
Every value below is a company claim or a court or regulator record with its check date, never a confirmed earning, compared as one pairing within AI training data licensing.
No company wins by fees. The one criterion the sources decide is whether a published route for company data exists: Scale has one, Surge does not. Scale's court record holds a settled contributor class action, Surge's one pending suit, as of 2026-11-09.
Scale AI and Surge AI Side by Side, Dated
Each cell quotes the company's own page or a court record as checked on November 9, 2026, with its source and check date beside it. The table compares both companies as of 2026-11-09 for data holders, introducers and contributors, and carries no score or winner.
| Attribute | Scale AI (Scale AI profile) | Scale source, checked | Surge AI (Surge AI profile) | Surge source, checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Legal entity | Scale AI, Inc., Delaware corporation | outlier.ai Terms of Use, 2026-11-09 | Surge Labs, Inc.; Delaware corporation, principal place of business San Francisco, as a complaint alleges | Cavalier complaint para. 17, 2026-11-09 |
| Business | human-data and data-labeling company | scale.com/data-partnership, 2026-11-09 | human-data vendor; homepage lists Products, Off-the-Shelf, Training Lab, Expert Workforce | surgehq.ai, 2026-11-09 |
| Company data program | Scale Data Partnerships | scale.com/data-partnership, 2026-11-09 | none on record | surgehq.ai, 2026-11-09 |
| Stated value to a data holder | "$10K–$1M+ illustrative value per data partnership, scaling with cadence" | same, 2026-11-09 | none stated | same, 2026-11-09 |
| Payment timing and structure | not published; "opportunity for recurring revenue" | same, 2026-11-09 | no program | same, 2026-11-09 |
| Eligibility and data wanted | 40+ employees preferred, case by case; warehouses, chat, email and calendar, documents, work tools, business platforms | same, 2026-11-09 | no program | same, 2026-11-09 |
| Process and anonymization | scoping call or application; anonymized inside the company's environment before extraction; per-package approval; on-prem or VPC | same, 2026-11-09 | no program | same, 2026-11-09 |
| License terms published | no: exclusivity, term, deletion, retraining not published | same, 2026-11-09 | no program | same, 2026-11-09 |
| Referral offer for introducers | up to USD 50,000, only if Scale signs; one referral paid per deal | scale.com/data-partnership and /apply, 2026-11-09 | none found | surgehq.ai; dataannotation.tech, 2026-11-09 |
| Contributor brand | Outlier, operated with affiliate Smart Ecosystem, Inc. dba Outlier AI | outlier.ai Terms of Use, 2026-11-09 | DataAnnotation: "Surge Labs, Inc. dba DataAnnotation" in a complaint caption; logo file "da-by-surge-2026" | complaint PDF; dataannotation.tech, 2026-11-09 |
| Stated contributor pay | no rate published; hourly or per task, paid weekly | outlier.ai/faq, 2026-11-09 | DataAnnotation up to USD 75 to 125+ (experts), from USD 25 to 50 (general); one surgehq.ai listing USD 200 to 400 per hour | dataannotation.tech; surgehq.ai/workforce, 2026-11-09 |
| Ownership statement | Meta holds "a minority of Scale's outstanding equity"; valuation over USD 29 billion, announced 2025-06-12 | scale.com blog, 2026-11-09 | none stated in the sources checked | n/a |
| Court and complaint record | McKinney settled (final approval 2026-10-30); Schuster voluntarily dismissed; Ramey notice of settlement; 5 noyb GDPR complaints | court and noyb records in the record table, as of 2026-11-09 | Cavalier v. Surge Labs pending | complaint PDF, as of 2026-11-09 |
Licensing Company Data: A Published Offer Against None on Record
On company data the two records are not comparable term by term: Scale states an offer, value range and referral bonus, and Surge states none of them. The sections below take each side in turn.
What Scale Publishes for Data Holders, and What It Leaves Out
Scale states "$10K–$1M+ illustrative value per data partnership, scaling with cadence", with 40+ employees as a preferred starting point, checked 2026-11-09. Eligibility is decided case by case, and the data Scale names sits in warehouses, chat, email, documents, work tools and business platforms.
Scale describes a process that starts with an application or a scoping call, anonymizes the data inside the company's environment before extraction, and releases it through per-package approval gates.
The page leaves out what a seller would sign: payment timing and structure, beyond "opportunity for recurring revenue", and any clause on exclusivity, term, deletion or retraining.
The range is an illustration, not a quote. Scale's stated values can be read beside other buyers' under program terms compared.
What Surge Lists Instead: Contributor Work, No Intake for Records
Surge's homepage lists Products, Off-the-Shelf, Training Lab and Expert Workforce and no program to license records that companies already hold, checked 2026-11-09. It shows no intake form for data holders, no license terms and no payout to companies; the offerings are named here, not described.
An approach that offers to license a company's records "to Surge" therefore cannot be matched to any published Surge route. Its sender, contracting party and terms have to be checked against surgehq.ai and dataannotation.tech, the domains Surge uses.
With no Surge route on record as of 2026-11-09, such outreach is tested with the red-flag checks that decide whether a data licensing email is legitimate.
Referral Bonus for Introducers: Up to USD 50,000 Against None Found
Scale states "Refer a company and earn up to $50,000 bonus", paid only if Scale signs a partnership agreement and once per deal, checked 2026-11-09, while no referral offer for companies was found for Surge. Scale reviews referrer profiles "within 1–2 business days".
Neither Surge's homepage nor DataAnnotation shows a referral program in the sources checked. Outlier lets contributors refer candidates they "can personally vouch for" from the dashboard, with no bonus amount or terms published.
Every other published offer is compared under referral programs of AI data buyers.
Expert Work Behind Each Company: Outlier and DataAnnotation
Both companies acquire human work through a contributor brand: Scale through Outlier, run with its affiliate Smart Ecosystem, Inc., and Surge through DataAnnotation, which a 2025 complaint names as Surge Labs, Inc.'s dba.
The evidence differs in kind. Outlier's Terms of Use, effective 2026-05-11, name Scale AI, Inc. and Smart Ecosystem, Inc. as contracting parties.
DataAnnotation names no legal entity on its site; the link rests on a complaint caption and a logo file named "da-by-surge-2026". The table sets both platforms side by side as of 2026-11-09, each value the platform's own claim.
| Term | Outlier, Scale AI (Outlier AI profile) | DataAnnotation, Surge Labs (DataAnnotation (Surge Labs) profile) | Checked | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Contracting entity named | Scale AI, Inc. and affiliate Smart Ecosystem, Inc.; Terms of Use effective 2026-05-11 | no entity named on the site; Surge Labs, Inc. by complaint caption | 2026-11-09 | outlier.ai/legal/terms-of-use; dataannotation.tech |
| Stated pay | "Rates vary by expertise, project complexity, and location"; no rate | expert rates "up to $75-$125+/hr"; general "$25-$50 per hour"; language roles up to USD 40 | 2026-11-09 | outlier.ai/faq; dataannotation.tech/faq |
| Payment | weekly on Tuesdays via PayPal, AirTM or ACH | PayPal, deposits "within a few days after you request them" | 2026-11-09 | same |
| Screening | skill screenings, ID and location verification; 117 allowed locations | Starter Assessment about an hour, taken once; no minimum hours | 2026-11-09 | outlier.ai; dataannotation.tech/faq |
| Contributor terms | irrevocable assignment of work product (s.4(b)); individual arbitration with class waiver, 30-day opt-out (s.10) | public terms not found; privacy notice effective 2026-06-23 allows facial recognition data | 2026-11-09 | outlier.ai/legal/terms-of-use; app.dataannotation.tech/da-privacy-policy |
| Paid-out claims | USD 500M+ (home page) vs USD 600M+ (about page); 900K+ experts | none stated | 2026-11-09 | outlier.ai; outlier.ai/about-us |
The two platforms cannot be ranked by pay: Outlier publishes no rate, while DataAnnotation states a ladder from general to expert work.
Surge's workforce page showed USD 200 to 400 per hour on one of its seven listings (checked 2026-11-16), a separate claim never merged with that ladder. Outlier's two paid-out figures stay side by side as stated.
Rates across platforms and fields are compared under pay for AI training work.
Court and Complaint Record of Scale AI and Surge AI
Scale AI's record holds three US contributor lawsuits and five GDPR complaints, of which only McKinney v. Scale AI has a court-approved settlement, while Surge's holds one pending contributor suit, Cavalier v. Surge Labs, as of 2026-11-09. The table lists each record by date with its status on that date; allegations are not findings.
| Date | Company | Record | Forum / docket | Status as of 2026-11-09 | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025-01-17 | Scale AI | Schuster v. Scale AI (psychological-harm class action, allegations) | N.D. Cal. 3:25-cv-00620-JSC | voluntarily dismissed 2026-08-10 (with prejudice as to named plaintiffs, without as to the putative class); terminated 2026-08-20 | Dkt. 34 |
| 2025-02-11 | Scale AI | Ramey v. Scale AI (class action; claims not recorded) | N.D. Cal. 3:24-cv-06999 | joint notice of settlement (Dkt. 32), terms not public; HireArt stipulation for dismissal 2025-05-12 (Dkt. 36) | docket feed |
| 2025-05-20 | Surge Labs | Cavalier v. Surge Labs, Inc. dba DataAnnotation (misclassification, unpaid training and qualification time, allegations) | Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco | pending; no ruling or settlement found | complaint PDF |
| 2026-10-27 | Scale AI | 5 GDPR complaints by noyb with Intérêt à Agir, DIPLab and Reversing.Works over Outlier | authorities in France, Italy, the Netherlands, Austria | no authority decision found | noyb.eu |
| 2026-10-30 | Scale AI | McKinney v. Scale AI (misclassification; gross settlement USD 12,500,000) | Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco, CGC-24-620481 | settled; final approval filed 2026-10-30 | final approval order |
Every record concerns contributors, and none concerns a company data deal. McKinney names Scale AI, Inc., Smart Ecosystem, Inc. and HireArt, Inc. among the defendants. Schuster was voluntarily dismissed, not settled.
The noyb complaints concern trackers, Persona biometric checks, data minimization and unanswered access requests at Outlier. No breach notice, regulator complaint or data-licensing dispute involving Surge was found in the sources checked.
Each record also sits in the register of data buyer incidents, beside other buyers.
Ownership and Valuation: What Each Company Has Stated
Scale AI announced on 2025-06-12 that Meta would hold a minority of Scale's outstanding equity in an investment valuing Scale at over USD 29 billion; Surge has published no comparable figure in the sources checked.
The same announcement named an interim chief executive; Scale stated no stake percentage or investment amount, and the detail stays on the Scale profile.
Surge has stated no revenue, funding or valuation figure in the sources checked. Figures circulating in press coverage conflict, so none is repeated here.
Neither company's revenue or headcount is stated, so neither is called the larger. Sector figures are gathered under funding and valuations of AI data companies.
Which Data Holder or Contributor Each Company Fits
Neither company is better by fees; each one's own pages point to different readers, and only Scale addresses a company holding data. As each company states it on 2026-11-09:
Scale's stated terms point to:
- Companies of 40 or more employees with data in warehouses, chat, email, work tools and business platforms.
- Holders who want anonymization in their own environment and approval per package.
- Introducers who accept a bonus paid only if Scale signs.
Surge's record points to:
- Contributors in DataAnnotation's fields: coding, STEM, medical, legal, finance and 43 languages.
- No data holder: Surge publishes no route for company records.
Neither may suit:
- A holder that needs published license terms or named receiving labs first.
- A holder that must secure deletion or retraining rights in writing from the start.
Buyers beyond these two are weighed under choosing a buyer for your data.
Licensing to Scale AI, or Neither: Benefits, Risks, Downsides and Alternatives
For a data holder the choice is Scale or neither, since Surge publishes no route, and licensing to Scale means signing terms that are not public in advance. The lists draw on the record as of 2026-11-09.
Benefits
- A published process with anonymization inside the company's environment.
- Per-package approval gates.
- A stated value range and eligibility, as dated claims.
Risks
- No published license scope, exclusivity, term, deletion or retraining terms.
- Contributor lawsuits and GDPR complaints on Scale's record, none about data partnerships.
- Outreach invoking Surge has no published program to match.
Downsides
- The range is illustrative, not a quote.
- No payment timing or structure is published.
- Surge offers no route for company data at all.
Alternatives
- Other published programs, among them Handshake AI Data Partnerships, Mercor Data and micro1 Company Data Partnerships.
- An intermediary or sell-side adviser.
- An enquiry for an independent introduction.
- Not licensing the data at all.
Keeping the data is a complete outcome, and every option is laid out under alternatives to selling data to AI labs.
Where This Comparison Sits Among the Buyer and Human Data Pages
This page sets two human-data companies against each other; each profile holds the full record, and the directory places them among every other buyer. See who buys AI training data.
- Every program: company data partnership programs.
- Mercor vs Scale AI and micro1 vs Scale AI.
- Surge AI vs Mercor.
- Scale AI alternatives and Surge AI alternatives.
- McKinney v. Scale AI settlement.
- noyb complaints against Scale AI and contributor lawsuits against human data platforms.
How This Comparison Is Checked and Kept Independent
Each cell is read from the company's own page or a court or regulator record and dated; a cell changes only when its source has been read again. Scale comes first only by URL order; see how DataPacts is funded. Court summaries are information, not legal advice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Scale AI and Outlier AI the same company?
Outlier is operated by Scale AI through its affiliate Smart Ecosystem, Inc., which does business as Outlier AI; its Terms of Use, effective 2026-05-11, name Scale AI, Inc., a Delaware corporation, as a contracting party. Outlier's pay, terms and record are on its own profile.
Which pays contributors more, Outlier or DataAnnotation?
Neither can be ranked: Outlier publishes no rate, and DataAnnotation states general projects from USD 25 to 50 per hour, both checked 2026-11-09.
Applications and assessments are compared under AI training jobs and platforms.
Does Surge AI buy company data like Scale AI?
No program for it is on record: Surge lists none, while Scale runs Scale Data Partnerships, both checked 2026-11-09.
Which is bigger, Scale AI or Surge AI?
No primary source compares them: neither publishes revenue or headcount in the sources checked, and Scale's only stated size figure is a valuation of over USD 29 billion, announced 2025-06-12.
Who else competes with Scale AI and Surge AI?
Other human-data and labeling vendors, several of which also license company records. Choosing a vendor to label a lab's own data is outside this page.
Vendors of this kind are compared under data labeling companies.