DataPacts

Toronto Star and Canadian News Publishers v. OpenAI (Ontario): Claims, Rulings and Status

Checked

At a glance

Toronto Star Newspapers Limited et al. v. OpenAI, Inc. et al. is an Ontario lawsuit by seven Canadian news organizations, led in the caption by the Toronto Star's publisher, against ten OpenAI entities, alleging breaches of the Copyright Act, breach of website terms of use and unjust enrichment from the crawling and scraping of their content and the training of the models behind ChatGPT.

Independent reference. Every buyer is covered on the same terms, every figure carries its source and check date, and no buyer pays to be listed or placed higher.

Request an independent introduction

Tell us what data your company holds. We reply with the buyers that fit and what their terms leave out. Your details reach a buyer only after you agree to a named introduction.

IndependentYour details stay with us until you agreeNot selling is a valid outcome

The Superior Court of Justice refused on November 7, 2025 to set the claim aside for lack of jurisdiction, except against four defendants, and the Court of Appeal for Ontario dismissed OpenAI's appeal on November 13, 2026 (2026 ONCA 814).

Neither court has decided whether anything infringed, and the case is pending as of 2026-11-18. This page is part of the independent reference on AI training data licensing, DataPacts is not affiliated with any court or party, and nothing here is legal advice.

Every court detail below comes from the Court of Appeal's decision, and how figures are sourced and dated is set out on the methodology page.

Toronto Star and Canadian News Publishers v. OpenAI at a Glance: Courts, Parties and Status

The case is pending in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, with the jurisdiction challenge finally decided at the Court of Appeal and the merits untouched. The table gives the record as of 2026-11-18, from the Court of Appeal's decision of 2026-11-13.

Field Value Source
Case Toronto Star Newspapers Limited et al. v. OpenAI, Inc. et al. 2026 ONCA 814 caption
Courts Ontario Superior Court of Justice (motion judge Kimmel J.); Court of Appeal for Ontario (Miller, Favreau and Rahman JJ.A.) 2026 ONCA 814
Court file numbers Court of Appeal: COA-25-CV-1620; Superior Court file number not stated in the decision 2026 ONCA 814
Filed not stated in the decision 2026 ONCA 814
Plaintiffs (respondents) Toronto Star Newspapers Limited; Metroland Media Group Ltd.; Postmedia Network Inc.; PMO Maritimes LP; The Globe and Mail Inc.; Canadian Press Enterprises Inc.; Canadian Broadcasting Corporation 2026 ONCA 814 caption
Defendants OpenAI, Inc.; OpenAI GP, LLC; OpenAI, LLC; OpenAI Startup Fund I, LP; OpenAI Startup Fund GP I, LLC; OpenAI Startup Fund Management, LLC; OpenAI Global, LLC; OpenAI OpCo, LLC; OAI Corporation; OpenAI Holdings, LLC (10; six are appellants) 2026 ONCA 814 caption
Claims Copyright Act breaches, breach of contract (website terms of use), unjust enrichment (allegations) 2026 ONCA 814 paras. 2, 14
Status pending; jurisdiction challenge dismissed on appeal 2026-11-13; no settlement recorded 2026 ONCA 814

What the Canadian News Organizations Allege About Crawling, Training and Reproduction

The news organizations allege that OpenAI misappropriated their journalistic content to build commercial AI products such as ChatGPT, through crawling and scraping their web content, training the large language models behind ChatGPT, and reproducing and using the copyrighted content.

The statement of claim pleads three causes of action: breaches of the Copyright Act, breach of contract and unjust enrichment (para. 2).

The motion judge read the copyright theory as alleging that OpenAI used the plaintiffs' "proprietary content to build, train, augment and operate its GPT models" and that it "sanctions, encourages, and permits users in Canada (including in Toronto) to infringe" their works (para. 32).

OpenAI argued that the claim pleads only reproduction under section 3(1)(a) and circumvention of technological protection measures (para. 31), and the Court of Appeal held that the motion judge was entitled to read the pleading more broadly (para. 32).

The contract allegation is that the crawling and scraping breached the terms of use on the plaintiffs' websites, which the plaintiffs describe as contracts originating in Ontario (paras. 14, 42).

The unjust enrichment claim extends to the for-profit parent entities. How copyright and contract claims over scraping compare across countries is covered on the page on web scraping for AI training.

Court Record on Jurisdiction, 2025 to 2026

Three court events are on record for the jurisdiction challenge: the Superior Court order of November 7, 2025, the Court of Appeal hearing of April 29, 2026 and the Court of Appeal decision of November 13, 2026. The table lists them as of 2026-11-18.

Date Court and reference Event What it decided or reported Source
2025-11-07 Superior Court of Justice, 2025 ONSC 6217 (Kimmel J.) Order on jurisdiction motion motion granted for four defendants, dismissed for the others; Ontario held to be the forum 2026 ONCA 814 (summary of the order)
2026-04-29 Court of Appeal for Ontario, COA-25-CV-1620 Appeal heard OpenAI's appeal from the 2025-11-07 order 2026 ONCA 814
2026-11-13 Court of Appeal for Ontario, 2026 ONCA 814 Decision (Miller J.A.; Favreau and Rahman JJ.A. agreeing) appeal dismissed; costs of $100,000 to the respondents as agreed 2026 ONCA 814

The November 7, 2025 Superior Court Order on OpenAI's Jurisdiction Motion

Justice Kimmel of the Superior Court of Justice granted OpenAI's jurisdiction motion for four of the named defendants and dismissed it for the others in an order dated November 7, 2025, with reasons at 2025 ONSC 6217.

The reasons themselves were not read for this page, so everything in the three sections below is the Court of Appeal's summary of them (para. 5). The order decided only where the case may be heard, not whether OpenAI infringed.

What OpenAI Asked the Court to Do

OpenAI's Delaware corporations were served with the statement of claim outside Ontario and moved to set the service aside under rule 17.06 of the Rules of Civil Procedure and to stay or dismiss the proceeding under section 106 of the Courts of Justice Act (para. 3).

The motion judge addressed four issues: subject matter jurisdiction, attornment (whether OpenAI had accepted the court's jurisdiction by what it argued), jurisdiction over the defendants themselves, known as in personam jurisdiction, and whether to decline jurisdiction in favor of the United States (para. 5).

What the Motion Judge Found on Jurisdiction

The motion judge found that Ontario has subject matter jurisdiction, that OpenAI had not attorned, and that the plaintiffs had a good arguable case on at least one connecting factor for each remaining defendant. On subject matter, a court has jurisdiction if the claim pleaded is cognizable in the Superior Court, following TeleZone.

OpenAI's argument that the territorial limits of the Copyright Act restrict jurisdiction was treated as an argument on the merits for a different motion under rule 21, and OpenAI had not attorned because it challenged jurisdiction from the outset (paras. 6 to 18).

On the connecting factors under Van Breda, the motion judge relied on several points. Some defendants used web crawlers to gather data located in Ontario, made contractual arrangements in Ontario, used user-generated training data from Ontario and held trademarks there. The main procurement entity advertised and provided services in Ontario.

The alleged copying included material transmitted from Canada and returned to Canada for users. The terms of use are contracts originating in Ontario, and the unjust enrichment claim reaches the for-profit parents. The argument that the works were authored in Ontario was rejected (paras. 6 to 18).

Why the Motion Judge Kept the Case in Ontario Rather Than the United States

The motion judge refused to decline jurisdiction in favor of the United States and found Ontario the preferred forum.

Witnesses were neutral, the law to apply is Canadian and Ontario law, and there was no multiplicity of proceedings because the Toronto Star's other proceedings against OpenAI entities in the United States are brought under US law (para. 18).

She also found no evidence of a conflict with US law on enforcement, and held that the fair and efficient working of the Canadian system favors letting Canadian authors sue foreign companies for breaches of Canadian law. The Delhi High Court faced a comparable question in ANI v. OpenAI.

The November 13, 2026 Court of Appeal Decision

The Court of Appeal for Ontario (Miller, Favreau and Rahman JJ.A.) dismissed OpenAI's appeal in full on November 13, 2026 and awarded the news organizations costs of $100,000, as agreed among the parties.

The decision is 2026 ONCA 814, docket COA-25-CV-1620, heard April 29, 2026, with reasons by Miller J.A. The court reviews a finding of a real and substantial connection for palpable and overriding error, and the forum decision with deference (paras. 34, 52, 55, 60). The table gives the five issues as of 2026-11-13.

Issue What OpenAI argued Holding Source
1. Subject matter jurisdiction SOCAN real and substantial connection test applies; territoriality of the Copyright Act limits jurisdiction no error: SOCAN concerned jurisdiction over the defendant, not subject matter 2026 ONCA 814 paras. 20 to 23
2. Personal (in personam) jurisdiction Van Breda misapplied; unpleaded rights relied on; no physical presence; no contract formed no error: Van Breda governs; three presumptive factors on a good arguable case paras. 24 to 44
3. Claims precluded Copyright Act is a complete code that ousts contract and unjust enrichment claims no error: a merits argument for a rule 21 motion; cannot be raised without attorning paras. 45 to 47
4. Presumption rebutted connections too weak no error: OpenAI bore the onus and showed no palpable and overriding error paras. 48 to 52
5. Forum non conveniens United States clearly more appropriate no error: discretionary decision; Ontario "more appropriate, suitable, and convenient" paras. 53 to 59

Subject Matter, Territorial Reach and Attornment

The Court of Appeal held that the motion judge was right to treat Copyright Act territoriality as a question for a later motion and not for subject matter jurisdiction.

OpenAI argued that the SOCAN real and substantial connection framework decides subject matter jurisdiction for Copyright Act claims, and the court held that SOCAN addressed jurisdiction over the extraterritorial defendant, not subject matter jurisdiction (paras. 20 to 23).

The argument that the conduct falls outside the territorial reach of the Act, and the argument that the Act pre-empts the contract and unjust enrichment claims, are arguments that the claim discloses no reasonable cause of action.

They belong to a rule 21 motion, which OpenAI cannot bring without attorning to the court's jurisdiction (paras. 45 to 47).

Assumed Jurisdiction Without a Physical Presence in Ontario

The Court of Appeal held that the Van Breda test governs and that the plaintiffs had a good arguable case on three presumptive connecting factors, so a physical presence in Ontario was not required. Copyright infringement is "essentially a statutory tort", and the court rejected OpenAI's argument that the motion judge relied on unpleaded rights.

On carrying on business, the court pointed to multiple indicia, including contractual arrangements, advertising and licensing tools to customers, relied on Equustek, and did not need to adopt the plaintiffs' concept of "active commercial participation" (paras. 24 to 44).

Contract, through browse-wrap terms of use following Century 21, and unjust enrichment, for parents in control of or profiting from the operating companies, were open to the motion judge.

Any one factor suffices and here there are three, so even a win for OpenAI on the copyright factor would not have been dispositive. The forum decision is discretionary and shows no error (paras. 44, 53 to 59).

What the Appeal Decision Does Not Decide

Neither Ontario court has decided whether OpenAI infringed any copyright, breached any terms of use or was unjustly enriched: they decided only that the Ontario court may hear the claims.

The Court of Appeal records the motion judge's view that the copyright claims could be narrower at trial if the Copyright Act does not reach conduct outside Canada (para. 28).

The decisions say nothing on fair dealing or any other defense, and the rules that apply are set out on the page on Canada: rules for licensing data for AI training.

Status as of 2026-11-18

The case is pending: the jurisdiction challenge ended at the Court of Appeal on November 13, 2026, and the claims go forward in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice. No settlement, license, trial date or statement of defense is on record in the sources checked.

Whether OpenAI seeks leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada is not recorded in the sources checked. The Court of Appeal's published decision was read on 2026-11-18, five days after its release.

What the Ontario Case Shows to News Publishers and Data Holders

The record shows where a Canadian publisher may sue a US AI developer, not who is right on the copyright question. The courts treated virtual activity, meaning crawling, serving users, advertising and contracts, as enough for a good arguable case (paras. 24 to 44).

Website terms of use were pleaded and accepted as arguably binding contracts for the purpose of jurisdiction, which is a point reached at the allegation stage and not a finding that a contract exists (paras. 14, 42).

How publishers license content to AI companies, and the option of not licensing, is covered on the page for news publishers licensing content to AI companies.

The Ontario case is one of several non-US proceedings against OpenAI over training data, and it is the one in which a court has ruled on where a case may be heard after an appeal.

Every tracked case with its docket and status is listed in the case tracker of AI copyright lawsuits over training data.

The table compares four related OpenAI matters as of 2026-11-18, with the status each page gives on its own date.

Case Court and reference Status Source
ANI v. OpenAI High Court of Delhi, CS(COMM) 1028/2024 interim injunction refused 2026-07-24; suit pending as of 2026-11-09 judgment of 2026-07-24
GEMA v. OpenAI Landgericht München I, 42 O 14139/24 judgment 2025-11-11 largely for GEMA; not final Munich Regional Court press release 11/2025
Canadian Privacy Commissioners' OpenAI investigation PIPEDA Findings #2026-002, published 2026-05-06 well-founded and conditionally resolved; commitments under implementation, no completion published as of 2026-11-17 OPC report
In re OpenAI Copyright Infringement Litigation S.D.N.Y., 1:25-md-03143-SHS-OTW summary-judgment motions briefed; no ruling as of 2026-11-09 MDL docket

Licensing deals between publishers and AI companies are logged on the tracker of AI data licensing deals.

More About the Toronto Star Lawsuit Against OpenAI

Pending Versus Final: What Is Decided and What Is Open

The jurisdiction question is decided; liability, damages, schedule and any settlement are open. The table sets the two sides against each other as of 2026-11-18.

Decided (2026 ONCA 814) Still open
Ontario may hear the claims against the six appellants whether anything infringed or was breached
OpenAI's appeal dismissed, costs of $100,000 as agreed how far the copyright claims reach conduct outside Canada
the Superior Court order of 2025-11-07 stands any schedule, defense, settlement or further appeal

Frequently Asked Questions About the Toronto Star Lawsuit Against OpenAI

Who sued OpenAI in Ontario and why?

Seven Canadian news organizations, led in the caption by Toronto Star Newspapers Limited. They allege Copyright Act, contract and unjust enrichment claims over crawling, scraping and training.

No. They decided only that the Ontario court may hear the claims, and the merits are untouched.

Can OpenAI appeal again?

Leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada is not recorded in the sources checked as of 2026-11-18.

Is the Ontario case settled?

No settlement is recorded as of 2026-11-18. The case is pending.

Is there a trial date?

None is recorded in the sources checked as of 2026-11-18.