DataPacts

Ziff Davis v. OpenAI: Claims, Rulings and Status

Checked

At a glance

Ziff Davis v. OpenAI is a copyright and DMCA lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York (No. 1:25-cv-04315) in which the publisher Ziff Davis, Inc. and five affiliates, among them IGN, Mashable, CNET and Everyday Health, claim that OpenAI copied their articles to train its models, including by crawling their sites with GPTBot despite robots.txt files.

Independent reference. Every buyer is covered on the same terms, every figure carries its source and check date, and no buyer pays to be listed or placed higher.

Request an independent introduction

Tell us what data your company holds. We reply with the buyers that fit and what their terms leave out. Your details reach a buyer only after you agree to a named introduction.

IndependentYour details stay with us until you agreeNot selling is a valid outcome

It was filed in the District of Delaware on April 24, 2025 and centralized in MDL No. 3143.

The court dismissed the unjust enrichment and anti-circumvention claims on December 15, 2025 and refused to re-plead the latter on December 18, 2025, and as of November 17, 2026 the remaining claims are in summary-judgment briefing with no ruling located.

DataPacts is not affiliated with any party or court and gives no legal advice; this page is part of the independent reference on AI training data licensing.

Dates, dockets and quotations come from the court filings named in each table, read on November 17, 2026, and how figures are sourced and dated is set out on the methodology page.

Ziff Davis v. OpenAI at a Glance: Court, Docket, Parties and Status

The case is pending in the OpenAI multidistrict litigation before Judge Stein on the claims the orders of December 2025 and August 2026 left standing. The table lists the case facts as of 2026-11-17.

Field Value Source
Case Ziff Davis, Inc. et al. v. OpenAI, Inc. et al. Dkt. 300
Court and docket S.D.N.Y. 1:25-cv-04315-SHS-OTW, in MDL 1:25-md-03143-SHS-OTW; from D. Del. 1:25-cv-00501 (-UNA at filing, -CFC from Dkt. 15) Dkt. 300; D. Del. Dkt. 1, 15
Judges Sidney H. Stein, U.S. District Judge; Magistrate Judge Ona T. Wang Dkt. 300; MDL captions
Filed and transferred 2025-04-24 (D. Del. Dkt. 1); listed on the conditional transfer order 2025-05-06 (JPML Doc. 1); transfer listing 2025-05-14 (JPML Doc. 4) D. Del. Dkt. 1; JPML Doc. 1, 4
Plaintiffs Ziff Davis, Inc.; Ziff Davis, LLC; IGN Entertainment, Inc.; Everyday Health Media, LLC; Mashable, Inc.; CNET Media, Inc. (the first four in the original complaint) Dkt. 300 n.2; D. Del. Dkt. 24
Defendants OpenAI, Inc.; OpenAI GP, LLC; OpenAI, LLC; OpenAI OpCo LLC; OpenAI Global LLC; OAI Corporation, LLC; OpenAI Holdings, LLC; OpenAI Startup Fund I LP; OpenAI Startup Fund GP I LLC; OpenAI Startup Fund Management LLC (no Microsoft entity) Dkt. 300 n.1
Pleading at the December 2025 ruling First Amended Complaint (case ECF No. 105, filed 2025-07-02) Dkt. 106; Dkt. 300
Counts standing after the orders read 1, 2, 6 and 7 for the models in the MDL's scope; the amended complaint ordered in August 2026 is not described here Dkt. 300, 302, 571
Status pending in MDL No. 3143, summary-judgment stage, no ruling located as of 2026-11-17 MDL Dkt. 1738, 1980, 2128, 2314

What Ziff Davis Claims: The Counts of the First Amended Complaint

The First Amended Complaint pleads nine counts: two for copyright infringement (training and outputs), one for contributory infringement, one for unjust enrichment, one for circumvention under 17 U.S.C. 1201(a)(1), two for copyright management information under 1202(b), and two for trademark dilution, one federal and one under Delaware law. The table lists the counts as of 2026-11-17, with the order that decided each.

No. Count In OpenAI's motion to dismiss Outcome Source
1 copyright infringement by OpenAI in training its models no pending Dkt. 300
2 copyright infringement based on model outputs no pending Dkt. 300
3 contributory copyright infringement yes motion denied 2025-12-15; active claim dismissed with prejudice, stayed claim without prejudice 2026-08-06 Dkt. 300; 571
4 common-law unjust enrichment yes dismissed 2025-12-15, preempted by 17 U.S.C. 301 Dkt. 300
5 circumvention, 17 U.S.C. 1201(a)(1) yes dismissed 2025-12-15; leave to re-plead denied as futile 2025-12-18 Dkt. 300; 302
6 removal of copyright management information, 1202(b)(1) yes motion denied 2025-12-15; pending Dkt. 300
7 distribution of works with that information removed, 1202(b)(3) yes motion and stay denied 2025-12-15; pending Dkt. 300
8 federal trademark dilution, 15 U.S.C. 1125(c) yes MASHABLE mark sufficient, six others not, 2025-12-15; active claim out with prejudice, stayed claim without 2026-08-06 Dkt. 300; 571
9 dilution and injury to business reputation, Delaware law no active claim out with prejudice, stayed claim without 2026-08-06 Dkt. 571

Counts are Ziff Davis's allegations, and outcomes are dated rulings, not findings of infringement.

Counts 1, 2 and 9 were not in OpenAI's motion to dismiss, which covered counts 3 to 8. The table follows the First Amended Complaint only and assigns no count to any later pleading.

How the Complaint Says GPTBot Copied Ziff Davis Sites Despite robots.txt Files

The First Amended Complaint alleges that OpenAI put Ziff Davis articles into its training sets from pools of scraped web content and by scraping Ziff Davis sites directly with GPTBot, and that the copies carried no copyright management information. It also alleges that model outputs sometimes reproduce or misattribute Ziff Davis content.

According to the complaint, the sites' robots.txt files told GPTBot not to crawl and OpenAI ignored them. The proposed second amended complaint of December 2025 added that OpenAI encouraged site owners to use robots.txt, found that compliance hindered its work and reconfigured the bot to bypass the files (Dkt. 302).

The user agents and documented behavior of the crawler are described on the page about GPTBot and OpenAI's other crawlers.

The complaint further alleges that hundreds of full copies of Ziff Davis article text sit in the WebText sample that OpenAI published on GitHub under a license allowing any recipient to "use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell copies".

OpenAI moved to dismiss six of the nine counts, and its motion papers are listed in the docket table below.

Ziff Davis v. OpenAI Docket Entries, 2025 to 2026

The entries below carry the case from the Delaware complaint through the December 2025 opinion and the August 2026 orders to the summary-judgment briefing. "Dkt." is an entry on the S.D.N.Y. case docket 1:25-cv-04315 and "MDL Dkt." an entry on the MDL docket 1:25-md-03143, and the court's PACER docket is authoritative.

Date Entry What it decided or showed Source
2025-04-24 D. Del. Dkt. 1 complaint, 1:25-cv-00501, filed D. Del. Dkt. 1
2025-05-06 JPML Doc. 1 conditional transfer order lists the Delaware action as a tag-along JPML Doc. 1
2025-05-14 JPML Doc. 4 transfer listing into MDL No. 3143 JPML Doc. 4
2025-06-10 Dkt. 53 OpenAI memorandum on its motion to dismiss (no technological measure, preemption, no 1202(b)(3) claim, no fame, by its headings) Dkt. 53
2025-07-02 Dkt. 106 motion denied as moot; First Amended Complaint (ECF No. 105) filed; response due 2025-07-16 Dkt. 106
2025-07-30 Dkt. 141 OpenAI memorandum on the motion to dismiss the First Amended Complaint Dkt. 141
2025-09-10 Dkt. 178 OpenAI reply memorandum Dkt. 178
2025-10-30 Dkt. 222 further oral argument set for 2025-11-13 on the motion and the motion to partially stay Dkt. 222
2025-12-15 Dkt. 300 Opinion & Order, 2025 WL 3635559: counts 4 and 5 out; count 8 split; counts 3, 6 and 7 kept; stay for later models Dkt. 300
2025-12-18 Dkt. 302 leave to file the proposed second amended complaint denied as futile (section 1201(a)) Dkt. 302
2026-06-11 Dkt. 543 OpenAI memorandum on judgment on the pleadings (contributory claim after Cox) Dkt. 543
2026-07-02 Dkt. 552 (MDL Dkt. 1608) Ziff Davis cross-motion: dismiss counts 3, 8 and 9 and file an amended complaint Dkt. 552
2026-07-13 Dkt. 556 OpenAI reply Dkt. 556
2026-08-06 Dkt. 571 active contributory and dilution claims out with prejudice, stayed ones without; amended complaint within 15 days Dkt. 571
2026-09-04 and 2026-09-17 MDL Dkt. 1738; 1980 OpenAI Rule 56.1 statement and summary-judgment memorandum, captions list 1:25-cv-04315 MDL Dkt. 1738, 1980
2026-10-23 MDL Dkt. 2128 News Plaintiffs' counterstatement, which says they cross-moved MDL Dkt. 2128
2026-10-29 MDL Dkt. 2314 OpenAI opposition to the News Plaintiffs' motion for partial summary judgment MDL Dkt. 2314

The December 15, 2025 Opinion: Which Claims Survived

Judge Stein's Opinion & Order of December 15, 2025 (Dkt. 300, 2025 WL 3635559) dismissed the unjust enrichment and section 1201(a) counts, split the federal dilution count, kept the contributory, 1202(b)(1) and 1202(b)(3) counts, and stayed the case for models outside the MDL's scope. The four rulings on the counts were:

  • Count 4 is preempted by 17 U.S.C. 301 and dismissed.
  • Count 5 is dismissed, for the reasons in the next section.
  • Count 7 survives because distribution is alleged (outputs handed to third parties, ownership transferred under the Terms of Use, and the WebText sample under its license) together with complete copies lacking copyright management information.
  • Count 8 survives only for MASHABLE, because the LIFEHACKER, CNET, ZDNET, PCMAG, BABYCENTER and IGN marks are not pleaded as famous.

Counts 3 and 6 were kept "for the reasons" in the opinion in The New York Times v. Microsoft and OpenAI (777 F. Supp. 3d 283). That Times opinion of April 4, 2025 dismissed all 1202(b)(3) claims there without prejudice, so count 7 here tests a different pleading and does not reverse that ruling.

The stay covers the o1, o1 mini, o1-pro, GPT-4.1, GPT-4.5, o3, o3-mini, o4-mini and GPT-5 models, and the court denied the request to stay count 7.

The Section 1201(a) Ruling: Why robots.txt Files Were Held Not to Control Access

The court held that the robots.txt files in Ziff Davis's complaint are not a "technological measure that effectively controls access" to its works, so the section 1201(a) claim fails. Dkt. 300 gives two grounds in its own words.

The files are requests that do not "effectively control" access "any more than a sign requesting that visitors 'keep off the grass' effectively controls access to a lawn", and disregarding them is not "circumvention", which the statute defines through acts such as descrambling, decrypting or otherwise avoiding a measure. The court distinguished Healthcare Advocates, which Ziff Davis had cited.

On December 18, 2025, Dkt. 302 denied leave to file the proposed second amended complaint as futile.

Its own allegations, the court wrote, show that robots.txt files "require an affirmative action by the creator of a bot for the files to impede access", so a bot reads them only if its operator configures it to. The court did not reach the circumvention question for that proposal.

The scope is narrow: a pleading-stage ruling by one judge on this complaint. It does not decide infringement, since counts 1 and 2 continue, and it does not address contract terms or EU opt-out effects. How the protocol works and what operators ignore is set out on the page on robots.txt for AI crawlers.

The August 6, 2026 Orders: Contributory and Trademark Dilution Claims Narrowed

After the Supreme Court's decision in Cox Communications v. Sony Music Entertainment, which the court's order describes as holding that "material contribution" is not a valid theory of contributory copyright liability, Ziff Davis gave up three counts and the court set the terms on August 6, 2026 (Dkt. 571).

OpenAI moved on June 11, 2026 for judgment on the pleadings (Dkt. 543, reply Dkt. 556), and Ziff Davis cross-moved on July 2, 2026 (Dkt. 552).

The order denied OpenAI's motion as moot, dismissed the active contributory and dilution claims with prejudice, and dismissed the contributory and dilution claims stayed since December 2025 (the o1 through GPT-5 models) without prejudice under the Zagano factors.

It directed Ziff Davis to file an amended complaint within fifteen days, which this page does not describe. The order quotes Ziff Davis's own reason for dropping dilution, a "mixed picture on dilutive uses of the MASHABLE mark" in the record for the models in scope.

Where the Ziff Davis Claims Stand as of November 17, 2026

As of November 17, 2026 the Ziff Davis claims that remain are pending in MDL No. 3143 at the summary-judgment stage, with no ruling located.

Ziff Davis is one of five News Plaintiffs, a later transfer that was never among the original 12 actions, and the page on the MDL membership, cross-cutting orders and schedule holds the shared record.

The summary-judgment papers carry captions listing 1:25-cv-04315, and the latest document read was filed on 2026-11-10 and is not a ruling.

The stay for later models still splits the case, and the News Plaintiffs, including the Ziff Davis plaintiffs, moved for sanctions against OpenAI in July 2026; the motion's content and outcome are not described here.

The record read does not show:

  • a trial date;
  • a ruling on fair use;
  • a settlement.

How courts have applied the four factors is covered on the page on fair use and AI training in US law.

What the Ziff Davis Rulings Mean for Publishers With Licensable Archives

The rulings so far decide how far four statutes reach a crawler, not what a publisher's archive is worth, so they set no license price and decide no fair use question. The allegations are Ziff Davis's, the rulings are pleading-stage, and no damages have been awarded.

In this court a robots.txt file alone did not support an anti-circumvention claim, while copyright, 1202(b)(1) and 1202(b)(3) claims proceeded. The opinions show what a holder can document:

  • the crawl logs and robots.txt history the complaint relies on;
  • the copyright management information on published copies, since count 7 turned on complete copies without it;
  • the models and dates in scope, since the stay split the case by model.

Licensing routes are covered on the page about news publishers licensing content to AI companies. This page is information, not legal advice, and the rulings do not address the option of not licensing at all.

Ziff Davis is one of five News Plaintiffs in MDL No. 3143, and its section 1201(a) claim was dismissed on the pleadings. The case tracker of AI copyright lawsuits over training data lists every tracked case, and the table compares the related DMCA outcomes as of 2026-11-17.

Case Court and docket 1201 / 1202 outcome Status Page
The New York Times v. Microsoft and OpenAI S.D.N.Y. 1:23-cv-11195-SHS-OTW 1202(b)(1) against OpenAI there and all 1202(b)(3) claims dismissed without prejudice 2025-04-04 (Dkt. 514) summary-judgment stage, no ruling as of 2026-11-09 above
Daily News v. Microsoft and OpenAI S.D.N.Y. 1:24-cv-03285-SHS see its page summary-judgment stage as of 2026-11-09 Daily News v. Microsoft and OpenAI
The Intercept v. OpenAI S.D.N.Y. 1:24-cv-01515 1202(b)(1) against OpenAI survived 2025-02-20 pending in the MDL as of 2026-11-09 The Intercept v. OpenAI
Reddit v. SerpApi, Oxylabs, AWMProxy and Perplexity S.D.N.Y. 1:25-cv-08736-PAE 1201(a)(1)(A) claims sustained against SerpApi and Perplexity 2026-07-31 (Dkt. 104) pending as of 2026-11-17 Reddit v. SerpApi and Perplexity

OpenAI's acquisition programs are on the profile of how OpenAI acquires training data. Reddit v. SerpApi sustained 1201(a)(1)(A) claims on a different pleading about scraping Reddit content from Google search results, and the two outcomes are not compared here.

More About Ziff Davis v. OpenAI

Decided Versus Still Open in the Ziff Davis Case

The pleading-stage rulings and the 2026 narrowing are decided, and the merits of the remaining claims are not.

  • Decided: counts 4 and 5 are out, with leave to re-plead count 5 denied; count 8 was split and then dropped as to active claims; the active contributory count is out; the stay for later models was granted.
  • Still open: summary judgment on counts 1, 2, 6 and 7; the stayed claims; the amended complaint ordered in August 2026; the sanctions motion.

Frequently Asked Questions About Ziff Davis v. OpenAI

Is Ziff Davis v. OpenAI part of the OpenAI MDL?

Yes, it is in MDL No. 3143 before Judge Stein. It was listed on the conditional transfer order and is captioned 25-md-3143, as a later transfer and not one of the original 12 actions.

Did the court rule that ignoring robots.txt is circumvention?

No, the court held that the pleaded robots.txt files are not an access control under section 1201(a) and that disregarding them is not circumvention (December 15 and 18, 2025). The copyright claims continue, and scraping law beyond this case is on its own page.

Which Ziff Davis claims against OpenAI are still active?

On the orders read, counts 1, 2, 6 and 7 for the models in the MDL's scope. The amended complaint ordered in August 2026 is not described here.

Is Microsoft a defendant in the Ziff Davis case?

No. The captions and the court's definition of "OpenAI" name only OpenAI entities.

Has Ziff Davis settled with OpenAI?

No settlement appears in the documents read through 2026-11-10.