On November 13, 2025 the court denied Cohere's partial motion to dismiss (Doc. 59), a pleading-stage order that decides no merits. The case was in discovery as of the latest docket entry on record, 2026-11-02, and no settlement is recorded.
DataPacts is the independent reference on AI training data licensing, is not affiliated with the court or any party, and gives information, not legal advice.
Fact-check note: every court statement below comes from the court documents named in the text and carries its date, and the methodology page explains how figures are sourced and dated. The docket was not re-read on 2026-11-17, so the status stays as of 2026-11-02.
Advance Local Media v. Cohere at a Glance: Court, Docket, Parties and Status
The case is pending in discovery, with the pleading-stage motion decided and no settlement or trial date on record. The table gives the case facts as of 2026-11-02, with the court document behind each.
| Field | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Case | Advance Local Media LLC et al. v. Cohere Inc. | Doc. 59 caption |
| Court | U.S. District Court, S.D.N.Y. | Doc. 59 |
| Docket | 1:25-cv-01305-CM-OTW | Doc. 168 header |
| Judges | McMahon, J.; Wang, M.J. (discovery orders) | Doc. 59; Doc. 168 |
| Filed | 2025-02-13 | complaint |
| Plaintiffs | 14 news and magazine publishers: Advance Local Media; Advance Magazine Publishers (Conde Nast); The Atlantic Monthly Group; Forbes Media; Guardian News & Media; Insider; Los Angeles Times Communications; The McClatchy Company; Newsday; Plain Dealer Publishing; Politico; The Republican Company; Toronto Star Newspapers; Vox Media | Doc. 59 caption |
| Defendant | Cohere Inc. | Doc. 59 caption |
| Claims | direct and secondary copyright infringement; Lanham Act trademark infringement and false designation of origin (allegations) | Doc. 59 |
| Status | discovery; motion to dismiss denied 2025-11-13; no settlement recorded | Docs. 59, 168 |
What the Publishers Allege About Cohere's Copying and Command Outputs
The publishers allege that Cohere copies their articles in three ways: crawling websites, including theirs, and relying on the Common Crawl dataset to build training data, retrieving their articles at query time through retrieval augmented generation (RAG), and showing full copies of articles to users. Doc. 59 summarizes these allegations from the complaint, and none is a finding.
On training, the publishers allege that Cohere copies text from websites using crawlers and other bots, relies on the Common Crawl dataset, and crawls particular sites, including theirs. These are allegations as summarized by the court.
On outputs, the publishers allege that when RAG is on, Command returns verbatim copies, substantial excerpts or substitutive summaries of their articles, and that its "Under the Hood" view shows full copies even of paywalled articles.
Their Exhibit B holds 75 example outputs, of which 50 are alleged verbatim copies and 25 a mix of verbatim copying and close paraphrase.
On notice and marks, the publishers allege that they signaled non-authorization through copyright notices, terms of service, robots.txt instructions to Cohere's bots and a cease-and-desist letter, and that copying continued.
How AI crawlers and robots.txt instructions work is explained on the crawlers page. With RAG off, the publishers also allege, Command writes hallucinated articles bearing marks indistinguishable from their registered marks. The complaint pleads four counts, set out in the ruling section below.
Docket Entries on Record, 2025 to 2026
Five docket entries are recorded for this case: the complaint, the order on the partial motion to dismiss, the parties' joint discovery letter and two orders of November 2, 2026. The table lists them as of 2026-11-02.
| Date | Doc. | Entry | What it decided or reported | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025-02-13 | 1 | Complaint | suit filed by the publishers against Cohere Inc. | complaint PDF |
| 2025-11-13 | 59 | Decision and Order Denying Defendant's Partial Motion to Dismiss (McMahon, J.) | denies Dkt. 49 as to Counts I (summaries theory), II, III and IV | court-stamped copy of Doc. 59 |
| 2026-09-25 | 149 | Parties' joint letter | plaintiffs produced about 43,000 documents (the plaintiffs' statement) | CourtListener PDF of Doc. 149 |
| 2026-11-02 | 167 | Order | concerns a clawback of a Slack thread | docket entry of 2026-11-02 |
| 2026-11-02 | 168 | Order (Wang, M.J.) | denies Cohere's letter motion to compel (ECF 161, 162) because Cohere had agreed not to seek the discovery | CourtListener PDF of Doc. 168 |
The November 13, 2025 Ruling on Cohere's Partial Motion to Dismiss
Judge McMahon denied Cohere's partial motion to dismiss in full on November 13, 2025 (Doc. 59), which means every challenged claim and theory proceeds to discovery. The 23-page opinion is a pleading-stage decision that assumes the complaint's facts are true.
It opens by calling the case "one of more than fifty lawsuits" before the courts challenging the use of copyrighted works by AI companies to train large language models, as of 2025-11-13.
| Count | Claim | What Cohere argued | Ruling in Doc. 59 | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| I (summaries theory only) | direct infringement | summaries repeat facts and copy only minimally | denied; substantial similarity plausibly alleged from 75 examples | Doc. 59 pp. 5-8 |
| II | secondary infringement (material contribution, inducement, vicarious) | no underlying direct infringement shown; no actual knowledge; inducement conclusory | denied on each argument | Doc. 59 pp. 9-15 |
| III | trademark infringement, 15 U.S.C. 1114(1) | no use in commerce; no confusion; nominative fair use | denied | Doc. 59 pp. 15-22 |
| IV | false designation of origin, 15 U.S.C. 1125(a)(1)(A) | same three arguments | denied (same standard) | Doc. 59 p. 15 n.1 |
What Cohere Asked the Court to Dismiss
Cohere moved to dismiss Counts II, III and IV in full and Count I only to the extent the direct infringement claim rests on "substitutive summaries". Count I is direct infringement, Count II secondary infringement, Count III trademark infringement (15 U.S.C. 1114(1)) and Count IV false designation of origin (15 U.S.C. 1125(a)(1)(A)).
The motion (Dkt. 49) did not challenge the training-copy theory of Count I, so that part of the case was never before the court on this motion.
Direct Infringement and the "Substitutive Summaries" Theory
The court held that the publishers plausibly alleged substantial similarity between Command's summaries and their articles, so the summaries theory stays in the case. Cohere argued that the summaries repeat only facts, which are not copyrightable, and copy minimally.
The court accepted that facts are free to republish but compared only original expression, and it pointed to the 75 examples, including one output that allegedly copies eight of ten paragraphs of a magazine article.
The court also declined to treat the 20 percent figure from a Second Circuit news case as a rule, because quantity is judged "in the shadow" of quality. It does not rule on whether any output actually infringes.
Secondary Infringement: Investigator Examples, Knowledge and Inducement
The court rejected all three of Cohere's arguments against secondary liability: that direct infringement by users was not shown, that actual knowledge of specific infringement was missing, and that inducement was pleaded only in conclusory terms.
Cohere said the examples came from the publishers' investigators and not from typical users, and that obtaining them breached its terms of service.
The court held that investigator outputs can support an infringement claim at the pleading stage and that Cohere cited no case dismissing a claim over a terms-of-service breach used to uncover infringement.
On knowledge, Judge McMahon followed Judge Stein's earlier decision in The New York Times v. Microsoft and OpenAI: the standard is that the defendant knows or has reason to know of infringement, not actual knowledge of specific acts.
On inducement, the court found enough in Cohere's alleged advertising of Command as a way to get "the latest news": a September 2023 pitch, the September 2024 Cohere app and a free demo prepopulated with a request to summarize technology news.
The theory that Cohere programmed Command to retrieve and deliver copies was also enough at this stage.
The court describes the publishers' theory as more than mere knowledge that a product could be used to infringe. It remains a theory to be tested in discovery.
The Lanham Act Counts: Marks on Hallucinated Articles
The court held that the publishers plausibly alleged use of their marks in commerce, likelihood of confusion and facts that could defeat nominative fair use for the hallucinated-article theory.
The marks are allegedly shown to users of a free trial that exists to capture paying customers, and Cohere's argument that customers buy output-agnostic API access failed at this stage.
The court called the theory "a classic passing-off claim". On confusion, the marks are alleged to be "indistinguishable" from the registered marks, so the court did not need to walk through the Polaroid factors at the pleading stage.
On nominative fair use, the court was "doubtful" that the defense applies but decided only that the complaint alleges facts that could lead a trier of fact to reject it. It also held that Dastar does not bar passing-off claims.
What the Ruling Does Not Decide
The order makes no finding that Cohere infringed anything: it accepts the complaint's allegations as true for the motion and decides only that they are enough to go forward.
It does not address training-copy liability or a copyright fair use defense; its only fair use discussion concerns trademark nominative fair use. The doctrine and the other rulings are covered on the page about fair use and AI training in US law. The order also sets no schedule.
Discovery and Status as of 2026-11-02
The case is in discovery: the parties' joint letter of September 25, 2026 (Doc. 149) reports that the plaintiffs had produced about 43,000 documents, and two orders of November 2, 2026 are the latest on record. The 43,000 figure is the plaintiffs' own statement in that letter, not a finding.
On November 2, 2026, Magistrate Judge Wang denied Cohere's letter motion to compel (ECF 161, 162) in Doc. 168 because Cohere had agreed not to seek that discovery.
A same-day order, Doc. 167, concerns a clawback of a Slack thread, and no further detail is written here. Cohere as a data buyer holds the lab-side record, including the absence of a licensing deal in the sources checked.
No settlement, license or trial date is on record. The status is taken from the latest entry on record, 2026-11-02, and the docket was not re-read on 2026-11-17.
What the Cohere Case Shows to Publishers and Data Holders
The record shows a dispute about content used without a license, not a licensing outcome: no settlement or license between the plaintiffs and Cohere is on record. The claims join two uses, training copies and retrieval-time copies. A content owner assessing exposure keeps them apart, because the partial motion left training-copy liability unchallenged.
The signals the court recorded as pleaded, namely copyright notices, terms of service, robots.txt and a cease-and-desist letter, are allegations, not findings. How news publishers licensing content to AI companies do so, including the option not to license at all, is covered on the publishers page.
Where Advance v. Cohere Sits Among News Publisher Cases
Advance v. Cohere is one of several news publisher suits in the tracker, and it is the one centered on an enterprise model developer rather than a consumer chatbot.
Every tracked case with docket and status is on the case tracker of AI copyright lawsuits over training data, and the table lists three related news cases as of 2026-11-09.
| Case | Court and docket | Status | Page |
|---|---|---|---|
| The New York Times v. Microsoft and OpenAI | S.D.N.Y. 1:23-cv-11195-SHS-OTW, MDL No. 3143 | summary-judgment stage, no ruling located | The New York Times v. Microsoft and OpenAI |
| Dow Jones and NY Post v. Perplexity | S.D.N.Y. 1:24-cv-07984-KPF | discovery; motion to compel granted in full 2026-10-29 (Doc. 227) | Dow Jones and NY Post v. Perplexity |
| News Publishers v. Perplexity | S.D.N.Y. 1:25-cv-10106-LAP, 1:25-cv-10094-LAP, 1:26-cv-04427-LAP | pending before Judge Preska | News Publishers v. Perplexity (NYT, Chicago Tribune, CNN) |
Publisher licensing deals with parties and dates are logged on the tracker of AI data licensing deals.
More About the Cohere Lawsuit
Pending Versus Final: What Is Decided and What Is Open
The pleading-stage ruling is decided; liability, damages, schedule and any settlement are open.
- Decided: the partial motion to dismiss is denied (Doc. 59, 2025-11-13); the order is a pleading-stage decision only; the discovery letter motion of Cohere is denied (Doc. 168, 2026-11-02).
- Open: whether Cohere is liable for any count; any damages; the schedule and any trial date; any settlement or license (none recorded as of 2026-11-02).
Frequently Asked Questions About the Cohere Lawsuit
Who sued Cohere and why?
Fourteen news and magazine publishers sued Cohere Inc. on 2025-02-13. They allege copying of their articles for training and in outputs, plus misuse of their marks on hallucinated articles.
Did the court rule that Cohere infringed copyright?
No, the court denied a motion to dismiss on 2025-11-13 and made no finding on the merits. The order only holds that the claims are plausibly pleaded.
Is the Cohere case settled?
No settlement is recorded as of 2026-11-02. The case was in discovery at the latest docket entry on record.
Does Cohere license news content?
No licensing deal with the plaintiffs or other news publishers is recorded in the sources checked. The Cohere profile holds the detail.
Is there a trial date?
No trial date is recorded in the sources checked as of 2026-11-02. The case is in discovery.