DataPacts

McKinney v. Scale AI: Contributor Misclassification Settlement, Amounts and Dates

Checked

At a glance

McKinney v. Scale AI is a California class and PAGA settlement, approved by final order on October 30, 2026, in which Scale AI, its affiliate Smart Ecosystem (which runs Outlier), the staffing company HireArt and four individuals agreed to pay a gross USD 12,500,000 to resolve claims that contributors who produced AI training data were misclassified as independent contractors (San Francisco Superior Court, Case No. CGC-24-620481).

Independent reference. Every buyer is covered on the same terms, every figure carries its source and check date, and no buyer pays to be listed or placed higher.

Request an independent introduction

Tell us what data your company holds. We reply with the buyers that fit and what their terms leave out. Your details reach a buyer only after you agree to a named introduction.

IndependentYour details stay with us until you agreeNot selling is a valid outcome

Judge Ethan P. Schulman granted final approval and entered judgment that day. As of November 17, 2026, no payment to contributors is on the record, payments are due within 14 days after the judgment becomes final, and a status conference on distribution is set for September 13, 2027.

A settlement is a compromise, not a finding: the defendants deny the claims and no court has ruled on the merits.

The case belongs to the independent reference on AI training data licensing because it concerns the human route, data made by paid contributors. DataPacts is not affiliated with any party and gives no legal or tax advice.

Amounts, dates and quotations come from the court-approved class notice, the settlement agreement with its addendum, the final approval order and the judgment, read on November 17, 2026, and how figures are sourced and dated is set out on the methodology page.

McKinney v. Scale AI at a Glance: Court, Case Number, Parties and Status

The case is settled: the court approved the settlement and entered judgment on October 30, 2026, and the defendants funded the USD 12,500,000 on July 1, 2026. The table gives the case facts as of 2026-11-17.

Field Value Source
Case McKinney, et al. v. Scale AI, Inc., et al. final approval order caption
Court Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco, Department 304 (Judge Ethan P. Schulman) final approval order
Case number CGC-24-620481 (consolidated with three related suits) order; settlement agreement 1.1
Class representatives Steve McKinney, Michelle Lynn Brunetti, Roger Justin Caffier, Chloe Agape, Amber Rogowicz, Alexander Ovadal final approval order para. 8
Defendants Scale AI, Inc.; Smart Ecosystem, Inc. (Outlier); HireArt, Inc.; Alexandr Wang; Dennis Cinelli; Daniel Berrios; Xiaote Zhu final approval order caption
Claims misclassification as independent contractors; unpaid wages; unreimbursed expenses; PAGA penalties (Cal. Lab. Code 2698 et seq.) class notice
Class individuals who provided services as contributors while residing in California, or were placed by HireArt with Scale AI or Smart Ecosystem, 2020-12-10 to 2026-02-28 order para. 7
PAGA period 2023-10-29 to 2026-02-28 order para. 15
Gross settlement USD 12,500,000 plus employer-side payroll taxes; funded 2026-07-01 judgment; order para. 11
Administrator Simpluris, Inc.; mckinneyscaleaisettlement.com class notice
Status settled: final approval and judgment 2026-10-30; status conference on distribution 2027-09-13 order paras. 11, 17; judgment

Four San Francisco Lawsuits Folded Into One Settlement

The settlement resolves four lawsuits filed in San Francisco County Superior Court, which the parties agreed to combine into one consolidated complaint in the McKinney case. The table lists them as of 2026-02-06, the date of the settlement agreement.

Action Case number Filed Who it covers Source
McKinney, et al. v. Scale AI, Inc., et al. CGC-24-620481 lead case contractors of Scale AI; lead case for the consolidated complaint agreement 1.1, 2.1, 2.9
Rogowicz, et al. v. Smart Ecosystem, Inc. CGC-25-621144 2025-01-03 PAGA claims; class claims added 2025-08-04 agreement 2.2
Agape v. Scale AI, Inc., et al. (PAGA) CGC-25-624303 2025-04-11 HireArt-placed workers and contractors agreement 2.3
Agape v. Scale AI, Inc., et al. (class) CGC-25-625224 2025-05-09 HireArt-placed workers and contractors agreement 2.3

Rogowicz began as a PAGA-only action and added class claims on August 4, 2025, and the two Agape suits bring in workers placed through HireArt.

McKinney was amended on February 28, 2025 and again on May 19, 2025, when two plaintiffs were added, and the consolidated complaint adds claims such as paid sick leave and CalWARN. Search results titled "Agape v. Scale AI" are two of these suits, not a separate case.

What the Contributors Alleged and What the Defendants Deny

The plaintiffs alleged that Scale AI and its co-defendants treated contributors as independent contractors when California law made them employees, and so failed to pay minimum wage, overtime and expenses, among other Labor Code violations.

The class notice also lists claims over records and wage statements, meal and rest breaks, paid sick leave, workers' compensation insurance, the seventh day of rest, the Wage Theft Prevention Act, unfair competition and CalWARN. In the agreement, "Contributors" include Generative AI Annotators, Prompt Engineers and Subject Matter Experts.

The defendants strongly deny every claim, maintain that contributors are independent contractors and say the claims belong in binding arbitration. The agreement records no admission, certifies the class for settlement purposes only, and no court has made a merits determination.

As of November 17, 2026, the settlement terms follow below, and the legal test behind the dispute is covered in how AI training contributors are classified.

Where the USD 12.5 Million Goes: Deductions Before Contributors Are Paid

As of October 30, 2026, the USD 12,500,000 gross amount pays six kinds of deductions first, and what remains, the net settlement amount, is divided among contributors who did not opt out. The table shows each term as of 2026-10-30.

Item Term in the notice and agreement Who receives it Source
Gross settlement amount USD 12,500,000, non-reversionary, no claim form; employer-side payroll taxes paid on top administrator's settlement fund agreement 1.23, 3.1; judgment
Attorneys' fees up to one-third of the gross (USD 4,166,666.67) class counsel (four firms) notice 3.B.1; agreement 3.2.2
Litigation expenses up to USD 100,000 class counsel notice 3.B.1; agreement 3.2.2
Service payments up to USD 15,000 per representative, USD 90,000 total six class representatives notice 3.B.2; agreement 3.2.1
Administration up to USD 100,000 Simpluris, Inc. notice 3.B.3; agreement 3.2.3
PAGA payment USD 500,000, approved: USD 325,000 (65 %) to the LWDA, USD 175,000 (35 %) to PAGA workers State of California; PAGA workers order para. 15
Net settlement amount the remainder after court-approved deductions, paid by class workweeks participating class members notice 3.C; agreement 1.30

The caps come from the court-approved notice and the agreement, and the court set each award in the final approval order of October 30, 2026, together with the USD 500,000 PAGA payment.

Any amount the court does not award is added to the net settlement amount. The gross amount is non-reversionary, so no part returns to the defendants, no claim form is needed, and the employer-side payroll taxes are paid on top of it.

How an Individual Payment Is Calculated: Class Workweeks and PAGA Pay Periods

Each contributor's class payment is the net settlement amount divided by all participating members' class workweeks, multiplied by that contributor's own class workweeks. A class workweek is a week in which the person was paid for contributor work or for a HireArt placement.

The USD 175,000 PAGA share approved on October 30, 2026 is divided among PAGA workers the same way by pay periods, and PAGA workers cannot opt out of that part. The notice showed each person's workweeks, and challenges to them closed on September 3, 2026.

The defendants estimated, as of June 30, 2025, about 15,333 contractor class members with 118,844 class workweeks, about 14,100 PAGA workers with 109,275 PAGA pay periods, and about 144 HireArt-placed members. These are the defendants' estimates, not court findings, and the record read gives no per-person or per-week amount.

How Settlement Payments Are Reported for Tax

Class payments to people who worked as contributors are allocated 100 % to non-wages and reported on Form 1099, not on a W-2. The class notice and agreement set four reporting rules:

  • Contributors: 100 % non-wages, Form 1099.
  • Class members who were not contributors (HireArt placements): 10 % wages on a W-2 and 90 % non-wages on Form 1099.
  • PAGA payments: Form 1099.
  • Any second distribution: 100 % non-wages on Form 1099 for everyone.

The parties give no tax advice. Thresholds and self-employment tax are covered under taxes for AI training contributors.

McKinney v. Scale AI Dates, 2024 to 2027

Fifteen dated steps run from the first PAGA notice in October 2024 to the status conference on distribution set for September 13, 2027. The table is based on the agreement, the class notice, the order and the judgment, as of 2026-11-17.

Date Step Source
2024-10-29 first PAGA notice letter to the LWDA agreement 1.33
2025-01-03 Rogowicz action filed agreement 2.2
2025-02-28 McKinney amended complaint adds PAGA and willful-misclassification claims agreement 2.1
2025-04-11 Agape PAGA action filed agreement 2.3
2025-05-09 Agape class action filed agreement 2.3
2025-05-19 McKinney second amended complaint adds two plaintiffs agreement 2.1
2025-09-15 all-day mediation before a retired judge agreement 2.6
2025-11-21 amended PAGA notice agreement 2.8
2026-02-06 settlement agreement executed addendum recital; order fn. 1
2026-03-03 court continues preliminary approval, orders email notice and favors a second distribution addendum recital
2026-05-07 preliminary approval order para. 2
2026-07-01 defendants fund the gross amount order para. 11
2026-09-03 deadline for opt-outs, objections and workweek challenges class notice
2026-10-30 final approval hearing, final approval order and judgment order; judgment
2027-09-13 status conference on distribution (9:00 a.m.) order para. 17

The dates come from the court-filed documents; the San Francisco register of actions was not opened, and no later entry was confirmed on 2026-11-17.

When the Money Moves: Effective Date, Check Void Dates and the 2027 Status Report

The administrator sends all payments within 14 days after the Effective Date, the day the judgment becomes final, which without an appeal is the day after the appeal deadline, 61 days from notice of entry of the judgment (agreement 1.20 and 4.4).

The notice of entry of judgment is not on the record read, so the Effective Date and the payment date are not yet known.

Payments go out by first-class mail as checks. The void date is not less than 180 days after mailing, and a replacement is issued if requested before that date.

Under the agreement as amended by the addendum of April 27 and 28, 2026, if more than USD 10,000 stays uncashed, a second distribution follows with checks valid for 45 days; otherwise the residue goes to the cy pres recipient, Per Scholas (agreement 4.4).

The status report is due five court days before the conference of September 13, 2027 and must state the distribution date, the checks issued, cashed and uncashed, and any residual funds. The order and judgment stay posted on the administrator's website for 180 days, and the site is removed at the check void deadline.

What Class Members Release, Including Claims Against Scale AI's Customers

Class members who did not opt out release every claim arising in the class period that was or could have been based on the facts of the four complaints, the operative complaint or the PAGA notices.

The release runs from the Effective Date and binds whether or not a check is cashed. PAGA workers release PAGA claims even after opting out, and the three class members who opted out are bound by the judgment only as PAGA workers, where applicable.

The Released Parties include affiliates, investors and "customers (only as it pertains to work performed for the customers through Defendants)" (agreement 1.45, 5.3 and 5.4). No customer is named in the documents read, and nothing in them says an AI developer was a party to the case.

What the Settlement Shows Companies That Buy Human Data

For companies that buy training data made by paid contributors, the settlement shows the contributor's legal status as a cost and a risk that sits with the platform, and that a platform's settlement can also release its customers for that work.

Scale AI also acquires data from companies, a side covered under Scale AI as a data buyer.

The case turned on classification and pay, not on who owns the work product. The release of customers is limited to work performed through the defendants in the class and PAGA periods, so it carries no warranty about other platforms or other periods.

The settlement is one dated data point, not a rule for the sector. Outlier's own terms, pay and record are set out in the Outlier AI contributor platform profile.

McKinney is the only proceeding against Scale AI or Outlier tracked here with a court-approved settlement amount; two federal suits took other paths, and five GDPR complaints have no decision found as of 2026-11-09. The case tracker of AI lawsuits over training data lists it among related proceedings rather than among training-data copyright cases.

The table gives each proceeding as of 2026-11-17, with the earlier check date shown where a status was last confirmed before it.

Proceeding Forum and number Claim Status Source
Ramey v. Scale AI, Inc., et al. N.D. Cal. 3:24-cv-06999 class action; claims not recorded joint notice of settlement 2025-02-11 (Dkt. 32); HireArt stipulation for dismissal 2025-05-12 (Dkt. 36); terms not public; as of 2026-11-09 CourtListener docket feed
Schuster v. Scale AI, Inc., et al. N.D. Cal. 3:25-cv-00620-JSC psychological harm from writing violent and abusive prompts (negligence, UCL) voluntarily dismissed 2026-08-10, with prejudice as to named plaintiffs, without as to the putative class; no settlement amount Dkt. 34
noyb GDPR complaints against Scale AI (Outlier) data protection authorities of France, Italy, the Netherlands and Austria; no reference numbers published trackers, Persona biometric checks, unanswered access requests (complainants' allegations) filed, announced 2026-10-27; no decision found as of 2026-11-09 noyb announcement

The full set of contributor suits against other platforms sits on the lawsuits page reached through the Ramey row.

More About the McKinney v. Scale AI Settlement

This section lists what is decided and what is open, and answers the questions most often asked about the settlement.

Decided Versus Still Open in McKinney v. Scale AI

The settlement terms are decided; when and how much each contributor is paid is not yet on the record.

Decided

  • Final approval and judgment on October 30, 2026.
  • Funding of the gross amount on July 1, 2026.
  • The class period (2020-12-10 to 2026-02-28) and the PAGA period (2023-10-29 to 2026-02-28).
  • Three opt-outs and no objections.

Still open

  • The Effective Date and the payment date.
  • Per-person amounts.
  • Whether a second distribution is needed.
  • The 2027 status report.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Scale AI Settlement

How much is the Scale AI settlement?

The settlement is a gross USD 12,500,000, approved on October 30, 2026. Fees, costs, service awards, administration and USD 500,000 in PAGA penalties come out first.

How much will each contributor receive?

It depends on that person's class workweeks. The record read on November 17, 2026 gives no per-person or per-week figure.

When will the Outlier settlement pay out?

Payments are due within 14 days after the judgment becomes final. The payment date is not yet on the record, and a status conference is set for September 13, 2027.

Do I need to file a claim?

No, the administrator pays participating class members without a claim form. Payment is by check to the address on file.

Did the court find that Scale AI misclassified contributors?

No, the court made no merits finding. The defendants deny the claims, and the settlement is a compromise.

Is this the lawsuit over disturbing prompts?

No, those claims are Schuster v. Scale AI (N.D. Cal. 3:25-cv-00620-JSC). It was voluntarily dismissed on August 10, 2026 without a settlement amount.