DataPacts

noyb Complaints Against Scale AI (Outlier): Claims and Status

Checked

At a glance

The noyb complaints against Scale AI are five GDPR complaints that the Austrian privacy group noyb, with Intérêt à Agir, DIPLab and Reversing.Works, announced on October 27, 2026 in France, Italy, the Netherlands and Austria over how Scale AI's Outlier platform tracks and identifies its workers.

Independent reference. Every buyer is covered on the same terms, every figure carries its source and check date, and no buyer pays to be listed or placed higher.

Request an independent introduction

Tell us what data your company holds. We reply with the buyers that fit and what their terms leave out. Your details reach a buyer only after you agree to a named introduction.

IndependentYour details stay with us until you agreeNot selling is a valid outcome

As of November 17, 2026 no data protection authority decision is found. noyb asks for a full investigation and suggests an administrative fine.

Every point below is noyb's allegation. The complaints concern the personal data of the people who produce data for AI training data licensing and its supply chain, not data that companies license to Scale AI. DataPacts is not affiliated with any party and gives no legal advice.

Figures and dates on this page follow noyb's release of October 27, 2026, corrected October 29, 2026, and Outlier's own pages, as described in how figures are sourced and dated.

The Five Complaints at a Glance: Complainants, Countries and Status

noyb's release is the only published record of the complaints: it names the complainant groups, the four countries and the date, and nothing filed at any authority is public as of November 17, 2026.

Table 1 compares the facts the release states with the items it leaves out, as of 2026-11-17.

Field Value Source
Proceeding five GDPR complaints against Scale AI over Outlier noyb release
Complainants noyb with Intérêt à Agir, DIPLab and Reversing.Works; Outlier workers as complainants noyb release
Respondent Scale AI, Inc. (operates Outlier through Smart Ecosystem, Inc.) noyb release; Outlier Terms of Use
Countries France, Italy, the Netherlands, Austria noyb release
Announced 2026-10-27 (release corrected 2026-10-29) noyb release
Authority per complaint not published noyb release
Reference numbers not published noyb release
Grounds trackers without legal basis; data minimization; biometric processing (Persona); unanswered access requests noyb release
Requests full investigation; administrative fine suggested noyb release
Status filed; no decision found noyb release, checked 2026-11-17

What the Complaints Allege About Outlier Workers' Personal Data

noyb states four grounds: trackers placed on workers' devices without a valid legal basis or consent, a breach of the GDPR's data minimization principle, biometric processing through Persona, and access requests Scale AI did not answer.

Table 2 sets each ground against the data it concerns, in noyb's wording, as of 2026-10-27.

Ground (noyb's wording) Data concerned (noyb's allegation) What noyb says is wrong Source
Third-party trackers IP addresses, contact details, unique identifiers, visited page, sent every few seconds to TikTok, LinkedIn, Facebook, Sprig, Datadog no valid legal basis to place trackers without consent noyb release
Data minimization the personal data collected from workers collection beyond what is necessary noyb release
Biometric verification via Persona repeated face video recordings and ID uploads processing of biometric data beyond what is necessary noyb release
Access requests complainants' requests to Scale AI no response, right of access breached noyb release

These are the grounds in noyb's words. The release cites no GDPR article numbers, so this page attaches none to the complaints, and every statement is "noyb alleges" or "noyb states".

Third-Party Trackers While Workers Complete Tasks

noyb states that its technical analysis found trackers from TikTok, LinkedIn, Facebook, the survey platform Sprig and the analytics company Datadog on workers' devices while they are on the Outlier platform. noyb alleges that the trackers send personal data to third parties "every few seconds", including IP addresses, contact details, unique identifiers and information about the visited page, and that such data can be used for targeted advertising and profiling. noyb alleges there is no valid legal basis to place them without consent.

No tracker company is a party to the complaints, and the release alleges nothing beyond this about any of them. Outlier's own pages name no tracker tool.

Repeated Persona Face and ID Checks

noyb alleges that Scale AI makes workers repeatedly pass a biometric verification run by Persona, including video recordings of their face and an uploaded ID.

noyb states that Scale AI gives fraud prevention and verifying "the workers' skills" as reasons, which noyb says go far beyond what is necessary. noyb also states that Persona's own terms allow it to collect IP addresses, device information, geolocation, addresses and consumer credit data; that is noyb's description, and DataPacts has not read those terms for this page.

Outlier's Aether FAQ names Persona as its identity verification provider, with images of the ID plus a selfie (checked 2026-11-10).

How ID checks and monitoring work across AI training platforms is set out under contributor privacy on human data platforms. That page compares the platforms and their ID providers; this page covers only what noyb alleges about Outlier and what Outlier's own FAQ says about Persona.

Access Requests Left Unanswered

noyb states that Scale AI did not respond to the complainants' access requests, which noyb counts as a breach of the GDPR right of access. The release gives no request dates, no number of requests and no deadline computation, so this page states none.

What noyb Asks For, and What Its Release Does Not Publish

noyb requests a full investigation of the alleged violations and suggests that the competent authorities impose an administrative fine to prevent similar violations.

No fine amount is proposed. noyb states that the complaints are part of AI-WORLD, an initiative on working conditions across AI value chains, led by Intérêt à Agir with DIPLab and supported by the European AI & Society Fund and the Digital Freedom Fund.

The release links no complaint document, names no authority per complaint, does not say which of the four countries received two complaints, cites no GDPR article and publishes no reference number. noyb corrected the release on October 29, 2026 regarding a statement about Persona. Table 3 lists what the release publishes, read on 2026-11-17.

Item Published? Source checked
Authority receiving each complaint no (countries only) noyb release
Split of the five complaints across the four countries no noyb release
GDPR articles cited no (principles named, no article numbers) noyb release
Authority reference numbers no noyb release
Complaint documents no (no file linked) noyb release

For law context only, and not tied to these complaints: biometric data processed to uniquely identify a person is a special category under GDPR Art. 9(1) (Regulation (EU) 2016/679, in force since 2016-05-24 and applying from 2018-05-25), and its processing is prohibited unless an Art. 9(2) exception applies. The GDPR rules for AI training data are covered on the GDPR page.

Status as of November 17, 2026: Filed, No Decision Found

As of November 17, 2026, no published decision, reference number or opened investigation by a data protection authority on the complaints is found, and noyb's release records no step after filing beyond its correction of October 29, 2026.

The release was re-read on November 17, 2026. A decision by an authority or an update by noyb would change this status, and until then the complaints stay allegations that no authority has ruled on, whatever the strength of the technical analysis noyb describes.

This page predicts no outcome, fine or timeline and does not say which authority leads.

On Scale AI's side, no statement on the complaints was found on Scale's blog or in Outlier's Aether FAQ (checked 2026-11-17). Press reports of a response are not a primary source and are not stated here.

Why Complaints About Contributors Concern AI Training Data

Outlier is the contributor platform through which Scale AI pays people to write prompts and rate and rank AI responses, so the complaints concern the personal data of the people who produce human data for AI training, not data that companies license to Scale.

Scale AI, Inc. operates Outlier through its affiliate Smart Ecosystem, Inc., according to Outlier's Terms of Use. noyb states that Outlier has more than 900,000 "freelance" workers, a claim dated October 27, 2026.

Pay, terms and the platform record are covered on the Outlier AI contributor platform profile. A reader weighing contributor work, or a data deal with Scale, reads these complaints as allegations about worker data handling with no finding, which neither supports nor undermines any claim about how Scale handles data it licenses from companies.

The noyb complaints are one of three dated records about the data or pay of people who produce AI training data, next to noyb's earlier complaints over Meta's AI training on user data. They appear among related proceedings beside the case tracker of AI copyright lawsuits over training data.

Table 4 compares the three records, with the status date in the Status column.

Record Forum and number Subject Status Page
McKinney v. Scale AI Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco, CGC-24-620481 contributor misclassification, wage and hour settled; final approval filed 2026-10-30 (as of 2026-11-09) Case page
In re Mercor.io Corporation Data Breach Litigation N.D. Cal., lead case 3:26-cv-02821-WHO contributor data breach consolidated 2026-05-19; stayed pending mediation (Dkt. 44); no merits ruling as of 2026-11-09 Case page
noyb complaints over Meta AI training 11 data protection authorities (2024-06-06); OLG Köln 15 UKl 2/25 user data for AI training noyb complaints filed 2024-06-06 (noyb's claim); Cologne court rejected an injunction application 2025-05-23; main proceedings not found (as of 2026-11-09) Case page

Contributor pay and classification suits are compared on the page on contributor lawsuits against human data platforms.

Scale's record on the buyer side, including its data partnership program, is on the profile of Scale AI as a data buyer.

More About the noyb Complaints Against Scale AI

This page is information, not legal advice.

Known Versus Not Yet Known

Only the filing is on the record: who complained, in which four countries, on what grounds and with what requests.

  • Known: five complaints announced 2026-10-27; four countries; four grounds; investigation and fine requested.
  • Not yet known: authority and reference number per complaint; complaint text and articles cited; Scale AI's response on record; any decision or timeline.

Frequently Asked Questions About the noyb Complaints

Has a regulator fined Scale AI over Outlier?

No decision or fine is found as of 2026-11-17. noyb only suggests that the competent authorities impose a fine.

Where can I read the complaints?

noyb has not published the complaint texts. Its release of 2026-10-27, corrected 2026-10-29, is the only document.

Who filed the complaints against Scale AI?

noyb filed them with Intérêt à Agir, DIPLab and Reversing.Works. Outlier workers are the complainants.

Did noyb correct its release?

Yes, on 2026-10-29. A statement about Persona was corrected.