The court approved an equity-stake settlement on March 20, 2025, the Seventh Circuit vacated that approval on July 13, 2026 and remanded, and as of November 17, 2026 no replacement settlement is recorded.
The case matters to AI training data because it prices scraped biometric data in court: a company that collected public photos at scale and turned them into searchable templates faced a class action in which the class was paid with equity, not cash.
Readers who hold image or video data can use the record to see which claims followed the data and which remedies the court weighed.
This page belongs to the independent reference on AI training data licensing, and DataPacts is not affiliated with any party and gives no legal advice. Every date and docket entry comes from court records, and how figures are sourced and dated is set out on the methodology page.
The Clearview AI Cases at a Glance: Courts, Dockets, Parties and Status
Three proceedings carry the Clearview record: the federal class action and its Seventh Circuit appeal, the ACLU's Illinois state case settled in 2022, and the Vermont Attorney General's consumer protection suit refiled in 2025. The table lists the facts as of 2026-11-17.
| Field | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Case | In re Clearview AI, Inc. Consumer Privacy Litigation | 7th Cir. Doc. 69 |
| Court | U.S. District Court, N.D. Ill., Eastern Division (Coleman, J.); eleven cases transferred by the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation (28 U.S.C. 1407) | Doc. 69 p. 3 |
| Docket | 1:21-cv-00135 | Doc. 69 caption |
| Appeal | 7th Cir. No. 25-1673, argued 2026-01-28, decided 2026-07-13 | Seventh Circuit opinions database |
| Plaintiffs | Rodell Sanders et al., for a Nationwide Class and Illinois, California, New York and Virginia Subclasses | Doc. 69 caption, p. 4 |
| Defendants | Clearview AI, Inc. (a Delaware corporation headquartered in New York), co-founders Hoan Ton-That and Richard Schwartz, Rocky Mountain Data Analytics LLC, Macy's and others | Doc. 69 p. 3 |
| Objectors-appellants | Robert Weissman and Rick Claypool (Nationwide Class members) | Doc. 69 caption, p. 7 |
| Settlement | approved 2025-03-20; approval vacated and remanded 2026-07-13 | Doc. 42; Doc. 69 |
| Status | remanded to the district court; no replacement settlement recorded | Doc. 69; checked 2026-11-17 |
| Related: ACLU v. Clearview AI | Illinois Circuit Court No. 2020-CH-04353; settled 2022-05-11 with an injunction on private-party access | Doc. 69 pp. 5, 10 to 11 |
| Related: Vermont Attorney General | Vermont Superior Court, Washington Civil Division; Consumer Protection Act suit refiled 2025-04-25 after a venue dismissal; docket and status not recorded | Vermont Attorney General release |
What the Class Claimed Over Scraped Face Images
The consolidated complaint split the class into a Nationwide Class and four state subclasses, and only the Illinois Subclass pleaded BIPA claims. The table sets out the five groups as the Seventh Circuit describes them, as of 2026-07-13.
| Class group | Members | Claims pleaded | Remedies the court noted | Settlement shares | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nationwide Class | everyone in the U.S. whose biometric data is or was in the database | declaratory judgment; unjust enrichment | none statutory | 1 (members of only this class) | Doc. 69 pp. 4, 19, 22 |
| Illinois Subclass | Illinois residents | BIPA (740 ILCS 14) | USD 1,000 negligent, USD 5,000 reckless or intentional, injunctive relief (14/20(a)) | 10 | pp. 4, 19, 22 |
| California Subclass | California residents | Unfair Competition Law; statutory commercial misappropriation of identity; common-law right of publicity; state constitutional privacy | Cal. Civ. Code 3344(a), as of 2026-07-13: USD 750 liquidated damages, profits, punitive damages | 5 | pp. 4, 22 |
| New York Subclass | New York residents | civil rights code claim | injunctive relief sought; no liquidated or punitive damages pleaded | 5 | pp. 4, 22 |
| Virginia Subclass | Virginia residents | statutory commercial misappropriation of identity; Virginia Computer Crimes Act | punitive damages (Va. Code 8.01-40(A)) | 5 | pp. 4, 22 |
The Seventh Circuit describes Clearview as a Delaware corporation headquartered in New York that scrapes photographs from public websites, including social media, and uses AI to produce "facial vectors"; a search returns all matching photos with their source sites.
This is the court's description of the allegations, not a finding of liability. On January 27, 2022 the district court held that BIPA 15(b) and 15(c) claims against Macy's, a Clearview customer, were plausibly alleged.
Only the Nationwide Class pleaded declaratory judgment and unjust enrichment, the claims the court of appeals later called speculative.
The other three subclasses pleaded state statutes on misappropriation of identity, privacy and computer crime, so the strength of a member's claim depended on the state of residence, a point that drove the settlement allocation described below.
How BIPA's notice, release, sale ban and damages work is set out on the page on BIPA and AI training data in Illinois. The court quoted two damages amounts, USD 1,000 per negligent violation and USD 5,000 per reckless or intentional violation (740 ILCS 14/20(a), as of 2026-11-17).
The Equity-Stake Settlement Approved in March 2025
The settlement paid the class with a stake in Clearview's future value instead of a cash fund, because Clearview could not make a large immediate payment. The table lists the terms as approved on 2025-03-20; the approval was vacated on 2026-07-13, so none of them is in force as of November 17, 2026.
| Term | What the settlement provided | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Form of relief | monetary only; no added limits on Clearview's business | Doc. 69 p. 6 |
| Trigger | IPO, or liquidation event (merger, consolidation or sale): payment equal to an equity stake in Clearview as of 2023-09-06, diluted like the founders' stake | Doc. 42; Doc. 69 p. 5 |
| Alternative 1 | settlement master sells the stake to a third party at a commercially reasonable price | Doc. 69 p. 5 |
| Alternative 2 | cash demand for 17 % of Clearview's GAAP revenue from final approval to the demand date | Doc. 42; Doc. 69 p. 5 |
| Deadline | cash demand no later than 2027-09-30 | Doc. 69 p. 5 |
| Settlement master | retired Magistrate Judge Sidney Schenkier; may inspect Clearview's books; owes a fiduciary duty to the class | Doc. 69 pp. 5, 14 |
| Allocation | 10 shares per Illinois Subclass member, 5 per California, New York and Virginia Subclass member, 1 per member of only the Nationwide Class | Doc. 69 pp. 6, 19 |
| Attorneys' fees | paid only when the class is paid | Doc. 69 p. 16 |
| Release | claims that were or could have been advanced in the MDL; appears to exclude claims based on future enactments | Doc. 69 p. 17 |
Mediation before retired Judge Wayne Andersen failed in 2022 because Clearview, in the court's words "an undercapitalized start-up", could not pay. In early 2023 the parties agreed in principle on an equity stake, and the ACLU settlement had already restricted private-party access to the database (Doc. 69 pp. 4 to 5).
Payment would come from one of three routes: a stake in Clearview's equity as of September 6, 2023 on an IPO or a liquidation event, the settlement master's sale of the stake, or a cash demand for 17 % of Clearview's GAAP revenue from final approval, to be made by September 30, 2027.
Relief was monetary only, so Clearview accepted no added limits on its business beyond the ACLU injunction, and the attorneys were to be paid only when the class was paid.
The settlement master, a retired magistrate judge, could inspect Clearview's books and owed a fiduciary duty to the class. The Seventh Circuit called the monetary value of the stake "of course uncertain".
None of the eight original class representatives agreed to the deal, and four new ones replaced them, all members of the favored subclasses.
The court received 16 objections, approved the settlement on March 20, 2025, and in a written opinion of May 12, 2025 called equity-based relief "novel in the context of past BIPA settlements", as quoted in the state attorneys general's amicus brief.
The Objectors' Appeal and the July 2026 Seventh Circuit Decision
The Seventh Circuit vacated the approval on July 13, 2026 (No. 25-1673, Doc. 69, opinion by Judge Hamilton for a panel with Judges Maldonado and Taibleson) because no class representative or lawyer spoke solely for the Nationwide Class when the money was divided. The table gives the objectors' six challenges and the court's answers, as of 2026-07-13.
| Objectors' challenge | Seventh Circuit's answer | Outcome | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| No injunctive relief | BIPA only for Illinois; ACLU injunction already in place; unjust enrichment speculative | rejected | pp. 9 to 13 |
| Uncertain equity stake | "For equity-based settlements, uncertainty is inherent"; the alternative was a risk of bankruptcy | rejected | pp. 13 to 15 |
| Victims turned into shareholders | weight depends on untested privacy claims; Clearview extended its opt-out | rejected | pp. 16 to 17 |
| Value of the cash demand | no finding made below; on a similar deal the court must review Clearview's finances directly | concern for remand | p. 18 |
| No separate representation of the Nationwide Class | representatives and counsel all tied to favored subclasses | upheld: approval vacated | pp. 19 to 26 |
| Replacement of all eight original representatives | a potential "red flag" | to be weighed on remand | pp. 25 to 26 |
Robert Weissman and Rick Claypool, members of the Nationwide Class, appealed under 28 U.S.C. 1291. The appellees filed their joint brief on September 26, 2025, 24 states and the District of Columbia filed an amicus brief supporting the objectors (Doc. 33), and the court heard argument on January 28, 2026.
The court accepted that no injunction was required: BIPA belonged to the Illinois Subclass only, the ACLU injunction already covered private access, and unjust enrichment was speculative.
It wrote that "for equity-based settlements, uncertainty is inherent", and it gave little weight to the objection that the deal turned victims into shareholders, because the claims were untested.
What failed was the allocation. The 10, 5 and 1 share split was endorsed only by members of the favored subclasses, so the court could not tell whether it was fair.
The panel wrote that it was "not saying that the result was unreasonable or unfair", vacated the approval, remanded and awarded costs to the objectors.
Clearview AI Case Docket Entries, 2020 to 2026
Nine dated events lead from the first suits in 2020 to the appellate decision of July 2026. The table lists them as of 2026-11-17, and no later entry was confirmed on that date.
| Date | Court and entry | What it decided or recorded | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2020-01 | press exposé, then suits in N.D. Ill. and S.D.N.Y. | origin of the class actions | Doc. 69 p. 3 |
| 2022-01-27 | N.D. Ill. opinion | BIPA 15(b) and 15(c) claims against Macy's plausibly alleged | govinfo |
| 2022-05-11 | Ill. Cir. Ct. 2020-CH-04353 | ACLU settlement: injunction on private-party access, Illinois opt-out | Doc. 69 pp. 5, 10 to 11 |
| 2025-03-20 | N.D. Ill. | final settlement approval | Doc. 42; Doc. 69 p. 7 |
| 2025-05-12 | N.D. Ill., 2025 WL 1371330 | written approval opinion ("novel in the context of past BIPA settlements") | Doc. 33 |
| 2025-09-26 | 7th Cir. Doc. 42 | joint appellees' brief | CourtListener PDF |
| 2026-01-23 | 7th Cir. Doc. 66 | Rule 28(j) letters | CourtListener |
| 2026-01-28 | 7th Cir. | oral argument | Doc. 69 p. 1 |
| 2026-07-13 | 7th Cir. Doc. 69 | approval vacated and remanded; costs to objectors | Seventh Circuit opinions database |
Appellate dates come from the Seventh Circuit's opinion, and district-court dates from the opinion, the appeal briefs and govinfo.
Where the Clearview Case Stands After the Remand
As of November 17, 2026, the case is back before the Northern District of Illinois with no replacement settlement on the record DataPacts has read. The remand is general, so a future settlement need not resemble the vacated one, and the parties may change the structure, the class definitions or the representatives.
If the parties reach a substantially similar deal, the district court must be informed directly about Clearview's finances and make findings on the cash demand, and it should weigh the replacement of all eight original representatives (opinion pp. 7, 18, 26).
No payment flows from the vacated approval. The settlement administrator's website is not a source for status, and the court docket after the remand was not opened: the mandate date, any new representatives and any schedule are not confirmed.
The status is therefore "no replacement settlement recorded as of November 17, 2026", which is not a statement about talks or a prediction of the outcome.
What the Clearview Cases Show Holders of Image Data
The Clearview record shows that photos posted publicly can still carry biometric claims once a company turns faces into templates for AI search.
The court's description of the pipeline, public photos, AI facial vectors and a search tool, stands apart from licensed image supply, which the page on selling photos and images for AI training covers for photographers, agencies and archives.
The settlement allocation tracks the strength of the statute. Illinois residents with BIPA claims received ten shares each, members of the other three subclasses five, and members of the Nationwide Class alone one, and the court wrote that equal ratios would have been unfair to the subclasses, "certainly to the Illinois Subclass".
Biometric rules across jurisdictions are compared on the biometrics law page, which DataPacts has not yet published.
Clearview's own conduct shows state law changing practice outside the class settlement. The Seventh Circuit wrote that Clearview extended its opt-out program from Illinois to other states, including California and Virginia but not, so far, New York.
The court's account of the opt-out comes from the opinion, and this page does not assess whether it satisfies any statute. This page recommends neither suing, licensing nor refusing.
Where the Clearview Cases Sit Among Privacy and Scraping Cases
Clearview is the tracker's only biometric privacy class action with a settlement on appeal, next to a voiceprint privacy case, a scraped-image dataset case and a scraping case pleaded under contract law. Every tracked case, with docket and status, is on the case tracker of AI copyright lawsuits over training data.
| Case | Court and docket | Claim type | Status | Page |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| In re Otter.AI Privacy Litigation | N.D. Cal. 5:25-cv-06911-EKL | privacy, including BIPA (voiceprints) | motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part 2026-08-13; BIPA claims proceed (as of 2026-11-09) | In re Otter.AI Privacy Litigation |
| Kneschke v. LAION | LG Hamburg 310 O 227/23; OLG Hamburg 5 U 104/24; BGH I ZR 281/25 | copyright (photo in LAION-5B) | BGH pronouncement scheduled 2026-12-17 (as of 2026-11-09) | Kneschke v. LAION |
| Reddit v. Anthropic | S.F. Superior Court CGC-25-625892 | contract and unfair competition (scraping) | narrowed September 2026 to three claims, per Anthropic's S-1/A (as of 2026-11-09) | Reddit v. Anthropic |
More About the Clearview AI Cases
Decided Versus Still Open in the Clearview Litigation
The Seventh Circuit decided how the settlement failed, not whether Clearview broke any law.
| Decided | Still open |
|---|---|
| approval vacated and remanded (2026-07-13) | any new settlement and its terms |
| no injunction required for a fair settlement | the cash demand's value |
| equity-stake uncertainty not disqualifying | liability on any claim |
| the Nationwide Class needs its own representative and counsel | the Vermont suit's outcome |
Frequently Asked Questions About the Clearview AI Lawsuit
Did the Seventh Circuit overturn the Clearview AI settlement?
Yes: on July 13, 2026 it vacated the March 20, 2025 approval and remanded. The Nationwide Class had no separate representative in the allocation, so the court could not tell whether its one-share allocation was fair, and it said it was "not saying that the result was unreasonable or unfair".
When will Clearview class members be paid?
No payment is due under the vacated approval, and no replacement settlement is recorded as of November 17, 2026. Even the approved terms paid only on an IPO, a liquidation event, a sale of the stake or a cash demand.
What did the Clearview settlement offer instead of cash?
A stake in Clearview's equity as of September 6, 2023, with a cash demand for 17 % of GAAP revenue as the alternative. The stake's value was called "of course uncertain" by the court.
Is Clearview AI legal?
No court has ruled on the merits of the class claims. Under the 2022 ACLU settlement Clearview may not give private parties database access except in compliance with BIPA, and the court of appeals describes its customers as government agencies and their contractors. This is not legal advice.
Does Clearview AI's opt-out cover California?
The Seventh Circuit wrote that Clearview extended its opt-out program from Illinois to California and Virginia, citing their privacy statutes. The court cited the California Consumer Privacy Act for that step. California's own rules for training data are set out on the page on California privacy rules for training data.
Is ACLU v. Clearview AI the same case?
No: it is an Illinois Circuit Court case (No. 2020-CH-04353, as the Seventh Circuit cites it), settled on May 11, 2022 with an injunction. It is separate from the federal class action, has its own injunction on private-party access, and is not part of the vacated approval.