DataPacts

Music Publishers v. Anthropic (Concord I and II, BMG, Round Hill, Sony, ABG): Claims, Rulings and Status

Checked

At a glance

Concord Music Group v. Anthropic is a copyright suit by music publishers, among them Concord, Universal Music Publishing Group and ABKCO, claiming that Anthropic infringed their song lyrics by training Claude on them and by reproducing them in Claude's outputs.

Independent reference. Every buyer is covered on the same terms, every figure carries its source and check date, and no buyer pays to be listed or placed higher.

Request an independent introduction

Tell us what data your company holds. We reply with the buyers that fit and what their terms leave out. Your details reach a buyer only after you agree to a named introduction.

IndependentYour details stay with us until you agreeNot selling is a valid outcome

Publishers' lyrics run through training into Claude, which fans out into verbatim lyrics, mash-ups and new lyrics; the court asked for a separate fair use analysis of each of the four uses. Concord II adds a downloading claim.

Filed in October 2023 in the Middle District of Tennessee, it now sits in the Northern District of California as No. 5:24-cv-03811-EKL.

A second suit by the publishers, Concord II (No. 5:26-cv-00880-EKL, filed January 28, 2026), adds claims over 20,517 works. As of November 9, 2026, neither case has a final ruling or a settlement.

This page belongs to the independent reference on AI training data licensing, and DataPacts is not affiliated with any party or counsel and gives no legal advice.

All dates and docket numbers here come from court filings and SEC filings, and how figures are sourced and dated is set out on the methodology page.

Concord I and Concord II at a Glance: Courts, Dockets, Parties and Status

Both suits are pending before Judge Eumi K. Lee in the Northern District of California, and neither has reached a ruling on the merits as of November 9, 2026. The table compares the two cases as of 2026-11-09.

Field Concord I Concord II Source
Case Concord Music Group, Inc. et al. v. Anthropic PBC Concord Music Group, Inc. et al. v. Anthropic PBC et al. complaints; S-1/A
Court N.D. Cal. (filed M.D. Tenn., transferred) N.D. Cal. case records
Docket 5:24-cv-03811-EKL (M.D. Tenn. 3:23-cv-01092) 5:26-cv-00880-EKL case records
Judge Eumi K. Lee, J. Eumi K. Lee, J. Dkt. 918; Dkt. 141
Filed 2023-10 2026-01-28 case records
Plaintiffs Concord Music Group, Universal Music Publishing Group, ABKCO and other music publishers music publishers case records
Defendants Anthropic, PBC Anthropic, PBC; Dario Amodei Dkt. 1 (Concord II)
Claims lyrics in training and in Claude outputs; DMCA CMI removal 20,517 works allegedly used to train Claude, including acquisition by downloading; output infringement (Count II) case records
Status cross-motions for summary judgment and Daubert motions argued; ruling pending individual defendant's motion granted with leave to amend; meet and confer on Anthropic's motion Dkt. 918; Dkt. 141

The court records name Concord Music Group, Universal Music Publishing Group, ABKCO and other music publishers as plaintiffs, and Anthropic, PBC is the defendant in both suits. The further names in this page's title are not described here, because no claim, date or docket for them is verified.

Concord II also names Dario Amodei as a defendant in its complaint (Dkt. 1), and no title is stated. Anthropic, PBC is a Delaware public benefit corporation (SEC CIK 0002130357), and its S-1/A is the primary source for the existence and the 2023 filing month of Concord I.

What the Music Publishers Claim About Lyrics in Claude's Training and Outputs

The publishers claim two kinds of copying, the use of their lyrics to train Claude and the reproduction of those lyrics in Claude's answers, plus the removal of copyright management information in violation of the DMCA.

These are allegations, and no court has found any of them proven as of 2026-11-09. The training claim is about the copies made to teach the model, while the output claim is about what Claude writes in answer to a prompt, and the court has asked for the two to be analyzed as separate uses.

The court has since asked for verbatim outputs, mash-up outputs and new lyrics to be analyzed separately from training, a split set out below.

The amount a copyright owner can recover is set by statute: under 17 U.S.C. 504(c), checked 2026-11-09, statutory damages run from USD 750 to USD 30,000 per work, and up to USD 150,000 per work if the infringement is willful. This page states no amount that the publishers demand.

How the Lyrics Were Allegedly Acquired: The Concord II Downloading Claim

In Concord II, filed on January 28, 2026, the publishers allege that 20,517 works were used to train Claude and that Anthropic acquired them in part by downloading. The complaint (Dkt. 1) also pleads output infringement as Count II.

The claim concerns the route by which copies reached the training set, which separates it from Concord I's focus on lyrics in training and outputs.

How the publishers say the copies were obtained beyond "downloading", including sources, dates and file types, is not stated here, and nor is any amendment of Concord I to add acquisition claims, because the record behind them is not verified.

The court's concern of November 6, 2026 about the same 20,517 works is covered in the Concord II section below.

In Bartz, the other Anthropic training case, the court treated purchased and pirated book copies differently in its Order on Fair Use (Dkt. 231, June 23, 2025), so the route of acquisition is a recurring question in claims against Anthropic.

Concord I Docket Entries, 2023 to 2026

Four dated steps carry Concord I from its Tennessee filing to the pending summary judgment ruling: the complaint, the transfer to California, the court's pre-hearing questions and their publication by clerk's notice. The table lists them as of 2026-11-09.

Date Dkt. Entry What it decided or reported Source
2023-10 not stated complaint, M.D. Tenn. 3:23-cv-01092 suit filed Anthropic S-1/A
not stated not stated transfer to N.D. Cal. case continues as 5:24-cv-03811-EKL case record
2026-10-20 not stated court's pre-hearing questions four separate fair use analyses; market dilution in a but-for licensing world Dkt. 918 PDF
2026-10-23 918 Clerk's Notice publishes the questions Dkt. 918 PDF

The hearing date is not stated, and the ruling is pending as of 2026-11-09. The date of the transfer and the rulings on earlier motions are likewise not stated here, because they are not verified.

What Judge Lee Asked Before the Summary Judgment Hearing

On October 20, 2026, the court sent the parties questions for the hearing on the cross-motions for summary judgment and the Daubert motions, published by Clerk's Notice on October 23, 2026 (Dkt. 918).

The notice publishes the questions and is not an order deciding them, so it reports what the court wants argued and decides nothing about infringement. The court asked the parties to analyze fair use separately for four uses:

  1. training;
  2. verbatim lyric outputs;
  3. mash-up outputs;
  4. model-written "new" lyrics.

The court also asked about market dilution in a "but-for world in which Anthropic is required to license the Works in Suit", that is, whether Claude could then still generate AI lyrics that compete with the publishers, and the ruling is pending as of 2026-11-09. How the four factors apply to training is set out in fair use and AI training in US law.

Concord II Docket and the November 2026 Order on the Motions to Dismiss

The court heard motions to dismiss Concord II on November 4, 2026, and on November 6, 2026 it granted the individual defendant's motion with leave to amend and ordered the parties to meet and confer on Anthropic's motion (Dkt. 141). The table lists the three entries as of 2026-11-09.

Date Dkt. Entry What it decided or reported Source
2026-01-28 1 complaint 20,517 works; downloading; Count II outputs archive.org Dkt. 1
2026-11-04 not stated hearing on motions to dismiss heard Dkt. 141
2026-11-06 141 order regarding the hearing individual defendant's motion granted with leave to amend; meet and confer on Anthropic's motion; concern about implied output reproduction of all 20,517 works Dkt. 141 PDF

The order states a concern that the publishers implied that all 20,517 trained-on works were also reproduced in outputs. Leave to amend means the publishers may replead the claim against the individual defendant, so nothing about that claim is final.

Anthropic's own motion to dismiss is not decided as of 2026-11-09. The parties were ordered only to confer, so the next recorded step depends on whether an amended complaint is filed or the motion is renewed, and neither is recorded here.

What the Music Publisher Suits Signal to Holders of Licensable Data

The suits do not set a price for lyrics or music as training data, because no court has ruled and no settlement has been filed, but the court's own question assumes a world in which the lyrics are licensed for training.

The court asks about market dilution in a "but-for world in which Anthropic is required to license the Works in Suit" (Dkt. 918), and that point is pending without a prediction here.

In the same market, Universal Music Group announced on 2025-10-29 that it had settled copyright infringement litigation with Udio and agreed new licenses, with terms undisclosed (UMG release); Universal Music Group AI licensing deals are logged on their own page. The release states no relationship between that settlement and the publishers' suits.

Concord I itself stays unresolved: the court has set out its analysis structure but has not ruled on any of the four uses, and Concord II has not passed the pleading stage.

A holder of licensable data can read the two dockets as a record of what a court asks about training copies, and not as a price signal or a prediction of any outcome.

Catalogs, stems and the terms on which rights holders license recordings and lyrics are covered by the page on music as AI training data.

Concord I and II are two of the three training-data suits against Anthropic in the tracker, and the only ones about music.

Every tracked case appears with its docket and status in the case tracker of AI copyright lawsuits over training data. The table compares the music publisher suits with three related cases as of 2026-11-09.

Case Court and docket What it concerns Status Source
Bartz v. Anthropic N.D. Cal. 3:24-cv-05417-AMO books, including pirated copies USD 1.5 billion settlement, final approval and judgment 2026-07-20 (Dkt. 680) Dkt. 680
GEMA v. OpenAI LG München I, 42 O 14139/24 memorisation of 9 song lyrics judgment 2025-11-11 largely for GEMA; not final Munich court press release
GEMA v. Suno LG München I, 42 O 763/25 6 musical works (lyrics not at issue) judgment 2026-07-31 largely for GEMA; not final Munich court press release

The music suits and Bartz differ in subject, since one concerns lyrics and the other books, but both come to the same defendant and the same court. Anthropic's acquisition practices and programs are covered on its data buyer profile, which explains how Anthropic acquires training data.

More About Concord v. Anthropic

Nothing on this page is legal advice, and the sections below collect the status split and the common questions.

Pending Versus Decided in the Music Publisher Suits

Only procedural steps are decided; every question about infringement, fair use and damages is still open.

Decided Still open
transfer of Concord I to N.D. Cal. summary judgment in Concord I
the court's questions of 2026-10-20 Anthropic's motion to dismiss in Concord II
the 2026-11-06 order on the individual defendant, with leave to amend any remedy

Frequently Asked Questions About Concord v. Anthropic

Is Concord v. Anthropic settled?

No: no settlement is recorded in either case. The summary judgment ruling in Concord I is pending as of 2026-11-09.

Has the court decided whether training Claude on lyrics was fair use?

No: the court has not ruled. It asked for separate analyses of training and three output types (Dkt. 918), and the ruling is pending as of 2026-11-09.

What is the difference between Concord I and Concord II?

Concord I (2023) targets lyrics in training and outputs; Concord II (filed 2026-01-28) adds 20,517 works and the downloading allegation. Both are before Judge Lee.

Is Concord v. Anthropic part of the Bartz settlement?

No: Bartz settled authors' book claims (N.D. Cal. 3:24-cv-05417-AMO) and is a separate case. The music publishers are not part of that class settlement.