
Six lawsuits are on the record as of 2026-11-10, and one has a court-approved settlement: McKinney v. Scale AI, with final approval filed on 2026-10-30.
The cases are disputes on the human side of AI training data licensing: they concern how the people who make training data are classified and paid, not whether a model may train on a work.
Copyright suits against AI developers sit elsewhere on the site. Every claim below is an allegation unless a docket entry records an order.
DataPacts takes its dockets from court documents and administrator notices, and how DataPacts sources and dates every figure is set out in the methodology.
Contributor cases on the record, by operator and status
Six contributor lawsuits are on the record as of 2026-11-10: one settled with final approval, one with a noticed settlement, one voluntarily dismissed and three pending or stayed. The table lists them by filing or first docket date, with the latest docket entry read and its date.
- "Allegation" means a claim pleaded in a complaint, never decided by a court.
- "Status" is the latest docket entry read, with its date; the Cavalier register number is not stated here.
- A row ends with the document or docket feed it comes from.
| Case | Operator (brand) | Court and docket | What the complaint claims | Status as of 2026-11-10 | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ramey v. Scale AI, Inc., et al. | Scale AI, Inc.; Outlier AI, Inc.; HireArt, Inc. (Outlier) | N.D. Cal. 3:24-cv-06999 | class action; claims not recorded | joint notice of settlement, Dkt. 32, 2025-02-11; HireArt stipulation for dismissal, Dkt. 36, 2025-05-12; no dismissal order; terms not public | courtlistener.com docket feed |
| Schuster v. Scale AI, Inc., et al. | Scale AI, Inc.; Smart Ecosystem, Inc.; Outlier AI, Inc. (Outlier) | N.D. Cal. 3:25-cv-00620-JSC; complaint Dkt. 1, 2025-01-17 | psychological harm from writing violent and abusive prompts (negligence, UCL) | voluntarily dismissed by notice of 2026-08-10, with prejudice as to named plaintiffs, without as to the putative class | courtlistener.com, Dkt. 34 |
| McKinney v. Scale AI, Inc., et al. | Scale AI, Inc.; Smart Ecosystem, Inc.; HireArt, Inc.; individual defendants (Outlier) | Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco, CGC-24-620481 | misclassification; unpaid wages; unreimbursed expenses; PAGA penalties | settled: final approval order filed 2026-10-30; gross USD 12,500,000; class period 2020-12-10 to 2026-02-28 | class notice and final approval order (Simpluris) |
| Cavalier v. Surge Labs, Inc. dba DataAnnotation, et al. | Surge Labs, Inc. (DataAnnotation) | Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco; filed 2025-05-20; number not stated | misclassification; minimum wage; meal and rest periods; unpaid training and qualification exams | pending as of 2026-11-09; no ruling or settlement found | complaint of 2025-05-20 (court register not openable) |
| White v. Mercor.io Corporation | Mercor.io Corporation (Mercor) | N.D. Tex. (San Angelo) 6:26-cv-00201-H; complaint Dkt. 1, 2026-05-08 | misclassification; Section 7434 subclass (Forms 1099-NEC); excess self-employment tax; unpaid monitored time | amended complaint Dkt. 16, 2026-06-25; Mercor's amended motion to compel arbitration Dkt. 19, 2026-07-09; docket lists an order on the motions to compel, dismiss, stay and strike, Dkt. 28, 2026-11-12 (order text not read as of 2026-11-16) | courtlistener.com, Dkt. 16 and docket feed |
| Boggs v. Stryder Corp., et al. | Stryder Corp. (d/b/a Handshake); Handshake AI Solutions, LLC (Handshake AI Fellowship) | N.D. Cal. 3:26-cv-07498-TSH; complaint 2026-07-20 | FLSA minimum wage and overtime; Cal. Lab. Code 2775 misclassification; unpaid assessments and onboarding | stayed pending mediation, Dkt. 22 order, 2026-10-22; status report due 2027-02-05 | courtlistener.com, Dkt. 1 and docket feed |
What the complaints claim: misclassification, unpaid time, tax forms and harm
Four of the six cases claim that contributors were employees treated as independent contractors; Schuster claims psychological harm from the work itself, and the Ramey claims are not recorded. McKinney adds unpaid wages, unreimbursed expenses and penalties under the California Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA).
Cavalier and Boggs plead unpaid time that the platform does not count as work: training and qualification exams in Cavalier, assessments and onboarding in Boggs. White pleads the tax side, a claim over Forms 1099-NEC that Mercor filed.
The table lists the laws these complaints rely on, as of 2026-11-09, with the official text as source.
| Law | Citation and date | What it decides | Pleaded in | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| California ABC test | Cal. Lab. Code 2775 et seq. (AB 5, amended by AB 2257); in force 2020-01-01 | a worker is an employee unless the hiring entity proves all three prongs | Cavalier, Boggs | dir.ca.gov |
| FLSA classification rule | 89 FR 1638, effective 2024-03-11; NPRM 91 FR 9932, published 2026-02-27, not final | economic-reality test for minimum wage and overtime (29 U.S.C. 206, 207) | Boggs | federalregister.gov |
| Fraudulent information returns | 26 U.S.C. 7434(a) | a person may sue anyone who willfully files a fraudulent information return about payments to them | White | law.cornell.edu |
| California PAGA | Cal. Lab. Code 2698 et seq. | civil penalties for Labor Code violations | McKinney | class notice |
Under the ABC test, the hiring entity must show that the worker is free from its control, does work outside its usual course of business and is customarily engaged in an independent trade.
The 2024 federal rule applies an economic-reality analysis, and the 2026 proposal that would replace it is not final. For how the ABC test and the FLSA classify contributors, the classification page sets out both tests.
Scale AI and Outlier: one approved settlement, one noticed settlement, one dismissal
Scale AI and its affiliates face the longest record: McKinney settled for a gross USD 12,500,000 with final approval on 2026-10-30, Ramey reached a joint notice of settlement on 2025-02-11, and Schuster was voluntarily dismissed on 2026-08-10. In McKinney the defendants are Scale AI, Inc., its affiliate Smart Ecosystem, Inc. (which operates Outlier) and HireArt, Inc., a staffing company that placed workers with Scale AI, together with individual defendants. Scale AI's company-data side sits in its Scale AI data buyer profile.
The court-appointed administrator is Simpluris, Inc. According to the final approval order of 2026-10-30, the defendants funded the settlement on 2026-07-01, preliminary approval came on 2026-05-07, and the record shows no objections and 3 opt-outs.
In Ramey, a class action in the Northern District of California (3:24-cv-06999), the docket shows a joint notice of settlement on 2025-02-11 and a stipulation for dismissal by HireArt on 2025-05-12. It shows no dismissal order, the terms are not public and the claims are not recorded.
Schuster (3:25-cv-00620-JSC) ended by voluntary dismissal, not settlement. The notice of 2026-08-10 dismissed with prejudice as to the named plaintiffs and without prejudice as to the putative class. The record of the full McKinney schedule is kept in the McKinney settlement amounts and dates.
Surge Labs (DataAnnotation) and Stryder (Handshake): classification claims still open
Two misclassification class actions remain undecided: Cavalier v. Surge Labs, filed 2025-05-20 in San Francisco Superior Court, and Boggs v.
Stryder Corp., filed 2026-07-20 in the Northern District of California and stayed pending mediation since 2026-10-22. Surge Labs, Inc. operates DataAnnotation, and its company-data side sits in the Surge AI data buyer profile. The Cavalier register number is not stated here, and the case was pending as of 2026-11-09.
The Cavalier complaint alleges misclassification, unpaid minimum wage, missed meal and rest periods, and unpaid training and qualification exams. It also alleges that recruitment promised hourly rates of USD 20 to 40, per the complaint filed on 2025-05-20. No ruling or settlement has been found.
Boggs names Stryder Corp., doing business as Handshake, and Handshake AI Solutions, LLC, the entity behind the Handshake AI Fellowship. It pleads minimum wage and overtime under 29 U.S.C. 206 and 207, misclassification under Cal.
Lab. Code 2775, and unpaid assessments and onboarding. The order of 2026-10-22 (Dkt. 22) stays the case pending mediation, and a status report is due on 2027-02-05.
The complaint alleges pay of about USD 4 per chat interaction on a first project, as filed on 2026-07-20. That figure is an allegation, not a finding. Handshake's own program terms are in the Handshake AI data buyer profile.
Mercor: a tax-form claim in Texas, and a breach case kept apart
White v. Mercor.io Corporation, filed in the Northern District of Texas, is the only contributor case that sues over the tax forms themselves, pleading a Section 7434 subclass for workers who received Forms 1099-NEC.
Mercor's own program is described in the Mercor data buyer profile. The complaint was filed on 2026-05-08 (6:26-cv-00201-H), and the first amended complaint of 2026-06-25 added the subclass.
Beyond the tax-form claim, the amended complaint alleges misclassification, excess self-employment tax, unpaid time monitored by Insightful software and unpaid benefits. All of these are allegations.
Mercor filed an amended motion to compel arbitration and stay or dismiss on 2026-07-09 (Dkt. 19); the docket lists an order on the motions to compel, dismiss, stay and strike on 2026-11-12 (Dkt. 28), whose text was not read as of 2026-11-16.
The size of the workforce is stated two ways. The amended complaint cites "more than 30,000" publicly reported Mercor experts, while Mercor stated an expert network of "nearly five million" on 2026-06-25. The two figures stay side by side, because the complaint's count is an allegation and Mercor's is its own claim.
Two proceedings sit near the pay cases but are not about pay. The table lists them, as of 2026-11-09, and the breach case in full is on its own page.
| Proceeding | Forum and reference | What it concerns | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| In re Mercor.io Corporation Data Breach Litigation | N.D. Cal. Lead Case 3:26-cv-02821-WHO | contractors and job applicants; breach via compromised LiteLLM versions, breach dates 2026-03-24 and 2026-03-30 as reported to the California AG | consolidated 2026-05-19 (ECF 29); stay pending mediation stipulated 2026-07-21 (Dkt. 44); no merits ruling | archive.org RECAP, Dkt. 44 |
| Five GDPR complaints against Scale AI (Outlier) | data protection authorities in France, Italy, the Netherlands and Austria; no reference numbers published | trackers, Persona biometric checks, unanswered access requests (allegations) | filed 2026-10-27 by noyb with Intérêt à Agir, DIPLab and Reversing.Works; no decision found | noyb.eu |
How arbitration clauses and class waivers shape who can sue
A contributor who accepts a platform's arbitration clause and does not opt out usually brings pay claims alone before an arbitrator, not as part of a class in court.
Outlier's Terms of Use, effective 2026-05-11 and checked 2026-11-09, send disputes to individual arbitration before the American Arbitration Association (AAA) with a class waiver, and allow US residents to opt out within 30 days (section 10).
In Schuster the defendants moved to compel arbitration and stay the case on 2025-04-02. The case then ended by voluntary dismissal, so no ruling on that motion is recorded.
In White, the docket lists an order on Mercor's amended motion to compel arbitration (Dkt. 19) on 2026-11-12 (Dkt. 28); its outcome was not read as of 2026-11-16.
Other platforms write their dispute terms differently, and the dispute terms compared across platforms are set out on the comparison page. This section is information, not a prediction of how a court treats any clause.
What a class settlement means for a contributor: membership, payment and Form 1099
A class settlement pays only the people inside the class definition who did not opt out, and in McKinney that means contributors residing in California between 2020-12-10 and 2026-02-28. Simpluris, the court-appointed administrator, runs the settlement website, and the opt-out deadline of 2026-09-03 has passed.
The payment path has dates. The final approval order was filed on 2026-10-30, and a status conference on distribution is set for 2027-09-13. Per-person amounts are not recorded in the sources read.
A contributor checks four things in a class settlement notice:
- the class definition, including residence and dates;
- the opt-out deadline;
- the administrator that runs the claim and payment;
- the tax form on which payments are reported.
In McKinney the class notice allocates the contributor payments 100 % to non-wages reported on Form 1099, never on a W-2. The threshold for Form 1099-NEC is USD 2,000 for payments after 2025-12-31, and self-employment tax is 15.3 % on net earnings of USD 400 or more in 2026. For 1099s and self-employment tax, the taxes page gives the detail.
What the court record does not show
The court record shows filings, orders and one approved settlement, but not the terms of Ramey, the per-person payments in McKinney or any finding that a contributor was an employee. Five gaps follow from that:
- Ramey: the settlement terms are not public, and the claims are not recorded.
- McKinney: the per-person payments are not recorded.
- Merits: no court has ruled that a contributor was or was not an employee in any of the six cases.
- noyb: no data protection authority decision is known on the five complaints.
- Cases without a primary court record are left out of the table.
How these cases are tracked: court sources, as-of dates, allegations apart
Every row comes from a court document, a docket feed or a court-appointed administrator's notice, and every status carries the date the docket was last read. Forum threads, plaintiff-firm intake pages and press reports are not sources.
Settlements are stated only from the notice and the order, so an amount appears only where an administrator or court document gives it. Allegations stay allegations until a docket entry records an order. This page is information, not legal advice, and it takes no part in any claim.
For the method behind each date, see how we source, date and check every figure.
Where contributor cases meet the rest of human data
This page tracks contributor lawsuits; the pages below cover the platforms, pay, legitimacy checks, privacy and the copyright cases that concern training data itself.
- The companies behind contributor work
- Outlier's pay, terms and record
- DataAnnotation's pay, terms and record
- Stated rates, dated
- Scams and how to check a platform
- Copyright cases about the training data itself
- Breaches and complaints, dated
- ID checks, monitoring and breaches
- The GDPR complaints in full
Frequently asked questions
Is there a class action against Outlier AI?
Yes: McKinney v. Scale AI, a class action against Scale AI and Smart Ecosystem, which does business as Outlier AI, settled with final approval on 2026-10-30. Ramey has a joint notice of settlement, and Schuster was voluntarily dismissed. The GDPR complaints of 2026-10-27 are not lawsuits.
How much did Scale AI pay to settle with contractors?
The McKinney settlement is a gross USD 12,500,000, with final approval filed on 2026-10-30. The defendants funded it on 2026-07-01. The gross figure is not the amount contributors receive, and the sources read do not record deductions or the net.
When will the Scale AI settlement pay out?
The record sets a status conference on distribution for 2027-09-13. The court-appointed administrator, Simpluris, runs payment, and payments are reported on Form 1099. Per-person amounts are not recorded.
Has DataAnnotation been sued by its contributors?
Yes: Cavalier v. Surge Labs, Inc. dba DataAnnotation, filed on 2025-05-20 in San Francisco Superior Court, was pending as of 2026-11-09. The claims are allegations only, and no ruling or settlement has been found.
Can contributors outside California bring these claims?
The McKinney class covers only contributors residing in California, but Boggs and White plead federal law. Outlier's opt-out right applies to US residents. In the EU, Directive (EU) 2024/2831 on platform work is to be transposed by 2026-12-02.