For a holder weighing AI training data licensing, every term below is a company claim or a court or regulator record with its check date.
Toloka sets compensation in a statement of work (SOW); Scale stated on 2026-11-16 an illustrative value of USD 10,000 to USD 1,000,000 or more per data partnership. No seller payment under either is on record.
Neither company wins. Scale holds a contributor settlement and five GDPR complaints, Toloka no record in the sources checked, and neither program is a valid answer.
Toloka and Scale AI Side by Side, Dated
Each cell quotes the company's own page or a court or regulator record with its check date: November 9, 2026, or November 16, 2026 where a program page was read again. The table carries no score, rank or winner.
| Attribute | Toloka (Toloka profile) | Scale AI (Scale AI profile) | Checked | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Legal entity, location | Toloka AI BV; headquarters Amsterdam, Netherlands; founded 2014; registry number not published | Scale AI, Inc., a Delaware corporation; affiliate Smart Ecosystem, Inc. dba Outlier AI; United States | 2026-11-16 / 2026-11-09 | toloka.ai/about; Outlier Terms of Use |
| Company data program | Physical AI Data Partner Program | Scale Data Partnerships | 2026-11-16 | program pages |
| Data taken | New egocentric video, UMI three-camera capture, teleoperation, recorded at the company's usual location | Existing records: data warehouses, chat and messaging, email and calendar, documents, work tools, business platforms | 2026-11-16 | program pages |
| Who may apply | Companies and capture teams; individuals sent to Mindrift | 40+ employees preferred, case by case; established systems, real workflows, domain depth, a stakeholder owner | 2026-11-16 | program pages |
| Stated value to a company | Depends on data type, volume and quality; set in a SOW | "$10K–$1M+ illustrative value per data partnership, scaling with cadence" | 2026-11-16 | program pages |
| Payment trigger and timing | "Get compensated" is the last step, after Toloka prepares and licenses the data; no date or period stated | Not published; "opportunity for recurring revenue" | 2026-11-16 | program pages |
| Steps | Form; reply within 3 working days; intro call; sample request; partner agreement before recording | Application or scoping call; anonymization in the company's environment; per-package approval; on-prem or VPC | 2026-11-16 | program pages |
| Personal data removal | Faces, palms, fingerprints, identifying tattoos blurred for everyone in frame, including bystanders; voices and identifying metadata such as location removed, before delivery | Anonymized inside the company's environment before any extraction | 2026-11-16 | program pages |
| License terms published | Confidentiality and IP terms in the partner agreement; exclusivity, term, deletion not stated | Exclusivity, term, deletion, retraining not published | 2026-11-16 | program pages |
| Receiving AI developers named | None on the program page | None; "AI companies" only | 2026-11-16 | program pages |
| Referral offer for introducers | None on record | Up to USD 50,000, only if Scale signs; one per deal; repeat intros not paid | 2026-11-16 | program pages |
| Ownership statement | Nebius a shareholder "while no longer having controlling voting power" | Meta minority stake, valuation over USD 29 billion, 2025-06-12 | 2026-11-16 / 2025-06-12 | company blogs |
| Court and complaint record | None in the sources checked | McKinney settled (final approval 2026-10-30); Schuster voluntarily dismissed; Ramey notice of settlement; 5 noyb GDPR complaints | as of 2026-11-09 | court and complaint table below |
Company Data: Footage Recorded to Order Against Records a Company Already Holds
The two company programs barely overlap: Toloka commissions recordings of a company's own work, and Scale licenses the operating records a company has built up over years. Five differences follow: delivery, payment, personal data, unpublished terms and referral offers.
What Each Program Asks a Company to Deliver
Toloka's program takes egocentric video, UMI three-camera capture and teleoperation recordings from companies and capture teams, while Scale's takes data from warehouses, chat, email and calendar, documents, work tools and business platforms, with 40 or more employees as a preferred starting point.
Toloka defines egocentric video as "First-person video recorded with a camera or phone mounted on a headset worn by the worker", checked 2026-11-16. The team records its usual work at its usual location, and individuals are sent to Mindrift.
Scale asks for nothing new: it names tools such as Snowflake, Slack, Jira, Salesforce and SAP, and assesses established systems and a clear stakeholder owner case by case.
Workshops and robots fit Toloka's list; years of software records fit Scale's. Other buyers of egocentric (first-person) video take footage on different terms.
How Each Program Pays: A Statement of Work Against an Illustrative Value Range
Toloka states that compensation depends on the data type, volume and quality requirements and is set in a statement of work, and its program page, re-read 2026-11-16, lists "Get compensated" as the last step, described as "We prepare the data for use in AI training and license it from your company". No payment date or period is stated.
Scale states "$10K–$1M+ illustrative value per data partnership, scaling with cadence", checked 2026-11-16, and adds that it designs partnerships "so there's opportunity for recurring revenue". It publishes no payment timing or structure.
Neither can be ranked: Toloka's amount exists only in a SOW and Scale's range is an illustration. Mindrift's first-person footage projects state USD 6 to 15 per hour in a blog post dated 2026-09-17; that is a contributor wage, not a license price. Payment shapes are compared under when and how AI data buyers pay.
Where Personal Data Comes Out: Blurring Before Delivery Against Anonymization in Place
Toloka states that faces, palms, fingerprints and identifying tattoos are blurred for everyone in frame, including bystanders, and that voices and identifying metadata such as location are removed, while Scale states that it anonymizes everything inside the company's environment before any data is extracted, with sign-off on every data package.
Toloka does not say who blurs or whether the sample is treated the same way, so raw footage may reach Toloka unless agreed otherwise. Consent of the people filmed stays with the company.
Scale adds per-package approval and on-prem or VPC options. Both are program-page descriptions, not audits.
Steps a holder keeps under its own control are covered in de-identification before licensing data.
What Neither Program Publishes Before Signing
Neither program page states exclusivity, license term, deletion or the AI developers that receive the data, so each company's agreement, not its page, decides what the data holder gives up. As read on 2026-11-16:
- Exclusivity: Toloka: not stated. Scale: not published.
- Term: Toloka: not stated. Scale: not published; the page speaks of a continuous partnership.
- Deletion and retraining: Toloka: not stated. Scale: not published.
- Receiving AI developers: Toloka: none named. Scale: "AI companies" only.
Toloka puts confidentiality and IP terms into a partner agreement signed before recording. The clauses to request before signing, as of 2026-11-16, are set out under AI data licensing agreements.
Referral Offers for Introducers: None on Record Against Up to USD 50,000
Scale states "Refer a company and earn up to $50,000 bonus", paid only if Scale signs a partnership agreement, once per deal and not for repeat introductions of the same company, while no referral program for Toloka's partner program is on record, both re-read 2026-11-16.
Every published offer is compared under referral programs of AI data buyers.
Expert Data: Mindrift and Outlier Contributor Terms Side by Side
Toloka runs its contributor work through Mindrift, whose site names Toloka AI BV, and Scale runs its through Outlier, whose Terms of Use name Scale AI, Inc. and its affiliate Smart Ecosystem, Inc.; Mindrift publishes hourly ranges and Outlier states that rates vary.
The table, as of 2026-11-09 unless dated otherwise, lists each platform's own claims without rank.
| Term | Mindrift (Toloka AI BV) | Outlier, Scale AI (Outlier AI profile) | Checked | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Contracting entity named | Toloka AI BV (footer; "built by" Toloka) | Scale AI, Inc. and affiliate Smart Ecosystem, Inc.; Terms of Use effective 2026-05-11 | 2026-11-09 | mindrift.ai; outlier.ai/legal/terms-of-use |
| Stated pay | "Entry-level: $15-30 per hour"; "Domain experts: $60-100+/hr"; per completed task, amount shown before start | "Competitive pay + quality-based rewards, paid weekly"; hourly or per task; "Rates vary by expertise, project complexity, and location" | 2026-11-09 | mindrift.ai; outlier.ai/faq |
| Payment | "Payments are processed bi-weekly" | Weekly, processed Tuesdays, via PayPal, AirTM or ACH | 2026-11-09 | same |
| First-person footage work | "between $6 and $15 per hour"; no assessment; setup time unpaid (blog dated 2026-09-17) | None on record | 2026-11-09 | mindrift.ai/blog/video-data-collection-jobs |
| Work status and clauses | "no employment contract and no fixed hours" | Independent contractors (FAQ); no withholding except as required by law (s.3); assignment of work product (s.4(b)); individual AAA arbitration, class waiver, 30-day opt-out for US residents (s.10) | 2026-11-09 | mindrift.ai; outlier.ai/faq and Terms of Use |
| Size and paid-out claims | 20K trainers (stats block) vs 10,000+ (page meta) | 900K+ experts; "$500M+" paid to experts (home page) vs "$600M+" paid out (about page) | 2026-11-09 | mindrift.ai; outlier.ai; outlier.ai/about-us |
Each brand contradicts itself on size, as the table shows; both figures stay visible, and Toloka separately states 6,000+ active expert contributors, checked 2026-11-09.
Outlier publishes no rate, so no comparison is possible. Rates across platforms and fields sit under pay for AI training work.
Ownership in Each Company's Own Words: Nebius at Toloka, Meta at Scale
Toloka's own blog states that Nebius no longer has controlling voting power, while Scale AI announced on 2025-06-12 that Meta would hold a minority of Scale's outstanding equity at a valuation of over USD 29 billion.
Toloka's post, re-read 2026-11-16, says Nebius "continues to support Toloka as a shareholder, while no longer having controlling voting power"; Scale gives no stake percentage.
Both statements come from the companies, not from filings. A holder can ask either in writing which affiliates and AI developers receive its data. Meta's own data acquisition is covered under Meta as a data buyer.
Court and Complaint Record of Toloka and Scale AI
Scale's record holds a court-approved contributor settlement, a voluntarily dismissed contributor suit, a suit with a joint notice of settlement and five GDPR complaints, while no court case, breach notice or regulator action involving Toloka or Mindrift appears in the sources checked as of 2026-11-09. The table lists each record by date with its status as of 2026-11-09; allegations are not findings.
| Date | Company | Record | Forum / docket | Status as of 2026-11-09 | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| n/a | Toloka | None recorded: no court case, breach notice or regulator action involving Toloka AI BV or Mindrift | n/a | n/a | court and regulator sources checked |
| 2025-01-17 | Scale AI | Schuster v. Scale AI, Inc. et al. filed (contributor class action; allegations) | N.D. Cal. No. 3:25-cv-00620-JSC | Voluntarily dismissed by notice dated 2026-08-10 (with prejudice as to named plaintiffs, without as to the putative class) | Dkt. 34 |
| 2025-02-11 | Scale AI | Ramey v. Scale AI, Inc. et al.: joint notice of settlement (Dkt. 32); claims not recorded | N.D. Cal. No. 3:24-cv-06999 | HireArt stipulation for dismissal 2025-05-12 (Dkt. 36); no dismissal order on the docket feed | docket feed |
| 2026-10-27 | Scale AI | 5 GDPR complaints by noyb and three partner organizations over Outlier (trackers, Persona biometric checks, access requests) | Data protection authorities in France, Italy, the Netherlands and Austria | No authority decision recorded | noyb.eu |
| 2026-10-30 | Scale AI | McKinney v. Scale AI, Inc. et al. (contributor misclassification class settlement), gross USD 12,500,000; payments reported on Form 1099, not W-2 | Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco, CGC-24-620481 | Settled; final approval order filed 2026-10-30 | final approval order |
Every Scale record concerns contributors, none a company data license, and a settlement is not a finding.
Toloka's empty row is scoped to the sources checked, not a clean bill.
The full narratives of these suits sit under contributor lawsuits against human data platforms.
Which Company Each Program Fits, and When Neither Does
Neither company is better by fees; each program's own criteria point to a different kind of company, as of 2026-11-16.
Toloka's stated terms point to:
- Companies or capture teams whose staff can record their usual tasks on site.
- Holders who accept payment after Toloka prepares and licenses the data.
- Holders who want faces, voices and location metadata removed before delivery.
Scale's stated terms point to:
- Companies with 40 or more employees and years of records in its six source groups.
- Holders who want raw data to stay inside their environment until anonymized.
- Holders open to repeated deliveries.
Neither may suit:
- Holders that need published license terms or named recipients first.
- Holders that need a fixed amount or payment date at signing.
- Individuals, who join Mindrift or Outlier as contributors instead.
Programs beyond these two are weighed under choosing a buyer for your data.
Licensing to Toloka or Scale AI: Benefits, Risks, Downsides and Alternatives
Licensing to either company turns a company's records or recordings into income whose size and timing cannot be read in advance, because Toloka sets the amount in a statement of work and Scale publishes only an illustrative range.
Benefits
- Both publish their process with privacy steps.
- Toloka's partner agreement is signed before any recording.
- Scale keeps raw data in place and approves package by package.
Risks
- Neither publishes license scope, term or deletion.
- Neither names the AI developers that receive the data.
- Scale's contributor record and GDPR complaints (none about data partnerships); Toloka's ownership rests on its own post.
Downsides
- Toloka requests a sample before the agreement, and recording ties up staff time.
- Toloka pays only after it prepares and licenses the data, with no period stated.
- Scale's range is illustrative and its payment timing unpublished.
Alternatives
- Other published company data programs, among them Handshake AI Data Partnerships, Labelbox Prism, Mercor, micro1 Company Data Partnerships and Turing Project Lazarus.
- Other collectors of first-person and robot footage.
- An enquiry for an independent introduction.
- Not licensing at all.
Every option, including keeping the data, is set out under alternatives to selling data to AI labs.
Where This Comparison Sits Among the Buyer and Human Data Pages
This page sets two human-data companies against each other; each profile holds the full record. The directory of who buys AI training data lists every buyer type.
- Every program and its terms: company data partnership programs and data partnership payouts and program terms.
- Scale against other programs: Turing vs Scale AI, Snorkel AI vs Scale AI and Mercor vs Scale AI.
- Who competes with Scale: Scale AI alternatives.
- Toloka's labeling peers: data labeling companies.
- Teleoperation and robot footage buyers: robotics data for AI training.
- Records in depth: data buyer incidents, McKinney v. Scale AI and noyb complaints against Scale AI.
- The contributor side: human data for AI.
How This Comparison Is Checked and Kept Independent
Each cell is read from the company's own page, a court filing or a regulator record and dated; a cell changes only when its source has been read again. Toloka comes first only by URL order, and tone does not depend on either company; see the disclosure. The court summaries are information, not legal advice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do Toloka and Scale AI want the same company data?
No: Toloka takes new first-person, multi-camera and teleoperation footage recorded to order, and Scale takes existing records from warehouses, chat, email, documents and business systems, checked 2026-11-16.
Which pays a company more, Toloka or Scale AI?
Neither can be ranked: Toloka sets compensation in a statement of work and Scale states an illustrative range per partnership, and no seller has confirmed a payment under either.
Does Toloka pay contributors real money, and how does that compare with Outlier?
Mindrift states USD 15 to 30 per hour entry-level and USD 60 to 100+ for domain experts, paid bi-weekly; Outlier states that rates vary and pays weekly, checked 2026-11-09.
Applications, assessments and reputation are compared under AI training jobs and platforms.
Are Mindrift and Outlier the same as Toloka and Scale AI?
Mindrift's site names Toloka AI BV, the same legal entity as Toloka; Outlier's Terms of Use name Scale AI, Inc. and its affiliate Smart Ecosystem, Inc., which does business as Outlier AI.
Can a company work with both Toloka and Scale AI?
Neither page publishes exclusivity terms, and the programs take different data, so each signed agreement decides what else the company may license.