and carve-outs, belongs to the rights audit of the data to be licensed.
How buyers and intermediaries test the chain before signing
Published terms show that buyers and intermediaries mostly test the chain through warranties and indemnities rather than by reading every document in it. The table lists seven programs alphabetically, as of each check date, with the role column keeping intermediaries apart from buyers.
| Program | Role | Chain test or condition | Remedy or consequence | Checked | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| aitrainer.work | broker | seller must own the asset or hold written permission from each contributor | not stated | 2026-11-17 | aitrainer.work/sell |
| Grepped | marketplace | licences to buyers are perpetual | seller indemnifies Grepped for third-party and regulator claims | 2026-11-08 | grepped.ai/terms |
| micro1 Data License Master Terms | buyer | no-prior-grant warranty (s.5.1); excluded categories (s.5.7) | licensor indemnifies IP, privacy, publicity and data protection claims (s.8.1); clawback with refund for a materially inaccurate Data Manifest, surviving acceptance (s.4.3) | terms last updated 2026-11-12, re-read 2026-11-17 (s.5.1 as read 2026-11-09) | micro1.ai/legal/data-license-master-terms |
| Pangea.ai code licensing | marketplace | owned private code only; no client-owned, public or forked code | uncapped ownership warranty | 2026-11-09 | pangea.ai |
| PIXTA AI data provider listing | data vendor (listing) | seller warrants lawful acquisition and the necessary rights (Art. 6.6) | written consent records available to PIXTA where personal information is included | 2026-11-09 (terms last updated 2025-03-03) | pixta.ai/term |
| Protege provider terms | marketplace | worldwide, royalty-free, non-exclusive license to Protege (s.1.1) | provider indemnifies (s.4.1); liability cap 2x fees in 12 months (s.6.2) | 2026-11-09 | withprotege.ai/provider-terms |
| TollBit Publisher Platform Agreement | platform (not a party to content licenses) | publisher warrants its rights | publisher indemnifies TollBit | 2026-11-09 (agreement 2025-10-29) | tollbit.com/legal |
Only micro1 links three remedies in its public terms: a no-prior-grant warranty, an indemnity and a clawback with refund for a materially inaccurate manifest that survives acceptance. The aitrainer.work broker page asks for ownership or written permission from each contributor, the only program here that names the contributor link.
TollBit states that it is not a party to the content licenses and that the publisher warrants its rights, so the chain test sits with the publisher. The full diligence process, on both sides, is set out under due diligence in an AI data deal.
Links added after signing: sublicensees, successors and termination
The chain does not stop at the licensee: a sublicensable grant adds links the licensor never signs. In micro1's master terms the license is "sublicensable through multiple tiers" (s.1.2), so every tier is a further link.
Either party may assign the master terms without consent in a merger, acquisition or sale of substantially all assets, but not to a competitor (s.9.1); the terms were last updated 2026-11-12. On the UK side, s.90(4) of the CDPA means a licence binds the licensor's successors in title, so the licensee's rights follow the copyright to a new owner.
Onward recipients and flow-down duties are compared under sublicensing and onward transfer in AI data licenses.
Benefits, risks, downsides and alternatives of documenting a full chain, including not licensing
A documented chain lets a holder give the warranties buyers ask for with less exposure, and the work of tracing it can show that some data should not be licensed at all.
Benefits
- Warranties such as micro1 s.5.1 and Pangea's uncapped ownership warranty can be given on evidence.
- Signed writings meet 17 U.S.C. 204(a) and CDPA s.90(3).
- A recorded transfer can win priority under 205(d).
Risks
- Indemnities stay with the licensor (micro1 s.8.1, Protege s.4.1, Grepped).
- A clawback can follow a materially inaccurate manifest after acceptance (micro1 s.4.3).
- An earlier license or a termination right may surface later (205(e); 203).
Downsides
- Staff time to trace each item back to its creator.
- Records for user and contributor content depend on terms versions the holder may not have kept.
Alternatives
- License only the datasets whose chain is complete.
- Carve out the rest.
- Use a collective or platform route where the intermediary sets the terms.
- Not licensing at all.
Where the chain of rights meets the rights audit, the contract and the source pages
The chain of rights is the record; the pages below take the audit that builds it, the clauses that rely on it and the sources it starts from.
- Sources of the first links: who owns code written by employees and contractors, platforms licensing user content, Outlier contributor terms, Datacurve and Shipd and Human Archive contributor terms.
- Changes of owner: data from acquired companies and data licenses in an M&A sale.
- Contract: indemnities and warranties in AI data licenses, the data manifest and dataset licenses for AI training.
- Law and records: UK copyright and AI training, dataset documentation, training data certifications and provenance pages at a glance.
- Programs: micro1 data buyer profile, Pangea.ai code licensing, aitrainer.work profile and TollBit publisher platform.
- Options: alternatives to selling data, including not selling.
Frequently asked questions
What does a chain of title establish for training data?
A chain of title establishes that each party from the creator to the licensor held, and validly passed on, the right it granted. A clean chain has a signed document for every link without gaps in time or parties, so the licensor can warrant what it licenses.
Does a transfer of copyright have to be in writing?
Yes for a transfer of ownership in the US and for an assignment in the UK. In the US that includes an exclusive license (17 U.S.C. 101, 204(a)); in the UK it covers an assignment (CDPA s.90(3)) and an exclusive licence (s.92(1)). A nonexclusive license is not a transfer under section 101.
Can two parties own rights in the same work?
Yes, exclusive rights can be transferred and owned separately. 17 U.S.C. 201(d)(2) allows any exclusive right or subdivision of it to be owned apart, and CDPA s.90(2) allows an assignment limited to some acts or part of the term. Joint authorship is not covered on this page.
Is a nonexclusive license part of the chain of rights?
Yes, it belongs in the record even though it is not a transfer of ownership. A signed nonexclusive license can prevail over a later conflicting transfer (17 U.S.C. 205(e)), and a UK licence binds successors in title (CDPA s.90(4)).
How this page is sourced and dated
Statutes were read on govinfo.gov (U.S. Code, 2023 edition) and legislation.gov.uk on 2026-11-17, and buyers' and platforms' terms are kept as published, with check dates from 2026-11-08 to 2026-11-17. The approach is set out under how we source and date figures. The page is information, not legal advice.