This page, as of 2026-11-17, sets the acts side by side with what each does and does not decide, including the Rome court's treatment of the OpenAI decision, and what they mean for a holder deciding whether to license.
It is written for Italian holders and buyers' counsel as the regulator layer of AI training data licensing.
Every act cites the Garante's own doc. web page and date, consulted 2026-11-17; the method is in how we source, date and check every figure.
Which Garante Acts Bear on AI Training Data?
Seven entries from 2024-05-20 to 2026-04-17 bear on AI training data, and only two of them are fines on an AI developer. The table, as of 2026-11-17, compares the acts by date, kind and content; the "Relevance" column is analysis.
| Date | Act | Kind | Outcome or content | Relevance to AI training data | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-04-17 | Ordinanza ingiunzione, Framos Italia s.r.l. in liquidazione, registro n. 278, doc. web 10250265 | order and fine | EUR 5,000 (order of 2026-04-17); mailboxes kept active six months | retention and balancing test for staff data | garanteprivacy.it |
| 2025-05-19 | Press page on Luka Inc. (Replika), doc. web 10132048 | fine and investigation | EUR 5 million (press page of 2025-05-19); new investigation into the model lifecycle | training practices named in the investigation | garanteprivacy.it |
| 2025-01-30 | Press page and limitation order on DeepSeek, doc. web 10097450 | urgent limitation | processing of Italian users' data limited; investigation opened | outcome not stated | garanteprivacy.it |
| 2024-12-20 | Press release on n. 755, doc. web 10085432 | press release | announces the decision of 2024-11-02: EUR 15 million, six-month campaign | training without adequate legal basis was a finding | garanteprivacy.it |
| 2024-11-02 | Provvedimento n. 755, OpenAI | fine | opposition upheld by Tribunale di Roma n. 4153/2026 (published 2026-03-18), doc. web 10085455 | status: opposition upheld by court, decision temporarily removed | garanteprivacy.it |
| 2024-06-06 | Documento di indirizzo, registro n. 364, doc. web 10026277 | guidance | metadata orientation of 21 days | staff mailbox retention | garanteprivacy.it |
| 2024-05-20 | Nota informativa on web scraping and generative AI, doc. web 10020334 | guidance | four measures for site operators | reserving a holder's own site from scraping | garanteprivacy.it |
The Garante's formal warning to GEDI is covered on its own page, linked in the border below.
The Web-Scraping Note of 2024-05-20: Guidance for Site Operators, Not a Ruling
The note of 2024-05-20 (nota informativa, doc. web 10020334) is guidance addressed to website and platform operators as controllers of the personal data they publish, and it states no verdict on whether a given scraping is lawful.
It follows the fact-finding survey decided on 2023-12-21 (Gazzetta Ufficiale n. 14 of 2024-01-18) and says lawfulness is assessed case by case. Its bot-countermeasure family names robots.txt as an example, and the technical rules are set out under robots.txt rules for AI crawlers.
The note lists four measures a site operator can take:
- Reserved areas: content placed behind registration, so that it is not freely reachable.
- Terms of service: clauses that ban scraping, a legal measure that works after the fact.
- Traffic monitoring: checks on network traffic with rate limiting for abnormal request volumes.
- Bot countermeasures: technical steps against automated access, with robots.txt named as one example.
The Garante calls these measures "not exhaustive" in method or result and says no technique cancels bots 100 percent. The note is not binding and sets no duty. Copyright and text-and-data-mining opt-outs sit on other pages.
Measures Against AI Developers: OpenAI, DeepSeek and Replika
The Garante has fined two AI operators, OpenAI by a decision dated 2024-11-02 (provvedimento n. 755, EUR 15 million) and Luka Inc., the Replika operator (EUR 5 million, press page of 2025-05-19), and on 2025-01-30 it limited DeepSeek's processing of Italian users' data.
On OpenAI, the press release of 2024-12-20 announces the decision, and that date is not the decision date. The Garante's findings are that OpenAI gave no notification of the March 2023 breach, trained its models without an adequate legal basis, breached transparency duties and had no age verification.
It also ordered a six-month information campaign, its first use of Art. 166(7) of the Privacy Code, and sent the file to Ireland after OpenAI set up its European headquarters there, as the one-stop-shop rule provides; the Irish Data Protection Commission oversight of AI training is covered on its own page.
The Tribunale di Roma, in judgment n. 4153/2026 published on 2026-03-18, upheld ("accolta") OpenAI's opposition, and the Garante temporarily removed the decision from its site.
The Garante's notice does not say whether the decision was set aside in whole or in part, and the fine cannot be called in force. The grounds and any appeal are not stated in the sources read.
On DeepSeek, the limitation of 2025-01-30 targets Hangzhou DeepSeek Artificial Intelligence and Beijing DeepSeek Artificial Intelligence, and an investigation was opened. The companies answered that they do not operate in Italy and that EU law does not apply, and the Garante found the answer "entirely insufficient" (del tutto insufficiente). The outcome is not stated.
On Replika, the Garante found no legal basis identified as of 2023-02-02, an inadequate privacy policy and no age verification, ordered the company to comply and opened a new investigation into the generative model's whole lifecycle, including training practices, risk assessments and anonymization. Publication of the order is not applied while Luka's opposition proceedings are pending.
The training-data point common to these acts is the legal basis for the data a model learns from, which is analysis, not a holding. The Italian Garante v. OpenAI case record holds the OpenAI detail.
Employee Mailboxes: The Metadata Guidance and the Framos Order
The Garante's guidance on email metadata at work (documento di indirizzo of 2024-06-06, doc. web 10026277) is non-binding and orients employers to keep metadata for no more than 21 days unless documented needs justify longer. The table, as of 2026-11-17, compares the three mailbox acts.
| Act | Date | What it says | Binding | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Documento di indirizzo, first version, provv. 642, doc. web 9978728 | 2023-12-21 | metadata no more than seven days, 48 hours more on documented need; effect deferred by the consultation of provv. 127 of 2024-02-22 | no (guidance) | garanteprivacy.it |
| Documento di indirizzo, post-consultation, registro n. 364, doc. web 10026277 | 2024-06-06 | orientation of 21 days, longer only with documented need; no new duties; Statuto art. 4(1) applies to broader collection | no (guidance) | garanteprivacy.it |
| Ordinanza ingiunzione, Framos Italia, registro n. 278, doc. web 10250265 | 2026-04-17 | six months against a three-month own period; no balancing test at the time; EUR 5,000 | yes (order to one company) | garanteprivacy.it |
The first version said no more than seven days, with 48 hours more on documented need, and its effect was deferred when the Garante opened a consultation.
The version of 2024-06-06 says it creates no new duties. Broader collection and retention can amount to indirect remote monitoring, and then Statuto dei lavoratori art. 4(1) applies, which requires a union agreement or public authorization.
In the Framos order (ordinanza ingiunzione of 2026-04-17), two mailboxes of a former employee stayed active from 2023-06-30 to 2023-12-21, against the company's own three-month period.
No balancing test existed at the time, and one was produced only with the defence of 2024-10-03. The Garante rejected Art. 17(3)(e) GDPR because no dispute was pending, fined the company EUR 5,000 in the order of 2026-04-17 and set the amount taking account of the company being in liquidation.
The Statuto art. 4 analysis is on the page on licensing employee email and chat data in Italy, not yet published.
Neither act concerns licensing mailbox content to an AI developer, which is analysis, not a holding.
What the Garante's Acts Mean for a Data License: Benefits, Risks, Downsides and Alternatives, Including Not Licensing
The Garante's acts reward a license built on a documented legal basis and a bounded data set, but they do not clear any deal, and not licensing stays a valid choice.
Benefits
- A written legal-basis assessment before delivery answers the question the OpenAI and Framos findings turn on.
- Staff and user data de-identified or removed before delivery keeps the personal-data question out of the file, and the seller's employee notice and consent when licensing internal communications steps cover the staff side.
- Operators who reserved scraping by the note's measures hold a dated record of the reservation.
Risks
- A fine (OpenAI, Replika) or a limitation (DeepSeek) is the Garante's tool against AI operators.
- Processing without an identified legal basis and without age verification was the finding in two acts (OpenAI, Replika).
- Retention beyond the stated period was the Framos finding.
Downsides
- The court outcome on n. 755 shows an act can be successfully opposed in court, so no act settles a question for good.
- Documenting a legal basis takes time before any income.
Alternatives
- License only non-personal or de-identified data.
- Reserve scraping of the holder's own site by the note's measures.
- Keep the data internal.
- Not license at all.
The full weighing of these choices is set out under should you sell or license your data to AI companies.
Beyond the Garante: Italian Law, EU Rules and the Seller Process
The Garante's acts are one layer of Italian practice; the statute, the staff rules, the GEDI warning, the Irish file and the seller steps sit on their own pages. The parent page, Italy: rules for licensing data for AI training, holds the statute, the staff rule and the Garante in one place.
- Italy's AI law, the statute this page does not repeat.
- Licensing employee email and chat data in Italy, for Statuto art. 4 (not yet published).
- GEDI and OpenAI, the formal warning of 2024-11-27.
- Web scraping for AI training, copyright, contract and misuse law.
- Legitimate interest for AI training data, the balancing test the Framos order turned on.
- Employee data under GDPR Article 88, how collective rules count.
- France: CNIL guidance on AI training data, another authority's AI sheets, for contrast.
- Licensing a company email archive for AI training, email archives as a data type.
- PII removal and de-identification before licensing data, removing personal data before delivery.
- Alternatives to selling data to AI labs, including not selling.
- AI training data law by jurisdiction, every jurisdiction.
What This Page Does Not Cover
This page covers the Garante's acts on AI training data, scraping and employee mailboxes, not Legge 132/2025, not the mining article and not the Statuto art. 4 analysis. The formal warning to GEDI is on its own page, and royalty withholding and liquidation are on the parent.
How This Page Is Sourced and Dated
Every act cites the Garante's doc. web page and its date, consulted 2026-11-17. The checking rules are in how we source, date and check every figure, and this page is general information about Italian law, not legal advice for any specific deal.
Frequently Asked Questions
The answers below are as of 2026-11-17 and cite the Garante's own pages.
Is the Garante's EUR 15 million fine on OpenAI still in force?
The Tribunale di Roma upheld OpenAI's opposition in judgment n. 4153/2026, published 2026-03-18. The Garante temporarily removed decision n. 755 of 2024-11-02 from its site, and its notice does not say more.
Is the Garante's web-scraping note binding?
No: the note of 2024-05-20 is guidance to site operators. It lists four possible measures and sets no duty.
How long may an employer keep email metadata under the Garante's guidance?
The guidance of 2024-06-06 orients to no more than 21 days, longer only with documented need. The first version of 2023-12-21 said seven days and was superseded.