DataPacts

Brazil's AI Bill (PL 2338/2023): Training Data Disclosure, Opt-out and Remuneration

Checked

At a glance

Brazil's AI bill, PL 2338/2023, would require an AI developer that uses copyrighted content to publish a summary of it (Art. 62), give rightsholders a right to prohibit use outside a research exception (Arts. 63 and 64) and remunerate rightsholders for training use (Art. 65), and it is not law.

Independent reference. Every buyer is covered on the same terms, every figure carries its source and check date, and no buyer pays to be listed or placed higher.

Request an independent introduction

Tell us what data your company holds. We reply with the buyers that fit and what their terms leave out. Your details reach a buyer only after you agree to a named introduction.

IndependentYour details stay with us until you agreeNot selling is a valid outcome

The Senate passed the text on 2024-12-10, and the Chamber of Deputies shows the bill as Aguardando Parecer under the priority regime on 2026-11-17. Every article here is read in the Senate text (Parecer nº 208/2024-PLEN/SF), so numbering can change if the Chamber amends it.

The bill matters to AI training data licensing because Art. 65 would put a legal basis under paid licenses.

The bill's copyright rules sit in Chapter X, Section IV (Dos Direitos de Autor e Conexos), Arts. 62 to 66, and the table gives each article's rule, who it binds and when Art. 80 would start it.

The table is as of 2026-11-17 and reads the Senate text of 2024-12-10; Art. 30 V also asks for a dataset summary.

Article What the bill provides Who it binds Start under Art. 80 Source
Art. 30 V developer of a general-purpose or generative system with systemic risk publishes a summary of the training dataset, as regulated such developers, before commercial release 730 days after publication (general rule) Senate text
Art. 62 developer informs which protected content was used, by a summary on an easily accessible website, subject to trade and industrial secrets, as regulated AI developer immediately on publication (Art. 80 par. 1 III) Senate text
Art. 63 research and development text and data mining is no infringement for scientific, research and educational organizations, museums, archives and libraries, on conditions; for-profit-linked institutions excluded (par. 3) such institutions 180 days Senate text
Art. 64 rightsholder may prohibit use in AI development outside Art. 63; a later prohibition does not release the AI agent from damages rightsholders; AI agents 180 days Senate text
Art. 65 AI agent remunerates rightsholders for use in mining, training or development; collective or direct negotiation, free of charge or paid; domiciled or reciprocal rightsholders only AI agents 180 days Senate text
Art. 66 use of image, audio, voice or video that identifies natural persons respects personality rights under the Civil Code AI systems' use 180 days Senate text

Publishing a Summary of the Copyrighted Content Used (Articles 62 and 30)

Art. 62 requires an AI developer that uses content protected by copyright and related rights to inform which protected content was used in developing its systems, by publishing a summary on an easily accessible website, subject to trade and industrial secrets, under a specific regulation.

  • Art. 62 sole paragraph says development covers mining, training, retraining, testing, validation and application of AI systems, so the duty reaches more than the training run.
  • Art. 30 V separately requires the developer of a general-purpose or generative system with systemic risk to publish a summary of the dataset used in training, "nos termos de regulamentação".

The text read leaves format and detail to a regulation. The EU sets a comparable summary through the EU AI Act Article 53 training data summary, which has its own template.

The Research Exception and the Right to Prohibit (Articles 63 and 64)

Art. 63 says that automated use of protected content in text and data mining for research and development of AI systems is not an infringement when done by scientific, research and educational organizations, museums, public archives and libraries, and Art. 64 lets the rightsholder prohibit use in development in the cases Art. 63 does not cover.

Art. 4 XIII defines text and data mining as highly automated extraction and analysis of large amounts of data for patterns and correlations. Art. 64 sole paragraph adds that a prohibition made after training does not release the AI agent from damages.

Three Conditions and a For-profit Exclusion in Article 63

Art. 63 requires lawful access (I), no commercial purpose (II) and use only as far as necessary, without harm to the economic interests of rightsholders or competition with normal exploitation (III), and its paragraphs add secure storage for the time needed only (par. 1), a ban on displaying or disseminating the works (par. 2) and the same rule for mining to combat civil and criminal wrongs against copyright (par. 4).

Par. 3 excludes institutions linked to, affiliated with or controlled by a for-profit entity that supplies AI systems, or that hold shares between them, so the exception does not reach commercial developers through a research arm.

What the Prohibition Right Does Not Say

The text of Arts. 62 to 66 gives rightsholders the right to prohibit (proibir) but prescribes no format, registry or protocol for exercising it, and states no penalty specific to these articles.

"Opt-out" is therefore the reader's shorthand: the bill does not use the word. The general sanctions in Art. 50 apply to infringements of the Act. Signaling tools are covered on the page for opting out of AI training.

Remuneration of Rightsholders Under Article 65

Art. 65 says that an AI agent that uses protected content in mining, training or development of AI systems must remunerate the rightsholders for that use, while ensuring effective conditions to negotiate collectively under Title VI of Lei 9.610, or directly, and allowing the use to be free of charge or paid (I). "Agentes de IA" covers developers, distributors and applicators (Art. 4 VIII).

Who Would Be Paid: Domicile and Reciprocity

Art. 65 par. 1 makes remuneration due only to national or foreign rightsholders domiciled in Brazil, and to persons domiciled in a country that assures equivalent protection of Brazilian rightsholders' rights, with collection barred where reciprocity is not assured.

The paragraph cites Arts. 2 sole paragraph and 97 par. 4 of Lei 9.610. The text names no country as reciprocal, so a holder outside Brazil cannot tell from the bill alone whether it would qualify, and no conclusion is drawn.

Direct Negotiation and the Calculation Principles

A rightsholder that chooses direct negotiation and authorization may exercise the remuneration right without later regulation (Art. 65 par. 2). The article sets three principles:

  • Collective or direct negotiation, free of charge or paid, under Title VI of Lei 9.610 (I).
  • Calculation by reasonableness and proportionality, with relevant elements such as the size of the AI agent and the competitive effects of results on the original content (II).
  • Free negotiation that does not restrict freedom of contract, under arts. 156, 157, 421, 422, 478 and 479 of the Civil Code and Art. 4 of Lei 9.610 (III).

Art. 66 adds that use of image, audio, voice or video that identifies natural persons must respect personality rights under the Civil Code, and no article sets an amount or a tariff. Parties that negotiate directly would still need AI data licensing agreements with clauses for scope, term and payment.

When the Chapter Would Apply: Article 80 and the Article 1 Carve-out

The bill would enter into force 730 days after official publication, but Art. 62 would apply immediately, Arts. 63 to 66 would apply 180 days after publication, and the Art. 50 sanctions are the one part of Chapter IX outside the immediate list.

Art. 80 and Art. 50 of the Senate text of 2024-12-10 set the dates and sanctions:

  • Par. 1 III: Section IV of Chapter X applies after 180 days, except Art. 62, which applies immediately.
  • Par. 2 I: Chapter IX applies on publication, except Art. 50.
  • Art. 50 II: a simple fine limited to BRL 50,000,000 per infraction or, for a private legal entity, up to 2% of the gross revenue in Brazil of the entity, group or conglomerate in its last year, excluding taxes; Art. 50 VI adds a ban on processing certain databases.

Art. 1 par. 1 III excludes AI systems used in research, testing and development before market placement, with the LGPD, consumer and copyright statutes applying to those activities. The text read does not say how that carve-out interacts with Arts. 62 to 65, and nothing is concluded here.

Where the Bill Stands in the Chamber of Deputies

PL 2338/2023 is a bill, and on 2026-11-17 the Chamber of Deputies' open data show it as Aguardando Parecer under the priority regime (Art. 151, II, RICD). The table lists the dated steps, newest first, as of 2026-11-17, and a step in it is not an approval.

Date Step Status or note Source
2026-11-13 latest entry (MESA, Notificação de Apensação): PL 4302/2026 attached to PL 1523/2026 Aguardando Parecer, priority regime (Art. 151, II, RICD); not a step on this bill dadosabertos.camara.leg.br
2026-04-07 last entry under the special committee (a notice of attachment) no committee opinion entry in the record dadosabertos.camara.leg.br
2025-10-23 last request approved by the special committee (public hearings and events) 161 approved by the committee, 162 in the whole record dadosabertos.camara.leg.br
2025-05-20 special committee installed; rapporteur designated no end date recorded dadosabertos.camara.leg.br, organ 539776
2025-04-29 special committee constituted (Presidency act, DCD Extra) constituted dadosabertos.camara.leg.br
2025-04-04 distributed to six committees (merit and Art. 54 RICD); special committee created (RICD Art. 34, II) created dadosabertos.camara.leg.br
2025-03-17 received from the Senate (Ofício nº 235/2025); presented as PL 2338/2023 received dadosabertos.camara.leg.br; senado.leg.br
2024-12-10 Senate text, redação para o turno suplementar (Parecer nº 208/2024-PLEN/SF, Emenda nº 199-CTIA Substitutivo) completed in the Senate legis.senado.leg.br

From the Senate Vote to the Special Committee

The Senate approved the redação para o turno suplementar on 2024-12-10, the Chamber received it by Ofício nº 235/2025 on 2025-03-17 for revision under Art. 65 of the Constitution, and on 2025-04-04 it went to six committees (merit and Art. 54 RICD) and the Presidency created a special committee because more than four merit committees were named. The committee was constituted on 2025-04-29 and installed on 2025-05-20.

What the Committee Record Shows as of 2026-11-17

The open-data record lists 392 entries for the bill and none is a committee opinion (parecer). Of these, 326 sit under the special committee between 2025-05-20 and 2026-04-07, mostly requests (159 presented, 161 approved, the last approval on 2025-10-23), and 51 entries in the record are attachments.

The latest entry, on 2026-11-13, is not a step on this bill. A rapporteur was designated on 2025-05-20.

Benefits, Risks, Downsides and Alternatives for a Data Holder if the Bill Passes as Written, Including Not Licensing

If the bill passes as written, a rightsholder with Brazilian domicile would gain a right to prohibit and to remuneration, a data holder would gain a clearer basis for a paid license, and not licensing at all would remain available.

Benefits

  • Art. 65 par. 2 lets a rightsholder that negotiates directly act without further regulation.
  • Art. 64 gives a right to prohibit use outside Art. 63.
  • Art. 65 I allows the use to be free of charge or paid.

Risks

  • The text can change in the Chamber, and the bill is not law.
  • Reciprocity may exclude foreign holders (Art. 65 par. 1).
  • The text prescribes no format for exercising the prohibition.

Downsides

  • No amount or tariff is set, so the value of a license stays open.
  • The Art. 62 summary can reveal licensed sources unless trade and industrial secrets apply.
  • Art. 66 and the LGPD still bind data about people.

Alternatives

  • License under the existing Lei 9.610 authorization rule described on the parent page.
  • License only content the holder owns, after a rights audit.
  • Wait for the Chamber.
  • Not licensing at all, which the page on alternatives to selling data to AI labs lays out.

Beyond the Bill: Brazil, Other Disclosure and Opt-out Rules and the Seller Process

This bill is one part of Brazilian law and one of several disclosure and opt-out models. The parent page on Brazil: rules for licensing data for AI training covers the LGPD, Lei 9.610 and the ANPD order.

How This Page Is Sourced and Dated

Every rule here cites an article of the Senate text of PL 2338/2023 or an entry of the Chamber's open data, with the date it was read. The method is set out in how we source and date every rule.

This page is general information about a bill, not legal advice for any specific deal; English renderings of Portuguese are the editorial team's own and the Portuguese text governs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Brazil's AI bill law?

No, PL 2338/2023 is a bill. It passed the Senate on 2024-12-10 and is Aguardando Parecer in the Chamber on 2026-11-17.

Does the Brazilian bill give rightsholders an opt-out?

Art. 64 gives rightsholders a right to prohibit use outside the Art. 63 research exception. The articles read prescribe no format for exercising it.

Would AI developers have to pay for training data in Brazil?

Art. 65 would require remuneration to rightsholders for training use, free of charge or paid by negotiation. The articles read set no amount.

Does the bill apply to a company outside Brazil?

Art. 65 par. 1 limits remuneration to rightsholders domiciled in Brazil or in a country with reciprocity. Whether the Act binds a foreign developer is not stated in the articles read.