
Article L122-5-3 has been in force since 2021-11-26, and the Senate adopted the bill on 2026-04-08.
This page sets out the instruments, dated changes and seller-side programs as of 2026-11-09, for the data holder and for the AI developer.
It is a free-to-read part of the wider reference on AI training data licensing, covers EU rules only where France differs from or adds to them, and cites Légifrance, the CNIL and the parliamentary dossiers.
The CNIL's English summary of its AI sheets is dated 2026-01-05, and a works council is consulted, never asked for consent.
Each figure is dated and checked against the official text, as described in the method for sourcing and dating every figure.
What French Law Adds to EU Rules Before a Company Licenses Data for Training
French law decides five things on top of the EU instruments: how a rightholder words an objection to mining, what the French regulator expects of a training data set, who inside the company must be consulted, how a liquidated company's data is sold, and how royalties are taxed.
- Objection to mining: CPI article L122-5-3 III.
- Regulator expectations: the CNIL's AI sheets, which are not binding.
- Staff consultation: the social and economic committee (CSE), under Code du travail L2312-8 II 4° and L2312-38.
- Liquidation: the juge-commissaire under Code de commerce L642-19, in a historic version.
- Tax: the US treaty rate on royalties paid to French residents.
The GDPR (Regulation (EU) 2016/679, applies from 2018-05-25) applies directly in France. The French Data Protection Act and the French rules on recording calls are not recorded on this page.
French Instruments, Regulator Guidance and Bills That Apply to a Training Data Deal
Ten French instruments, regulator texts, bills and record gaps shape a training-data license, and the table gives each citation, its date and whether it is final, pending, guidance or not stated. "Not stated" means no primary source was verified on 2026-11-09, not that no rule exists.
| Instrument | Citation | Dates | What it decides in a data deal | Final, pending, guidance or not stated | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CPI art. L122-5-3 | Ordonnance n° 2021-1518, art. 1; CPI L122-5-3 II and III | in force 2021-11-26 | text and data mining exception; objection in an appropriate manner, notably machine-readable for online content (III); research exception (II) | final | legifrance.gouv.fr |
| Presumption-of-use bill | Sénat texte n° 85 (2025-2026); Assemblée nationale n° 2634, commission text n° 2864 | Senate 2026-04-08; committee text 2026-06-02 | would presume use of a protected work by an AI provider where an indication makes use plausible | pending | senat.fr; assemblee-nationale.fr |
| CNIL AI recommendations | CNIL fiches pratiques IA, sheets 0 to 13 | English summary 2026-01-05; tool update 2026-08-26 | legal basis, legitimate interest and scraping, information and rights, annotation, model status | guidance, not binding | cnil.fr |
| CNIL note on selling customer files | CNIL, "Vente de fichiers clients" | 2022-12-05 | buyer informs people within 1 month; prospect data at most 3 years after the relationship ends | guidance | cnil.fr |
| GDPR | Regulation (EU) 2016/679 | applies from 2018-05-25 | legal basis, notices and transfers for personal data in the set | final | eur-lex.europa.eu |
| Code du travail L2312-8 and L2312-38 | L2312-8 II 2° and 4° (Ordonnance n° 2017-1386); L2312-38 | in force 2018-01-01 | CSE informed and consulted on new technologies and monitoring tools before the decision; not consent | final | code.travail.gouv.fr |
| Code de commerce L642-19 | Code de commerce art. L642-19 | version 2009-02-15 to 2016-11-20; current wording not stated | juge-commissaire orders auction or authorizes private sale at set prices and conditions | final (historic version) | legifrance.gouv.fr |
| US-France treaty rates on royalties | IRS Tax Treaty Table 1, Rev. May 2023, income codes 10 and 12 | as of 2026-11-09 | 0% US withholding for French residents, subject to limitation on benefits | final | irs.gov |
| French Data Protection Act | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | n/a |
| Recording of calls and meetings | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | n/a |
How Each French Rule Reaches the Seller and the Buyer
The table lists each instrument; the sections below show what each one asks of the data holder and of the AI developer.
Objecting to Mining Under CPI Article L122-5-3: Appropriate and Machine-Readable
Article L122-5-3 of the Code de la propriété intellectuelle, created by Ordonnance n° 2021-1518 of 2021-11-24 and in force since 2021-11-26, is France's text and data mining exception, and a rightholder takes content out of it by objecting.
Under paragraph III the author may object in an appropriate manner, in particular by machine-readable processes ("par des procédés lisibles par machine") for content made available online. Paragraph II adds a research exception for research organizations and cultural heritage institutions.
For a seller, a machine-readable objection is what keeps a license necessary for published content. The presumption-of-use bill would shift the burden of proof toward the AI provider if it passes, and it is pending. The Directive's rule and the opt-out debate sit on the page about the EU text and data mining exception.
Personal Data in the Set: The Seller's Questions in the CNIL's AI Sheets
The CNIL, France's data protection authority, sets out how it reads the GDPR for AI development in how-to sheets whose English summary is dated 2026-01-05, and they are recommendations, not binding law.
Sheet 4 covers the legal basis and the extra checks when data is re-used, sheets 8 and 8 bis cover legitimate interest including web scraping, sheets 9 and 10 cover informing people and respecting their rights, sheet 11 covers annotation, and sheet 13 covers the GDPR status of a model. The CNIL updated its open-weights model traceability tool on 2026-08-26.
On selling customer files, the CNIL's note of 2022-12-05 says the buyer informs the people concerned within one month and keeps prospect data at most three years after the commercial relationship ends.
It is written for prospecting files and is the only French file-sale position recorded here; CNIL sanctions and the French Data Protection Act are not stated. The Art. 6(1)(f) test itself is on the page for legitimate interest for AI training data.
Staff Archives and the Works Council: Information Before the Decision, Not Consent
A French company with a social and economic committee (CSE) informs and consults it before introducing new technologies (Code du travail L2312-8 II 4°) and before deciding to use tools that can monitor employee activity (L2312-38), and the committee is consulted, not asked for consent.
Both provisions are in force since 2018-01-01, and L2312-8 II 2° also covers changes to the company's economic or legal organization.
On our analysis, export, labeling or de-identification tooling and the license decision itself may fall under these items, so consultation precedes signature. No court decision on the point is stated here. The comparison across countries is on employee data and AI training rules by jurisdiction.
Recorded Calls and Meetings: Not Yet Recorded for France
No French rule on recording calls or meetings, or on passing recordings to a third party, is recorded on this page as of 2026-11-09, so recordings are assessed under the GDPR alone here. The comparison pages in the last section hold the jurisdictions that are recorded.
When a Liquidateur Sells the Data: The Juge-Commissaire Sets the Terms
In a French liquidation judiciaire, the juge-commissaire orders a public auction or authorizes a private sale of the remaining assets, data included, at the prices and conditions the judge sets (Code de commerce art. L642-19, in the version in force from 2009-02-15 to 2016-11-20).
The judge may require the draft private sale to be submitted first. The current wording of the article is not stated.
French rules on data in liquidation beyond this article are not stated either. How administrators and liquidators sell data assets in several countries, and what each approval gate asks of the buyer, is compared on the page about data assets in insolvency.
Royalty Payments Between France and the United States
A US buyer paying a royalty to a French-resident seller withholds 0% on copyright royalties (income code 12) and on other industrial royalties (income code 10) under IRS Table 1, Rev.
May 2023, subject to the treaty's limitation-on-benefits test. French withholding when a French buyer such as Mistral AI SAS pays a non-resident is not stated here. Rates for other countries are compared on the withholding page for royalties.
Enacted, Pending and Announced: French Changes and Publisher Deals as of November 2026
Eleven dated items show how French law, regulators and publishers treat training data, and the table keeps statutes, bills, regulator acts and deals apart.
| Date | Item | Citation or actor | Status as of 2026-11-09 | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-10-16 | Senate dossier update: no National Assembly plenary step | presumption bill | pending | senat.fr |
| 2026-08-26 | CNIL open-weights model traceability tool updated | CNIL | published | cnil.fr |
| 2026-06-02 | Committee text n° 2864 filed | Assemblée nationale culture committee | pending | assemblee-nationale.fr |
| 2026-04-08 | Presumption bill adopted at first reading by the Senate (texte n° 85); transmitted 2026-04-09 (n° 2634) | Sénat | pending | senat.fr |
| 2026-01-05 | English summary of the CNIL AI recommendations | CNIL | guidance, not binding | cnil.fr |
| 2025-12-05 | Le Monde Group named a Meta AI news partner | Meta | display with links; training not mentioned; value not disclosed | about.fb.com |
| 2025-05-14 | Le Monde and Perplexity agreement announced | Le Monde | training excluded; output only; value not disclosed | lemonde.fr |
| 2025-01-16 | AFP stories in Le Chat | Mistral AI | 2,300 dispatches a day in six languages, Mistral's claim; training not mentioned; financial terms not disclosed | mistral.ai |
| 2024-03-20 | Google fined EUR 250 million for breaching related-rights commitments | Autorité de la concurrence | decided; Bard training link not stated | autoritedelaconcurrence.fr |
| 2024-03-13 | Le Monde and OpenAI agreement announced | Le Monde | multi-year; covers model training and answer engines; value not disclosed | lemonde.fr |
| 2021-11-26 | CPI L122-5-3 in force | Ordonnance n° 2021-1518 of 2021-11-24 | final | legifrance.gouv.fr |
The bill is pending, would apply to pending proceedings subject to final decisions, and had no National Assembly plenary step on the Senate dossier updated 2026-10-16. The Autorité de la concurrence fine of 2024-03-20 concerns related-rights commitments, and its link to Bard training is not stated.
Only the Le Monde and OpenAI agreement states training use, the Le Monde and Perplexity agreement excludes it, and no value is disclosed for any of the three.
The Mistral and AFP announcement and the Meta news partnership do not mention training, and Mistral states no duration. Every deal and its terms is listed in the tracker of AI data licensing deals.
Programs That Accept Company Data From French Holders
Seven programs state on their own pages that they accept company data from the EU, Europe or France, each as a claim checked 2026-11-09, and none changes what French law requires of the seller.
| Program | Role | What it acquires or handles | What its own pages say about EU, European or French companies (checked 2026-11-09) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Collinear AI, paid data licensing | buyer program | repositories with PRs and tickets, Slack, Gmail, Jira and similar company records | English data; US, CA, UK, EU, AU, NZ; teams of about 50+ | collinear.ai |
| Handshake AI, Data Partnerships | buyer program | workflow and documentation data | estimator country input: USA, Canada, Europe, Other | joinhandshake.com |
| Mercor, Data Monetization (Call Center or BPO listing) | buyer program | call audio and transcripts | location preference names India, France and francophone markets, Latin America, U.S. Hispanic markets, Japan | api.data.mercor.com |
| Mode, data partnership program | buyer program | email, documents, chat, calls and transcripts | agreement names US, EU, Canada, Australia; home page calls the US the strongest fit (contradiction kept visible) | data.mode.inc |
| Nyne, data partnerships | buyer program | operational workflow data | country selector offers Europe, yet requires 20+ full-time U.S. W-2 employees (contradiction kept visible) | nyne.ai |
| Ooak Data, data partner program | buyer program | Slack, Gmail, Notion, Jira and similar records | EU partner data processed and stored in the EU via Ooak Data SAS (Paris); company must own its records | ooakdata.com |
| Turing, Project Lazarus | buyer program | records of active and shut-down companies | most regions; strongest demand US, UK, Canada, EU | lazarus.turing.com |
Ooak Data SAS (RCS Paris 932 867 963) is the EU arm of a US parent, Ooak Data, Inc. (Delaware), and processes EU partner data in the EU. Mercor's call-center listing is the only one that names France.
Two contradictions stay visible: Mode's agreement names the EU while its home page calls the US the strongest fit, and Nyne offers Europe in its selector but asks for 20+ U.S. W-2 employees. Terms across all programs are compared in the company data partnership programs page.
Benefits, Risks, Downsides and Alternatives of Licensing Data Under French Law, Including Not Selling
French law lets a company license data it holds the rights to, and a machine-readable objection gives published content license value, but the CNIL's expectations, the CSE calendar and a pending bill add conditions, and not licensing remains a valid choice.
Benefits
- A machine-readable objection under L122-5-3 III keeps a license necessary for online content.
- The CNIL's reading of the GDPR for AI is published in advance, dated 2026-01-05.
- A 0% US treaty rate applies to royalties paid to French residents, subject to limitation on benefits.
Risks
- Missing the CSE consultation before the decision can leave the company exposed on L2312-8 and L2312-38.
- The presumption bill, if passed, would apply to pending proceedings.
- A buyer of a customer file owes the one-month notice to the people concerned.
Downsides
- Consultation and assessments cost time before any income.
- Items not stated here, such as the Data Protection Act and French withholding, mean advice per deal.
Alternatives
- License only content without personal data.
- Keep the data and record a machine-readable objection.
- License de-identified data.
- Not selling or licensing at all, among the alternatives to selling data to AI labs.
Beyond the French Layer: EU Instruments, Topic Comparisons and the Sale
French law stops at the EU layer above it and at the contract; the pages below cover the EU instruments, compare topics across jurisdictions and apply the rules to a sale.
- European Union rules for AI training data, the parent and the EU layer above French law.
- AI training data law by jurisdiction, every jurisdiction compared.
- GDPR and AI training data, the GDPR layer in full.
- EU AI Act Article 53, what the AI Act asks of model providers.
- copyright and AI training across jurisdictions, how copyright exceptions compare.
- call and meeting recording consent rules compared.
- privacy law and AI training data compared across jurisdictions.
- web scraping for AI training, including the CNIL sheets on scraped data.
- robots.txt for AI crawlers, machine-readable signals.
- news publishers licensing content to AI companies.
- Germany rules for licensing data, the neighbor next door.
- selling data to AI companies from outside the US.
- sell or license company data to AI companies, the steps of a sale.
How This Page Is Sourced and Dated
Every rule here cites Légifrance or the Code du travail site, the CNIL's own pages, the Senate and National Assembly dossiers, the Autorité de la concurrence or the IRS treaty table, with the date it was checked.
The rules for dating and checking are set out in the method for sourcing and dating every figure. This page is general information about French law, not legal advice for any specific deal.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does a French rightholder object to AI mining of online content?
By objecting in an appropriate manner, notably by machine-readable processes. Article L122-5-3 III of the Code de la propriété intellectuelle has applied since 2021-11-26.
Does a French company need its CSE's consent to license staff data?
No, the CSE is informed and consulted, not asked for consent. Code du travail L2312-8 II 4° and L2312-38 require this before the decision, in force since 2018-01-01.
Is the CNIL's AI guidance binding?
No, it is regulator guidance, not law. The English summary of the sheets is dated 2026-01-05.
Has France passed the presumption-of-use bill?
No, it is pending. The Senate adopted it on 2026-04-08, committee text n° 2864 was filed on 2026-06-02, and the Senate dossier updated 2026-10-16 shows no plenary step.